4 ms·
That article isn't trying to remain impartial at all. By about half way down they gave up all pretence and started arguing that Pao's case was valid/accurate e
by Someone1234 12y ago
That article isn't trying to remain impartial at all.
By about half way down they gave up all pretence and started arguing that Pao's case was valid/accurate even if the jury disagreed.
You'd almost think the author forgot she actually lost. 12 people decided she had no case, what would be enough for this author? 20? 50? I doubt even that would do it, they've pre-decided what actually occurred.
- smackfu 12y agoThe verdict just happened. Writing the article did not.
- Someone1234 12y agoThat's an interesting point. I didn't actually consider that maybe they pre-wrote this article. That does explain a lot.
- jckt 12y agoIndeed, the last sentence > One of the stranger points brought up in testimony was how Ms. Pao, before she was married, had dated a colleague for six months without ever realizing he was still living with his wife. sounds like the article wasn't even finished.
- sp332 12y ago"Realizing"? She asked him about it and he lied to her.
- scott_karana 12y agoYes, and she was in a relationship for six months after the lie and failed to realize he was still married. (Or, she lied)
- rosser 12y ago...and what about the married man who was also in that relationship, and lying about being married for those six months? And not just a lie of omission, but "We aren't together any more." Yeah, maybe she ... "showed questionable judgement" for believing his lies, but he actively lied. What does that say about his judgement?
- true_religion 12y agoI thought the same thing. While it is kind of odd that one can go out with someone for 6 months, live in the same city as them and never visit their house.... this guy was actively lying. Its entirely possible, wanted to visit his place all the time, and gave a laundry list of bad excuses until she finally broke up with him for being dishonest as the relationship was becoming increasingly serious in her mind.
- jckt 12y agoSorry, I was just quoting the last sentence in the article.
- sp332 12y agoI know, it's just really poor word choice on the part of the author.
- aaardvark 12y agoIt's highly unusual to see someone for 6 months and not realize that they're still living with their spouse and kids. Even if the other person tells you it's not the case.
- wavefunction 12y agoI don't think it's necessarily that unusual if you're dealing with a person of means or capability in deception.
- Smoofer 12y agoWe don't know what kind of "seeing" they were doing though - "dating" someone in modern lingo can mean anything from casual sex twice weekly to having breakfast every morning together. There's a huge variance in the type of information you know about someone between those two types of relationships.
- andylei 12y ago> By about half way down they gave up all pretence and started arguing that Pao's case was valid/accurate even if the jury disagreed. where?
- Someone1234 12y agoAbout half way down and beyond.
- anigbrowl 12y agoListing someone's claims is not the same as an endorsement of them. I find the article quite neutral and well-written. Writers cannot and should not speculate on why a jury may have decided claims were deficient because juries don't supply justifications for their verdicts, although jurors may choose to give interviews afterwards.
- Someone1234 12y ago> I find the article quite neutral and well-written. Sorry but this is not neutral: > Most were heavily disputed by the defense, but they nevertheless served to define Kleiner as having refused to evolve since it was formed in the early 1970s. So she claimed one thing, the defence claimed another, but the author thinks "Kleiner [.] refused to evolve since it was formed in the early 1970s." The article spends a great deal of time talking about her accusations, but absolutely no time talking about their accusations towards her. It doesn't even try to qualify her accusations, and they're stated as near facts (which is ludicrous given the jury decision). Essentially the article has taken a side. The whole third of the article is dedicated to "women in SV" and how they're discriminated against. Hard to call that neutral given the subject matter, it hardly reads like something which could be supportive of Kleiner for example. Look, I can totally understand if people agree with the article. I cannot understand how anyone could call the article neutral or balanced. It simply is not. It has a side/agenda/bias, regardless of where you stand on the issue.
- andylei 12y ago
- devindotcom 12y agoNot to say I agree or disagree with this jury, but a dismissal or acquittal does not necessarily mean the case had no merit. OJ was acquitted, after all, and many, many people are wrongfully found guilty.
- hnnewguy 12y ago>OJ was acquitted, after all Do you know something that the jurors don't? Reasonable doubt. That's how the system works.
- esrauch 12y ago> Do you know something that the jurors don't? This is weird question, because in OJ's case we know a lot of things that the jurors didn't. Part of the critique of the prosecutors in the case was that they decided not to enter a lot of material things into evidence (e.g. the entire Bronco chase). Also, there are a lot of things that happened since then that the jurors did not know (because they didn't happen yet). He did write a book that was a description of himself committing the murders (but it is "hypothetical").
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 12y ago> OJ was unanimously found guilty by the jury in his civil trial. Civil trials don't find guilt, they find liability. And, aside from the difference in evidentiary standards (beyond a reasonable doubt vs. preponderance of the evidence), the actual fact question in a criminal murder charge is substantially different than that in a civil wrongful death charge -- one can be liable for wrongful death on the same pattern of facts under which one would not be guilty of murder.
- dragonwriter 12y ago
- harryh 12y agoStrictly speaking only some of those 12 decided she had not case. The verdict was no unanimous.
- rosser 12y ago12 people decided she had no case... Factually incorrect on two counts: 1. They didn't decide "she had no case". Deciding whether or not a claimant "has a case" isn't even the jury's job. They're there to decide whether or not the evidence supports the claims. 2. You might want to re-check the jury poll again. (Hint: not all 12 jurors decided against Pao.)
- kenko 12y ago> By about half way down they gave up all pretence and started arguing that Pao's case was valid/accurate even if the jury disagreed. So what? The reporter isn't obligated to think the jury was correct.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bmelton 12y agoWell, I don't see anywhere in the article that flags it as an opinion piece. The reporter has a right to his opinion. The jury has a right to theirs. We have a right to ours. None of that excuses opinion journalism masquerading as journalism.
- eropple 12y agoLiterally all journalism is opinion journalism. There's no unbiased way to record any story where the word "why" must at any point be asked. The desire of some well-meaning but foolish people to hold journalism to that standard gives cover to the ones who will adopt that cloak of impartiality and use it to lie to you.
- nazgul 12y agoThe goal of journalism is impartiality. And most good journalism comes as close as it can come. This article is not an example of that.
- eropple 12y agoWhat? The goal of journalism according to whom? Because Tom Wolfe--from whom a very large chunk of modern journalists can be said to descend--would laugh at that notion. There's also the natural fallout of "impartial journalism" having that imprint; Chomsky and others have noted that it leads to a massive endorsement of moneyed and powerful parties in most cases at which you'll point. Which may be fine for you, but certainly not me.
- matt4077 12y agoThe article speaks to the larger issue of discrimination of women in the valley in general. Just because Pao's case didn't convince a jury doesn't mean everything is peachy. And even in her case there's a grey area where discrimination can occur without it being illegal. In that case, you can win in court but lose the trial of public opinion.
- s3r3nity 12y agoI found this to be surprising about the entire coverage of the case. Following tech blogs and checking HN links, you would've thought that Pao's case was bulletproof, with some minor nuances and qualifications. After reading the full details of the arguments on both sides, I now understand why the jury ruled the way it did.
- matt4077 12y agoThat's probably not media bias but a function of trial mechanics: the plaintiff gets to present their case first and that's where the first reports – and your first opinion – are drawn from.
- sukilot 12y agoNote that it is still bias! In a psychological/statistical sense. A good lesson to remember.
- mikedmiked 12y agoThe right wing news sources I read made it look bulletproof that she was manipulating things and would lose. I didn't even read the tech news as SV has a crazy liberal bias. Steve sailer had nailed a good analysis right from the start I believe
- MollyR 12y agoYea, That is how I feel too. I was really shocked, by the verdict. Then I looked into more of the details, and I'm shocked again by how irresponsible the media is. After the Brian Williams fiasco, my faith in american journalism seems to keep taking massive hits.
- borgia 12y ago>That article isn't trying to remain impartial at all. I have not seen one single article on this trial that hasn't been very heavily biased in favour of Ellen Pao. Not one. I'm not surprised this isn't the case yet again. The media are calling this institutional misogyny regardless of the facts or the judgement by the jury. If she wins, it's institutional misogyny, if she loses it's institutional misogyny. At this stage I'm convinced that tech journalism is the lowest form of journalism available today.
- steveeq1 12y agoI agree. Discrimination and drama sells regardless of their probability.
- dyno12345 12y agoDavid Streitfield writes anti-tech hit pieces almost exclusively, and sometimes forgets to try to remove his opinions from what would otherwise appear to be factual articles.