6 ms·
The Great Filter – Are We Almost Past It? (1998)
- Mahn 12y agoAnother argument against the great filter, and one I'm surprised it's not considered more often, is the relativity of the space and time. We assume, long story short, that the colonization explosion is rare because we can't see it, but what if all that we can observe in terms of space and time is a incredibly "microscopic" slice compared to all that there is/has been/will be out there? The way I see it it looks like we've concluded water must be commonplace on earth, but then we act puzzled when we can't find a lake down the street and assume water must be rarer than we thought.
- jeremyjh 12y agoWe're only talking about what we can observe. Just a few dozen billions of stars. That is sufficient for the Fermi paradox.
- Mahn 12y ago> That is sufficient for the Fermi paradox. Is it? How do we know it is?
- has2k1 12y agoThe Fermi paradox is based on the vastness of we can observe. It says nothing about that which may exist beyond (not hidden) what we observe.
- taygetea 12y agoThe terms we know in the Drake equation make it very difficult to say it is unlikely for intelligence to arise more than once. ~100 billion stars * ~100 billion galaxies in the observable universe. Exoplanet surveys seem to be suggesting at least one planet per star on average. In addition, chemical self replication seems to happen fairly easily given the right chemical conditions, which don't appear to require much more than liquid water.
- exratione 12y agoTwo things to bear in mind when thinking about the Fermi paradox: 1) The more important observation is that everything we see is a wilderness of apparently natural origins and processes, not that we have apparently not been visited. 2) No hypothesis involving choice that leads to failure to carry out self-replicating colonization can explain (1). All it takes is one small group in one sufficiently advanced species. This rules out wolves, berserkers, relinquishment, self-destruction, and so on and so forth. Clearly something is missing or incorrect in how the pieces of the various sciences fit together to explain what we see. Some of the best reading on the subject is speculation on what it is that we don't know or the relative odds on where the present consensus is incorrect.
- chevman 12y agoCan you suggest some of your favorite speculations? Or links to other material?
- Zigurd 12y agoThere remain some big tests, among them: Can we accumulate and release enough energy to take us to the stars without having a civilization-ending war with ultra-destructive directed energy weapons? Can we avoid mistakes in modifying life, and in nanotech, that would cover the planet in goo? Can we master germline modifications of humans without doing something that ends with no humans, and no post-humans? So plenty of filter to go yet. Never mind the smaller-scale "do we have way too many humans already to not overheat the planet we're on?" questions.
- wyager 12y ago>Can we accumulate and release enough energy to take us to the stars without having a civilization-ending war This is why, if I invented antimatter production, I would absolutely demand that it not be used on Earth until it had been used to send hundreds of human-bearing seed ships to other solar systems. The risk is too great.
- Udo 12y agoThere is a disconnect between these two statements: "No alien civilizations have substantially colonized our solar system or systems nearby. Thus among the billion trillion stars in our past universe, none has reached the level of technology and growth that we may soon reach." While the article is in a way all about exploring that disconnect, it's a bit strange to find it written down so explicitly in the conclusion. We can ascribe a very high level of confidence to hypothesis that neither our own nor any of the directly neighboring star systems have been colonized. But to postulate that therefore the universe has not yet produced a civilization as technologically sophisticated as our own is still a non-sequitur, at least in my opinion. The article also makes a lot of assumptions (it has to!), some plausible, some seemingly arbitrary, which might in the end not be important factors at all. For example, any consideration about radio communication must be on very shaky grounds, in particular when charting the absence of it. The reason why we're not seeing alien neighbors or predecessors (which would be "neighbors" in time), might well be a combination of factors. While we can exclude certain scenarios, such as a cloud of Von Neuman Probes eating the galaxy, it still leaves room for a lot of little factors that can change the galactic stage for us in a fundamental way - especially if they work in conjunction. For example, the average duration of the technologically recognizable phase a civilization goes through may be smaller, and there may well be less of them than expected. In addition, willful avoidance or isolation may well play a role; the zoo hypothesis is an extreme example of this, but in a sparse cosmos the measures you have to undertake in order to isolate an emerging civilizations become less heroic. It's also worth mentioning that we ourselves are not past the Filter by any means. In fact, as time progresses, it seems to become less likely we'll ever move off the Earth as an exclusive habitat. Part of this is due to psychology, we could have made it happen by now but didn't. The best bet at becoming an interstellar civilization right now seems to be to wait until we're pure computer systems, unburdened by aging and the passage of time, but that development, too, might end up being something we never elect to actually pursue. Luckily, this whole thing is a mystery we can solve over time, just by gathering data about what's out there.
- Retra 12y agoThe 'soonness' of our interplanetary colonization is really not safe to assume. The obstacles to self-sustaining life on other worlds are not insignificant -- in fact, they are the explanation for why there is no life there to begin with.
- tomjen3 12y agoI forgot who came up with the idea, but the great filter may not exist - it is just that an intergalactic civilisation wouldn't be using radio communication (due to the lag because of the slow speed of light). Or the put it a bit different: unless the Culture want us to see it, we won't.
- jeremyjh 12y agoWhy aren't they building Dyson spheres?
- tomjen3 12y agoThat is a really good question. The thing is that if they are powerful enough to actually do that, perhaps they have come up with something better? I mean there could easily be a couple 1000 years between us, which means that the difference is at least as great as us and the Romans. The Romans might very well question why we weren't breeding more horses then, since we have such a huge need of transport and horses are the best way to do that.
- krapp 12y agoMaybe it turns out Dyson spheres are a bad idea for some reason? Maybe Dyson spheres are out there, but constructed in such a way that they don't look obvious to a distant observer? Maybe the idea that advanced civilizations exponentially consuming energy as per the Kardashev Scale is a flawed and anthropocentric premise based entirely on what we know of our own civilization, and a lack of observable stellar engineering doesn't necessarily mean a lack of advanced life?
- guard-of-terra 12y agoMaybe there's a lot of lower hanging fruits in the galaxy energy-wise than building Dyson shperes.
- PeterWhittaker 12y agoWe suffer from hubris when we label it the "Fermi paradox": It implies that somehow we are interesting, worth visiting. If we are, it may well be as a cautionary tale or for tourism. Consider the energy and material engineering necessary to achieve long-distance space transport of any sizable amount of people, equipment, and supplies. Regardless of whether the transport is subluminal or FTL, the energy requirements are tremendous and the engineering requirements for a durable vessel astounding. My guess is that by the time our materials science and our energy production are up to the task, our interests may well have changed - because (and here I speculate wildly) science at engineering at that level will reveal so much about the fundamental nature of the universe and give us so much interesting practical technology that biochemical life clinging desperately to lucky rocks in the lucky zone won't be near so interesting anymore. No one comes near because we have nothing to offer those able to come near and get home again to report what they found. As to simply detecting signals, we have to consider how lucky we are to have so much ore so close to the surface: Metallurgy and eventually radiated communications were a natural for us. Other civilizations may well start with fantastically engineered wood and eventually plastics, and go all-fibre, all line-of-sight, and have very, very different communications systems, systems undetectable at any remove.
- golergka 12y agoObligatory: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tScAyNaRdQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tScAyNaRdQ
- elorant 12y agoYour argument is kind of contradictory. It assumes that we are not worthy of visiting but an argument like that suggests that they’ve already found us and interstellar travel is feasible. They’ve also solved all the logistic problems you’re referring to. Whether they like to make contact or not is somewhat irrelevant to this context. For the sake of argument let’s linger on that assumption for a while. How for example did they found us when our civilization achieved radio signals transmission in the last couple of centuries? That means that they’re close by, unless FTL travel is feasible in which case we can safely assume the whole galaxy should be teeming with life. But if they’re close by shouldn’t we be able to spot them? And if they’re far away that means they should already have colonized half the galaxy before they decide to launch an expedition to a planet thousands of light years away. The worrying factor relating to the “Fermi Paradox” is that it suggests that maybe life is extremely rare. We could very well be the only living souls in this part of the Universe and that’s kind of heart breaking considering the sheer size of the whole thing. By the way, your assumption is called the "Zoo Hypothesis" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoo_hypothesis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zoo_hypothesis Oh, and while we're in this scenario I'd urge everyone to read the following SF short. http://www.terrybisson.com/page6/page6.html http://www.terrybisson.com/page6/page6.html
- berntb 12y agoI miss one aspect in the article? If space investment/exploration had continued in the 70s (with or without an Orion project) then by now, we would have lots of infrastructure outside the atmosphere. I.e., a large subset of species around our level of industrial advancement ought to be close to "planetary breakout". The point is, a Great Filter for intelligent species at our technology level would need to sterilize a whole solar system, not only on a planet. Otherwise it would miss, say, somewhere between one and ten percents of the civilizations. So I'd guess we're past the filter. Of course, possible filters that clean out a solar system do exist. Another species could soon wipe us out (any single galaxy just needs one early xenophobic and crazy species). Or e.g. unknown physics in a particle accelerator experiment will have very unexpected effects for the whole solar system, very soon...
- api 12y agoWe are provably not beyond the great filter. At least one great filter lies tangibly in front of us: ecological sustainability. Barring several fairly large changes to our energy and resource systems, our civilization is mathematically and physically guaranteed to collapse within the next 200 years at most. That's not a hypothetical filter. It's a real one that we can see, and we are not past it.
- zachalexander 12y agoThis is a great point – which I would paraphrase as, let's not worry about cosmic filters when we have a very tangible filter in front of us – but it doesn't follow that we're "provably not beyond the great filter". The Great Filter is just the thing that explains most of why intelligent life is (or seems) so rare in the universe. It could be true, for example, that some cosmic event kills life before it becomes technological 99% of the time (= Great Filter), and also that, say, 60% of technological civilizations destroy themselves via destroying their environment.
- api 12y agoGiven that we have only one known example of intelligent life, we are the only thing we can base any predictions upon. Given that we have a provable filter in front of us, I think it's reasonable to assume that similar situations might occur elsewhere in the universe: (1) An intelligence reaches a critical intellectual mass and begins to utilize the free resources that are present in its environment. (2) In doing so it grows and develops exponentially. (3) By the time it develops far enough intellectually to realize the problem -- exponential growth built on finite non-replenishable supply -- it's already too late. We seem to have realized this problem around 1950-1970, and we have done very little about it so far. That's because huge complex systems are hard to change, and all the incentives point the wrong way.
- zachalexander 12y agoSure, but that's just a case for "ecological sustainability is a reasonable candidate for the GF based on what we know about ourselves." Which is a weaker statement than "we are provably beyond the GF". Provable implies strong evidence and certainty.
- je_bailey 12y agoAmong other comments here, there is the question of why? Why does a civilization need to expand? Why should it? We can already see in our world where the birthrates start to decline in societies that have a certain level of technology and quality of live. When we reach a point where our whims are catered for and energy is cheap. Reproduction doesn't seem very cost effective.
- killnine 12y agoAt least for me, it's because all of our eggs are in one basket at the moment. Loosing this rock or our star essentially equals the extinction of our species.
- convexfunction 12y agoIt makes sense that we'd expect to observe civilizations that are good at growing and have in fact already grown, right? Same reason we observe animals with a strong sense of self-preservation. These hypothetical expanding civilizations might be awful or unnecessary by our standards but that doesn't change how memetic/biological/whatever selection processes generally work. This is why the Fermi Paradox is interesting in the first place!
- has2k1 12y agoExpansion can be due to a lot more than mere birthrates. First and foremost expansion will happen only when there is means to do so. And, 'means' can be driven by a combination of curiosity and necessity. On earth people have gone somewhere far off (migrated), because there was the place to go and the means to get there. In many cases that (migration) was the option over having to fight (or find some form of accommodation) within the local social & political system. If this is why an intelligence can spread out on a planet, couldn't other intelligences (if they exist) spread out for similar reasons in the galaxy.
- sgt101 12y agoThere is a review in the FT today of "The Future of Violence" a book in which the authors apparently (I haven't read it) assert that as technology improves the risk of a violent individual to society increases (because that person has more leverage). This raises an interesting problem : to make it as a society may require a high level of dynamism and aggression. To cope as a society (as technology becomes more potent) passivity and sensitivity may be necessary. It may be that there is no balance, and that if you have enough vim to create a technical society you will reach a point where progress becomes impossible due to progress so far.