10 ms·
You can have technological, scientific and cultural advancement without economic growth. Building more shopping malls out in the suburbs leads to growth, but i
by enraged_camel 12y ago
You can have technological, scientific and cultural advancement without economic growth.
Building more shopping malls out in the suburbs leads to growth, but it doesn't advance society.
- collyw 12y agoI have discussed this with friends recently. Why do we need growth? I don't need a faster iPhone, or more tech. I honestly don't see my life being any better for the last ten years worth of "growth" (much of which seems to have been pumping up asset prices). I would quite like to relax and coast a bit in life, but with the constant chasing of growth by everyone else, standing still means you will get left behind (i.e you will become poor).
- beamatronic 12y agoI'll take "peace" over "growth" at this point.
- cmdkeen 12y agoThe world as a whole is in one of its most peaceful periods ever. The 1990s saw a genocide in Europe, horrific civil wars in Africa, before that you had the Cold War with all of its attendant problems. Growth and Peace aren't mutually incompatible aims.
- ethbro 12y ago> Growth and Peace aren't mutually incompatible aims. Indeed, I'd offer that Economic Stagnation and Peace might be mutually incompatible situations.
- angularly 12y ago"Growth and Peace aren't mutually incompatible aims." No shit, almost all wars start with economic discontent. So all things equal, growth will mean less wars.
- collyw 12y agoThere has been a lot of growth in the States and the UK over the last 40 years. yet within both of those countries inequality has grown a lot. Few people under 40 can afford to buy a house in the UK these days, as opposed to 20 or thirty years ago. Maybe I am just more politically aware than I used to be but I feel discontent is rising.
- pbreit 12y agoAnd that is why you need growth.
- enraged_camel 12y agoI think you're simply demonstrating that it's incredibly easy to take technology for granted and not realize how much it has improved our lives just within the last ten years. Very simple example: back in 2005, most people had to print or memorize directions when they were traveling somewhere they didn't know. A few tech enthusiasts had discrete GPS gadgets, but navigation was a manual and tedious (not to mention dangerous) process for most. Today, almost everyone carries a device that can quickly and reliably find directions, and dynamically re-calculate them. I don't know about you, but I do a lot of driving on my own and this has improved my driving experience considerably. Now, you could argue that incremental improvements in technology (e.g. faster CPUs, more RAM, etc.) don't actually improve quality of life that much. As someone who is still rocking an iPhone 4S, I agree. It's sufficient for my needs. But incremental improvements tend to be "placeholders" while more significant technology is in development, so it's fine that they happen.
- jdmichal 12y agoAlso, those "incremental" improvements often lead the way for more advanced applications of the device. To carry your example, at some point GPS is not feasible because, off the top of my head: * Screens are not good enough. * Processors are not fast enough. * Radios are not sensitive enough. * Data storage isn't small enough. * Batteries aren't dense enough. It took these things all converging with "incremental" improvements to allow the major advancement of consumer GPS.
- jdmichal 12y agoSo you'd be happy without the last 10 years, with your iPhone that was initially released 8 years ago -- and which promptly increased the cell phone market from race-to-the-bottom "dumb phones" to high-margin "smart phones"?
- NickM 12y agoAs someone who owns an iPhone, I don't think it's really substantially improved my quality of life. It makes some things more convenient, but doesn't really enable me to do anything I couldn't do before with other separate devices, and it can be a major source of distraction at times.
- beambot 12y agoWould you be willing to test that...? I.e. Would you be willing to give up the iPhone for a dumb phone for 12 months? What if we collectively donated to a charity to make it more enticing?
- Qu4Z 12y agoNot the GP, but I'd be happy enough to do that. Then again, my personal computer is a ThinkPad T41 I bought online for like $100 recently when my T420 died, so maybe I don't count? But honestly, so little of my quality of life comes from tech advances (though I do love me some computer science, and work with computers every day).
- steveklabnik 12y agoI did this a year or three back, and the only thing was that with the amount of travel I did, the mobile maps were too useful. If I didn't travel, I'm pretty sure I'd be fine without a phone.
- branchless 12y agoIMHO we need more growth because the more growth we have the more the establishment can skim off and the more they can then consume. If we all stopped producing a surplus how will movie stars and bankers get the energy to run their private jets?
- nickff 12y agoGrowth and technology are actually reducing the difference between rich and poor in almost every aspect of life. Between 1920 and 1960 the only people who could travel quickly around the world were the super-rich. With the advent of the turbofan engine, and the widebody jet, quick and comfortable travel became accessible to the general public. Cell phones and the internet are another paradigmatic case of this. It used to be that only people with a great deal of resources could get quick answers to uncommon problems, but now everyone can get those answers from a device they carry in their pocket. You can communicate more easily than the ultra-wealthy were able to only 20 years ago. Most Americans have access to communications technology on par or above that of the president. There are many different examples of this, and the best description of it may be the following quote by Schumpeter: >"Electric lighting is no great boon to anyone who has enough money to buy a sufficient number of candles and to pay servants to attend them. It is the cheap cloth, the cheap cotton and rayon fabric, boots, motorcars and so on that are the typical achievements of capitalist production, and not as rule improvements that would mean much to the rich man. Queen Elizabeth owned silk stockings. The capitalist achievement does not typically consist in providing more silk stockings for queens but in bringing them within reach of factory girls in return for steadily decreasing amounts of effort."
- enraged_camel 12y ago>>Growth and technology are actually reducing the difference between rich and poor in almost every aspect of life. It seriously annoys me when people say this, because it's so incredibly short-sighted. It's only in terms of physical, tangible standard of living factors. Travel, as you noted, is one of those. And yeah, everyone has refrigerators in their homes nowadays. Yay! But being ultra-rich gives a tremendous amount of intangible perks, such as the ability to greatly influence public policy and the ability to afford top-notch legal representation, which lets them get away with serious crimes that would put normal people like you and I in jail for decades. There's also inter-generational perks. For example, children of ultra-rich parents can afford excellent education and are much more likely to get into the top schools. I can go on. The fact is, the differences between the haves and the have-nots today are vast, and they are getting bigger every day as wealth inequality increases. Yes, it is good that we have the basics covered for most people but beyond those basics things look pretty grim.
- sliverstorm 12y agoIf you want to freeze on ten years back, there's nothing stopping you from getting an old flip phone. Or if you want to freeze on 8 years back, nobody will prevent you from buying a iPhone 2G. It sounds like you are saying you won't do that because you don't want to be "left behind", so you'd like everyone else to stop moving forward to accommodate you. But that's their choice, just like using an iPhone 2G is your choice. "We have too much progress, can everybody just slow down a bit here!?" - first world problems :)
- ido 12y agoThere was actually no iPhone 2g, although there were iPhone and iPhone 3G.
- sliverstorm 12y agoThe "iPhone" worked on 2g networks, so I call it the 2g to be clear. The same way the "Xbox" is now called "Original Xbox", to distinguish it from the others, esp. the Xbox One.
- pdonis 12y ago> I don't need a faster iPhone, or more tech. Maybe you don't, but lots of people do, as evidenced by the fact that they pay for it. If you don't need it, then don't pay for it. > the last ten years worth of "growth" (much of which seems to have been pumping up asset prices) This is true, but faster iPhones and other tech weren't what did that. Investment banks did that, by playing risky zero-sum games with other people's money. > with the constant chasing of growth by everyone else, standing still means you will get left behind Really? You need a faster iPhone just to keep up?
- Retra 12y ago>Maybe you don't, but lots of people do, as evidenced by the fact that they pay for it. If you don't need it, then don't pay for it. That's not really how it works. I will get a new phone when mine dies because (A) I need a phone and (B) the phone I have isn't being made anymore. Does this means I am paying for 'more tech'? If you do not keep buying new stuff, you don't stagnate, you regress. If I don't want new technology, I have to go with no technology, not the same-old technology.
- pdonis 12y ago> I will get a new phone when mine dies because (A) I need a phone and (B) the phone I have isn't being made anymore. But you'll still have a pretty wide range of choices; last I checked, not every phone available was a smartphone, let alone an iPhone. Granted, the exact model you had before won't be there, but that's true of just about anything. My car is a 2002 model; I'm going to have to get a new one pretty soon, and I certainly won't be able to buy the same model. But I'll still have a pretty wide range of choices; it's not as though I'll either have to buy a luxury model or go without. > If you do not keep buying new stuff, you don't stagnate, you regress. Well, of course; stuff wears out and dies, so you have to get new stuff, and the new stuff won't be the same as the stuff you used to have, because stuff is always changing. Everything wears out eventually; that's just a fact of life. But nobody is forcing you to get the fanciest phone available, or the fanciest anything else.
- collyw 12y agoI got mine because it cam with the internet. "How much is internet?" "40 euros" "How much is internet with a phone contract bundle?" "40 euros" I was perfectly happy with my Nokia. Battery lasted a week. I could bounce it off the ground. The smartphone can be useful at times, but at other times it is so frustrating to use it cancels out the benefit. And since everyone else is using whatsapp, I might as well join in. I take my pleasure in life from things outside a 4 inch screen.
- deciplex 12y ago> I don't need a faster iPhone, or more tech. I need computing power equivalent to several thousand million human brains within the physical space of my home by 2050, and fitting in my pocket by 2075.
- gmays 12y ago> I don't need a faster iPhone, or more tech. I honestly don't see my life being any better for the last ten years worth of "growth" (much of which seems to have been pumping up asset prices). I'd be careful not to confuse the limits of your imagination with the limits of reality. I've seen this sentiment many times in many different ways and it has never been accurate. It's easy to feel like now is different and we've never been here before, but we have. The key isn't that you don't need a faster iPhone or faster computer, it's that you need them. There will always be another iPhone/computer, whatever that will be.
- baddox 12y agoLots of people love living in suburbs and visiting shopping malls. You'll have to define "advancing society."
- enraged_camel 12y ago>>You'll have to define "advancing society." Actually, if you follow the discussion, it has already been defined in the comment I responded to: >>The people who might think today is "big enough" might also have thought that say 1990 was big enough, and yet very few people would want to be limited to 1990's tech / culture. What is being implied here is that we want economic growth because we don't want to be limited in tech / culture. I simply pointed out that this is a false association.
- Retric 12y agoThere are several examples of ethnic cleansing over the last 5 years. But, I guess as long as it’s not "in Europe" then it’s ok.... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ongoing_armed_conflicts http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ongoing_armed_conflicts Yes, WWII saw 10+ times the number of dead per year, but that's not such a huge gap as you might think. PS: Many of those conflicts have far more civilian deaths than that link suggests.
- mcguire 12y agoCan you? How can you have technological or scientific advancement without someone to pay for it in advance? Who would pay for it without a reasonable expectation of getting more out than they had to put in? (For some reason, I'm reminded of the Superconducting Super Collider and the western invention (discovery? reverse-engineering?) of porcelain.) I'm going to leave the idea of "cultural advancement" alone, 'cause I can't easily and convincingly define it or figure out where it comes from. And I don't believe anyone else can either.
- boomlinde 12y ago> Who would pay for it without a reasonable expectation of getting more out than they had to put in? Perhaps no one, in that sense limiting technological advancement to things that would benefit people.
- ethbro 12y agoWhich leaves us in a fair quagmire when you have substantial gaps between discoveries and engineered products (e.g. quantum theory -> semiconductors -> the computing revolution).
- freyr 12y ago> How can you have technological or scientific advancement without someone to pay for it in advance? Who would pay for it without a reasonable expectation of getting more out than they had to put in? Value is not the same as growth. We may pursue technological advancement because we think it will provide more value than whatever assets we have on hand. Continual reward is not the same as continually increasing reward. Continually increasing reward might be good, but at some point that goal may come at too great a cost.
- marcosdumay 12y agoSome advancements just redistribute money from an older incumbent to a new one (that will want to research it). Anyway, there are plenty of technological developments that bring money to their creator, bring positive overall wealth to the population, but counts as a negative at the GDP accounting. I guess that's the cause of lots of the "let's not care about growth" cries. Well, let's fix our GDP measurement first! (And yes, I know there are several people working on it.)
- anigbrowl 12y agoThat's backwards; your example is one of economic growth without technological, scientific, or cultural advancement. By contrast, the invention of the laser didn't yield much economic growth for a long time because nobody was too sure how to commercialize it, but once the ability to produce an intense light at a single narrow wavelength got some utility, economic growth resulted automatically.
- randyrand 12y agoNo you can't. If I invent a self driving car, economic growth is inevitable. What is the difference between now and 1800 other than technology and growth (hint, technology is growth). Of course, there is also growth that doesn't come from technology. Like building shopping malls, employing people, and letting the economy operate at full tilt, producing things that we can then either consume, save (a form of growth), or spend on investment (another possible form of growth). You might not think building a shopping malls advances society, but it's second order effects 100% do.
- siculars 12y agoI donn't think that is actually the case. You may think, and I might have agreed with you, that at first blush building yet another insipid shopping mall does not necessarily yield any enhancement to society but after further thought I would tend to disagree. The "market" is where society comes together to mingle and it is also where goods and services are presented to the people who may not have had an avenue to receive them previously. The modern day mall is the modern day town square market of yesteryear. It is yet another avenue for ideas to germinate and goods to be exchanged. Someone will buy something that allows them to free up time which will allow them to spend more time thinking about something new or caring for someone who will think of something new. Expansion is the only way forward and often everything can be measured in economic output.