4 ms·
I think this just goes to show exactly why these systems will become more commonplace. There are only so many security experts to go around. Having all the ve
by jedberg 12y ago
I think this just goes to show exactly why these systems will become more commonplace. There are only so many security experts to go around. Having all the very best concentrated on a smaller set of services seems like it makes more sense than trying to get a security expert for every service.
- patcon 12y agoI agree, but can't deny self-hosted means your security lapses see less fanfare, which has value to the biggest and most lumberingest risk-adverse organizations
- riffraff 12y agonot to mention: you can host a chat server in your company network, somewhat protected from random people on the internet, and your ops people should already be securing that from external intrusions anyway.
- acdha 12y agoI'm mixed on this. It's undeniably true if everyone is in the same building but in my experience this is rarely actually true as people need to work from home, use mobile devices, other offices open, partnerships or acquisitions happen, etc. That tends to lead to people requesting holes in firewalls or using VPNs as a sort of aftermarket spray-on security measure, which inevitably makes things much worse because now you have exposed services[1] which were setup and operated by people whose threat-model was “Sheltered internal service accessed by trusted staff”. It's much better to start with the assumption that your services are exposed to the internet and secure them accordingly. 1. VPNs are almost always terrible for security because people tend to get them for one need (i.e. email, one line of business app, etc.) but when their computer gets compromised the attacker now has access to the superset of everything which every VPN user has ever needed to access and in all likelihood a bunch of other things which were never intended to be exposed but were never adequately firewalled internally.
- rudolf0 12y agoYou have to look at it from a regulatory and compliance standpoint. While I agree from a technical standpoint that the average company's data is probably going to be safer at Slack than in some internal system, the accountability risk is just too high. You can't prove your cloud provider is using security best practices, while you theoretically can prove (or disprove) the same internally. Few companies do proper auditing, reviews, and pentests, but they have the capability to do so.
- jedberg 12y ago> You can't prove your cloud provider is using security best practices But you don't have to. They do. Look at Amazon. They publish their security audit each year, and now every company that uses them doesn't have to do their own audit. They can point their auditor at Amazon's report and say "see our datacenter passes". Also, do you do a security review on your power company, or do you assume they've done it?
- sbov 12y agoI have a friend who works security, previously for the government, and now for Visa. In his opinion: if you haven't been hacked, you just aren't an interesting enough target for the right people. I don't know how common this line of thought is in security. But if it is common, then if you're a small company, aren't you better off not hosting my stuff at these large companies, because it's putting information you collect with someone who is more likely to be "interesting" to the right people?
- sounds 12y agoI think a more correct assessment would be: If you think you haven't been hacked, you probably have (or you are so small that you may have only been probed by bots). If you haven't actually been hacked yet, it is only a matter of time. Ideally you start designing security layers now, before you are compromised.
- freehunter 12y agoAs the famous quote goes: there's two types of companies - those who have been hacked and those who will be. Actually, there is a third kind: those that will back hacked again.