4 ms·
>> The actual problems with health insurance markets have less to do with information asymmetry and adverse selection than with too much information. That can m
by phkahler 12y ago
>> The actual problems with health insurance markets have less to do with information asymmetry and adverse selection than with too much information. That can make some people’s insurance very expensive at actuarially sound rates. For instance if you have a cancer of a given kind, this is verifiable to the outside world, and if the treatment costs are $200,000, the cost of an insurance policy will in turn be about $200,000. Buying the policy won’t be cheaper than buying the treatments, and in that sense the market for insurance is not always present. That is a very real public policy problem, but it is not well understood by invoking standard theories of asymmetric information.
I think the problem with insurance is too much competition. With a single provider there is no incentive to lock people out. The entire point of insurance is to amortize unexpected costs over time and population. In a market with multiple providers and people changing providers there is a financial incentive to exclude higher cost individuals rather than just spread the cost of treatment over everyone. This is not an argument in favor of any particular system, just pointing out a problem with the notion of free market insurance plans. There are plenty of problems with every solution.
- maxxxxx 12y agothere should just be one country-wide insurance pool. No company insurance pools or any other insurance through groups. that way risk gets spread out nicely. And I think administrative costs would be much lower.
- ticviking 12y agoI believe that is called universal healthcare...
- maxxxxx 12y agoNot necessarily. There can also be private companies that offer insurance for all citizens.
- 1123581321 12y agoThe difficulty is that when a risk pool goes from large to very large, the proportionate amount of necessary reserves does not decrease meaningfully, but the costs of managing the complexity of the relationships with all parties - employees, customers, providers - increase, in some cases, exponentially. This suggests that a decentralized network of risk pools balanced near the optimal point between risking being too small and being too expensively and chaotically large would be more effective than a single payer. The public-private system in the United States could function this well, but many factors prevent it from occurring, some by design and some due to context/inertia.
- maxxxxx 12y agoI don't see how insuring everybody increases complexity. If anything it should increase efficiency. Two more things should probably happen to make this work: - Eliminate employment-based insurance. Employers should be totally out of the loop - Have providers post the same price for everybody independently how they are insured Works pretty well in other counties
- jjoonathan 12y ago> when a risk pool goes from large to very large, the proportionate amount of necessary reserves does not decrease meaningfully What? Summed random fluctuations grow like sqrt(N), so per person risk "grows" (falls) like sqrt(N)/N. Larger population = less risk = lower cost of risk because the Law of Large Numbers is on your side. This is how casinos work. It's also why you aren't crushed to death by thermodynamic pressure fluctuations in the atmosphere. > the costs of managing the complexity of the relationships with all parties - employees, customers, providers - increase, in some cases, [grow] exponentially. The hell? Do you really mean to claim that having 5 different insurance companies and 100 different policies all with different paperwork is going to increase efficiency vs having one for everyone (nevermind the overhead of all the fighting over who pays, advertising, paying for access to capital, etc)? Neither common sense nor reality agrees: Medicare: 3.1% administrative overhead Private Health Insurance: 14.1% administrative overhead http://healthcarereform.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=004083 http://healthcarereform.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourc...
- phkahler 12y ago>> No company insurance pools or any other insurance through groups Agreed. Company pools consist of healthier people since they specifically exclude those who can't work or are retired. This actually increase the per-person cost of medicaid vs having everyone on it. Of course we working folks get a better deal now when we don't actually need it.
- lotsofpulp 12y agoI think the problem with "health insurance" is that the purpose of insurance is at not compatible with the goal of providing healthcare to everyone. Insurance is a mechanism for spreading the costs of unknown events with some probability distribution. Out of a population, most of the population will not experience an event (e.g. a car crash), but individuals in the population cannot afford the consequences so they buy insurance where a group of people figure out the probability distribution and how much they need to charge to maintain adequate reserves and pay themselves. On the other hand, healthcare is an event with 100% probability and ridiculously high costs. People's bodies will break down, they will also stay alive for a long time needing expensive medications, and newer, more expensive treatments will be developed to keep people alive even longer. This is not what insurance is made for, and our current health insurance industry is not even real health insurance. It's more like "pay $x a month to get access to negotiated pricing at certain medical facilities and pharmacies". The real solution is for the country to figure out A) does everyone deserve to live, and if so, are the citizens willing to pay for it in taxes B) figure out how much of people's healthcare should be subsidized and start triage
- rm445 12y agoIn the real world as it stands, there isn't a 100% probability of ridiculously high costs. Plenty of us will go out with a bang in some way, or at least quietly and quickly. (Perhaps that isn't the utopian ideal). The whole system could be reasonably modelled as personal saving for significant expected costs plus insurance against the really big hitters - I read a rather breathless article singing the praises of Singapore for organising things this way. That doesn't really change for a national system except the country self-insures against the expensive illnesses. I agree wholeheartedly with your last paragraph, but while national health systems probably look nice from the vantage point of the USA, it hasn't really been tested whether such systems will hold together - whether the populace has the will to pay the real costs - in a world that keeps moving in the direction of longer lives with more expensive care.
- lotsofpulp 12y agoEven though I know that it's not exactly 100%, I assumed it since factoring in end of life costs like ambulance, emergency room procedures for resuscitation and whatnot would probably apply to so many people that for the ones that go out without cost is inconsequential, e.g. falling off a bridge or something. And if most people can't even save for a rainy day fund, how can we expect them to save for diabetes and hypertension and dialysis meds that cost hundreds or thousands of dollars? The funny thing is that in the US, we have some stupid hybrid taxpayer/insurance subsidized healthcare scheme called Medicaid, but only if you're old. Bottom line is the US public thinks it's unconscionable (or politically untenable) to deny healthcare if someone is dying, but not in any other situation, and at the same time thinks people should be responsible for providing for themselves, which at current healthcare costs is simply not going to happen.