7 ms·
'Revenge porn’ site runner gets 18 years in prison
- vvpan 12y agoOk, bad guy, but that sentence is insane. 18 years!?
- butwhy 12y agoI feel like some information is being left or. What was the nature of the counts for identity fraud?
- raverbashing 12y agoMaybe the fact that the girls posted on the site had their name and Facebook profile included?
- michaelchisari 12y agoI think the extortion part is probably a bigger factor in sentencing than identity fraud. Soliciting compromising photos, and then extorting people to have them removed. He effectively started a criminal organization. A stupid, poorly hidden white collar criminal enterprise, but one nonetheless. Not much different from sending muscle to collect protection money.
- michaelchisari 12y agoAmerica in general has extraordinarily long prison sentences. But this isn't that long, in relation to others, if you consider that this amounts to a criminal enterprise with many multiple, provable victims.
- venomsnake 12y agoAnd how 18 years will help reform that guy better than 5 or 10? While some short stints in prison may be a good way to cool off some heads, spending the majority of one's productive life behind bars for non violent crime is troubling. Home arrest without internet is better option. He wastes government money, he will come out without job or ability to be reintegrated into the society ...
- dragonwriter 12y agoUnlike, say, the Federal system, California has near universal parole; IIRC, the norm, barring particularly bad conduct in prison, is serving 1/3 to 1/2 the sentence, so an 18 year sentence is effectively pretty close to 5 or 10 years.
- michaelchisari 12y agoI think that's a valid point, but if you're going to take up that cause, there are much better people to champion than him.
- venomsnake 12y agoI think that starting from unsympathetic person is better. It was despicable, but still non violent. If he is not physically dangerous for anyone, then the case for keeping him behind bars is weak ...
- falcolas 12y agoMost Americans don't see prison as a place we send people to reform them, we see prison as a place we send people to punish them. Viewed in this light, the 18 year sentence (ensuring that with parole opportunities and overcrowding he will stay in prison at least 4-9 years), sees that he is "appropriately" punished, and others who might try and follow in his footsteps are deterred for fear of getting the same punishment.
- UnoriginalGuy 12y agoIndeed. The guy definitely deserves jail, no doubt about that. But for 18 years he literally could have killed someone or committed roughly three rapes. It is also worth considering that the people actually doing the literal posting deserve some of the "credit" for the crime also. He facilitated, and that definitely can be illegal, however they too deserve culpability here. I'd say this was a 1-3 year crime. With the people doing the literal postings also getting 6 months to 1.5 years a each. PS - Maybe I lack the full facts of the case. edit: Appears like some of the victims were under age and he used a "hacker" to steal revealing images somehow(?) from victims which got him 15 charges under CFAA.
- michaelchisari 12y agoPS - Maybe I lack the full facts of the case. Pay attention to the extortion aspect of it. Identity fraud and harassment are one thing, but directly extorting people has never been something you get off with a slap on the wrist.
- Dylan16807 12y ago300 bucks each from 100 people, that's not something that deserves multiple decades.
- cldellow 12y agoThose are the successful extortions. The article doesn't say how many other people sensibly decided "Fuck this blackmail" and refused to pay up.
- Dylan16807 12y agoAttempted extortion isn't worth decades either, no matter how many people were involved.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoWell it will be interesting what the actual term is, since in California the prisons are over crowded, the most anyone actually serves seems to be 1/2 their sentence [1], so 9 years. There are also changes all the time to the parole system [2] which try to relieve over crowding by getting non-violent offenders out early. That said, the guy really did a lot of damage to a lot of people who will never get their life back the way they want too, and this has to weigh on the judge's mind as well. [1] http://blog.la-criminal-defense.com/how-credit-for-time-served-works/ http://blog.la-criminal-defense.com/how-credit-for-time-serv... -- note he doesn't have to register as a 'sex offender' [2] http://www.shouselaw.com/parolehub.html http://www.shouselaw.com/parolehub.html
- anigbrowl 12y agosix counts of extortion and 21 counts of identity theft so about 8 months each, if you want to think of it that way. He'll be up for parole in 6 or 8 years - I think, but it's late and I don't feel like reading through the rules now.
- abalone 12y agoWith reportedly 10,000 pictures posted, that's only 1.5 days per picture. It's not murder, each incident is a lesser crime, but by replicating it manifold with the tool of the internet he magnified its impact by several orders of magnitude. He's responsible for using that tool and allowing it to grow to an extraordinary level of criminality and grief.
- flexie 12y ago18 years! The guy surely deserves some correction but 18 years? That's more than most murderers get where I'm from.
- ics 12y agoI'm sure if you could murder people en-masse from a website (or offer them "we won't murder you" service for a fee) that they would be getting much longer than 18 years...
- nikanj 12y agoI think the extortion played a big role in the sentencing. Hard to claim you didn't know they didn't want their pictures on the internet, if you're actively taking money from them to remove the pictures.
- kenjackson 12y agoDon't you think that murderers getting less than 18 years is the real problem?
- cgag 12y agoNo, it's you and people like you.
- totony 12y agoI felt an upvote wasn't enough, I completely agree.
- Crito 12y agoPeople who want murderers in jail for a long time are the problem? Not, you know, the people that actually murder?
- totony 12y agoThey don't need extra jail time, they need to be rehabilitated. Jail once was for this purpose, you know.
- codezero 12y agoI'll break the mold in this thread by saying this outcome is ideal. At the core, this was a new kind of case. This sets a precedent for people who may try to replicate his business model, and it makes it seem less desirable. Sure, people could just do it internationally, etc, but this is a good outcome for a tenacious and abusive criminal. edit: it is an injustice that people are jailed for minor crimes, it seems wild that this is longer than some murderers receive, but recognize that what effectively happened here's was the monetization of widespread psychological and social abuse. 18 years is likely less than the sum time his victims have spent trying to deal with the abuse he inflicted, willingly and for profit. edit 2: removed downvote gripe, in response to feedback, previously the first paragraph ended with "Let the downvotes flow."
- raldi 12y agoDamn it, I was all set to upvote you, and then you had to go attempt the reverse-psychology "I'm sure I'll be downvoted for this" ploy. Sorry, but that's an automatic "stop reading and downvote" in my book.
- codezero 12y agoGiven the tone of the thread when I posted this, it felt necessary. Reactions on HN are truly stochastic and if what I said before the defensive comment wasn't meaningful enough for you to upvote then I'm glad you downvoted it, it only reinforces how reactionary people can be.
- muglug 12y agoI wonder what sort of sentence he might have had if he'd plead guilty: http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-revenge-porn-verdict-20150202-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-revenge-porn-ver...
- venomsnake 12y agoFile this under "On personal level I like the outcome, but I am troubled enough by the way we got there and the wider implications". 18 years is just absurdly high.
- locusm 12y agoDoes the U.S have victims of crime compensation now that there has been a conviction?
- dragonwriter 12y agoCalifornia has crime victim compensation, but only for certain violent crimes; neither extortion nor identity theft qualify. http://vcgcb.ca.gov/victims/ http://vcgcb.ca.gov/victims/
- mynameishere 12y agohttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/04/03/kevin-bollaert-revenge-porn-sentenced_n_7002364.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/04/03/kevin-bollaert-reve... Bollaert earned about $900 a month in website ad revenue and collected about $30,000 from victims. Ha ha ha. Yelp and the Better Business Bureau laugh at him. This guy was an amateur in the extortion business, that's for sure. And he's paying for it with 18 years! Can you believe it? 18 years! He should have raped a nun while he was at it and got 19 years instead.
- littletimmy 12y agoThe US is a weirdly moralistic society. It is almost as if Americans pride themselves on punishing people as severely and brutally as possible. Perhaps in order to reinforce in our own minds how righteous a group of people we are. 18 years is absolutely insane. Utterly, terrifyingly insane. That's more than murder gets in many countries. That's more than rape gets. That's more than terrorism gets. How long before someone just automates building these sort of websites on a prepared template. Who'll be punished then?
- martin1975 12y agoUSA is one country under God, for liberty and justice for all... that includes the asshole who abused these women's privacy - which isn't only illegal, but immoral as well. He deserves to do time. Having said that, 18 years does seem unusually harsh, as I know countries where the maximum penalty for murder is 25 years, 7 over and above what this guy got. Chances are the sentencing will be appealed and/or he will be able to get out on parole probably within a fraction of his sentence.
- coldtea 12y ago>USA is one country under God, for liberty and justice for all... that includes the asshole who abused these women's privacy You conflate justice with punishment, when the whole premise of the parent comment what that such a term is not "just".
- martin1975 12y agoJustice without force is powerless; force without justice is tyrannical - Blaise Pascal They are necessarily conflated.
- vacri 12y agoI think it's overly cruel as well, but it's worth noting that this is multiple counts of extortion and has done significant damage to quite a few people's lives.
- s3nnyy 12y agoI wonder how much it was taken into account that a significant "part of the damange" was done by people posting the photos. His platform was merely an enabler and the nude photos could have been also posted elsewhere.
- malandrew 12y agoI can kind of understand the extortion charges, but from what evidence did the charges of identity theft stem? Seems like an unusual charge unless he was involved in doing more than just hosting revenge porn.
- Dylan16807 12y agoLooking at older articles I find: authorities say he ran afoul of state laws against identity theft, which prevent even simple personal information like names and addresses from being used "for any unlawful purpose, including with the intent to annoy or harass." Sounds like the legislature mixed in some privacy crimes and gave them a misleading name.
- sytelus 12y agoShouldn't the people who posted the photos be really paying the price? My guess is that the guy's lawyers might have invoked the strong defense that they were just the hosting company, they didn't created or owned the material and that they just wanted to allow their users to express with freedom. I guess the core mistake he made was not allowing "Flag this" button on his website because obviously he wanted to monetize this and that would have made his defense very weak because it simply means he was running a public exhortation service company. When you do think about legally risky startup ideas, one way to figure out the "badness" is to use the old world analogy: Let's say you ran a company in 1960 that accepts nude photos of your ex by postal mail and makes call to your ex that if they don't pay $300 then the photos would be in newspaper. Would you be punished for running such company? Of course, you will. However 18 yrs is insane. Looking at his income of $30,000 looks like he probably managed to get money from 100 victims. Considering 1 week of pain to get it removed, this still would come out to ~2 years in prison. To compare, people doing Enron billion dollar frauds got less than that.
- dietrichepp 12y ago> Considering 1 week of pain to get it removed I think you haven't really been following these cases. To his victims, it was far from "1 week of pain"... his actions cost people their jobs and damaged their relationships. 100 victims only counts the ones who paid, I suspect many wouldn't. You can argue that the posters should pay the price, and they should, but Bollaert is also culpable. Just like I would be culpable if I offered a "bank robbery getaway driver" service. And let's be honest here, the masterminds behind Enron didn't get the punishment they were due. But they were rich and well-connected. Miscarriage of justice, sure, but a bad comparison. It's 18 years because US prosecutors want to set an example for a new category of cases, and this guy is neither rich nor well-connected.
- ninjayi 12y agoSurely the service provider should be sentenced to 10 years at least, if they host his server and allow his service to go online.
- dennisgorelik 12y agoThe article did not show the defense argument.