17 ms·
I’ve Joined the White House’s U.S. Digital Service
- anthonyarroyo 12y agoCongrats! I feel like too much of what I read on here is about despair and how TPP is going to eat us and Ted Cruz is going to steal our lunch money. Good for you for taking a positive step.
- mattdeboard 12y agoI am really not clear on the structure of the "US Digital Service." The phrase "US Digital Service" makes it sound like a "reified" civil service organization in its own right. There is a USDS Headquarters, which seems to support this notion. In the copy[1], however, it says that the bulk of the work is done by "agency teams" which, if I'm understanding right, kind of "embed" with their assigned gov't agency. The copy also says they're recruiting founding members for new agency teams. The phrase "founding members" makes it sound, almost, like the teams are independent operations but knowing the federal gov't as I do, that can't possibly be right. Does anyone here have any light they can cast on whether the USDS is an agency unto itself? If not, what cabinet secretary does it fall under? I have a ton of questions about how this works. edit: My biggest fear with the USDS is that it can be smothered in the cradle by the next administration. There simply doesn't seem to be enough employees to make dissolving it -- or, maybe more likely, starving it to death budget-wise -- a big deal. [1] https://www.whitehouse.gov/digital/united-states-digital-service/story https://www.whitehouse.gov/digital/united-states-digital-ser...
- wpietri 12y agoI recently went to a recruiting event of theirs in SF, and here is my personal understanding, probably wrong in spots: The broad notion is that private-sector IT culture has undergone major change in the last couple of decades. The failure of HealthCare.gov under the old model and its subsequent turnaround using the sort of modern methods common in Silicon Valley woke people up to the possibility of doing something new. The question, then, is how to get government working like we do. (At least where it's beneficial; we solve a lot of our mistakes by shutting down companies, but government departments can't work like that.) A number of things have been tried, starting with the Presidential Innovation Fellows. [1] The US Digital Service is the latest pass. The USDS HQ is under the US CTO, which I believe makes it part of the Office of Science and Technology Policy [2], which is part of the Executive Office of the President [3]. The agency teams are embedded in the agencies themselves, and so I'd assume those are legally under the appropriate cabinet secretaries. I get all this mainly from the USDS pages. [4] Personally, I suspect that this is not a lot of money. It's mainly people, and they made clear that they will be paying industry salaries, not government salaries. And given that it is getting government to reduce waste and learn from the private sector, I expect it has bipartisan appeal. Even if the next administration dissolves it all, though, I expect it will still have a fair bit of effect. As anybody in the industry knows, the switch from 18- to 36-month cycles to 1-4 week cycles is pretty much permanent because the culture has shifted. People just expect stuff sooner now. But I hope the next administration continues the effort. At the meeting it was clear there were a lot of people in tech who really want to go serve their country by taking a couple years to make the government run better. It'd be foolish not to take advantage of that yearning for public service. [1] https://www.whitehouse.gov/innovationfellows https://www.whitehouse.gov/innovationfellows [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Science_and_Technology_Policy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Science_and_Technolog... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Office_of_the_President_of_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Executive_Office_of_the_Preside... [4] https://www.whitehouse.gov/digital/united-states-digital-service/story https://www.whitehouse.gov/digital/united-states-digital-ser...
- mattdeboard 12y agoI would be extremely surprised -- and skeptical, actually -- if there is a USDS with its own budget, but the agency teams serving under the secretary. There would be two masters there, and that's just fertile breeding ground for major frustration. (This is also not how inter-unit embeds work in the military, which is what colors my perspective.) Regarding pay, I dunno. Based on quotes from this[1] article, the pay scale seems to cap out at GS15 Step 10 which is ~132k. Now obviously this is still a lot of money but if I'm reading between the lines of his quotes right, this is the most an engineer can make w/ USDS without bumping up to SES (Senior Executive Service) levels. Not to say that's substantively less than industry salaries, but they definitely are paying government salaries (by definition). As far as dissolution, I'm talking more from the perspective of attracting & retaining top talent. With a private sector startup, you trade job security for potentially out-sized payoff. But here... Anyway, point being I think the risks should be articulated well. [1] http://fcw.com/articles/2014/10/27/red-tape-holding-back-hiring.aspx http://fcw.com/articles/2014/10/27/red-tape-holding-back-hir...
- devonkim 12y agoThere's a strong possibility that many people that are recruited into USDS are actually contractors / consultants and are thus free to bill whatever rate the government can deem necessary and appropriate. This is how almost anyone I know has ever gotten beyond that kind of salary. Also, GS15 is usually reserved for people that have been with federal service for 15+ years and isn't exactly given out to newbies without considerable thought. However, that could certainly happen but there's not exactly much room to promote them up honestly. And frankly, $132k in the DC area is about as pitiful in the Bay Area if you ask me. Defense contractors alone command $140k salaries for senior developers frequently (the contractors that still do have contracts that is). If you're in "cybersecurity" (whatever BS that actually means is beyond me when it comes to the technical definitions) you can get that with some pretty solid experience beforehand and reach into $200k as an engineer (not being management, which is usually where the caps on compensation tend to lift - see the ES pay scale compared to the GS).
- 12y ago
- daveman692 12y agoStructure wise the Digital Service is made up of a headquarters team within the White House, 18F which is an internal software development organization within the General Services Administration, and then embedded teams growing to be within each cabinet level agency. This creates a mixture of distributed execution plus centralized resources to help each team as needed.
- kingkilr 12y ago(I work for the Digital Service @ the VA) This is correct. The HQ team is a part of OMB, the White House's Office of Management and Budgest. The agency teams can be thought of as a franchise model, we work closely with the HQ team and the other agency teams, but we're also a for real part of the agency we work at. (Just realized who I was replying to, welp!)
- mattdeboard 12y agoI was disappointed to find out yesterday from Jeff M. that there is no remote position available. I hope this changes at some point in the near future.
- jacquesm 12y agoYour profile blurb has a typo in it.
- natural219 12y agoI, too, would happily consume any content about the USDS, how it's structured, what it's plans are, what its focus is, etc. Specifically, I'd like to learn what I can do now to start thinking about the problems of scale and procurement on a government level. It's an area I don't know much about, but the noises made by Mikey Dickerson and his team have gotten me sufficiently inspired to want to learn more and build out my skillset as to eventually help the initiative in any way I can.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gmays 12y agoAnother similar interesting gov't gig is Presidential Innovation Fellow: - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Presidential_Innovation_Fellows http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Presidential_Innovation_Fellows - https://www.whitehouse.gov/innovationfellows https://www.whitehouse.gov/innovationfellows - http://www.jasonshen.com/2014/everything-wanted-know-presidential-innovation-fellowship-afraid-ask/ http://www.jasonshen.com/2014/everything-wanted-know-preside... - http://www.jasonshen.com/2013/a-new-adventure-working-at-the-smithsonian-as-a-presidential-innovation-fellow/ http://www.jasonshen.com/2013/a-new-adventure-working-at-the...
- thegreatpeter 12y agoIf this means the government's moving everything to Wordpress...
- rjbwork 12y agoMy thoughts exactly. "Oh cool, maybe some digital natives are going to beable to bring development practices in government into the 2010's. That would be a cool thing to be a part of! ...Wordpress?" /closetab
- smt88 12y agoI was tempted to think the same thing, but I'd assume his work with the government will not actually involve coding. It will involve driving adoption of web technology, which WordPress has done incredibly well. I'd also say that WordPress has/had a rotten core of code, and it's now 11 years old. This guy has only been working on it for 5. If you inherit a code base like that and make huge strides forward, people will still judge you without seeing how much you've cleaned it up. So unless you look at the code base before and after him, you can't judge his engineering skills.
- nacin 12y agoWell said, thank you.
- sarciszewski 12y agoOn the bright side, it's probably a lateral move as far as government application security goes. And if they're migrating from, e.g. DotNetNuke, probably a net gain.
- Jgrubb 12y agoA big chunk of the govt has been moving everything to Drupal for the last 5 years.
- aceperry 12y agoGreat to see a lot of interest and desire to help from the tech community. Most of what I've heard during the last few years regarding the government was a lot of complaints and a desire to get rid of it. I'm glad that there are people doing something positive instead of whining.
- praxeologist 12y ago"an open, transparent, and efficient government" is a blind alley. While the tasks you will be doing are not criminal, you are working for criminals. You might reject my radical statements out of hand but if you are open to why I say this and want to know more please let me know.
- jqm 12y agoOnly _some_ aspects and activities of government are criminal. We still need someone to build roads and make sure the water stays clean. Arguably, we also need an education system, an oversight of healthcare, a social safety net system and many other things. Working in these capacities helps society in general, and everyday citizens to have better lives. There are way too many ineffective people in bloated bureaucratic stasis managing these things at the moment, and very much poor and overpriced execution which costs all of us in terms of services received and increased tax burden. Helping to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of these socially important tasks is a very worthwhile use of work time and is not "working for criminals", as the recipients of this work are the citizens of the country.
- praxeologist 12y ago>Only _some_ aspects and activities of government are criminal. States do some "good" things like feeding hungry schoolchildren, but never without first committing some "bad". Typically this is extortion (taxation/"revenue"),but originally states are founded on other forms of aggression like military conquest. Those who perform "good" tasks like being a teacher or web developer can be forgiven totally. >We still need someone to build roads This is the #1 laugher for us anarchist libertarians. Here's a lengthy book if you would like to see the case against road socialism. https://mises.org/library/privatization-roads-and-highways https://mises.org/library/privatization-roads-and-highways Poke around that site and I'm sure you can find many more arguments for each of the things you mistakenly think a free society can't provide. Please realize that the blind alley is in part thinking that government is a business. It isn't and will never be. It's similar to your local mafioso, just a widely accepted one. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1gjTIhL8vM4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1gjTIhL8vM4
- bunkydoo 12y agoCongrats, now just don't follow the lead of the secret service by drinking on the job and letting people over the fence
- eropple 12y agoSo, I interviewed with the USDS. Very smart people, seemed like it'd be a fun and challenging gig. Then I was told two weeks later that, oops, they didn't actually have a req for the USDS at all when I had interviewed, would I like to go work for the Department of Veteran Affairs? (No, no I would not like to work for the Department of Veteran Affairs, the list of things I would rather do than that is quite long and includes stapling parts of myself to other parts of myself.) Felt like a shady as heck bait and switch. Can't speak to the work they do, but I was not thrilled at their hiring practices.
- brandonb 12y agoI'm sorry you had a bad experience. I am sure it was not their intention to bait and switch; I've forwarded your comment to somebody at USDS so that they can make sure things like this don't happen anymore.
- sarciszewski 12y agoAnd now the parent is probably blacklisted for life for speaking out about it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- eropple 12y agoI strongly doubt that, but thanks for your concern. =)
- usds_hiring 12y agoThis isn't a one-time thing, let me tell you about my experience. (Throwaway, for obvious reasons.) But first a little about me: CS degree, straight to engineering at blue-chip tech companies, did full stack development, then moved to product management, with a bit of project management experience jumbled in. I'm probably not the guy you want banging out 20K LoC/day on the Linux kernel, but I am the guy who can sketch out both the UI and the architecture of a new product, hold the big picture in his head on the one hand and still speak intelligently to specialists about minute details on the other hand. Fixing all the broken systems in government sounded like a dream job at the time. I thought I was a good fit from everything I heard. I initially reached out to you, Brandon, around the second big round of press that USDS got -- summer/fall 2014ish. You helpfully put me in touch with J. J rescheduled our calls twice. It's fine, shit happens. When we did get on the phone though, after explaining the above (with more evidence), she asked me if I wanted to do web-dev with 18F. No, I did not want to do web-dev with 18F, and there's very little in my background to suggest I'd be a good fit for web development. She flat out told me she didn't think I could hack it at USDS, but when I asked where she thought I wasn't a good fit, she backed down and said she'd get an engineer to interview me. Next thing I know, I get an email from H @ 18F, who I understand is a manager there, and says that J said I wanted to speak to her. Okay, fine, I figure what's the harm in a conversation? I respond that I'd be happy to chat. A month goes by, no response to 2-3 emails to J (or H). Finally J responds, so sorry, got busy, etc. Alright, fine, shit happens I guess. The call with the engineer is set up. The engineer and I speak, technical stuff, no phone-coding though (yay!). Seems to have gone well. I give it a week, no sign of life, so I email: nothing. I let two more weeks go by, email again: nothing. Two months later (by now I was just doing this for the curiosity): nothing. So. Maybe there's political will. Maybe they're bipartisan support. But I doubt you're hiring the best and brightest. Because hiring the best people is job #1 of any leadership team, and the best and brightest know that if this is the hiring process, run by deputy directors of these organizations, with the deputy CTO of the US cc'd on all these emails, and it's _this_ bad...well, it can only be even worse on the inside. And all the desire to give back and serve your country falls apart when you know that organization is going to hamstring you when it comes to the "giving back" and "serving your country" parts of the job description. Oh, but what about H/18F, you're wondering? Over the course of 8 months (half of that time radio silence), I've scheduled 5 phone calls with her, and she's missed every single one, most of them without a courtesy email saying she'd have to cancel before the call. It got to the point where I was scheduling them during times I knew I'd be driving or waiting around at places because I didn't want to waste anymore hours sitting by a phone that was unlikely to ring. So yeah, there was no "bait and switch" here, just the "bait and". Not that I'm irritated by this or anything...
- TheMagicHorsey 12y agoA bunch of smart Silicon Valley hackers cannot fix what is wrong with government IT. Government IT problems stem from the fact that government IT contracts are worth Billions, and they are doled out through privileged networks of insiders. There are plenty of smart companies in America that can fix America's IT problems if they are paid to do so. There is no political will to do so. That is why companies you never heard of come up again and again as subcontractors for things like Healthcare.gov Believe it or not, there are some very smart people working in government. They actually don't need us in Silicon Valley to tell them how to do stuff. They know what they could do with the latest technology. They are not allowed to do so because of bureaucracy.
- Bahamut 12y agoSadly, part of the cause of this is due to the small government mantra preached by "conservatives". This results in many tasks being offloaded onto contractors who end up bloating the cost and using various other backchannels. If a lot of these things were done in-house in the government itself, things would be a lot more efficient.
- refurb 12y agoWhy would the lack of efficiency suddenly disappear if these tasks were brought in house? Jesus, the VA system in in house and look at that mess.
- aceperry 12y agoPart of the VA's problems stem from the fact that it was overwhelmed by returning vets from our wars in the middle east, and funding cuts to the VA.
- danuker 12y agoThe passion it must have gone through.
- Lawtonfogle 12y ago
- javert 12y agoThe government only continues to molest taxpayers because good people like this support it and morally sanction it. This is a dirty job.
- shit_parade 12y agoThe fact that you are being down voted is a shame. The US government tortures people and cares not for the rule of law, this is the entity people seem perfectly happy to support? Where do people draw the line? Is it at genocide?
- praxeologist 12y agoJust a few hundred more million murders of our own citizens and we'll be more open, honest, transparent and efficient, we promise. http://www.hawaii.edu/powerkills/MURDER.HTM http://www.hawaii.edu/powerkills/MURDER.HTM
- Alleluja 12y agoThe problem with statements like this is their total lack of balance. What I mean is that because of Guantanamo you will have people like this going on the air at Russia TV claiming the US Government is a "criminal organization". Nevermind that you are hearing this from KGB sponsored Russia TV that will not discuss at any length things like genocide of over 1 milion chechens or murders ordered by Putin. For me, it's a bit like someone in the 1930s going to a German Nazi sponsored radio saying how bad racism is in the USA while not thinking twice about anti-semitism of the Germany. And then at the end of the day you really end up with people who think USA is horrible because of things like Guantanamo being totally prone to Russian propaganda. When Russia is so, so much worse. The things aren't in perspective when you get rid of context.
- 20after4 12y agoJust how much worse is Russia?
- 12y ago
- Animats 12y agoWell, they've created a set of minimal-information web pages with big type and useless clip art, using Wordpress. That's so modern. More usefully, they're creating a large number of minor software components and putting them on a Git server. https://www.govcode.org/repos https://www.govcode.org/repos
- shit_parade 12y agoDisgusting that anyone would receive praise someone for assisting an entity which tortures and murders.
- sarciszewski 12y agoI think this is good for Nacin. He's helped lead on of the most popular open source projects on the Internet for years and a well-paid (am I being too optimistic?) job which comes with a bit of autonomy, opportunity for mastery, and a sense of purpose is definitely well deserved. However, I do empathize a lot of the sentiments in the hidden-by-downvote comments on this thread. Although Nacin will probably never directly support any of the government agencies responsible for torture, drone-murdering innocent civilians in other countries, or the unprecedented surveillance state that has emerged in the wake of the terrorist attacks 14 years ago, he has still willingly become a cog in the machine of the US government. Whether he manipulates his environment or gets manipulated by it remains to be seen. Hopefully, he is able to do more than make sure the US government's human-rights-violating machines remain well-greased. For those who are concerned: From my limited interaction with him, I got more of a Jedi vibe than Sith side, if you catch my drift.
- ohashi 12y agoI don't understand this perspective of if you're willing to work for the government you're joining the dark side. If you aren't willing to work freely to make your own government better, what good are you as a citizen? He's willingly started a new job to try to improve people's lives. You want to make the government better? You have two major options, voting and joining the government and actually taking responsibility for some tiny piece of it.
- sarciszewski 12y ago> I don't understand this perspective of if you're willing to work for the government you're joining the dark side. The US government does more bad than good. http://www.livingunderdrones.org/ http://www.livingunderdrones.org/ http://thinkprogress.org/justice/2014/09/17/3568232/the-united-states-had-even-more-prisoners-in-2013/ http://thinkprogress.org/justice/2014/09/17/3568232/the-unit... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_surveillance_disclosures_%282013%E2%80%93present%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Global_surveillance_disclosure... > If you aren't willing to work freely to make your own government better, what good are you as a citizen? Agreed. That's why I applaud Nacin; I believe he is someone who has enough strength of character to help move the US government towards a better good:evil balance. > He's willingly started a new job to try to improve people's lives. Agreed. > You want to make the government better? You have two major options, voting and joining the government and actually taking responsibility for some tiny piece of it. Well, they took my voting right away (which means it's not really a right, it's a temporary privilege). :P No; I'm going to take the path less traveled. I'm going to try and improve everyone's lives, regardless of where they live. Borders be damned. Ethnicity, gender identity, sexuality... none of these things matter at all. American or not, we're all human. If I ever help any government, it will be on a city level, not a nation-state level. Which is probably closer to what Andrew Nacin is doing now. If you don't like that answer, simply walk your own path in life. This is mine.
- jacquesm 12y agoI'm pretty sure people go into government with the intention of really changing it from the inside out, this time things will be different. The evaluation period for efforts like these should be a decade or more, that would be a good time to review and see if things have really changed and if the change stuck or if the machine turned out to have too much inertia after all.
- nateabele 12y agoSorry, but the lead developer of WordPress belongs in, I don't know, maybe the office of the Press Secretary (since they're so great at marketing), but definitely nowhere near anything anybody depends on.
- 17people 12y agoSo the White House got a new intern? How is this news?