7 ms·
I know that its hard for someone to understand who doesn't work with farm chemicals on a regular basis but Roundup is on the low side in terms of toxicity. Her
by rmason 12y ago
I know that its hard for someone to understand who doesn't work with farm chemicals on a regular basis but Roundup is on the low side in terms of toxicity.
Here's a copy of a Material Safety Data Sheet that all those who handle herbicides need to maintain for employee access:
http://greenhouse.ucdavis.edu/pest/pmsds/Roundup.PDF http://greenhouse.ucdavis.edu/pest/pmsds/Roundup.PDF
Almost anything is toxic, even salt, if the dose is high enough. The question that must be answered is if there is a realistic chance that people in contact with the herbicide can receive a high enough dose to raise the chance of cancer. Or that the average person either living in the country or consuming the food has an increased risk.
It's becoming increasingly common for states to take blood tests at the beginning and ending of the season of commercial pesticide applicators to monitor them.
If anyone was to have an increased level of ill health this group, because of the sheer volume of material that they handle, would be the first to show it.
- fit2rule 12y agoWhats your point? That the WHO are scare-mongering? That Monsanto shouldn't be held accountable for knowingly marketing a poisonous, carcinogenic substance and profiting from it in the billions?
- thaumasiotes 12y agoYou must get really worked up about the companies that make X-ray machines.
- fit2rule 12y agoStay on topic. We're discussing Monsantos' culpability for poisoning the earth.
- jholman 12y agoNo, we're not. You might be, but no one else is. What people are generally discussing is whether or not Monsanto is poisoning humans, and meta-issues like whether or not the article does a good job of helping us understand whether or not Monsanto is poisoning humans. Although some (currently-absent) HN commenters probably feel otherwise, I don't see a single comment in this thread trying to downplay culpability (although not that many people are playing it up, either). And you're the only one talking about poisoning the earth (which is definitely an important subject, but not really relevant to the linked article, which is about the impact on human health). So why are YOU trying to change the topic? (Note, btw, that all of your comments in this thread-subtree have all been downvoted to hell. It appears to me that these same comments are sarcastic and nasty, and very poorly argued. On the other hand, your comment that begins with "The reason this is important to discuss is that..." is mostly pretty reasonable, and hasn't been smashed by downvotes. I think that's not a coincidence.)
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> (Note, btw, that all of your comments in this thread-subtree have all been downvoted to hell. It appears to me that these same comments are sarcastic and nasty, and very poorly argued. On the other hand, your comment that begins with "The reason this is important to discuss is that..." is mostly pretty reasonable, and hasn't been smashed by downvotes. I think that's not a coincidence.) Indeed. I disagree with fit2rule all around the comment threads for this article and I upvoted that one - because it's reasonable and thoughtful.
- fit2rule 12y agoIn the meantime, the pro-Monsanto downvote brigade has been quenched by more who agree with me than don't...
- TeMPOraL 12y agoCool. But how about just writing more of the constructive kind of comments? Then there will be no need for downvoting brigades for any side.
- fit2rule 12y agoI was calling into question the veracity by which some were willing to defend Monsanto, no matter the cost. I agree that the tone of responses can be moderated higher, but I also think that the reaction of the pro-Monsanto crowd has its own insidious nature, which must be dealt with - its a company well known for its own online PR tricks and campaigns, in an effort to manage its image. And it is not without its evil side, as a corporation. So I'll consider your feedback for the next time we have to discuss Monsanto's efforts to control the worlds food.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoIn general I don't think Monsanto has a very strong support group here - most of the discussions about that company I read here was pointing out various evil things they're doing. I myself I'm not a fan of the company - but I believe in what I call 'high-resolution discourse' - i.e. focusing precisely on the actual problem. In case of Monsanto, most of the problems with them is about their business practices, not about the GMO technology - so it's fair to blame them for acting like assholes, but it's not fair to automatically assume the tech is bad (or to extend it to the entire field, e.g. "GMOs are bad because Monsanto is evil"). If the hypothetical pro- and anti-Monsanto crowd is willing to engage in a constructive, high-resolution discourse then I think it's only for the better - everyone can learn something new from it.
- rmason 12y agoI'm trying to provide a background because I have twenty plus years in the fertilizer business. I'm old enough that I remember when it was introduced. I don't know WHO's agenda but I've seen enough cycles on both pesticides and GMO's when someone makes a provocative statement based on early research and are usually proven wrong.
- kyrra 12y agoSide question. If I wanted to explain with studies to someone that GMO hate is unfounded, do you have a recommendation on a place to gather facts or recent studies on it?
- soufron 12y agoWell begin by the website of Monsanto, lol.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoWell, why not? There are first to know the good arguments for their solutions. You can start there and then go look for independent analysis and verification of the claims.
- DataCreep 12y agoWhile we're at it, let's have BP teach us all why their oil spills and dumping of even more toxic chemicals into the ocean to cover those spills up are really no big deal.
- ideonexus 12y agoI wrote a blog post defending GMOs awhile back, with examples of non-Monsanto GMOs that have saved papayas in Hawaii, promise to deliver food to Africa, and improve nutrition. The thing many people don't realize is that all food is GMO. There are no such things as tomatoes, peaches, apples, or corn in nature. These are all products of just a few thousand years of selective breeding. With GMOs, we are also constantly performing a massive ongoing experiment involving over 100 billion livestock animals, and livestock farmers have seen no deleterious effects in the health of their products: http://ideonexus.com/2011/12/05/gmo-foods-and-the-promise-a-second-green-revolution/ http://ideonexus.com/2011/12/05/gmo-foods-and-the-promise-a-...
- healthisevil 12y agoThe acetaminophen in Tylenol ( a common over the counter pain and fever medication used by millions of children and adults every day ) is carcinogenic and hepatotoxic. " There are, however, published data giving clear evidence that paracetamol causes chromosomal damage in vitro in mammalian cells at high concentrations and indicating that similar effects occur in vivo at high dosages. Available data point to three possible mechanisms of paracetamol-induced genotoxicity: (1) inhibition of ribonucleotide reductase; (2) increase in cytosolic and intranuclear Ca2+ levels; (3) DNA damage caused by NAPQI after glutathione depletion. " "Paracetamol induced sister chromatid exchange in human cells in vivo, and it was aneugenic and induced chromosomal aberrations but not micronuclei in mammalian cells in vivo. It induced DNA single-strand breaks in mice treated in vivo. Paracetamol induced sister chromatid exchange and chromosomal aberrations in human cells in vitro. It weakly induced cell transformation in a mouse cell line. It induced chromosomal aberrations, micronuclei and sister chromatid exchange in mammalian cells in vitro. It did not induce gene mutation, and the results of tests in mammalian cells in vitro for unscheduled DNA synthesis and DNA damage were inconclusive. Overall, paracetamol was genotoxic in mammalian cells in vivo and in vitro. It was not mutagenic to insects but was clastogenic in plant cells." And here is an entry from the NIH TOXNET database about liver and bladder cancers induced by tylenol. http://toxnet.nlm.nih.gov/cpdb/chempages/ACETAMINOPHEN.html http://toxnet.nlm.nih.gov/cpdb/chempages/ACETAMINOPHEN.html Everything including water is toxic under the right conditions.
- fit2rule 12y agoOh, well then, no need to worry about this at all .. everything is toxic in the right numbers, so there's no wrong-doing here in the slightest and we shouldn't stop big companies from polluting the planet, because .. after all .. its already all polluted. What a ludicrous position.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoMore like "just because it's done by someone you don't like, doesn't mean it's wrong". Blame Monsanto for the evil things they do (there's plenty), but not everything else. Your argument is almost literally "Stalin believed 2+2=4, therefore 2+2 is 5".
- Htsthbjig 12y agoWe are not talking about toxicity, but about carcinogen products. Very different. Carbon monoxide is toxic. If I breath it while walking a previously fired forest, I feel bad today. If I breath too much I die. But if I get out alive tomorrow my body will be fine. Carcinogen work in totally different ways. If I contact or breath it I will feel fine today but I will have created damage to some of my cells DNA. This damage will create other damages when 5 years from no my cells transcribe some genes in a chain reaction, or will accumulate errors over time. Five years from now one of the damaged cells will start replicating itself without control, and I will get cancer. We get cancer by indirect ways, and delayed in time, on people that are not isolated so it is hard to get the cause effect relationship. I worked in a Hospital for some time. On oncology got people that smoke 3-4 cigarettes packages a day that got pulmonary cancer, but they were seriously convinced that smoking had nothing to do with it. It took decades to establish a relationship between smoking and cancer, and that was with half of the population smoking. With smaller populations it becomes harder and harder.
- jp555 12y agoMost people cook with oil at too high a temperature, causing it to smoke and develop carcinogenic compounds, regularly, over decades. There are many examples of this in our lives (ultravilot sunlight, cosmic radiation on intercontinental flights, radon rich basement bedrooms, etc), the point being that carcinogens and cancer are more complex than you suggest. Yes smoking 4 packs of cigarettes a day for decades increases one's risk for cancer, but so does just living to an old age as a non-smoker. I remember reading a study of cadavers that found everyone has microscopic cancers throughout their bodies, throughout their lives. It seems there's a dance between evironments that drive the proliferation of micro-cancers and our body's ability to repair this damage.
- pharke 12y agoTo make things even more complex, with ultra-violet for sure but possibly involving other forms of radiation as well, it is possible that small amounts of exposure actually produce a preventative effect in regards to cancer. With UV, that mechanism is the production of vitamin D in the body, a lack of which causes a wide variety of health issues and may have a link to the development of cancer. This panel by the Mars Society actually had a very interesting discussion of this area of human health that deserves much more study. https://youtu.be/sFHQlobJbwY https://youtu.be/sFHQlobJbwY
- Zigurd 12y ago> Almost anything is toxic, even salt, if the dose is high enough. That is tremendously misleading. You body needs salt to function. Your body does not need, and has no use for glyphosate. There is no beneficial dose. If it's harmful, an incredibly minute amount can be materially harmful. Moreover there are at least two ways to get a significant number of people developing diagnosed cancers from chemical exposure: A small population (ag workers) and a large dose, or a small dose and a large population - the rest of us.
- realjakedoe 12y agoAnd who has written this data sheet? This data sheet is based on whose data? Look back a few decades on the data sheets of Asbestos or Thalidomide. Or at the research about how smoking is safe. I believe a WHO panel of independent researchers more than your sponsored data sheet.
- mkempe 12y agoFrom the actual study, rather than speculation and red-herrings: "One study in community residents reported increases in blood markers of chromosomal damage (micronuclei) after glyphosate formulations were sprayed nearby." [1] [1, PDF] http://www.iarc.fr/en/media-centre/iarcnews/pdf/MonographVolume112.pdf http://www.iarc.fr/en/media-centre/iarcnews/pdf/MonographVol...
- anonbanker 12y agothe fact that this is the top comment on HN for this link is absolutely disgusting.