4 ms·
""" Examine a typical antivirus package and you'll see it knows about 75,000+ viruses that might infect your machine. Compare that to the legitimate 30 or s
by jodrellblank 17y ago
""" Examine a typical antivirus package and you'll see it knows about 75,000+ viruses that might infect your machine. Compare that to the legitimate 30 or so apps that I've installed on my machine, and you can see it's rather dumb to try to track 75,000 pieces of Badness when even a simpleton could track 30 pieces of Goodness. In fact, if I were to simply track the 30 pieces of Goodness on my machine, and allow nothing else to run, I would have simultaneously solved the following problems:
* Spyware
* Viruses
* Remote Control Trojans
* Exploits that involve executing pre-installed code that you don't use regularly
Thanks to all the marketing hype around disclosing and announcing vulnerabilities, there are (according to some industry analysts) between 200 and 700 new pieces of Badness hitting the Internet every month. Not only is "Enumerating Badness" a dumb idea, it's gotten dumber during the few minutes of your time you've bequeathed me by reading this article. """
- http://www.ranum.com/security/computer_security/editorials/dumb/ http://www.ranum.com/security/computer_security/editorials/d...
- nuclear_eclipse 17y agoAs Bruce mentioned in his article: "And whitelists aren't a panacea, either: they don't defend against malware that attaches itself to data files (think Word macro viruses), for example."
- pragmatic 17y agoBut this should be a solved (or at least solveable problem). You have complete control over email in the enterprise b/c you control the mail server. If you use a service like gmail then you can't even send certain attachments. I couldn't send .zip files the last I checked. Plus spam filtering has gotten better. I think white-listing could go a very long way towards solving the problem.
- bockris 17y agoHmmm. I can send zip files through GMail. However, I can't receive zip files through my work email which is a policy decision made by our network admins. (You can rename it .zipX or something like that and it will go through. They have been burnt by users clicking on any random attachment and getting Trojans and viruses.) I don't seem to be able to send an exe through GMail though.
- pwmanagerdied 17y agoYou can send zips, you just can't send exes or zips including exes.
- nuclear_eclipse 17y agoWhat does email have to do with opening Word documents with macro viruses? What does email have to do with opening any data file that maliciously exploits the application opening the data file? How can a whitelist prevent attack vectors as varied as opening a PDF file designed to exploit your PDF reader? The user cannot always be vigilant enough to know that site X is giving him a malicious file to open. Hell, site X might actually be a legitimate site that has itself been attacked and exploited...
- barrkel 17y agoThere are a lot more than "30 or so" pieces of goodness. Applications (directly user-invoked executables) aren't the only vectors for malware and viruses. A quick scan of my Windows 7 installation - just the Windows directory - turns up about 17600 EXEs, DLLs and SYS files, which isn't an exhaustive list of potential module types. Any of those are subject to change on a monthly basis as updates get installed. And this doesn't even start counting applications, and their update and patch mechanisms.
- skolor 17y agoAnd you can't even say "Any 'good' application is only going to do certain sorts of actions. We'll scan those and if the application does something else, stop it". UAC in Windows 7 and Vista went a long way to making this better, at least if you're opening yourself to malware you usually have to click "I know this is doing something which could be dangerous", and 7 went a step farther by making it far more un-obtrusive so that users are less likely to auto-click it. Its still a losing battle though. Run http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/bb896645.aspx http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/bb896645.asp... for a few minutes, and look at how many actions are being taken, just when your computer is supposedly idle. Trying to whitelist each and every one of those would be massive overhead. I've found (personally, this isn't for everyone) is to run with as minimal AV as possible (Right now, SSE), and if I notice anything out of the ordinary run an offline virus scan. I usually do this with Bart-PE, although I've been working on another method for it. Expecting an infected OS to report that it is infected isn't the best idea, it is too easy to fake the results. Doing a scan of the system while the OS is not running tends to be more reliable and remove any problems a lot easier. I'm currently working on a system which will PXE boot once a month, do a virus scan or two (with different, fully updated scanners), defrag, checkdisk and do a general cleanup.
- inpoiun 17y ago>Any 'good' application is only going to do certain sorts of actions Like delete files, read files, contact websites, read keyb, send email? There might also be naughty reasons to do these things