3 ms·
> 1. It was not free game. They could not take copies preemptively. Wrong. http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/04/us/monitoring-of-snail-mail.html?_r=0 http://www
by dragontamer 12y ago
> 1. It was not free game. They could not take copies preemptively.
Wrong.
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/04/us/monitoring-of-snail-mail.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/07/04/us/monitoring-of-snail-mai...
It's been free-game for a hundred years. Keep up with the law dude. USPS "metadata" has been copied and tracked. Such information was used for the Anthrax cases of early 2000s... and other such crimes.
It is illegal for police to read the contents of an envelope, but they can (and have been) scanning the outside of envelopes and storing that metadata for police use for decades.
The difference between snail-mail and the business records provision is... terrorism was added to the words. But I'd bet what they were doing was legal before the Patriot Act was made.
> 2. There is vastly more metadata being stored now, and the police don't need access to most of it. We might even be better off with laws against storing it.
That doesn't answer the question. How do you expect to track down a Swatter without using metadata?
- Dylan16807 12y agoOkay, doing it for decades doesn't mean they need it. It wasn't there from the start. >How do you expect to track down a Swatter without using metadata? As I said in my other post, you don't actually need call records to find a swatter. They called the police, the police have the number, tada. I'm not arguing against deleting everything that could possibly classify as metadata, I'm saying we should cut down the types of metadata available. And we need to stop the government from making copies of private data 'just in case' and declaring it not to be a search/seizure until some later stage.
- dragontamer 12y ago> As I said in my other post, you don't actually need call records to find a swatter. They called the police, the police have the number, tada. And if the Swatter used another phone to call a Google Voice number to create a local line in another city, they will need Metadata to figure out what that _OTHER_ telephone number is. Otherwise, they have a phone number to a fake google-account created in TOR. That's not very useful. Phone Number 555-0000 called Google-Voice 555-9991, which THEN called the Police. Only having "555-9991" is completely worthless. You need metadata analysis to unravel the proxies. Furthermore, executing a warrant generally requires a name and a case. You don't got a name yet, you're trying to build a case without warrant powers at this point of the Police game. Do you think these Swatters are dumb or something? They aren't using their personal phone numbers to call the police, they're actually redirecting themselves a little bit. > I'm not arguing against deleting everything that could possibly classify as metadata, I'm saying we should cut down the types of metadata available. And we need to stop the government from making copies of private data 'just in case' and declaring it not to be a search/seizure until some later stage. The legal standard between 1940s (since the closure of the Office of Censorship, which straight up allowed the US Agents to read mail and censor them), and now has been that metadata collection doesn't need a warrant. Metadata collection is NOT search/seizure in Smith v. Maryland. Its how things have operated for literally decades. Now if you don't like it, that's fine. But know that you're moving from the status-quo. This is how the government has operated since the 1970s at very least (see again... Smith v. Maryland). Going back to the cases before that was Olmstead v. United States, 1928, which collection of straight-up data was considered not search/seizure btw. (So we've actually cut back upon collection from a historical perspective. Police powers were greater in the 1920s than today)
- Dylan16807 12y agoOkay, you have a point, but that's about proxies, not normal calls between two people. If the police can't get access to limited phone metadata with oversight, the solution is to give them a way to get limited phone metadata with oversight, not to give them access to all the phone metadata. >Now if you don't like it, that's fine. But know that you're moving from the status-quo. This is how the government has operated since the 1970s at very least Fine, I want a change from the status quo. But it's not just that, I'm saying two things. 1. It is important that metadata (and data) collection does not expand because of the ease of technology. 2. I would prefer metadata collection to be rolled back a few decades and limited. It's 1 that really worries me, and no amount of historical collection is going to comfort that. Thanks for the disappointing enlightenment.
- dragontamer 12y ago> If the police can't get access to limited phone metadata with oversight, the solution is to give them a way to get limited phone metadata with oversight, not to give them access to all the phone metadata. Did you read the business records provision? https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1861 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1861 Read it again. It requires the agencies to check off with a Judge. It already _has_ oversight built into it. If something is wrong with the oversight, then tell me what you think is wrong with it.
- Dylan16807 12y agoFrom what I have heard, requests even by normal law enforcement are often for unreasonable amounts of data, and data is held onto and used for things other than the case they were requested for without oversight. In addition, the NSA collects data before asking for permission. And I am doubtful that their oversight is effective. But I don't want to argue about it for hours. I just want less metadata to be collected. Because even without the government it gets abused.
- dragontamer 12y ago