7 ms·
Why the obsession of economic growth? One alternate question might be, "At what point in time do you consider the economy to have become 'big enough' that you
by jseliger 12y ago
Why the obsession of economic growth?
One alternate question might be, "At what point in time do you consider the economy to have become 'big enough' that you don't care about growth?" Today? 2000? 1990? 1970?
The people who might think today is "big enough" might also have thought that say 1990 was big enough, and yet very few people would want to be limited to 1990's tech / culture. It seems reasonable to imagine that people in say 2050 will look back on benighted 2015 and marvel at the shit we had to put up with. What gets us from today to 2050? Economic growth, which is likely tied into lots of other things (like science, production, entrepreneurship, etc.).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- xorcist 12y agoThat's not an answer. You could just as well ask "at what point in time do you consider interest rates low enough"? 0%, -1% or -10%? There's no clear answer for either question, of course, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't discuss them.
- cloakandswagger 12y agoHow is it not an answer? He's saying that the "greed" described by the original commenter is the same source of innovation that's given us all of the modern amenities we enjoy today. Conversely, I would say outright dismissing the pursuit of growth is not an answer.
- gamerdonkey 12y agoI would say that outright dismissing any concept is not an answer. I do have a problem with equating greed to innovation and cultural growth. Greed, in economic terms, optimizes only for the accumulation of wealth. Many technological and cultural advances would do nothing to amass wealth and would be missing in a society focused solely on economic growth.
- Mikeb85 12y ago> He's saying that the "greed" described by the original commenter is the same source of innovation that's given us all of the modern amenities we enjoy today. And is life any better today than in 1990? Are we happier? I think he's arguing that material possessions don't necessarily correlate to 'quality of life' and happiness. I would personally be pretty happy without a car or computer. But I live in a ridiculous city that is sprawled out over hundreds of square kilometres with terrible public transportation, and live in a society where electronic communication is basically a requirement to do anything. My happiest childhood memories where on my grandfather's farm. My wife's happiest childhood memories where in her small village in an 'under-developed' country. Today life in Canada is stressful as hell, and her country has been consumed by violence and corruption.
- aetherson 12y agoThings that you can do today that you couldn't do in 1990: * Survive much longer with many types of cancer. * Live a pretty normal life, more or less indefinitely, despite being HIV+ * See your grandkids that live in a different state via a high-quality video connection. * Enjoy television shows that offer multi-month and multi-year arcs and are designed to be consumed by dedicated fans in order, rather than principally for syndication in random order. * Vacuum your floors with a robot. * Survive more car crashes dues to a variety of safety features. Is life "better" today than in 1990? Sure, of course it is. Does that make us happier? I genuinely don't know. Most hedonic research strikes me as obvious bullshit. Maybe people's happiness levels reset to the norms around them regardless of what those norms are. Maybe you'd literally be just as happy if you lived in a medieval village with open-trench sewers and a pretty decent chance of your wife dying in childbirth and you doing hard labor for your adult life to a brief, decrepit old age. I mean, seriously, maybe you would! It's not outside the realm of possibility. It's hard for me to argue that that kind of happiness means that there's no point to increased material prosperity.
- xorcist 12y agoWhile all those points are true, they are mainly because of advancing science, rather than economic growth. Those are partly interconnected, but there are also important differences. The Internet as you know it is also a direct product of its academic background. That's why we have had network neutrality so inherent in its culture. That's why there are only peers, not producers and consumers. If it had been designed as a product, the network itself would never have been designed to be dumb with smart endpoints. (And there are countless examples of this.) If Tim Berners-Lee designed the web to be a product, there would be a marketplace of competing web-like products, which in turn would have given us other features, but it would never have become societal infrastructure in the way it did. Sometimes we need academia and science, sometimes we need products. The question here is how to optimize between the two.
- xorcist 12y agoNo, the commenter asked a specific question about why we optimize for growth at the apparent cost of a negative interest rate, and rapidly rising salaries as well as housing prices. "When do you consider the economy big enough?" is rhetorical question which doesn't even touch on the trade-offs apparent to what's being asked.
- enraged_camel 12y agoYou can have technological, scientific and cultural advancement without economic growth. Building more shopping malls out in the suburbs leads to growth, but it doesn't advance society.
- collyw 12y agoI have discussed this with friends recently. Why do we need growth? I don't need a faster iPhone, or more tech. I honestly don't see my life being any better for the last ten years worth of "growth" (much of which seems to have been pumping up asset prices). I would quite like to relax and coast a bit in life, but with the constant chasing of growth by everyone else, standing still means you will get left behind (i.e you will become poor).
- beamatronic 12y agoI'll take "peace" over "growth" at this point.
- cmdkeen 12y agoThe world as a whole is in one of its most peaceful periods ever. The 1990s saw a genocide in Europe, horrific civil wars in Africa, before that you had the Cold War with all of its attendant problems. Growth and Peace aren't mutually incompatible aims.
- ethbro 12y ago> Growth and Peace aren't mutually incompatible aims. Indeed, I'd offer that Economic Stagnation and Peace might be mutually incompatible situations.
- angularly 12y ago"Growth and Peace aren't mutually incompatible aims." No shit, almost all wars start with economic discontent. So all things equal, growth will mean less wars.
- colund 12y agoAmazingly well written replies everyone! Wonderful community! I agree that the economy might not be "big enough" yet. And yes I agree that we need more progress and probably more growth. But do we need to be in a hurry? It surprises me that none of the commenters has mentioned global warming - a side effect of economic growth. So, what do HN readers think about the correlation between economic growth and global warming? Should monetary policy not bother about including global warming side effects due to increased co2 pollution due to economic growth into their economics equations?
- chonoo 12y agoWhat you are grappling with here is not "have we got a big enough economy". Global Warming does not come from value creation, or the statistical proxy that we call Economic Growth. It comes from burning fossile fuels. In terms of value, what we have learnt from the last two decades is that a few people with computers can create a lot of it, with negligible impact on our planetary ecosystem. Clearly it makes our lives easier, and gives us more "stuff". However, our physical existence still depends on fossilised energy to an alarming extent, and policymakers are still unable to wean us off it (witness the fuel subsidy debates in Egypy and Indonesia), or simply unwilling to. You can even say that we use so much of it due to lack of effort, i.e. an unwillingness to actually grow the economy enough by finding substitutes. Because that would involve people doing more work to learn the right technical skills, and that's unreasonable to demand, right? In fact, it might lower the environmental inpact, since an app with driving directions can make our car journeys more efficient.
- gcb0 12y agosorry to sound like the hippie, but doesn't the official metric is mostly influenced by monetary institutions? which generate none of your grandiose example (science, production, etc)