9 ms·
A Grand Juror Speaks: The inside story of how prosecutors always get their way
- PaulAJ 12y agoAmerica has systematically stripped judges of their authority to make judgements. This was done partly to ramp up sentencing due to fear of crime, and partly to make justice more even-handed. The latter is not an unreasonable goal; skin colour is well known for biasing all sorts of people, and other things can do too: http://www.economist.com/node/18557594 http://www.economist.com/node/18557594 Unfortunately this power of arbitrary judgement has not gone away. Instead it has been handed to prosecutors. In the past, if the judge thought a prosecutor was unfairly throwing the book at a felon then he or she could hand down a sentence in line with the facts rather than the charge sheet. Now this is not possible. Its up to the prosecutors to decide how long the charge sheet is, and its the charge sheet that determines the sentence.
- cmdrfred 12y agoJudges have also been known to threaten anyone with jail who suggests jury nullification is a possibility. It seems pretty clear that it was the sort of thing the founding fathers intended when the created the system, but never the less if it takes away from the judges and prosecutors power they will fight it tooth and nail. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification_in_the_Unite...
- mellavora 12y agoAgreed. Part of the purpose of a trial by a jury of your peers in your own state of residence is that the jury is to decide if the law is fair, or fairly applied.
- Karunamon 12y agoI'm sorry, but that's a rather inaccurate view as to the justification for jury nullification. It is not a thing that's directly provided for in the law, it's a confluence of two legal principles: juries can't be held liable for their decisions, and the prohibition against double jeopardy. There's also the problem that that when people are told about nullification, they consider evidence less than they otherwise would. In other words, i'd argue that there are some very good reasons for this setup, as inconsistent and illogical as it sounds. Great video that explains this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqH_Y1TupoQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uqH_Y1TupoQ
- dantheman 12y agoThis wouldn't be a problem if people actually went to trial. This whole concept of plea bargaining is immoral - we can't say you have a right to trial by jury, but if you exercise that right you run the risk of having the charges be 10x the plea bargain. If the plea bargain is enough to provide justice, then that's what the defendant should face in court.
- limeyx 12y agoIndeed. Sickening
- researcher88 12y agoEven Justin Bieber took a plea deal in his DUI case when it appears his BAC was .014 and the cops lied or exaggerated the facts during the arrest. Perhaps he was still guilty of reckless driving but there's no consequences for the cop who seems to have lied. He likely could had won the case or forced the prosecutor to drop the charges. Beyond facing a greater sentence, to fight the most minor of misdemeanor charges will cost $2,000 to $5,000 for a lawyer or just pay $250 and get it reduced to an infraction like jaywalking. It makes a mockery of the idea of justice.
- EGreg 12y agoI think the whole system of inadmissible evidence and plea bargains is unfair and dishonest. If a cop decides to lie or break into a house, what they find should be admissible, but they should also face the consequences of breaking and entering, armed robbery or whatever. In fact, these consequences would be more severe for public servants like cops. If the cop wants to lie to get a conviction, they should be able to do it BUT also pay for their lie. The mitigating circumstances would be considered and the cop might get off with less, but they should be under the same law as everybody else! If they want to get the guy so bad that they are willing to face prison themselves for a few years for entering without a warrant to photograph the smoking gun, they should be able to do it. This way the truth and justice actually wins out. As opposed to murderers getting off on a technicality or cops lying with impunity and ruining innocent people's lives. Of course, the above would still not obviate the need for entrapment defense etc.
- ghaff 12y agoIn addition to grand juries being, as the article says, mostly a "minor procedural hassle" to prosecutors they're also a significant imposition on citizens serving on them. I suspect that most people who really don't want to serve can get out of serving. (When I got called for duty, at least most of the slots were filled by people who either essentially volunteered or at least said they weren't opposed to serving.) However, depending on the individual state, juries are impaneled for some number of months and may meet for most days. Compensation is minimal; in Massachusetts, it's $50 per day. And federal grand juries are impaneled for 18 months I believe.
- revelation 12y agoThis is of course a major problem in and of itself. The (grand) jury system selects for people that are either too stupid or indifferent to getting out of duty.
- ghaff 12y agoI'm not sure "too stupid or indifferent" is quite fair. You have retirees who see it as a change of pace or just people who feel strongly about their civic duty (and whose companies will presumably continue to pay their salaries). That said, it's absolutely fair to say that it's far from a random slice of the population to an even greater degree that juries in general. I suspect that most (but not all) US readers on this site would try fairly hard to get out of a three month, five day a week grand jury commitment.
- Spooky23 12y agoGrand Jury service is usually one day a week for a few months. In my case, it was 8 weeks, and we were frequently dismissed before the end of the day. If your employer doesn't suck and pays you your normal salary, it's not a significant hardship. I've found my jury service in all instances a fascinating and educational experience the was worthwhile in the end.
- ghaff 12y ago
- csandreasen 12y agoI think this article glosses over the purpose of the grand jury - the grand jury doesn't vote to convict, they vote on whether or not to indict. The entire purpose is to prevent people from being harassed by prosecutors. They review all of the evidence that the prosecutor has gathered and determine if it's sufficient to send people to trial. If the prosecutor has compelling evidence, then they go to trial and both sides present their case. If not, the defendant never goes to trial to begin with.
- falcolas 12y agoThe problem with this assertion is that it implies that cases go to trial. Most never do: the charges are used with the threat of extended imprisonment to secure plea bargains. Since most never see trial, the Grand Jury is the closest to a "trial by peers" that most accused will ever face.
- notahacker 12y agoThe problem is with the post-indictment actions of prosecutors rather than the way grand juries are set up though. It's certainly within the realms of possibility to introduce legislation which limits the scope of plea bargains though (most likely by preventing prosecutors from pursuing charges and sentencing options they have indicated a willingness to drop in return for a guilty plea for a significantly lesser offence)
- whichfawkes 12y agoI may be misunderstanding, but that sounds a little off. Suppose that Some Guy has been arrested for having some marijuana, and at the time of his arrest, he also had a plastic ziplock bag in his possession. This case gets taken to the Grand Jury and they indict the guy for possession of marijuana, and dealing marijuana. At this point, the prosecutor could potentially offer some different plea deals: -1) "Plead guilty to possession, and we drop the dealing/distribution" -2) "Plead guilty to both, and we change the sentence from 5 years to 1 year." Are you suggesting that in case 1, once the prosecutor has offered that deal, that the prosecutor can no longer pursue the dealing/distribution charge, and that in case 2 the prosecutor can no longer pursue a sentence longer than 1 year? At that point, what purpose does a plea deal serve? As the indicted, you'd be a fool to accept the plea deal since you're guaranteeing the (now) worst outcome of the trial for yourself. As a prosecutor who knows that, you probably won't bother to offer any plea deals. I don't know if this is necessarily a problem...but then why not just get rid of the concept of a plea-deal? The conceptually more pleasing solution would be to see the grand jury not indict for the distribution charge in the first place, because of the lack of real evidence (a plastic baggie does not a dealer make). In that situation, the prosecutor cannot attempt to trump up charges to motivate a plea-deal. Of course, I don't know how you actually fix that...
- CHY872 12y agoVery interesting. It's intriguing how the ideals seem to remain in the procedure, whilst the enactment of the 'justice' differs wildly from that envisaged. To me, 90% felony plea-bargains would imply that the grand juries are doing an awful job; it suggests that they're bringing many charges that they don't think they can win. This is presumably one of those tragedy-of-the-commons type situations; if everyone decided to only charge fairly, there'd be less incentives for plea bargains, immediately all of the courts would be clogged, there'd be congressional attention, probably more funding, perhaps procedural shortcuts and it would eventually end up more fair for everyone. In the meantime, any one prosecutor who decides to do this simply ends up massively dropping their conviction rate and presumably losing their job. So they won't do it (and I don't blame them!). My guess is that what this needs is a large campaign from activists to pressure congress into making the changes on their own. That'll be really difficult.
- Zigurd 12y agoOr remove immunity from liability from prosecutors. Bond them, instead. That would price the most over-aggressive prosecutors out of the business.
- briandear 12y agoExactly this! The problem is entirely because of convict at all costs DAs.
- Spooky23 12y agoYour assertion is a big leap. Does justice require a maximum penalty for every offense? Is it immoral somehow to plea down a first time DWI to DWAI and spare the taxpayer the cost of a trial, police overtime, etc? Does getting a life sentence vs. 30 years justify the cost, risk and trauma to the victims of a 1st degree murder trial?
- CHY872 12y agoI don't think you read my point in the way I intended for you to, and I'm sorry that my point could be misread in that way. I agree with all of your points. I'm not saying at all that plea bargains shouldn't exist, I'm saying that at the moment there's an incentive to abuse them by indicting the accused on charges that they're very unlikely to be convicted of in court simply because it's known that the case will almost certainly be settled by plea bargain. Indicting them on the greater charges simply strengthen the prosecutor's bargaining position, which I see as wrong. We saw this in the article with the warning shot; if the other grand juror was correct and the warning shot was exactly that, then that charge would probably not stick in court. However, by having that charge, they get to bargain for a far larger sentence, because the potential cost of going to court is far greater. It also gives an incentive to (if someone opts for court) attempt to get them the highest possible sentence (if they are convicted) in order to set an example to future plea-bargainers.
- jgalt212 12y agoThis is just one data point, but I served on a NY grand jury a few years back. 30 cases, 27/28 found for indictment. of the 2 or 3 we dismissed, the accused testified on their own behalf during the grand jury process. In only about 5 of the 30 cases, the accused testified on their own behalf. I don't know why most accused don't testify during the grand jury process, but without their testimony the process is obviously a very one-sided affair. As a result, there are many indictments and many plea bargains.
- XorNot 12y agoI'm guessing a lot of the accused do not test well in public speaking engagements - which is not an unreasonable outcome to expect. I can't even imagine how I'd react to finding myself the accused in a major court case.
- jgalt212 12y agoWhile that may be true, so long as the accused didn't directly come out and say, "I did it!", our grand jury universally felt that accused testimonies helped them rather than hurt. And even though we only saw few accused speak on their own behalf, none of them were polished public speakers or witnesses.
- dtrizzle 12y agoMost of the time, defendant's are not invited to testify. Many times, they have no idea that a grand jury investigation is taking place.
- EGreg 12y agoThat last paragraph didn't contain much information. Wish it did, it seemed toyally illogical.
- mherdeg 12y agoJust to add some context … this story is interesting in the context of the Ferguson, MO grand jury decision not to indict Darren Wilson. Recall that Wilson shot and killed Michael Brown, an 18-year old black man, in August 2014. The circumstances of the shooting were controversial. In that case, the prosecutor, Bob McCulloch was asked by activists to recuse himself from the case because of apparent biases in his personal history (his father was a St. Louis police officer who was shot and killed in the line of duty). After the grand jury declined to indict Wilson, activists claimed that this probably happened because McCulloch convinced the grand jury not to indict. This story is interesting because it provides evidence that in the "normal" course of operations of a grand jury, grand juries nearly always indict as long as there is something which looks like plausible evidence. So when the person in this story says "We had, as ever, no choice. We voted to indict" — that is interesting to compare against the Ferguson grand jury's decision not to indict, a very, very rare occurrence which should raise questions about how it happened. Wikipedia glosses this as "Legal analysts raised concerns over McCulloch's unorthodox approach, asserting that this process could have influenced the grand jury to decide not to indict,[63][79] and highlighted significant differences between a typical grand jury proceeding in Missouri and Wilson's case.[33]".
- developer1 12y agoThe way you describe it though, it sounds pretty... disgusting... that grand juries nearly always indict. This would indicate that there is nearly no point in holding a trial if the norm is to always convict.
- dedward 12y agoA grand jury indicting is rather different than a trial jury convicting.
- Dylan16807 12y agoIndict and convict are different things. Indicting means proceeding to a trial.
- skwirl 12y ago
- usman11 12y agohttp://mytricks30.blogspot.com/2015/03/7-tips-to-hair-loss-prevention.html http://mytricks30.blogspot.com/2015/03/7-tips-to-hair-loss-p...
- markbnj 12y agoJust as a data point: my best friend served on a grand jury in New Jersey, and this account squares almost exactly with his experience as related to me in many conversations.
- briandear 12y agoI have a question. If the accused persons in the examples presented had not: 1. Fired a gun in the air; 2. Attacked some lady to steal her stuff; or 3. Taken things from a store that obviously weren't theirs, would they have been in front of a grand jury in the first place? If the 10 jacket thief had stolen zero jackets then there'd be no way that he'd be fighting a grand vs petit larceny charge. The warning shot guy, he also wouldn't have been facing an attempted murder charge. What's the excuse for the guys that robbed the lady on the sidewalk? Profiled or not, it doesn't seem that their actions were in dispute, even by the skeptic. I fail to understand how being "of color" forces someone to fire a gun threateningly, steal 10 jackets or rob a lady on the sidewalk. The trials and punishments could possibly be racially biased, but the crimes aren't. What percentage of people in prison are unequivocally innocent and have never broken a law? Even the Gary Graham case in Texas a few years ago, which claimed he was innocent of the specific murder with which he'd been charged still went on an undisputed rape and robbery spree (where he allegedly committed a murder.) Almost without question he would never had been on death row had he not made the decision to seriously harm others. His decisions led to his consequences. The lesson should be: Don't hurt people, don't steal stuff and you won't be facing the potential immorality of a Assistant DA looking to boost charges. However, I am aware that there are cases where the prosecution attempts to make a case where there isn't one. That should be a crime in itsef. I've been a victim of crime several times (I drove a taxi in Houston during college.) One (of the two) times I was robbed at gunpoint the perpetrator had his front teeth completely gold; however when I looked at the photo lineup, All of the teeth had been blacked out. I was informed that gold teeth use in identifying suspects had a racial unfairness aspect and to prevent the undue 'racial' influence from a gold tooth identification, they blacked them out. I explained, "but it was a black guy with gold teeth!" So we could have quickly eliminated all of the Asian guys with no teeth. Alas no. The fact is this, the guy and his friends that ambushed me in Houston that night on Coke Street likely set aside their criminal ways after that night, found Jesus and started volunteering in the community right? Or, more likely they found themselves in front of a grand jury debating whether they stole 10 or 11 jackets. After having a .38 pointed at my head while I was face down on the sidewalk over $130, I have very little patience with people who want to knit-pick over if the cops smelled alcohol on an assailant's breath after they robbed some lady on the street. You don't want to go in front of a grand jury? The way to do that with the highest degree of probability is to not commit crimes. The plea bargain debate is moot if there is no crime in the first place.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoMore of that sort of thing: http://www.texasmonthly.com/daily-post/grand-jury-system-texas-broken http://www.texasmonthly.com/daily-post/grand-jury-system-tex...
- jongraehl 12y agoInteresting story but nothing seems exactly wrong with any of it. Is it the case that prosecutors mostly make reasonable indictments because of the potential embarrassment of having a grand jury naysay them, or should we just scrap the grand juries because prosecutors will anyway only bring supported charges? As a small optimization I'd suggest using a single judge or a smaller number (5?) of jurors for the same purpose.