7 ms·
I had a debate with one of TechCrunch's head editors about the journalistic coverage of Meerkat: https://twitter.com/ryanlawler/status/582547758248136704 https:
by minimaxir 12y ago
I had a debate with one of TechCrunch's head editors about the journalistic coverage of Meerkat: https://twitter.com/ryanlawler/status/582547758248136704 https://twitter.com/ryanlawler/status/582547758248136704
Coincidentally TechCrunch published a more analytical approach a few hours later: http://techcrunch.com/2015/03/30/schrodingers-meerkat/ http://techcrunch.com/2015/03/30/schrodingers-meerkat/
What really annoys me is that no one took the devil's advocate approach to analyzing Meerkat. "It's a new paradigm in live-streaming," perhaps, but no one has considered that such a paradigm only fits in the narcissistic Silicon Valley culture.
Periscope atleast managed to appeal to non-techies, but even then, it appears to have peaked. In the first week of release.
There's a nonzero probability that everyone was wrong about personal livestreaming in the first place.
- killwhitey 12y agoOne thing I find curious is none of the articles about meerkat (that I've read) have mentioned that Color did the same idea in 2011 [1] as one of it's many pivots. I'm curious as to what's different between the two and why one might succeed where another failed. [1] http://www.androidstatic.com/color-for-facebook-streams-your-live-video-to-friends/ http://www.androidstatic.com/color-for-facebook-streams-your...
- untog 12y agoQik was doing this ages ago. If I were to be cynical I'd say that this is different because it's backed by a big VC firm, which in turn gives them access to hype. But nothing more.
- bjterry 12y agoQik had Marc Benioff, Marc Andreesen and Ben Horowitz as early investors, before the latter two started their fund as I recall. They didn't have a big VC firm backing them, but they did have notable investors.
- prawn 12y agoMeerkat could still go the way of Color. They're quite early in their public life, from what I can tell, and suddenly facing a much stronger competitor.
- johnrob 12y agoAnd, people forget that Justin.tv worked this space pretty hard before transitioning to video game broadcasting.
- bentcorner 12y agoAs a non-iPhone user that has seen neither meerkat or periscope, what's the new thing here? Justin.tv/twitch and ustream have been doing live streaming for a long time now.
- hodgesmr 12y agoI think there is an interesting conversation to be had about why, in a world with LiveStream, UStream, & YouTube Live Events, people see Meerkat/Periscope as revolutionary. Also apply that question to Spotify vs Rhapsody.
- tehwebguy 12y agoEven more interesting IMO is how Twitch has managed to be so successful (as far as I can tell much more so than any of those) while only serving one market segment - gaming.
- filmgirlcw 12y agoAgain, I would say good timing. They tapped in on teh fact that people like watching gameplay videos and they built a great system that made it easy for people to use what were becoming affordable video capture frontends to publish live streams. And its a niche, but it's in a sense, a way more accessible niche than watching a random person lifecast. You're watching someone game. Which isn't that different from watching people play sports on TV.
- slayed0 12y agoBecause they find a way to rapidly introduce new users into a previously stagnant market. The technology isn't revolutionary but something about their implementation is. To cite classic example, their were plenty of smartphones before the iPhone but the iPhone was still "revolutionary".
- jim_greco 12y agoOf course there's a nonzero probability. That's an easy conjecture to make about any startup taking on something brand new. You'll always find hundreds of reasons to say no in venture investing. But what if they're right? What if does become a hit? What if this is a great new communications paradigm? Then the $12M greylock put in or the $100M purchase of periscope is a frickin' bargain.
- minimaxir 12y agoThe nonzero probability was more toward the journalistic implications than the financial implications. TechCrunch had written several articles on how Meerkat would feed a new generation of empathy, which I strongly question.
- anigbrowl 12y agoI had never heard of Meerkat until the press started hyperventilating about the Periscope launch. I can see it being really useful for filming the police or other breaking news/public interest video where quality doesn't matter. But otherwise Vine probably does a better job; a 6-second glimpse into someone else's life is about as much unedited hand-held video as I'd want to see for most purposes.
- recursive 12y agoI had never heard of either one until I saw this post.
- azinman2 12y agoApples and oranges. Vine is about a curated video with some kind of very short & punchy narrative. Then spreading that as much as possible. Periscope/Meerkat is about 'teleporting' yourself into something... the fact that you know it's live gives you a sense of curiosity and waiting to see if something fun will happen. Furthermore, you can comment on it and have the person broadcasting see it so thus you can actually affect the video while it's happening. Being part of it is essential to the experience.
- tlrobinson 12y agoWhat makes Periscope more appealing to non-techies than Meerkat? Twitter certainly has a large existing user base they can promote Periscope to (I haven't been paying enough attention to know if they have been), whereas Meerkat has mostly been written about in the tech media. Also, there are plenty of other much more narcissistic cultures...
- xcrunner529 12y agoIt is pretty hilarious. Ben Thompson (who I usually like) was all bullish on it and kept using it and it just seemed sad...like old men in tech desperately trying to be "hip" and find the next hip thing and how the rest just "don't understand". Pretty funny.
- InspecteurConan 12y agoI want to know how Ben Rubin dare to pretend having more than 1 million users ? now we start to have to some data for both periscope and meerkat (http://lookats.com/stats http://lookats.com/stats), i don't understand how you can throw millions on something like this + all this media coverage for a few thousand users ?