28 ms·
After Snowden, the NSA Faces Recruitment Challenge
- a2tech 12y agoI think the only thing I can say about this is.. Good.
- tribaal 12y agoIt's funny how before the whole scandal was public (or at least, before I personally became aware of it), the NSA sounded like a hip place to work: for example, their keynote here was quite cool: https://www.openstack.org/summit/portland-2013/session-videos/presentation/keynote-openstack-at-the-national-security-agency-nsa https://www.openstack.org/summit/portland-2013/session-video... EDIT: I mean just look at that guy!
- LeonRobrotsky 12y ago> I mean just look at that guy! Yeah, I have no interest in working at a circus.
- LLWM 12y agoI'd say a lot of the things that have become known since then, like Regin or the ANT exploit catalog, have only intensified that image.
- timdaub 12y agoTIL: You can have a Mohawk and tattoos and still work for the NSA.
- adaml_623 12y agoImagine being a mathematician at the NSA and working there for 10 years and then wanting to go to work in Academia. And realise that you can't publish most of the things you've been working on for years because it's classified.
- ISL 12y agoThere's a flip side to this. Academia's hiring practices inherently prevent talented people from returning to academia. Hiring is slow (it takes at least six months), and it is absolutely contingent upon the candidate having a great publication record. When you leave for more than a year or so, it's a one-way ticket out. As an academic, I would love to have greater liquidity in the industry/academia job market.
- cmdkeen 12y agoIn the UK certain academic disciplines have a long record of post docs disappearing off for a few years and then coming back, often driving a nicer car. Being publicly funded universities probably helps, but all it takes is establishing a relationship with the university in question. There's enough DOD grant money out there that if they wanted to they could probably change academic hiring practices to support that process. So could private industries for that matter.
- jackmaney 12y agoLikewise. I left academia for industry, but would consider going back after a good long while as a transition to retirement. Oh well...in the meantime, I'll enjoy having more than double the pay I had when I left my tenure track position.
- logfromblammo 12y agoI have occasionally applied for (non-academia) software development jobs at universities, usually in relation to the health care sector. It takes all of them at least a month to even set up an initial phone screen, and some can't even manage that. Also, they tend to pay way below market wages. It's not just the hiring practices for researchers and professors. That idiocy likely extends all the way down to the part-time gardeners. You can't afford to endure the process unless you already have a job. The only reason universities can get away with this is because they are largely protected from competition, and are usually the largest single employer in whatever city they may be in.
- 12y ago
- chinathrow 12y agoGood. And to the folks still there: how about walking away? You should be one of the brightest minds anyway - find a better job! Thank you.
- jonlucc 12y agoSometimes I wonder how hard it would be to find a new job if you can't talk about much, if any, of your work for the past 5+ years.
- bradleyjg 12y agoYou can revolve into the "private industry" of government contractors.
- jonlucc 12y agoSure, but that's hardly getting away from the problems of working at the NSA.
- chinathrow 12y agoHow can you disclose to the "private industry" what you did before then?
- cnkeller 12y agoIt really depends on the project, but in my case, I could talk about technology, but not the specific problem we were trying to solve. I have the unclassified cover names listed on my resume as well.
- bradleyjg 12y agoImagine you are a hiring manager at Lockheed Martin, and you have two candidates' resumes in front of you: One has a bunch of certifications, a TS/SCI with polygraph, a list of skills/technologies that overlap strongly with the ones you are interested in, work experience with your biggest customers (responsible for 85% of revenue), but only has very vague information about what he has done specifically. Everything looks like a good fit, but it is hard to tell for sure because of the vagueness. The other has an excellent, detailed, resume listing several jobs in the purely private sector. Even though he has worked in large enterprises, they weren't DoD and so the technology overlap isn't quite as good. But by and large you think he'd be an excellent fit based on the projects he has undertaken so far. It will cost you six figures and take at least many months to get the second candidate security cleared, which will be necessary before he can start working on the project you have in mind. He might fail to get cleared in which case you will have to start all over. Who do you interview first?
- happyscrappy 12y agoWell there had to be some fallout from the leaks, tech companies seem to be making more money than ever.
- c0nsumer 12y agoTo be completely honest, I still think that the work done in the Tailored Access Operations group sounds like really, really interesting stuff.
- pwnna 12y agoJust because something is interesting doesn't mean you should be doing it. To put it another way, far off in the future, will you be satisfied with what you have done with your life?
- c0nsumer 12y ago...which is one of the major reasons why I haven't pursued this option. But it's still darn interesting, and I do believe that many of the NSA's missions are upstanding and moral.
- pluma 12y agoI'm sure the work done by Mengele sounded like really, really interesting stuff, too.
- bazillion 12y agoThe article doesn't truly address such a large claim -- it basically could be titled "After Snowden, the NSA Faces Recruitment Challenge from 3 College Students". The NSA has nearly unlimited hiring potential with just the pool of military folks alone that work there. There are constant hiring freezes for a year at a time, because a lot of buildings are over capacity. If one of these college students were to apply to the NSA through NSA.gov (mandated as the only way someone is allowed into the agency), they would have to apply a minimum of 2-4 times, because the application stays good for about 90 days, and the average applicant waits 6 months to a year to get accepted. This is assuming they're applying straight through without having someone with hiring power pull their application from the queue. After that, the process to get a clearance could take anywhere from another 6 months to 2 years (possibly more in some exceptional cases) and costs the agency about 250k. So, it goes without saying that bringing onboard a fresh college student who isn't going to even get to walk through the door at least a year after applying, can pale in comparison to bringing on someone who already has a clearance and training. The article assumes that the NSA relies heavily on its external recruitment, but the vast majority of folks working there just change out of a uniform into jeans and a shirt.
- chinathrow 12y ago"The NSA has nearly unlimited hiring potential with just the pool of military folks alone that work there." Well - NSA _is_ military.
- bazillion 12y agoIt's....not. It's part of the Department of Defense. Although this department includes the military forces (minus the coast guard), the vast majority of its member agencies are all civilian agencies, and the person who heads it up (Secretary of Defense) is a civilian.
- SEJeff 12y agoAnything under DoD should be considered military, as it falls under the jurisdiction of the Pentagon, which is military.
- cowardlydragon 12y agoI wish them mediocrity. Hm, but maybe mediocrity led them to where they are now.
- tribaal 12y agoWhile I agree with the first half of that (I wish them mediocrity as well), Snowden's revelations make it pretty clear that they are not mediocre at what they do. It takes some skill to deploy and run such a large-scale and pervasive operation.
- patcon 12y ago> the Snowden leaks have sparked other students' interest. NSA computer scientist Ziring also helps lead academic outreach for the agency. "[Students say], 'I actually know some of what you do now, and that's really cool and I want to come do that," he says. That's crazy. I'm inclined to believe they're just trying to avoid an awkward conversation with a grown man about how shitty his life choices have been
- josefresco 12y agoI think it's more about changing perceptions of the NSA. Most think of government as working slow, being archaic and having no effect. The Snowden leaks showed that the NSI is pushing the limits both technologically and tactically (whether you agree/think it's legal or not).
- LLWM 12y agoAs someone who feels the same way, I don't understand how someone who cares about technology can dismiss that point of view so casually. Every single developer I know can at least admit that the NSA's malware is technically impressive.
- jacquesm 12y agoLetting your fascination for technology lead you like this is a very dangerous thing. More than anything such a fascination or simply the lure of money allows one to be controlled in ways that could easily lead to serious regret in the longer term.
- LLWM 12y agoHow is it leading me anywhere? If anything, it's probably my belief in the obsolescence of privacy that makes it easier for me to appreciate what the NSA is capable of, rather than the other way around.
- jacquesm 12y agoIt's the same kind of fascination that gets people to work on bio-weapons and other singularly negative items. I'm a bit less cynical than you by the looks of it and I definitely do not believe in the 'obsolescence of privacy', in fact I think that privacy is one of the most important rights that we have. Appreciating what the NSA is capable of technologically whilst at the same time despising them for what they do to the world at large is entirely possible. To me it is very clear that all these politicians and their plans would go nowhere without enablers.
- mindcrime 12y agoGood. My fondest wish is that no computer science or math graduate ever chooses to go to work for the NSA again, ever. Screw those assholes. I don't care how much they cry "oooh, sigint is needed for national security" - I'm more scared of our government than I am of any foreign (or domestic, as far as that goes) "terrorist" group. The way I see it, these guys have created and are fighting an undeclared war on the American people... they've decided that "if you're not one of us, you're a bad guy". Fuck that.
- schoen 12y agoI think people often underestimate it, but one of the biggest influences you can have -- I mean you, the HN reader! -- may be cultural. People who work on building surveillance, people who have done it, people who may do it in the future, are your classmates in your CS program, your colleagues in your startup, your neighbors, your fellow conference attendees, you. Folks who work at NSA (and all the other places that don't get so much press) read xkcd religiously, they go to DEF CON, they have Linux and math t-shirts, they read HN, they are reading this thread right now, and all the other threads. If people like you in the cultures that you're part of decide that surveillance is cool and exciting, that's more talent to take the billions of dollars and vast intellectual challenges of figuring out how to eliminate the vestiges of privacy. If they decide it's uncool and sketchy, that's more talent that goes elsewhere and does something else. There are many overlapping subcultures in technology and they don't all understand or talk to each other that much, and plenty of technology employers are recruiting out of many different subcultures, so you can't assume that the culture you create in your circles will control the path of technology. But the cultural attitudes of people in the tech world can have a powerful effect on what people decide is worth working on.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pron 12y agoThat's quite a battle to wage, considering that at least two of Silicon Valley's largest companies are built around surveillance and invasion of privacy, and their core business model is selling their user's private information.
- discardorama 12y ago> I think people often underestimate it, but one of the biggest influences you can have -- I mean you, the HN reader! -- may be cultural. > People who work on building surveillance, people who have done it, people who may do it in the future, are your classmates in your CS program, your colleagues in your startup, your neighbors, your fellow conference attendees, you. Exactly. I wish more people here would realise this. The powers-that-be do realize this, and are concerned about it. I remember when the "Fifth Estate" movie came out (which was critical of Assange), everyone in our company (a large tech company that I won't name) was given free tickets (and the afternoon off) to go see it. First time ever we were given such free tickets; I wonder why?
- q7 12y agoHistory has shown that if you join an intelligence service, you basically forfeit your right to a fair trial if anything ever goes wrong. Your potential future opponent can make anything secret and off-bounds that you want to present in court, has unlimited funds and no qualms to invade your private life and present anything bad about you, has unlimited funds to haunt you for the rest of your life, and has no conscience except to preserve itself, even if it was in the wrong. I've also got a hunch that their culture is not "let's all chill and find the truth" but has more of a clan-like "you're either with us or against us" vibe. And this organization has guns, lots of guns. So in effect, it's a bit like joining the Mafia. Considering this, one has to wonder why anybody would ever join such a service.
- Taek 12y ago> History has shown I'm not well educated in this regard, but my general understanding is that such agencies tend to protect their own. Police men will protect other police men. The CIA will protect employees against crimes they may have committed. In general, you're only going to have a problem like this if you do something to piss off the rest of your organization. But as long as you conform they are more likely to protect you than turn against you.
- logfromblammo 12y agoAgain, exactly like the Mafia. Don't snitch. Give unconditional respect to everyone that's a made man or higher in the organization. Follow orders. Don't snitch. Pay your superior their cut of your business. Don't step on anyone else's toes [without getting permission first]. Don't snitch. The unwritten rules for any corrupt organization are pretty simple. "Keep your mouth shut," is always one of them, and possibly the only unforgivable offense.
- LLWM 12y agoYou've described exactly why it's not surprising. People join the mafia and equivalent organizations all the time.
- gadders 12y agoI wonder if they will still sponsor all the Top Coder competitions?
- bhauer 12y ago> "there are some of them ... that puts them off or they have doubts." On the other hand, Ziring says, the Snowden leaks have sparked other students' interest. "[They say], 'I actually know some of what you do now, and that's really cool and I want to come do that." I don't buy this. I find it just short of impossible that anyone is looking at the leaks and saying, "Yes, I want to be part of your wholesale abrogation of the Fourth Amendment. I used to think you were just a spy agency, but now I know you're the Information Nomenklatura and I want in!"
- rdtsc 12y agoThis is not to be underestimated. Obviously patriotism devotion to country and Constitution was very much desirable for recruits. The problem is a few of those patriots actually believe in the Constitution which at this point would make them quite dangerous. They would need to be filtered out and/or continuously brainwashed and monitored. "We want you to be patriotic, but not too much, just enough to swallow our brainwashing". The problem is it attracts undesirable people. They already have tons of polygraphs which accept either extremely honest people, or psychopaths. This will attract people who would have been happy working for the Stasi, SS or KGB -- particularly vile authoritarian types. Remember that even during the unpopular wars the military attracted people who just wanted to play with guns and kill other people. Same with police force. Bullies from high-school grow up want to keep bullying but they can do it within the law.
- pluma 12y agoSo they want redneck patriotism, basically?
- shitlord 12y agoYeah, pretty much. The two guys I know who worked at the NSA were both rednecks.
- jacquesm 12y ago> The problem is a few of those patriots actually believe in the Constitution which at this point would make them quite dangerous. That's exactly the bracket I fit Snowden into.
- FredericJ 12y agoEdward Snowden had predicted a radicalization of a class of professionals. We're coming to the point where, similarly to nuclear physicists after Hiroshima, we decide as a community to not let our skills be used for unethical purposes.
- briandear 12y agoOne could argue that those skills actually prevent far worse unethical actions. Without Hiroshima, how might World War II have ended? How would the Chinese and Koreans feel if Japan weren't defeated? Spend a few minutes at the Nanking museum or perhaps read about Bataan or Korean comfort women and then the moral high ground gets a bit slippery. One might, if one were so inclined, make an argument that nuclear weapons prevented World War III due to the mutually assured destruction concept. The Cold War would have become very hot if the politicians of both the Soviet Union and the U.S. didn't have to fear for their own annihilation. War and politics is dirty and not as academic as many people would like to think. It never is black and white. For example, if we take the moral high ground, our enemies won't. Pacifism sounds good until it's your sister getting raped in your living room or your parents being shot out of the sky.
- robot22 12y agoPrivacy is not just a moral good but necessary to for society to survive and thrive in the long-run. Countries and governments frequently do not act in their own best interest and I view mass surveillance as one of these instances.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- joshuapants 12y agoFor an interesting perspective on this, take a look at The Fog of War with Robert S. McNamara. He contrasts the firebombing of Tokyo with the use of nuclear weapons, among a variety of other topics.
- bediger4000 12y ago
- suprgeek 12y agoGood! (Even though the article is as close as it gets to a fluff piece. No solid data beyond a couple of stories) There has been Zero meaningful change after Snowden's leaks. This means essentially that that NSA routinely spies on all Americans, scoops up all communications Worldwide, runs various programs to undermine the Security of computer & Internet systems and acts like a massive advanced persistent threat. Imagine the same story with "After Snowden, the <biggest illegal hacker club worldwide> Faces Recruitment Challenge" Not surprising if you think that most bright people have a somewhat evolved moral compass.
- dataker 12y agoAlthough I'm not American and disapprove many NSA privacy concerns, I can't blame their technical employees: they are choosing a stable high-paying job. Articles like this try to put an ethical burden on analysts while ignoring the real actors and influences behind an ethical issue. Analysts are just doing their job and one certainly can't blame them.
- borgia 12y ago>Analysts are just doing their job and one certainly can't blame them. Yes, you can blame them and you can blame them very easily. This is a ridiculous argument.
- pluma 12y agoOne certainly can. Not to invoke Godwin's law, but you're relying on the Nuremberg defence (which was ruled invalid).
- milspec 12y agoYes, it was ruled invalid. That doesn't make it invalid. That ruling was pure evil. The trials were a sham, existing only so that a democracy could participate in dishing out victor's justice. It's revenge, pure and simple, coldly ignoring the pressure that people were under.
- jacquesm 12y agoThe whole idea is that no matter what pressure you are under there are some things that you can not get away with. Following orders is not a 'get out of jail free' level excuse, though it might be used for mitigation. So no, that ruling was not 'pure evil', it established a basic level of responsibility that applies even when acting under orders.
- milspec 12y agoDamned if you do and damned if you don't. Nice. You'll change your tune if you ever find yourself in that situation.
- drussell 12y agoSnowden and the fact that two people tried to attack the NSA yesterday. NSA does not seem to be a very popular choice at the moment.
- a3n 12y agoTwo people did not try to attack the NSA yesterday. Three people met in a hotel room overnight, two of them stole the third's car in the morning, and as they were escaping they took a wrong turn into the NSA. The driver's decision or panic to ram the police car was one more bad decision; I doubt they even knew they were taking the NSA exit, and I seriously doubt that attacking the NSA was their premeditated plan. But it's early days.
- borgia 12y agoI've a tough time believing they're having difficulties recruiting. Nothing has come from the Snowden leaks. Half of America has been very effectively turned against the guy. The rest don't care. There's also no shortage of the morally bankrupt or patriotically brainwashed. I don't know how those working with these entities can sleep at night knowing they're working to wreak havoc on their fellow American and further condemn their children and their children's children to a life under an oligarchy that listens to their every word.
- jackmaney 12y agoBack in 2007-8, I went through the lengthy interview process to join the NSA. In the end, it didn't work out, and although I was devastated at the time, I'm glad the job offer was pulled. When news of Snowden first broke out, the first thing I said was "there but for the grace of the gods go I".
- kyledrake 12y ago"After Snowden, the NSA Faces Recruitment Challenge" Good.
- newman8r 12y agoAnd he wasn't even an NSA employee. I'm surprised Booz Allen Hamilton isn't yet mentioned in this thread. The NSA uses(or used) a ton of contractors. If they're giving top secret access to BAH employees, I highly doubt they're as sophisticated as they say (which I doubt anyway)
- joshstrange 12y agoAll I can say is: GOOD! If the government will not act then a talent drain might be the next best thing. The NSA has clearly strayed from it's intended goal (or at least the one they present publically) and is a black organization that answers to seemingly no one. I'd rather that talent go to companies I use daily to protect me against not only my own government but other governments. It's clear to me that our government doesn't care about securing it's citizens but rather weakening crypto so that they can monitor everything we do. I see the NSA as a hugely corrupt and frankly evil organization that I wouldn't consider joining in a million years. Any organization that can outright lie to congress (and the American people) without repercussions is one we should burn to the ground (figuratively). I understand the need for secrets but there is difference between keeping secrets and monitoring every American citizen (and many people around the globe) without a warrant or cause. Here is to hoping that NSA becomes a graveyard of talent that eventually crumbles in on itself or is just so woefully equipped to compete with the private sector that we just do away with it. I cannot for the life of me come up with a single redeeming quality of the NSA in my life (I'm 24 so they may have done some good in the past but I seriously doubt it and even if they have the bad has FAR outweighed the good in my eyes).
- enraged_camel 12y ago>>If the government will not act then a talent drain might be the next best thing. Is it? While the NSA conducts unconstitutional mass surveillance and has played a huge role in eroding privacy, it also performs a lot of legitimate duties. I personally don't want the country's primary intelligence agency to be populated with a bunch of mediocre people.
- joshstrange 12y ago> it also performs a lot of legitimate duties Does it? I'd be very interested in what duties it performs that are considered legitimate that are not part of larger system that erodes privacy. As is a program that does not target American citizens in illegal (illegal by everyone's but the NSA and their team of dirty lawyers) that serves a real need. > I personally don't want the country's primary intelligence agency to be populated with a bunch of mediocre people. I'd rather that happen and the talent go to the private sector (Commercial and OS) because at least I have a say in which of those I support. As it is now a portion of my taxes fund this machine that infringes on our rights in the name of security.
- usefulcat 12y agoOn the plus side (for the NSA), this effect may filter out some of the people whose moral/ethical orientation would prove to be a liability in that organization.
- jgrowl 12y agoThe NSA essentially had a recruiting office on campus at the University of Kentucky. Even being Pre-Snowden, I remember everyone having a general feeling that the NSA was probably doing bad things, yet a lot of people still went to interview with them. Hell, even I did. It seems like that for some, the idea that the NSA was spying on everything was a big draw for them to join. They also liked the prestige, money, and benefits. I am not convinced that the NSA is facing a huge recruitment challenge. If anything it might just mean that more bad people get recruited.
- rdl 12y agoI wonder which is true -- this, or tptacek's assertion that this would be irrelevant to NSA recruiting, 2+ years ago. I'm pretty amazed at how much the NSA story has remained in popular press and thinking. I really didn't expect it. That probably accounts for the recruiting problems.
- tptacek 12y agoYou mean this comment, right? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6185322 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6185322 Think about it this way: other countries have no apparent problem feeding high-caliber talent into overtly, unmistakably evil applications of offensive security. Look at China, for instance. I don't think the Snowden saga had zero impact on recruiting at NSA; I just think the long-term marginal impact to NSA staffing is negligible. Worth adding: this article and my comment can't really falsify each other; they're somewhat orthogonal.
- rdl 12y agoYes. I guess I mainly think about IA/defense. NSA blowback is keeping good IA/defense (and in particular, people building IA/defense tools) people from joining USG. Instead, those people join private companies to build tools to protect companies from, among other threats, USG, or work on actual privacy tools for end users directly aimed at defeating governments. I don't know the people in the pipeline into TAO/offensive side well enough to speculate much about recruiting efforts. All the more kinetic offense people I know are there because 1) they believe deeply in the US/constitution/etc. 2) view the world in black/white 3) enjoy kicking in doors, so I assume the same is true in the TAO world.
- georgemcbay 12y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UrOZllbNarw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UrOZllbNarw How Do You Like Them Apples?
- tsunamifury 12y agoThere is a feedback problem people don't realize when a moral filter is added to an organization. I observed in Financial Tech that when the world judged bankers as bad... it attracted self-identified bad people to become bankers. People who desired to do good filtered themselves out of the industry, leaving a really horrible selection of individuals running our national financial institutions. Its really hard to digest, but I think self-identified good people MUST work at 'bad' places. Or else those places will become even worse as they become lost in a sea of real evil.
- blueprint 12y agoPlaces turn "bad" as-such when they are beyond repair. Do you believe that's it's possible to make the groups in power reform? If not, then it's impossible to make such a bad organization into a good one again, and we must start from scratch by cutting off the sections which have gone bad. Moreover, it is wrong for anyone to rationalize complicity in injustices. It doesn't matter what our intentions or level of prior ignorance are. If you make your money off things connected to something wrong, your way of life becomes wrong by connection. Perhaps these bitters truths are even more difficult to accept, and perhaps that is why people more commonly choose the more comfortable route of believing that they bear no responsibility for the company they keep.
- eyeareque 12y agoTake one for the team so to say? I don't think I could do it. I'd feel negative about myself and the contributions my job made to the world.
- imh 12y agoBut for ages, you'll just have to follow orders and do the bad stuff, otherwise get fired. Hell, someone else in the thread talked about a friend who didn't even know what he was working on. For good people to have a good effect, they have to be at the top, and getting there without doing bad things seems hard. No idea what the solution here is, but I agree the feedback issue is important.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wyclif 12y agoThe NSA's tactics, which include retaining data from American citizens... What a fascinating choice of words.
- Old_Thrashbarg 12y agoThis makes me very happy to hear that people are steering clear of the NSA. It often surprises me how easy it is to find people to do whatever you want them to do, regardless of the ethics of it. How come there's so many people willing to work at a cigarette company? What kind of programmers are willing to help their government attack Github? How can so many smart people join the NSA and essentially attack the internet?
- jacquesm 12y ago> How come there's so many people willing to work at a cigarette company? - Money > What kind of programmers are willing to help their government attack Github? People misguided by propaganda. > How can so many smart people join the NSA and essentially attack the internet? - Fascination with technology - Xenophobia - Patriotism
- lechevalierd3on 12y agoI wish companies like Google would systematically over-bid NSA offers to make it even harder for them to recruit.
- Old_Thrashbarg 12y agoIf anyone at the NSA is reading this, I urge you to consider following Snowden's example and help to further weaken the NSA and protect our constitution. (case in point: I was slightly nervous writing this, but hopefully my VPN will keep me anonymous)
- zby 12y agoRMS now prefixes all his public emails with: [[[ To any NSA and FBI agents reading my email: please consider ]]] [[[ whether defending the US Constitution against all enemies, ]]] [[[ foreign or domestic, requires you to follow Snowden's example. ]]]
- schoen 12y agoNot just his public e-mails. :-)
- jugbee 12y agooh, it fills my heart with joy reading this
- beamatronic 12y agoI imagine if they opened a Bay Area office they wouldn't have a problem.
- oneplease 12y ago" On the other hand, Ziring says, the Snowden leaks have sparked other students' interest. "[They say], 'I actually know some of what you do now, and that's really cool and I want to come do that," he says." These students scare me.
- Datsundere 12y agomaybe they should stop with unscientific tests (polygraphs)
- TallGuyShort 12y agoI spoke to an NSA employee recruiting on campus a few years ago, well before the Snowden leaks. I asked him if he genuinely felt like he was defending America or if sometimes he felt like he was just a tool in someone's political agenda. His answer was, "no - I wouldn't say it always about some political agenda". Conversation ended pretty abruptly...
- a3n 12y ago> Ever since the Snowden leaks, cybersecurity has been hot in Silicon Valley. In part that's because the industry no longer trusts the government as much as it once did. Companies want to develop their own security, and they're willing to pay top dollar to get the same people the NSA is trying to recruit. And that's one way to fight back. Starve or own the talent pipeline. Buy them away from the NSA's front door. Similar to how Apple controls much of the manufacturing capacity for smart phones. Until the NSA starts drafting people.
- CyberDildonics 12y agoI would rather be part of the solution.
- wtbob 12y agoThat would be a true pity, because NSA serves a great and legitimate purpose. They do a wonderful job for our nation. Sure, some of that work is not what some folks would like—frankly, there's one allegation which, while neither illegal nor unconstitutional, I don't like[1]—but that doesn't really matter: to the extent that the courts have deliberated, NSA has the national security of the United States of America at heart. What really makes me sad, though, is not its putative recruitment challenge, but the unpatriotic attitude of so many folks. The NSA do good and important work; it is good and important to labour in the service of one's nation. You can't blame them for acting within the outer limits (but still within the limits) of the law, because that's how nation-states work. That's not even a bad thing: if you wish to reduce the power of the NSA, reduce the power of the State, period. There's a very good chance that I'll be hell-banned for this post; if so, I've really enjoyed conversing with all of you, and hopefully I'll be able to converse with you again. [1] I have neither seen nor heard any allegations of activity which is actually illegal or unconstitutional; everything I've seen has been stuff someone wishes were such. Well, I wish some things illegal were legal, and some things legal were illegal. You can wish in one hand and spit in the other, and see which fills up first.
- devonkim 12y agoIt's funny to me that even before Snowden NSA (like literally every other federal agency) was facing a monumental challenge because you can hardly find anyone with decent qualifications to accept the middling salaries and hard cap on potential compensation as a government worker. Why go to NSA as a GG-9 (there's other schedules than GS, guys) out of college when you could go to Google for maybe similar... and maybe actually get to share your work possibly? The other part of the equation is that cost of living in the DC area has risen quite a lot and tech salaries in private sector have met the tide when most federal workers can't keep up with it. When it takes two federal workers at about $70k / yr each to have a chance at a comfortable living in the suburbs it's pretty sickening. Median house price in Fairfax County hit $700k the other year, and up in Anne Arundel County in Maryland it's maybe $550k last I saw years ago).
- lectrick 12y agoSorry, but what a fucking surprise.
- Hydraulix989 12y agoWhy Shouldn't I Work for the NSA? (Good Will Hunting) - YouTube http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=UrOZllbNarw http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=UrOZllbNarw