13 ms·
Sigh, I remain concerned that if you want to light off a bubble in Tech this is the way to do it. Time will tell of course. The reason I am concerned is that t
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
Sigh, I remain concerned that if you want to light off a bubble in Tech this is the way to do it. Time will tell of course.
The reason I am concerned is that the last tech bubble was fueled by retail investors who got to buy stock in companies that IPO'd (but shouldn't have). A lot of people invested their savings into companies they were not prepared to evaluate reasonably. Relying instead on "trusted advisors" who often were financially invested in the stocks they advised going up.
No doubt there are some really honest and worthwhile crowd investing companies, just like there were honest and worthwhile financial advisers in the 90's and honest and worthwhile Mortgage brokers in the naughts. But their existence will not deter nor mitigate their dishonest counterparts who will ruthlessly, and with all the tools available to them (legal and otherwise), separate people from their money under the guise of "getting in on the ground floor of the next Google or Facebook." I want with all my being to be wrong about this, and would love for people five years from now to be able to see this comment and say "Gee what a cynic, he really didn't get it did he?" But that future is not the one I expect.
- neovi 12y agoThere's a small chance something of the sort could happen, but there are some nice limitations included. In the 90s, the companies were issuing to be publicly traded; which means retail investors were free to put their whole income into a stock if they wanted to. Here they're only allowed a percentage of their income depending on their income bracket (over $100,000k or under). There's also a 30% cap to sell, which is far better than selling the whole entire fridge.
- wsidell 12y agoIt depends on if it is in Tier 1 or Tier 2. Tier 1 for companies raising less than $20m/year seems not to have a limit on the percentage of their income.
- staunch 12y agoWhy should only rich people get to invest in companies? Anyone can go to Vegas and blow their entire life savings, but buying shares in Dropbox or Oculus at launch is just too reckless?
- waterlesscloud 12y agoIt's not like rich people are all that much better at investing in companies anyway. They're just better able to afford the consequences of their ignorance.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- colinmegill 12y agoWhich makes them much better at not losing their life savings, hence the regs.
- briandear 12y agoSo we should ban the lottery for poor people.
- luch 12y agoActually yes, I know an economist (working for the BCE) half-jokingly preaching it. According to him, lottery should be reserved to people who can afford to lose 10$.
- notahacker 12y agoIn fairness to the lottery, few people consider it to be a sensible place to stick 50% of their net worth. Bearing in mind that top startups - which generate nearly all the return to VCs - have a marked preference for "smart money" and the majority of startups ventures fail hard, most lotteries probably have a higher expected value than retail investors are likely to see from the average crowdfunding portfolio.
- clarky07 12y agoluckily the new regs don't allow you to invest 50% of your net worth.
- SnakePlissken 12y agoNot to defend stockbrokers, but part of what made the tech bubble so uniquely frothy was that it was the first time retail investors could easily circumvent the Wall Street gatekeepers via online, discount brokerages. No doubt many mom and pop investors were led into the bubble by advisors, but a sizable portion entered the fray on their own. For a brief time, many malls had trading boutiques, Internet cafés that catered to aspiring traders. Police officers and schoolteachers were quitting in droves to daytrade. CNBC was on in every coffee shop across the country. It's common to hear financial pundits comparing it to the mania of the 20s, when shoeshine boys were offering hot stock tips. I'm not sure we could ever see that level of participation from crowdfunding, but I think you're correct to worry that retail investors will continue to behave irrationally, with or without predatory advisors [0]. [0] http://www.joshuakennon.com/gt-advanced-technologies-bankruptcy/ http://www.joshuakennon.com/gt-advanced-technologies-bankrup...
- api 12y ago"I'm not sure we could ever see that level of participation from crowdfunding" I would not bet on that. There could be loads of startups that work to further 'democratize' this.
- briandear 12y agoIt shouldn't be the government's role to protect people from their own ignorance or bad decisions. There are unscrupulous people who would try to get people to invest in the 'next Google,' but there are also people that try to sell expensive and worthless things all the time. Government shouldn't be your daddy; adults should have the freedom to invest in whatever they want, regardless of the stupidity of such investments. After all, there ar plenty of crap penny stocks that have no hope of making a return. Wouldn't you rather people invest in our compani s than in some near-bankrupt biotech trading for .32 on the OTC who claims to be looking for a cure to cancer but in fact is nowhere near such a cure? How about used car dealers? Should we prevent non accredited investors from buying used cars? After all, a car represents one of the worst investments with no chance of capital appreciation. How about Rent to Own shops? Those prey on the stupidity of poorer people. Let's support freedom and let adults make their own choices, good or bad. Unless we want to ban Keno, the lottery, pay day loans, penny stocks, and let the government manage everyone's money. Of course given the government's inability to manage their pocketbook, I would suspect that the average American is more intelligent in terms of investment screening than the U.S. government. Remember Solydra? Freedom means even the freedom to be stupid.
- _delirium 12y agoThere's no actual ban on poor people investing in SEC-registered securities. What is at issue is an exemption to the usual SEC disclosure requirements, which is available in limited circumstances. In cases where a company's investors consist solely of a small number of "accredited investors", Congress enacted an exemption to the usual SEC disclosure rules, on the assumption that such groups of investors have the resources to conduct their own independent investigation of the offering. A company can choose not to use that exemption, and instead do things the official, open way: issue securities to the general public accompanied by the required disclosures. That allows the company to take investment from anyone, while also protecting the public by ensuring that that the offering is above-board and accompanied by enough information for the public to make an informed investment decision.
- BryanBigs 12y agoVery VERY few cars are investments, most are tools.
- mellavora 12y agoAgreed, we have just entered bubble mode.
- s_henry_paulson 12y agoThe bubble started long ago. This is what happens when you have lots of extra money floating around and traditional investments aren't producing results that can beat inflation. People have been shoveling large amounts of money into tech for way too long, and even last year WhatsApp was sold for ~20 billion USD. We've now past that and are now at a point where we're going to pump that bubble up even further.
- marze 12y agoThere will always be people losing money in dumb investments. But with more diverse investment in startups, we should see a greater number and variety of successful ones.