6 ms·
Rejection massively reduces IQ
- fsniper 17y agoIs this post is a response to Y-Combinator rejections? :) It's a bit pity we've been rejected. But it did not made us angry or less intelligent. (As far as I know :))
- petercooper 17y agoThe core part of the article: "To live in society, people have to have an inner mechanism that regulates their behaviour. Rejection defeats the purpose of this, and people become impulsive and self-destructive. [..]" I'm going to go along with this. I'd say it's part of the reason teen crime is sky high in the UK right now. We've failed to interact as local communities in the last 10-15 years and we're paying the price in people being selfish and aggressive seeking only their own ends (teenagers don't beat up 2 year old kids in healthy communities - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/london/8348130.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/london/8348130.stm)
- fnid 17y agoYou know, I have to say that London was the most violent place I've ever been. 9 out of 10 times that I'd go out in the city, there were muggings, very aggressive fights, people thrown out of bars, guys running into the street kicking cars right in front of the cops, buses that smelled and left one feeling tense and threatened. And this wasn't just at night. At three in the afternoon, I saw a bar brawl flow out onto the street. On one of my trips to Amsterdam, a local commented on how aggressive the brits were who would visit for stag parties, get drunk and start fights. There really is something unhealthy going on there. It's worrisome really. There were lots of articles at the time about the youths. I can't remember what they called them, some kind of acronym. YAGs or something like that. It's a real tragedy.
- tokenadult 17y agoI have to say that London was the most violent place I've ever been. As a point of comparison, have you ever been anywhere in China? That's where I have seen the most open public violence, much more so than in any part of the United States (I have been to all fifty states, including some very tough parts of inner cities.)
- petercooper 17y agoChavs? Or, possibly, feral youth: http://www.google.com/search?q=feral+youth http://www.google.com/search?q=feral+youth
- diego 17y agoI just finished reading "How We Decide" by Jonah Lehrer. It discusses a number of similar experiments where scientists observe what parts of the brain are activated during different types of situations. According to some experiments dealing with feelings seems to draw resources away from the part of the brain used to solve problems that require analytical thought. A similar experiment involved having people perform analytical tasks while being exposed to situations that require self-restraint. The harder the tasks, the less people are able to resist temptation.
- bh23ha 17y agoI am not sure it is evolutionarily useful to become self destructive upon rejection, I imagine rejection has always been fairly common. I think the researchers' interpretation is very biased. I can easily imagine that the aggressive reaction is in fact useful. Perhaps not in modern high tech. society, but even in modern day we are still an aggressive species and aggression in often sexy, men with a criminal background on average have more children. And today still, aggressive behaviour is a pretty good way to gain social status in high school.
- robak 17y agohigh school and prisons, huh?
- fnid 17y agoPerhaps it does have an evolutionary purpose. Say you are a male who is constantly rejected by the female. If mate with the female, perhaps even against her will, then you produce offspring. Also, being rejected is a dominance issue. If rejected from more powerful members of the society produces aggression to the point of killing those more powerful then the aggressive individual rises to power and increases the odds of reproduction.
- enqk 17y agoThis also came to me as strange. It came to me that someone who is being rejected may not have good prospects in the future for succesful procreation. So having such individuals' nature turn self-destructive / aggressive will ensure he/she get further rejected. Increasing the selection process: only the socially/behaviourally fit remains in the community.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- ovi256 17y agoI hypothize that the counter - control mechanism that they claim absent is actually depression. You are rejected, you then either become aggressive or fall into a depression which has been shown to cause dwelling on issues and analying a problem endlessly, hopefuly allowing a solution to be found.
- fnid 17y agoThat's what I suspected too. The thoughts of rejection occupy brainwaves that are otherwise spent thinking about and answering questions correctly.
- Matti 17y agoThe original paper is behind a paywall but I found the 4-page article "Rejected and alone" by Roy Baumeister -- one of the researchers -- to be an interesting read. http://www.thepsychologist.org.uk/archive/archive_home.cfm/volumeID_18-editionID_130-ArticleID_960-getfile_getPDF/thepsychologist%5C1205baum.pdf http://www.thepsychologist.org.uk/archive/archive_home.cfm/v... * Rejection affects behavior, but has generally no or little effect on emotion: "Thus, social exclusion does have powerful effects on people, but these effects do not depend on emotional distress. This has been something of a shock to many of us and has even led us to question some widely held assumptions about the purpose of emotion and its relationship to behaviour." * Social exclusion results in a higher pain threshold and a higher tolerance for pain. "Further studies indicated that the numbness to physical pain can explain the emotional numbness that we had observed over and over."
- radu_floricica 17y agoThank you! I was really disappointed with the comments here - mostly mindless IQ bashing. The real revolution in psychology is happening right now, and I fear the people who should be most interested and in a position to benefit the most are exactly the ones who'll ignore it as more freudian bullshit.
- modelic3 17y agoThis is interesting I would have suspected that exclusion would have resulted in a lower pain threshold and higher sensitivity.
- rauljara 17y agoThe idea of IQ, or intelligence quotient, was originally formulated as measure of a person's innate intelligence. It was supposed to be something you were born with, and not something that would change with the environment. This is just the latest study that shows that IQ is, in fact, sensitive to one's environment, and can change. I hope people will someday learn to avoid taking IQ tests as these unquestionable measures of how smart someone is, or ever will be.
- jamesbressi 17y agoVery well put @rauljara -- The argument about SATs and IQ tests seems to come up almost weekly on here. To add to that fire, I also don't believe that GPA has much to tell about someone's performance and capabilities (don't get me wrong, in some ways it does, but now how companies like Google use it to "weed" out applicants).
- amichail 17y agoA CPU can slow down dramatically when it gets hot. That doesn't mean CPU maximum speeds are unimportant.
- pohl 17y agoTrue, that. Now if only we had a valid metric for one's mind's maximum speed. IQ ain't it.
- Matti 17y ago"Test-Score-Differences Fallacy 1: Nonfixedness Proves Malleability This fallacy uses evidence of any fluctuation or growth in the mental functioning of individuals as if it were proof that their rates of growth can be changed intentionally. IQ level is not made malleable by any means yet devised (Brody, 1996), ..." - Linda Gottfredson, Logical fallacies used to dismiss the evidence on intelligence testing http://www.udel.edu/educ/gottfredson/reprints/2009fallacies.pdf http://www.udel.edu/educ/gottfredson/reprints/2009fallacies.... (PDF page 24)
- Alex3917 17y ago
- astine 17y agoThis just in: Being aggrevated hurts when taking tests! Seriously, what did the researchers expect? That frustration wouldn't affect people's focus?
- jlees 17y agoYeah, it seems to me fairly obvious that if someone implied before a test that I would fail, and I had cause to trust their opinion, I'm not likely to do as well as I would have because of the nagging self doubt etc. No change on my innate ability to do the test, but the level of application and focus would be drastically different. (On the other hand it can go far enough as to improve focus, sometimes. "I'll show them", "I failed last time but I know I can do it", etc)
- fnid 17y agoI don't know why you guys got downmodded. I agree with both. The article is pretty bad and neglects a very common sense approach to thinking. I see little evidence that it actually reduces someone's intelligence. Maybe their test results acutely, but I highly doubt it makes someone dumber.
- Mz 17y agoIQ tests come with a lot of social and cultural bias. So, for example, immigrants tend to do more poorly and members of an outclass tend to do more poorly (for example, historically this meant Black Americans tended to test poorly). I would think one thing going on here is a kind of harm to the social orientation of the test-taker. If everyone "hates" you, what's your motivation for being "agreeable"? And if your answers stop "agreeing" with what is socially valued, your test score can be hurt. Does this mean you are dumber? Not necessarily. It's common for extremely intelligent children to test poorly because they are unable to gear their answers towards the test's expectations. One simple example: A child may fail to classify the picture of a "whale" as a "W" word because they know the type of whale it is (such as "Blue Whale") and aren't sophisticated enough to know that the test makes the assumption that children of a certain age won't have such specific information. A very socially savvy child may do better on such a test than a child whose interests are more "technical" (so to speak). Anecdotally, very socially savvy and socially oriented kids of high IQ often do a wonderful job of hiding how smart they are in order to fit in better. They may routinely shoot for roughly average even though they may be capable of substantially better performance than all their classmates. If no one likes you or accepts you and there is no fixing that, why bother? And if not bothering means you classify the "blue whale" as a B word instead of a W word because you feel that is more accurate and precise, your score may suffer.
- Alex3917 17y ago"It's common for extremely intelligent children to test poorly because they are unable to gear their answers towards the tests expectations." That's so weird. I distinctly remember this happening to me in third grade, but I never knew that it was an established phenomenon.
- Mz 17y agoI know that from participating on email lists for many years. I don't know how much of that type of information is in the standard literature. Tests are only a tool. The conclusions drawn from them are only as wise as the person(s) administering and interpreting them.
- foompy_katt 17y agoWouldn't it be more accurate to say "rejection reduces short-term performance"? It makes sense that someone who has just been rejected would have a hard time focusing on an immediate task- their brain is still stuck trying to understand and ameliorate the rejection. My question is, what are the long-term effects of a single rejection? Or even the effect of multiple episodes of rejection which aren't due to being poor or some other variable? I can think of many people who face a lot of rejection but thrive anyway, sometimes even because of rejection (i.e. they become more experienced, or they use rejection to motivate themselves). Entrepreneurs, for example.
- elblanco 17y agoInteresting ramifications for the startup that's struggling to make sales. Extrapolating on this finding might indicate that a startup that meets early failure is more less doomed to failure since those failures pile on one another and basically make them dumb and mean.
- Mz 17y agoMy read on it is that it only measured a short-term reduction in performance. I saw no indication that it suggests long-term consequences from a single instance of rejection. Some people are inherently more likely to be bitter, grudging, etc and hold onto such negative feelings. Other people are more inclined to get over it and move on. Bill Gates has said that your unhappiest customers are your best source of learning. Some people are inclined to view negative feedback as useful information and not wallow in a negative emotional reaction to it. This behavior can be learned to some degree. I would think that part of why the examples cited in the article resulted in negative reactions is because it was not constructive feedback: The artificially induced feeling of rejection apparently was delivered with zero feedback as to why they were being rejected. Some real life situations are like that. But other real life situations hold a great deal of information about why people are rejecting something. Anyone who wants to be an entrepreneur would be well advised to learn to view negative responses as "constructive feedback" and not take it too personally. Most sources I have seen indicate that entrepreneurs typically experience a lot of rejection (and failure) prior to achieving success.
- Estragon 17y agoWorking for New Scientist massively reduces the capacity for critical thinking.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- WilliamLP 17y agoGreat... so every time you guys down-vote me I get stupider. Edit: fixed grammar after being upvoted.
- chrischen 17y agoGreat, so every time I apply to YC I'm getting stupider.
- stcredzero 17y agoRemember, correlation does not imply causation! (jk) Maybe this is why sales guys are the way they are? Again, correlation doesn't imply causation.
- DrJokepu 17y agoCorrelation is not causation. It's a logical fallacy to state that "rejection reduces IQ" on learning that rejection correlates with a decreased ability to get high scores on IQ tests.
- tokenadult 17y agoThe study purported to have an experimental design. http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html It would, however, be a good idea to attempt to replicate this finding.
- gloob 17y agoIn the extreme case, it can be argued that it is philosophically impossible to establish causation beyond any doubt. What I'm trying to say here is "correlation != causation"-type comments are boring. Everyone on this site already knows they aren't the same. It's like someone mentioning in every thread that the Web is not the same as the Internet.
- modelic3 17y agoThis is just another drop in my bucket of suspicions about aspects of creativity and intelligence. Stress free and confident individuals tend to be more creative and intelligent than those that are constantly angry and stressed out.
- tokenadult 17y ago"15 March 2002" Where is the follow-up on this? Has this result ever been replicated? http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html http://norvig.com/experiment-design.html The guidelines for this site http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html which is, after all, called "Hacker NEWS," define "anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity" as on-topic, but I sure am curious if it is news to report one result from 2002 that didn't seem to result in any meaningful research follow-up. Is there any current news on this same issue?
- rooshdi 17y agoSo IQ is based on emotions? That doesn't sound right.
- jollojou 17y agoI'd introduce another perspective on rejection: having a rejective state of mind significantly reduces one's ability to analyse the situation at hand. It's about prejudices. We all hold a large amount of prejudices even though we would consider our selves open minded. Prejudices result in cognitive responses where one rejects an idea at hand before one even starts to evaluate the pros and cons of the idea.