3 ms·
Can you? How can you have technological or scientific advancement without someone to pay for it in advance? Who would pay for it without a reasonable expectatio
by mcguire 12y ago
Can you? How can you have technological or scientific advancement without someone to pay for it in advance? Who would pay for it without a reasonable expectation of getting more out than they had to put in?
(For some reason, I'm reminded of the Superconducting Super Collider and the western invention (discovery? reverse-engineering?) of porcelain.)
I'm going to leave the idea of "cultural advancement" alone, 'cause I can't easily and convincingly define it or figure out where it comes from. And I don't believe anyone else can either.
- boomlinde 12y ago> Who would pay for it without a reasonable expectation of getting more out than they had to put in? Perhaps no one, in that sense limiting technological advancement to things that would benefit people.
- ethbro 12y agoWhich leaves us in a fair quagmire when you have substantial gaps between discoveries and engineered products (e.g. quantum theory -> semiconductors -> the computing revolution).
- freyr 12y ago> How can you have technological or scientific advancement without someone to pay for it in advance? Who would pay for it without a reasonable expectation of getting more out than they had to put in? Value is not the same as growth. We may pursue technological advancement because we think it will provide more value than whatever assets we have on hand. Continual reward is not the same as continually increasing reward. Continually increasing reward might be good, but at some point that goal may come at too great a cost.
- marcosdumay 12y agoSome advancements just redistribute money from an older incumbent to a new one (that will want to research it). Anyway, there are plenty of technological developments that bring money to their creator, bring positive overall wealth to the population, but counts as a negative at the GDP accounting. I guess that's the cause of lots of the "let's not care about growth" cries. Well, let's fix our GDP measurement first! (And yes, I know there are several people working on it.)