4 ms·
Funny enough I just wrote one of my first blog posts in years, minutes before this article was written, about Magic. [0] My theory is that by positioning themse
by chatmasta 12y ago
Funny enough I just wrote one of my first blog posts in years, minutes before this article was written, about Magic. [0] My theory is that by positioning themselves as an aggregator, or a "platform for platforms," they retain the cashflow advantages of service based marketplaces, without the need to build supply because they piggyback on existing supply.
Some say this is unsustainable because of low barrier to entry, but I would say actually they are in a perfect position. With investment like this, direct partnerships with service providers are possible. Partnerships are a barrier to entry.
[0] https://milesrichardson.com/the-magic-of-service-business-cashflow/ https://milesrichardson.com/the-magic-of-service-business-ca...
- bitsweet 12y agoThis. I liken it to Segment.io who managed to move up the analytics stack and being the integration point for a product. This lowers the switching costs to using other analytic services and gives Segment all the leverage to create the highest value products in the future and offer one button migration. Additionally they have efficient platform economics with their emerging app-store. If I was an analytics provider I'd be really worried about Segment. Now Magic has something that could be similar, defaulting them to owning all the relationships with the consumer in the very hot on-demand industry.
- timr 12y agoTo use a different analytics service, I have to change my code. To use an alternative to Magic, I have to text a different phone number. apples and oranges.
- softdev12 12y agoDon't forget that they have a stored credit card with payment information as well (via Stripe). That's another barrier to entry - especially considering the effort in building up enough trust to hand over payment details.
- timr 12y agothat certainly appears to have been a barrier to their launch.
- martythemaniak 12y agoI haven't used magic, but their demos imply that they keep data on you. Example: "Send a cake to my girlfriend" "That'll be $45.43 in 90 minutes". "ok, do it" Who's the girlfriend? Where does she live? It's evident they've asked these questions the first time she's come up and then recorded them for later use. Since the service relies to much on personalization, the longer you use it the higher the switching cost will be.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- krisgenre 12y agoThink they might have over simplified it in the demo. There is no way for them to know if the girlfriend has become an ex or if the person is still living at the same location. They would have to confirm it every time.
- peteretep 12y ago> There is no way for them to know if the girlfriend has > become an ex or if the person is still living at the > same location. They would have to confirm it every time. "That'll be $45.43 in 90 minutes to Kate at 123 Bubble St". Big deal.
- timr 12y agoYeah, it's so much harder to just type that the first time: "send X to my girlfriend at 123 bubble st" So I stand corrected. This is obviously a massive, defensible industry. Nevermind the fact that there are a dozen of these things in Europe, and none are notable businesses.
- downandout 12y agoActually the barriers to entry aren't that low. You need to have at least 6 figures to deal with the "float" problem (7 or 8 figures if you're successful), you have to hire people to deal with the orders, etc. Then you have the whole fraud aspect, which if not carefully managed could quickly bankrupt the business regardless of its bankroll. If I were a Russian credit card thief, I'd be hammering away at Magic right now. "Find me a Rolex submariner with 2 tone gold and mother of pearl face".
- patio11 12y agoYou need to have at least 6 figures to deal with the "float" problem (7 or 8 figures if you're successful) What's your modeling look like here? They capture payment on day 0, are sent an ACH from Stripe on day 2, and physically have it in the bank on day 3~5. The worst possible credit terms they'll have with vendors is "We put it on our Amex on day 0, are invoiced by Amex on day 15, and pay the invoice on day 22." That lasts until they can tell without-loss-of-generality 1800Flowers "We did 100k with you last month. Give us 30 day net on a rolling monthly basis. [+]" My back-of-envelope math suggests they have ~15 days of float at present and will have ~40 days once they have direct relationships with suppliers. They're almost certainly generating tremendous positive cash flow, limited only by their ability to generate transactions. [+] That will not be the only ask in that conversation, believe me. I'd take pertinent note that 1800Flowers has fat, fat margins and is willing to pay affiliates 25% commissions, then ask them for their top-tier affiliate offer. Who benefits from that discount? Magic, because they're selecting for price-insensitive customers. If 1800Flowers doesn't want to play ball, you just update your CS docs to say "Our preferred flower vendor is $EMPLOYS_SANE_BD_TEAM."
- downandout 12y ago> "We put it on our Amex on day 0, are invoiced by Amex on day 15, and pay the invoice on day 22." Despite what people think, Amex is not unlimited [1]...in fact it has a limit, they just don't tell you what it is. Although he edited the comment, a very ignorant person posted below that they could just charge a few million dollars to their Amex, and pay it off at the end of the month. No, they couldn't. When you hit the Amex limit you don't know about, your card gets declined. That's why they don't say "unlimited," they say "no pre-set spending limit". So that may have been good for maybe $20K or so (depending on the credit of the person whose card it was) but that doesn't get them anywhere near the finish line if they really had 17K requests in the first 2 days. I agree with you that they could work out discounts/affiliate agreements with some large merchants, but given that this is a long-tail business, that won't be the norm. [1] http://www.moneyunder30.com/american-express-cards-do-have-spending-limits http://www.moneyunder30.com/american-express-cards-do-have-s...
- amirmc 12y agoA large part of your blog post seems to be premised on the difference between incoming cash and outgoing cash. That only works as long as the people you're paying will accept net-30 (or have it imposed on them) -- Amazon was a great example of this but their suppliers also got wise to it. In the current scenario, all those instacarts, eat24s, etc are also looking to get paid first, so this advantage should evaporate (leaving only those which are systemic -- ie banks, processors, etc).
- patio11 12y agoIf you receive money on a credit card and pay expenses on a credit card, you're virtually guaranteed to have positive cash flow. It's one of those services you're buying when you pay CC processing fees. Example: Suppose I am in a "Buy things for $50, sell them for $60" like Magic is. Day 0 is the transaction day. I buy the good/service for $50 on my Amex and capture a $60 transaction from the end-user using Stripe. Stripe sends me 97% of $60 on day 2. It arrives in my bank account on day 5. My next Amex statement is, probabilistically, issued on day 15, and includes the $50 I spent to service my customer. On day 22, I instruct my bank to transfer Amex $50. (We'll ignore the relevant detail that I'm generating cash rewards from Amex up the wazoo once I hit scale.) In addition to $8.20 or so of revenue I've also had ~17 days of use of someone else's $58.20.
- ojilles 12y agoExtremes in this area: insurance companies, pension funds. I think it's called "float".
- shalmanese 12y agoOK, so in the 17 days I have the $58.20, let's say I can make a completely optimistic 5% APR return risk free on my float. I've now made a whopping 13.5c extra on top of my $8.20 I made providing the service. Excuse me if I'm not getting excited over squeezing out an extra 1.6% profit.
- mikeyouse 12y ago