7 ms·
The Whitehouse’s New Executive Order on Cyber Crime Is (Unfortunately) No Joke
- pdkl95 12y agoA lot of you seem to be assuming the EO applies only to people outside the US. It would be a good idea to actually read the EO, which is NOT restricted to people outside the US. From the EO[1], reformatted to show clause structure: Section 1 (a) All property and interests ... of the following persons ... are blocked (i) any person determined by the Secretary of the Treasury ... to have engaged in ... directly or indirectly, ... any activity originating form, or directed by ... persons located outside the United States that are reasonably likely to result in ...a significant threat to national security ...or economic health ...of the united states. This language targets "any person" that meets some shockingly vague criteria[2] by few government officials[3]. The clause with "outside the United States" is not describing the person being targeted by the EO; that language is a detail about the type of activity that the targeted person is doing. If the attack is directed by someone outside the US, and you are determined to be indirectly "engaged in" or "complicit with" that that activity, you are targeted by this clause. Neither you nor the attack itself need to be outside the US, as long as it is directed by someone that is outside the US. What kinds of activities? In a previous thread I mentioned[4] how the EO doesn't prohibit harming "critical infrastructure", but instead prohibits: Section 1 (a) (i) (A) harming, or otherwise significantly compromising a computer or network of computers that support ... the provision of service ... in a critical infrastructure sector (C) causing a significant disruption to the availability of a computer or network of computers Note that section (C) does not limit itself to a "critical infrastructure sector". There are so many vague and undefined terms in this EO, I wouldn't be surprised if this EO could be used against some kid that is "indirectly" engaging in a DDOS[5] being run by some *chan troll outside the US. Also note: the EO doesn't mention the SDN list at all. -- [1] https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1699240/executive-order-obama-establishes-sanctions.pdf https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.documentcloud.org/documents/1699... [2] "reasonably likely to result in"? seriously? [3] those officials, by the way, can delegate the power according to Sec 8 of the EO [4] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9320343 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9320343 [5] does github-attack style injected javascript count?
- tptacek 12y agoThis analysis makes sense only if you believe the President can do whatever he wants in an executive order. Of course, he can't. Executive orders have only the flexibility allowed by Congress. You've read the text of the order, but not the laws its based on, and those laws contradict your analysis.
- pdkl95 12y agoThis is a good point, and may account for some of the vagueness I'm concerned about. I will have to do more reading.
- chubs 12y agoIs this related to China DDOS'ing the NY Times and Github a few days ago?
- DiabloD3 12y agoProbably, and I hate knee-jerk reactions like this.
- raquo 12y agoI don't think it's a knee-jerk reaction. For me it's easier to believe that this EO was signed deliberately to make every important security researcher guilty by default. It's hard to go against a government that can always punish you for what you have already done.
- BinaryIdiot 12y agoUnlikely; these things usually take some time to do (advisors provide feedback, multiple edit sessions likely, reviewed by lawyers, etc). I can't see them pulling this out so quickly...though I guess it's certainly possible just seems unlikely to me. I wonder if there is any data out there to show how long executive orders typically take from conception to execution.
- simonh 12y agoGiven how long it takes to formulate something like this, it's more likely to be a response to the Sony hack.
- deciplex 12y agoWell, I can paraphrase my own comment from the thread about Australian elections: You can slander everyone who discovers vulnerabilities in your software, and you can even lobby to make it illegal to disclose those vulnerabilities, and throw people in prison over it, and so on... and your software will go right on being vulnerable. You can put every security researcher and white hat in the world in prison on trumped-up charges and throw away the keys, and it will not make your software one bit more secure. It will probably make it a great deal less secure. Which is to say that this EO will accomplish exactly the opposite of its supposed goal. It's like, even if I convince every human being alive that I am not bound by the laws of gravity, if I jump off a cliff I will die all the same. To think otherwise is insane, but for some reason when it comes to software (and hardware) security we give people a pass. (Not we in the tech community, but we who vote.) This is one of the Big Problems with human reasoning. Maybe the biggest. It really does seem that most people, if you drill down, truly and fundamentally believe that the laws that govern all of reality, will respond to a popular vote. That if we all believe something hard enough, reality will take notice. Thus we get policy which is totally divorced from the goals it is purported to serve, and not held accountable to them at all. As though the President of the United States can argue with mathematics or psychology and win.
- shard972 12y ago> this executive order [does not] target the legitimate cybersecurity research community or professionals who help companies improve their cybersecurity Non-story, it's not targeted so I don't see why anyone would be against this unless maybe they are racist or love terrorism or something.
- sschueller 12y ago"We need to collect everything to protect you from terrorism. Trust us, we won't look at your dick pics."
- shiggerino 12y agoIf there was any genuine interest in making US systems more secure they would be more worried about making sure those systems don't succumb so easily to arbitrary strings of bytes sent over the network. The EO is completely pointless and toothless for any purpose BUT gaining an upper hand on legitimate security researchers.
- datashovel 12y agoWhen I read the executive order it appears to explicitly target people "outside the US". Basically the internet changes the paradigm of law enforcement. I get the impression this is a step toward allowing US to "penalize" people who actively seek to disrupt computers / networks in the US from abroad. If you spend too much time trying to figure out all the tiny details and put them into the eo this is where (a) you can waste time nitpicking instead of spending that time enforcing, (b) cases get thrown out of court on technicalities just because "this is what the law / eo says". Instead I prefer a system where executive / judicial branches of government can spend all their time analyzing a case based on the merits alone and not on the technical jargon that may or may not be included in the law / eo. I prefer the approach of "give the elected representatives a leash, but a short one". Spend less time agonizing over exactly what the law should say, and more time analyzing whether or not the law / eo is being enforced in good faith. The one exception to this rule is if you have (a) an overly broad law / executive order, and (b) an executive branch who is not transparent about how they enforce those laws / executive orders.
- akshatpradhan 12y ago>Spend less time agonizing over exactly what the law should say, and more time analyzing whether or not the law / eo is being enforced in good faith. The Patriot Act wasn't being enforced in good faith. In fact, the Patriot Act was being used for drug investigations, not terrorism. 303 points on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8536292 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8536292
- datashovel 12y agoThat's a perfect example of a situation where the feedback loop needs to be tightened in government. The more I think about it the more I feel governments should be alot more nimble than they have been historically. Alot more like an agile development team. There needs to be just as often "amendments to" or "repealing of" laws that aren't working as originally intended as there are signings of new laws. Instead we have in government the equivalent of a team of developers working on a project for months or maybe years nitpicking all the details before launching only to find that no one wants the product they spent all that time working on, or that it's out-dated, or impossible to maintain given all the complexity, or that it doesn't work on half the computers people try to run it on.
- nyar 12y agoDiscouraging hacking domestically it will widen the skill gap between foreign hackers and domestic white hats.
- atmosx 12y agoWhy? You can set a LAN on your VM and hack all you want. Do you really have to attack your neighbor?
- fla 12y agoIf you can't pratice defense / train on your grounds, isn't it giving your enemy an advantage ?
- jkot 12y agoPrisons are getting empty, it is time to start "war on hackers and pirates" :-(
- xnull2guest 12y agoA few others have mentioned this. The EO is tailored towards those outside the US and is a response to overwhelming cyber attacks. Sanctions are one of the US's tried and true international political weapons. They aren't going to be sanctioning US researchers, nor US-allied parties. The EFF seems to be confusing what is an EO targetting Chinese and Russian hackers and their funders with civil law? The EFF is normally very careful about these sorts of distinctions - so I'm very confused.
- tptacek 12y agoThe EFF's news sites are almost never careful about these distinctions. The EFF does some important work, but their online advocacy programs aren't part of it. EFF's layperson explanations of the law are almost uniformly misleading.
- Cyther606 12y agoIt has a clear purpose the public can get behind, but it will almost certainly be abused for persecuting domestic political rivals, software developers among them. Here are some entertaining thought exercises: A cyber 9/11 is linked to Bitcoin. Can Bitcoin developers be sanctioned? A cyber 9/11 is linked to Tor. Can Tor developers be sanctioned? You donate to Wikileaks, which is linked to a national security threat. Can you be sanctioned? Section 1(ii)(B) applies to _any_ individual or entity, domestic or abroad, developing or facilitating development of pentesting or related software employed against vague and faceless "national security interests". But don't you worry, because this is only applicable to the "Chinese" threat which may actually be true for the first couple of years to build political support for the eventual, predictable abuses of power.
- apsec112 12y agoShame on the EFF, which I normally support, for jumping on this bandwagon of terrible journalism. The EFF insinuates, without saying outright (since they must know it is false), that this is a law enforcement policy like the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. A law enforcement policy is one where, if you're sitting at your desk, and the government thinks you've hacked into someone's computer, the government throws you in jail. This executive order has nothing to do with domestic law enforcement, like Aaron Swartz or Kevin Mitnick or Dread Pirate Roberts or whatever. It is a foreign policy decision. The US maintains a public list, called the SDN list, of foreign entities that American citizens and companies aren't allowed to do business with. These are normally agents of governments the US doesn't like, eg. Iran and North Korea. This order adds hacking to the list of reasons why the President can put an entity on the SDN list. If, say, a Chinese defense contractor started hacking into American computers, the President can now prohibit American businesses from trading with them. Under this order, the only way you can go to jail (that you couldn't go to jail for before) is if a) the President suspects some foreign person or company (say, a Chinese defense contractor) of hacking; b) the President decides to put that company on the SDN list; c) you know that company is now on the SDN list; and d) you buy things from, sell things to, or otherwise do commercial business with that company. I think it's a bad idea for the executive to have the power to add people to the SDN list without judicial oversight. But they already had that power; this isn't really anything new. Claiming it is just confuses everybody.
- lazaroclapp 12y agoNot a lawyer, but sounds to me like Dread Pirate Roberts could still find himself on the wrong side of this sort of this EO: "Sec. 5. (a) Any transaction that evades or avoids, has the purpose of evading or avoiding, causes a violation of, or attempts to violate any of the prohibitions set forth in this order is prohibited" Broadly interpreted, wouldn't that be used against crypto-currency developers or secure communication tools developers that work on such tools with the knowledge that they can be used by sanctioned individuals or organizations? How about developers who write secure communication or security testing tools and sell them online without the ability or interest to verify who the purchaser is? The Patriot Act was also supposed to be about targeting only a few hostile foreign organizations, and yet it had massive implications for everyone living in the U.S. and abroad. Now, I get that an EO and a law are different things, but still, I can see potential implications of the general trend of the U.S. government seeing cybersecurity as something you throw sanctions and laws and deterrence at until it stops being an issue, without considering the potential collateral damage or overreach.
- kissickas 12y agoIt's hard to take an article seriously when they use the spelling "Whitehouse" in the title, and harder yet when they alternate between that and the (correct) White House within a single paragraph. I see there were two authors for the piece- wasn't there an editor? I would very much like to see a separation between the high-quality investigative journalism from the EFF and their opinion pieces, which I wouldn't mind if they were under that heading.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoIt may be time for a constitutional amendment forbidding the United States government from any action that would impact the Internet -- save those maintaining free and unencumbered flow. It'd be better for each of us to fight off APTs and other problems by ourselves than to head too far down the road of good intentions and unintended consequences.
- tptacek 12y agoIt shouldn't matter whether Section 1(ii)(B) restricts itself to foreign actors, because the underlying law that animates this executive order, the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (50 U.S.C. 1702) is limited to foreign transactions. In fact: it's kind of weird that they'd even raise the question. Fundamentally, the President can't make new laws, and they know that. He's exercising powers that Congress delegated to him, and he is limited by the scope of that delegation.