3 ms·
The difficulty is that when a risk pool goes from large to very large, the proportionate amount of necessary reserves does not decrease meaningfully, but the co
by 1123581321 12y ago
The difficulty is that when a risk pool goes from large to very large, the proportionate amount of necessary reserves does not decrease meaningfully, but the costs of managing the complexity of the relationships with all parties - employees, customers, providers - increase, in some cases, exponentially.
This suggests that a decentralized network of risk pools balanced near the optimal point between risking being too small and being too expensively and chaotically large would be more effective than a single payer.
The public-private system in the United States could function this well, but many factors prevent it from occurring, some by design and some due to context/inertia.
- maxxxxx 12y agoI don't see how insuring everybody increases complexity. If anything it should increase efficiency. Two more things should probably happen to make this work: - Eliminate employment-based insurance. Employers should be totally out of the loop - Have providers post the same price for everybody independently how they are insured Works pretty well in other counties
- jjoonathan 12y ago> when a risk pool goes from large to very large, the proportionate amount of necessary reserves does not decrease meaningfully What? Summed random fluctuations grow like sqrt(N), so per person risk "grows" (falls) like sqrt(N)/N. Larger population = less risk = lower cost of risk because the Law of Large Numbers is on your side. This is how casinos work. It's also why you aren't crushed to death by thermodynamic pressure fluctuations in the atmosphere. > the costs of managing the complexity of the relationships with all parties - employees, customers, providers - increase, in some cases, [grow] exponentially. The hell? Do you really mean to claim that having 5 different insurance companies and 100 different policies all with different paperwork is going to increase efficiency vs having one for everyone (nevermind the overhead of all the fighting over who pays, advertising, paying for access to capital, etc)? Neither common sense nor reality agrees: Medicare: 3.1% administrative overhead Private Health Insurance: 14.1% administrative overhead http://healthcarereform.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=004083 http://healthcarereform.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourc...
- 1123581321 12y agoYes, however, beyond a certain size, the returns of large numbers diminish, but other costs increase - both internally and externally. Medicare is a good example of a very large system that mostly has external costs. Due to the enormous complexity of the system it administers, its necessarily strict and automatic rules harm patients well beyond the ~11% cost savings difference you cite, and drive doctors whose diagnoses are too nuanced and studied away from Medicare patients towards more flexible insurers. However, Medicare doesn't risk financial catastrophe significantly more than Humana or Kaiser or even Google's self-insurance pool. Also, please do not preface comments with "what?" I understand you are trying to portray shock at how ignorant a comment I've made, but the content of your comment makes it unnecessary and it's rude.