3 ms·
> If the police can't get access to limited phone metadata with oversight, the solution is to give them a way to get limited phone metadata with oversight, not
by dragontamer 12y ago
> If the police can't get access to limited phone metadata with oversight, the solution is to give them a way to get limited phone metadata with oversight, not to give them access to all the phone metadata.
Did you read the business records provision?
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1861 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1861
Read it again. It requires the agencies to check off with a Judge. It already _has_ oversight built into it. If something is wrong with the oversight, then tell me what you think is wrong with it.
- Dylan16807 12y agoFrom what I have heard, requests even by normal law enforcement are often for unreasonable amounts of data, and data is held onto and used for things other than the case they were requested for without oversight. In addition, the NSA collects data before asking for permission. And I am doubtful that their oversight is effective. But I don't want to argue about it for hours. I just want less metadata to be collected. Because even without the government it gets abused.
- dragontamer 12y ago> In addition, the NSA collects data before asking for permission. And I am doubtful that their oversight is effective. Snowden's first revealed document was the court order where the NSA / FBI was asking for permission from the FISA courts. Now I don't think you've even read Snowden's docs. > But I don't want to argue about it for hours. Fair enough. I hope that in our short discussion, you learned how things actually work. > I just want less metadata to be collected. Because even without the government it gets abused. You're welcome to have your opinion, but your opinion was tainted by horribly inaccurate facts. I thank you for being a good sport and listening to me through this. In any case, now you know the specific law that grants the powers. You can now write to a Senator / House Representative and argue specifically against the law on your own. Even if you are on the "other side" of this debate, we Americans are much better off when all sides understand the debate. Our political system also works out well when discussions like what you and I just had happen more often. Summary: Business Records Provision of the Patriot Act. Know it well, so you can criticize it. Take it down and the metadata of the NSA should fall. Good luck on the political battlefield. Again, thank you for working with me in this debate.
- Dylan16807 12y ago>Snowden's first revealed document Okay I'll be more specific. Without specific permission pertaining to a specific case, they collect whatever they feel like to sort out later. I don't like that. >I hope that in our short discussion, you learned how things actually work. I learned there has been more access to metadata than I previously thought, but my main worry is and has been the exploding amount of metadata and analysis, which I do have a pretty good grasp on. Thanks for the discussion.
- dragontamer 12y agoI know we want to close the discussion, but let me note one more thing. > Okay I'll be more specific. Without specific permission pertaining to a specific case, they collect whatever they feel like to sort out later. I don't like that. How do you expect the Police to go after a swatter then? The creation of 'nameless warrants' is looked down upon in general, and is grossly illegal in many jurisdictions. You cannot get a warrant unless a specific person is named. Without a warrant, police cannot continue investigating. Police need access to the metadata to get a name so that they can get a warrant. I know John Doe warrants exist, but their use is highly criticized. And it should be! We can't have the police getting nameless warrants regularly. With that said, we have to give the Police enough room to maneuver so that they can build a case before they are granted the high-powers of a warrant. The Fourth Amendment promises _due process_. Metadata, in my opinion is a "reasonable" search. Or at least, we should _define_ metadata as the part that can be reasonably searched. (After all, not all data is innately private. The data that is "public" should be easily searched by the Police without warrants). The debate really should be about determining which bits of data are "public" and which bits aren't.
- Dylan16807 12y ago>How do you expect the Police to go after a swatter then? The creation of 'nameless warrants' is looked down upon in general, and is grossly illegal in many jurisdictions. Well we're talking about a 'nameless warrant' to only access something they could access at-will before, so I don't see that as a real problem. >we should _define_ metadata as the part that can be reasonably searched. That sounds like a mess. Metadata has a pretty clear meaning already when it comes to communication. >The debate really should be about determining which bits of data are "public" and which bits aren't. Maybe, but things are much more complicated than public and not public.
- rosser 12y agoIf you're seriously suggesting that FISA is some kind of check on the use/abuse of the government's surveillance powers, you're either a shill, or deluded.
- dragontamer 12y agoAnd if that is where you stop your argument, then you aren't helpful at all. Why don't you trust FISA? And if you don't trust it, what reforms to the FISA courts are you proposing? Or are you just a lazy armchair protester who doesn't even think about how to improve the world around you? Hey look, I can fling insults at you too and be unhelpful!! Seriously, the FISA system is documented, and it is part of the debate. Do you actually have an argument, or are you just gonna leave it there?
- nbouscal 12y agoSince 1979, out of 33,949 requests submitted, the FISA court has denied 12 of them, 4 of which were later partially granted after being resubmitted. You're correct in saying that it's good that this number is documented, but it also makes it extremely clear that the FISA court cannot be meaningfully said to constitute independent oversight.
- dragontamer 12y agoOr it makes it clear that the NSA is in fact, following the law. Which as far as I'm aware, none of what has been revealed by Snowden has been shown to be illegal. Correct me if I'm wrong of course.
- rosser 12y agoIrrespective of whether or not you're wrong, when the law is practically a blank check, staying within its bounds isn't much of an accomplishment.
- rosser 12y agoAt a minimum, I'd like something enabling me to trust that FISA isn't just the rubber stamp it has every appearance of being. It has denied less than 0.035% of the requests ever submitted to it (and a third of those were subsequently at least partially granted, anyway), and "modified" (where "modification" appears to be a request for clarification, given the public remarks one former FISA judge made on the subject) less than 1.5% of them. As "oversight" goes, that sounds rather a lot like, "That's nice, son. You run along and play, now..." Almost all of the sitting members of the court are former law enforcement in some way, and many of them have evinced strongly statist and authoritarian views in the rulings they've made in the trial courts they also sit in. So I'd also like to see some membership on the panel that doesn't seem hand-picked to yes-man (nearly) every request that comes along. I'm not suggesting this as a definitive proposal for changing the court, but what about including members from (or elected by) demonstrably pro-liberty organizations like the EFF or ACLU or whatever, with some kind of veto-like power? I legitimately believe that there is value in being able to investigate suspected "bad" actors — and that sometimes those investigations must be surreptitious, or that actor will become aware of the suspicion and change his behavior. I don't buy the leap from that being the case to, "We can look into anyone at any time for any reason, or no reason at all, and then use whatever we find against you down the road, or hand it off to sibling agencies for 'parallel construction' type purposes." (And don't even try to suggest that doesn't happen. We know it does.) So there's two thoughts off the top of my head.