7 ms·
This is going to be interesting. My gut feel is that "rogue root CAs" need to have the fear of having their entire business shut down if they're caught out act
by bigiain 12y ago
This is going to be interesting.
My gut feel is that "rogue root CAs" need to have the fear of having their entire business shut down if they're caught out acting badly, and that CNNIC is the ideal opportunity for US-centric technology companies to take a stand without treading on too many profitable toes. If Microsoft and Apple joined in solidarity and announce they're taking CNNIC out of trusted roots (and, to a lesser extent, Mozilla), then it will be clear that the threats to CA's business/profit have some teeth.
If they let this slide - it'll pretty much be open season for root trusted MITM certs to anyone with a few kilo or mega bucks to spare. It won't stop state-level actors from doing state-level bad-stuff(tm), but it might at least stop them from selling that ability to random big-corps as well.
(And surely the opportunity to stand up to the Chinese Government with broad internet-community backing, especially in the face of the recent Github DDOS - the timing is about as perfect as it's ever likely to get, right?)
- jeswin 12y agoAccording to Tim Cook, China is becoming Apple's biggest Market. Microsoft software is similarly entrenched in China. There is no way those companies will do anything that jeopardizes that relationship. I salute Google. For all its forgivable flaws, it stands alone among large corporations in protecting free speech. And the nerve to pull out of the largest internet market on the planet. Kudos.
- beaner 12y agoThat's because everything is growing in China, including probably Android and Chromebooks. Google just had the guts to do the right thing.
- chkuendig 12y agoAndroid in China is AOSP or 3rd Party forks, NOT google android. There are no google services in china, so it's definitely an easier stand to take for Google than for its competitors doing business there.
- TheDong 12y agoIt's the reverse; there are no Google services in China because they already took a stand. When the Chinese government demanded to be able to sniff all traffic, Google fought back, refused to play cozy enough with the government, and gave up its chance at a foothold. There's a whole wiki article on this mess: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_China#Ending_of_self-censorship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_China#Ending_of_self-ce...
- aveline 12y agoGoogle is inaccessible in China. It's banned by Great Firewall.
- tellarin 12y agoIt's not really banned or inaccessible. But connections are severely throttled down.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoIt really is inaccessible.
- jsprogrammer 12y agoYour browser, or trusted cert provider, should just have a clear policy that once trust is broken, according to well defined rules, the cert is auto-revoked with no appeal. Then it is only a matter of executing the policy, not an ex post facto political game. If your trusted source does not have such a policy, drop them.
- bigiain 12y agoDo you have any suggestions about where to look for such a "trusted source"? I fear my comfortable life with iOS/Android/OSX/Windows/mainstram-Linux OSen at my bidding in various devices and niches, would need to change radically to approach that ideal.
- mcintyre1994 12y agoI know it's a bit off topic but I would seriously love to have been a fly on the wall when Apple secured a deal with the likes of China Mobile. There must be conditions attached to access to the largest carrier in the world that just happens to be owned by the Chinese state - especially for a US company with their data collection abilities.
- Potando 12y agoThere certainly are. Iphones smuggled into mainland form Hong Kong are sold at a premium. Whatever the reasons for that are among the conditions that Apple must have conceded to to sell legally in the mainland.
- toyg 12y ago> it stands alone among large corporations in protecting free speech. As seen in the last few years, Google has a fairly cozy relationship with the US government and intelligence community, so I don't think they're doing this just to "protect free speech". Besides, breaking SSL goes well beyond free speech (e.g. industrial espionage etc).
- weberc2 12y agoReally? Everything I've read suggests Google does its best to resist subpoenas, takedowns, etc. Meanwhile, Microsoft was caught red-handed installing backdoors. What am I missing about Google "cozying up to" the US gov? > breaking SSL goes well beyond free speech (e.g., industrial espionage etc) So we should thank them for protecting us against that as well?
- toyg 12y agoSee this for what I meant: https://wikileaks.org/google-is-not-what-it-seems/ https://wikileaks.org/google-is-not-what-it-seems/ > So we should thank them for protecting us against [compromising SSL] as well? I'm just saying they have a much wider interest in keeping SSL reasonably secure than just to "defend free speech".
- methou 12y agoThe business is between Apple and Chinese people, not between Apple and CNNIC or its evil spawn. They have no reason to keep that rogue root of CNNIC's to protect its users for greater good.
- nickysielicki 12y agoHow far away are we from being able to kill this ridiculous system? I'm sick of trusting a bunch of certs that are deemed acceptable. Forget security concerns, I'm just appalled that to acceptably do encryption today I need to pay some company! That's wrong. Okay, so the question isn't actually "how we're going to kill it". It's going to die when there's a better alternative. So the question is really, "What can we do to build a strong web-of-trust system while continuing to use the broken one?" I see no reason we can't make some browser plugins, get some activism going in the tech community, and start building it. Just report back what cert was served to you. With that being said, there needs to be a selling point other than building a better internet, otherwise no one will use this plugin. I think there is one, though, and that's security. When your browser comes across a cert that differs, alert the user. You might not get grandma to use it, but it's something. There are issues with this. I want to anonymously report what cert a website serves me, rather than giving anyone curious my entire browsing history. And also poisoning. But the latter is fixed by using this both the existing CA model and the WoT. So yes, there are some problems. But c'mon, it's 2015, let's fix this already.
- rtpg 12y agoI don't get how it's ridiculous. How do I know that Bank of America's website is actually Bank of America? At least I know _somebody_ checked that it was BoA who is controlling the domain. It's obviously far from 100%, but the web of trust has to start somewhere. Distributed web-of-trust works for individuals, but am I supposed to go see Jeff Beezos in meatspace before going to amazon.com? The solution is, of course, delegation. But the end result is you end up with exactly the same CA system as today!
- TheDong 12y agoSomebody checked that in the past, yes, but that check doesn't matter for your current connection. Your browser will accept any CA signed cert as valid for the site it's for... if a hacker hacks into a low-profile CA, not even the one that verified BoA, they can MITM you every bit as easily as if they hacked BoA's actual cert authority. The problem here is that the delegation is too broad; we're delegating verifying all websites to all CAs and assume that all CAs are absolutely trustworthy for it to work. That's ridiculous. Chrome has a sort-of-solution built on top of this with certificate pinning where the organization gets a cert from the CA, and then gives it to chrome and claims "Only this cert is valid for our site" rather than all CA's certs... Continuing with our example of BoA, this doesn't matter because they have not opted in [0] to that and in any case that won't apply to non-chrome requests. [0]: https://code.google.com/p/chromium/codesearch#chromium/src/net/http/transport_security_state_static.json https://code.google.com/p/chromium/codesearch#chromium/src/n...
- methou 12y agoCNNIC is no ordinary CA we are talking about that fears out-of-service. Just like what its name states: China NIC, it is the entity that runs and manages whole block of Chinese part of internet, doing IP allocations and things like that. even if everybody decides to take CNNIC root out of their system, I doubt how much it would influence the CNNIC.
- bigiain 12y agoAt a first guess - any Chinese business wanting to do business with non-Chinese would then have websites which throw up warnings about their CNNIC issued SSL Certs. Surely _some_ of them would see a competitive advantage o the market by going to a non-CNNIC cert? And if the rules make that awkward, surey some of them will choose to host competitive customer marketing sites outside The Great Firewall? By selling inappropriately powerful certs to MCS Holdings, there's a chance they're going to lose some of their understood-but-ignored ability to MITM some (many?) Chinese corporate connections from outside China.
- throwaway7767 12y ago> If they let this slide - it'll pretty much be open season for root trusted MITM certs to anyone with a few kilo or mega bucks to spare. It's too late. TrustWave got a pass when they did the exact same thing. The message has been sent, there are no repercussions for willfully abusing your CA status. Only incompetence will be punished (DigiNotar). The CA system is broken. We will never find any authority that everyone in the world agrees to trust.