15 ms·
Suburbs rethink mass transit to court millennials
- michaelpinto 12y agoIt's not just millennials: As suburban boomers age, more of them won't be able drive due to health reasons. My hope is that self driving cars and better planning can help us rethink things.
- BrainInAJar 12y agoWe don't need driverless cars, we need carless drivers. Urban densification, not self-driving Ubers.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoNever going to happen. Self-driving cars will always be cheaper than rebuilding a non-insignificant amount of the US.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoGrowth is geometric. Whatever has come before is the smaller part of what we will need in future. We're always, constantly rebuilding a non-insignificant amount of the US.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoWant to make a long bet? You're counting on enough economic activity in the suburbs to drive the growth needed to revamp urban planning in those areas. With an aging populace in the US, we're hard pressed to pay for our existing obligations, let alone rebuilding communities on a massive scale.
- ghaff 12y agoThe article weaves a story out of some incremental light rail in areas where it makes sense. But that's a long way from transforming what suburbs (and even sprawling cities) look like on a broad scale. IMO autonomous vehicles that can really replace car ownership are a long way away but mass transit planning is a long time horizon as well. And if/when they do arrive it's almost inevitable that they'll make driving more attractive, not less.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> IMO autonomous vehicles that can really replace car ownership are a long way away but mass transit planning is a long time horizon as well. And if/when they do arrive it's almost inevitable that they'll make driving more attractive, not less. The problem is that you can approach self driving cars in an incremental way, while light rail is extremely expensive upfront. I don't have time at the moment to go into detail, but look at the Greenlight Proposal in Pinellas County (Florida). It was advertised as a light rail/bus transportation network overhaul, and it was downvoted due to being too expensive (while adding extremely minimal taxes to cover it). http://www.psta.net/plansandreports.php http://www.psta.net/plansandreports.php
- kansface 12y agoI'm not sure you are correct - maintaining suburban infrastructure is a net drain on coffers. However, even if you are right, driverless cars would not do much to stem the new wave of urbanization.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Tiktaalik 12y agoThe first suburbs were built around the public transportation option of the time, streetcars. It's a shame that most cities threw that away when cars appeared. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetcar_suburb http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streetcar_suburb Ignoring the implementation detail of the street car form, the fundamental idea of designing a suburb neighbourhood around major transit nodes, with some light commercial at the core stops makes tons of sense. Walk or bike 5-15 minutes to the transit node, get on transit, get to town. No car necessary.
- _delirium 12y agoThis is more or less how Copenhagen is built. It's most famous for the high degree of biking in the city (~50% of people living in the city proper commute by bike), but if you take the metro area as a whole, it's surprisingly sprawling. Of 1.5m total people, only about 500k live in the city, and the other 1m live in the suburbs, which spread out to a surprisingly large radius considering that it's not that large of a population (the outer suburbs are about 40-50km from downtown). However that quite geographically large sprawl is mostly channeled along five main corridors [1], with a fairly fast commuter-rail system serving as the backbone of each corridor. That allows having large expanses of single-family homes, but still good transit access. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finger_Plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finger_Plan
- rayiner 12y agoThat's also how Westchester in NYC is built. Lots of little suburban towns built around Metro North stations.
- maw 12y agoI agree with the main thrust of what you're saying but feel compelled to point out that suburbs are much older than streetcars. See http://etymonline.com/index.php?allowed_in_frame=0&search=suburb&searchmode=phrase http://etymonline.com/index.php?allowed_in_frame=0&search=su... for instance.
- Nicholas_C 12y agoDallas has a very small streetcar line. It's extremely useful for getting to downtown from uptown. If I worked in downtown I would use it every day,as many do.
- rayiner 12y agoIt's really interesting to see companies like Apple and Google double-down on faceless suburban office parks while the rest of the country is moving past them.
- MollyR 12y agoYea I've been thinking that was weird too. I suspect its for economical/space reason and dealing with expensive real estate. Still though it feels opposite to the their "image".
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- surfmike 12y agoIt's very hard to find the kind of space they need anywhere else. And while working at Google I get the sense that they would prefer more mixed use, higher-density development near their headquarters, but local city planning officials make that almost impossible.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoThey just need to build up.
- fuzzywalrus 12y agoI'd argue that the ideal of not owning car is more tethered to the lack of medium-to-high paying jobs for a huge swath of the population in the United States. I find the idea of millennials not driving simply due to aspiration sets a little nauseating, as depending on how you're slicing the age cut off, I'm part of "this generation". Owning a car is very expensive and out of reach of fair number of people. Even driving a modest economy car, between parking ($150 monthly downtown in my city) , my car loan ($200 mo.) and good insurance ($200ish mo.) + gas ($60ish) means I'm out $600+ of income. That's $7200 yearly without maintenance. That's as much as many people's rent in many places. I'm privileged enough that I can afford this without seriously impacting my lifestyle, and I have a sinking suspicion that if more millennials could, they'd also be car owners/drivers. With the average income per person, at $26,000, owning car is nearly out of reach. However, I suppose I shouldn't look the gift horse in the mouth. Giving more mass transit options for work is certainly a good thing.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoI'm always surprised how much cheaper it is to own/use a car in the states vs. almost every other country in the world. Even someone on minimum wage can (and often does) own one (if just used). Parking is cheap, free in many cities/suburbs, there is little tax on purchase (a $40k car in Beijing costs $20k in the USA, and lets not get to Singapore), and wow...gas.
- userulluipeste 12y agoAs I've mentioned in another post around here ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9297375 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9297375 ), it seems to be a cultural thing where car ownership is indeed strongly encouraged in the USA. You shred a little bit more light on it.
- cperciva 12y agoI'm privileged enough that I can afford this without seriously impacting my lifestyle, and I have a sinking suspicion that if more millennials could, they'd also be car owners/drivers. At 34, I'm at the upper end of the millennial age range, and I have had a car for the past decade. But I'm paying about $500/month extra rent for the privilege of living close to mass transit, and if it could efficiently get me everywhere I needed to go I would ditch my car in a heartbeat. Or to put that another way: I would pay extra for the privilege of not owning a car. I suspect that in Vancouver at least, 20 years from now the strongest predictor of car ownership will be "too poor to live close to mass transit".
- radicaledward 12y ago>> Researchers say they’re intrigued that millennials’ aversion to driving and owning a car has endured even since the recession ended. This is a direct response to the above quote. Every time I read one of these articles I'm surprised that the rise of smart phones isn't cited as a contributor to this change of preference. Every minute I'm driving is a minute that I am disconnected from the internet. Constant connection is arguably a bad thing, but I'm pretty much addicted, and I would bet that everyone else is too. Of course there are many other contributing factors to my preference for mass transit over driving. My perceptions that inform my preference (whether true or not): * Cars are simply not safe. It isn't just that I'm worried about getting hurt in an accident. I don't want to be responsible for harming someone else. * Many forms of media have constantly reminded me as I grow up that cars are bad for the environment. * Cars are incredibly expensive. If I never buy another car, I could easily afford a small house with the money I will save over my lifetime. In addition to the car, I have to pay for gas, insurance, and maintenance. However, in the end, I still have a car. I have a car because my city's public transit is still slow and unreliable. It is getting better. And I use it quite a lot to get to things in the interior of the city. My car gets me to the events I go to on the edge of town, and it covers me when I need to get somewhere in the middle of the night, when the bus isn't running. I'm not sure how similar I am to other millenials, but these are the things I think about when I see a quote like that.
- _delirium 12y ago> Cars are simply not safe. In addition to accident-type safety issues, I also find driving a bit worrying from the perspective of what you might call "legal safety". The chances of ending up in a negative interaction with the police seem much higher when you drive than when you travel via other modalities, because a traffic stop has a pretty low bar of evidence, and is often used as a lead-in to various other searches/etc. I probably am realistically not at that much risk (being a white middle-class person usually traveling in middle-class areas), but I still feel less exposed to the police when not driving.
- FD3SA 12y agoWhite, black or otherwise, you are quite susceptible to the tyranny of the police state [1]. The young man in that link was murdered in cold blood because he pissed off a cop. It was premeditated. The cop is still working actively on the force with zero repercussions. Cops have a license to kill with impunity. The race hysteria is used, ironically, to maintain the status quo via the clever bit of propaganda that "white" people are not at risk. Statistically, "whites" are less at risk, but only because they happen to be the richest demographic. As the article I've linked shows, the cops go after the weak and helpless, regardless of race or creed [2]. 1. http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/08/what-i-did-after-police-killed-my-son-110038.html#.VRmdAfnF8gQ http://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2014/08/what-i-did-af... 2. http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424127887323848804578608040780519904 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014241278873238488045786080...
- secabeen 12y agoIt will be interesting to see how millennials preferences change once they have kids. I lived for a few years in a large city without a car, and loved it. However, once you have kids, things change. Kids often have lots of accessories that you don't want to be dragging around with you everywhere (stroller, diaper bag, toys, books, etc). A car is a great place to store those. Kids also result in more multi-stop trips that aren't necessarily on the Metro lines. I think millennials probably won't adopt their parents' car-based solutions to these problems, but what they do choose will be different than what they're choosing now.
- jchrisa 12y agoWe sold our cars and moved (back) to Portland. Kids much prefer being in a cargo bike than in a car.
- mason240 12y agoYes. It always seems like these analyses of millennials don't account for our delay in starting a family compared to past generations. Certainly a generation living like man-children for the entirety of our 20s before starting a family will have lasting impacts on our outlook, but I predict that in 5 years we see most millennials transitioning into being the suburban boomers they all hate. I'm 31, right on the leading edge of millennials and I have been seeing it among people my age for several years now (partially because of the coincidence with economic recovery).
- acketon 12y agoIt's not just he car... most of these cities are not affordable to live in when you have kids. A 1 or 2 bedroom is fine for a young & single worker or a young couple. But bigger apartments have been converted into dorm style living in many cases since rents have shot through the roof. Many cities like Boston, NY and SF are trying to add affordable housing but that seems to be either a few units for very low income people or micro-units that are just a couple hundred square feet. Unless you make a huge amount of money I think most families get pushed to the suburbs to try to find somewhere they can afford to live. I'd like to see better designed suburbs that combine dense larger housing with public transit to connect the suburb communities with each other and the city they encircle. We need a size of home between the micro-apartment and the 2 million dollar mini mansion. I'd love to be able to take public transit into Boston from my place in the suburbs but train stations only have a few dozen parking spots and the bus service is limited to the city areas. So I drive for now.
- mason240 12y agoWhat I find most interesting in this pushback against cars and suburbs is just how temporary the criticisms of them are. We are on the verge of having self driving electric cars and most of the complaints about suburb life will seem silly.
- pavlov 12y agoIf you had written "helicopters" instead of "self driving electric cars", this post could be from 1950.
- mason240 12y agoA fair point, but I think we are way beyond Popular Science projections at this point.
- marssaxman 12y agoHelicopters actually exist. Self-driving cars are still nothing more than research prototypes.
- ghaff 12y agoI assume he meant in the sense of flying personal aircraft as helicopters were widely used in the 1950s. But I agree with your broader point. A lot of people aren't distinguishing the yawning distance between being able to operate on the highway with a backup driver ready to take over control and being able to operate just about anyplace, handle changes that aren't on a map, in any kind of weather, etc. even if there isn't a human inside the vehicle. I watched a recent video with John Leonard speaking at CMU and he had some interesting video showing some of the things he had to handle over the course of just a couple of weeks commuting. (Cops directing traffic around an accident, snow, left hand turn into heavy traffic, sun glare that made it hard to see a pedestrian or a light.) He makes the case that these are really hard problems that aren't anywhere close to being solved.
- 12y ago
- CalRobert 12y agoFor what it's worth, I'm moving from Europe to a very car-dependent city (San Diego) and desperately trying to find a neighborhood where I and my wife will at least not need _two_ cars, and ideally none. It's a hell of a sprawling city. Bankers Hill or Little Italy seem like good choices but the jets are damned loud. A suburb with good train/trolley service would be fairly appealing. I won't pretend to like National City or El Cajon (I don't), but at least Mission Hills is an option. However, Mission Hills hates bicyclists and opposes bike lines, so I'm trying to avoid that area out of principle.
- restalis 12y agoFor places like San Diego (sprawled and in a climate without snow), in the worst case you can opt for a motorbike or a scooter. That will give you mobility and avoid some of the car's drawbacks. It would be better if you won't have to own any transport though.
- CalRobert 12y agoI suspect we're going to wind up as a 1 cheap car (for long out of town trips) + 1 electric bicycle household. I can deal with that. Even if we're near the trolley, it barely goes anywhere. Alternately I might see how life is relying on car2go and then decide whether I really need to own a vehicle. I really, really don't miss having a car.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gglitch 12y agoMy whole line of thought on this subject changed when we decided to have a child. I am/was an enthusiastic user of public transportation, but the idea of trying to have a baby and not be able to get around on precisely my own terms (that is, on my own schedule, and with the burden of stuff my little family requires to be clean and comfortable) seemed absurd to me and now, though I still take the train to/from work every day, the idea of not having a car seems untenable.
- restalis 12y agoThe alternative of car ownership is not necessarily the reliance on public transportation. Having no need for public transportation (in the context of parenting), like having close-by all that you'd need is even better than having a car.
- shubb 12y agoMillennials is trending hard: https://www.google.co.uk/trends/explore#q=millennials https://www.google.co.uk/trends/explore#q=millennials It's hard to see why - I see a lot of pretend statistical articles on the subject but nothing validating that this group is actually any sort of cluster. It's also interesting that when they talk about millennial, commentators are usually not talking about poor people. They mean middle class kids. I guess it's good clickbait for ads because it's a category that could describe anyone with monies children.