12 ms·
for the record, Norway has had something like 98% of it's energy from renewables for a long time.
by riffraff 12y ago
for the record, Norway has had something like 98% of it's energy from renewables for a long time.
- boulos 12y agoAnd iceland (which the article points out is a leader in geothermal energy production)
- vidyesh 12y agoIIRC, it is somewhere between 80-90% of houses using geothermal energy to heat up their houses.
- rosser 12y agoAnd Costa Rica doesn't have a nearly trillion-dollar sovereign wealth fund. It's not a very fair comparison.
- digi_owl 12y agoMost of the renewables was built before the oil.
- zurn 12y agoIf this is said about Europe's largest oil producer (between Nigeria and Kuwait in world stats), there's something wrong with energy production accounting.
- Dylan16807 12y agoWhy do you say that? Shouldn't the burden go on the consumer?
- zurn 12y agoNo, placing the burden on the individual consumers doesn't work. "Tragedy of the commons" type problems are generally solvable only by organized collective decisionmaking. Irrespective of that, discounting oil production from "share of renewables in energy production" is just nonsensical.
- bidatzi 12y agoSo do we have to tally Saudi oil pollution on the exporting country instead of those that actually use it?
- zurn 12y agoI'm not sure which point you're responding to. Regarding accounting re. renewables share in energy production, yes, I think their oil exports should be taken into account, and we should say that Saudis aren't model citizens of renewable energy production. Regarding political responsibility, I think we should definitely hold producers responsible as well. We can't burn all the oil that's still in the ground without devastating climate effects, and it's in every nation's interest to reduce oil production and consumption in an orderly but swift fashion. EDIT: responding here as I can't reply below anymore. This discussion was about energy PRODUCTION, you are below talking about energy CONSUMPTION. US oil imports should indeed count as energy production in the exporting country. Re electricty production - this subthread was about general energy production, not electricity!
- bidatzi 12y agoLet's see, the US imports 30-40% of the oil it consumes. Should that oil be accounted as used by the exporters? Norway uses no fossil fuels for its electricity production. Norway happens to export a lot of oil. How does the second statement negate the first one?
- ptaipale 12y agoLast year that was only 27 %, btw. (If "oil" means "crude oil and petroleum products").
- bidatzi 12y agoAbout your edit: fair enough, if you are talking about primary energy production. I understood what the figure provided in the first comment was referring to (electricity production/consumption) and was addressing that. In the end, I think the fact that they produce all of their electricity from hydro is a fantastic achievement. That you (and many others, including a lot of people in Norway) would like them to stop pumping oil from the North Sea is (for me) a different issue. I don't think Norway producing less oil would reduce global oil consumption. FWIW, they produce about half of what they did in the early '00s.
- ende 12y agoIf you're fortunate to have a ton of renewables and petros, the renewables typically don't travel well so you use those domestically and sell the petros on the global market.
- bidatzi 12y agoThat figure (98%) is about electricity production, not total energy used by the country.
- fsloth 12y agoNot necessarily. Norway has lots of hydro power. As energy producers go, Norway is not comparable to other oil producers from internal economic point of view as they've extensively rigged their economy not to implode from the "resource curse" .
- Dewie 12y agoThe meaning is clear enough: 98% of its renewable energy that Norway itself uses is from renewables. And "energy" probably means electricity grid. It was probably very clear to you too, but you'd rather feign obtuseness in order to make a point.
- eigenvector 12y agoYou mean electricity. Electricity is only a fraction of energy use. Heating and transportation are the other big two contributors.
- tormeh 12y agoElectricity here is so cheap we use it to heat our porches. Other means of heating are very very unusual.
- fetbaffe 12y agoYes, people, especially Scandinavian journalists, tend to forget that when they copy-paste stories on the internet, that this is nothing new.
- justincormack 12y agoFrance has around 94%, largely form nuclear, but with around 15% hydro and up to 10% wind at times. Coal and gas are a few percent.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mikro2nd 12y agoIn what way would you regard nuclear as renewable? It is fuelled by finite stocks, the extraction and refining of which are completely dependent on fossil fuels as a base.
- adwn 12y agoUranium is available in seawater in virtually limitless quantity (for all practical intents and purposes), so nuclear power should be considered renewable.
- pizza234 12y agoActually, nuclear is not generally regarded as renewable energy by definition [0]. I can somewhat see the reason (of course, it's arguable) in the fact that there is some identification of renewable sources of energy with their "cleanness". [0] Quick google search! And wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_proposed_as_renewable_energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_power_proposed_as_rene...
- Filligree 12y agoBut how can you call solar power 'renewable'? It's powered by fusion reactions in the sun, which are finite; it's going to run out. Only partly tongue-in-cheek. Fission power will also last hundreds of millions of years, so although it is "non-renewable", it shouldn't carry the same connotations of "will therefore run out".
- 12y ago
- markvdb 12y agoMight Norwegian hydro be less polluting than Costa Rican? I am thinking of lower CO2 sequestration in northern versus (sub)tropical climate forests. Flood a forest for a dam, and you have less sequestration...
- jtlienwis 12y agoI believe Norway produces 140TWatt-Hr per year vs Costa Rica 9 GWatt-Hr per year. Norway produces a lot of aluminum that takes a lot of power to produce. Is this right 14 thousand times as much power generated by hydro in Norway than Costa Rica? National statistics can be very misleading.
- markvdb 12y agoI was actually wondering about CO2 sequestration per flooded unit of surface of forest...
- jtlienwis 12y agoI believe Norway produces 140TWatt-Hr per year vs Costa Rica 9 GWatt-Hr per year. Norway produces a lot of aluminum that takes a lot of power to produce. Is this right 14 thousand times as much power generated by hydro in Norway than Costa Rica? National statistics can be very misleading.