5 ms·
House Introduces Bill to Repeal the Patriot Act
- bkurtz13 12y agoI really want to believe this could become reality. But the past surrounding this issue, as well as seemingly widespread apathy about our loss of civil liberties, leaves me cynical. Nearly every time I fly, I hear someone in the security line (which to me resembles a cattle chute) remarking that they're in fact glad for the inconvenience, as they somehow feel safer. Nearly every family member or friend with whom I discuss Edward Snowden's revelations and the vast injustice of what the NSA is doing couldn't care less. I really don't have much hope for this bill. But I really wish I could believe in it as much as my younger self would have.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoPeople value 'feeling safer' far more than 'being safer' or 'having rights'. This is the classical problem of not appreciating what you have until it's gone.
- mc32 12y agoIs that surprising in any way? Not saying it's right kr desirable but we've understood this phenomenon to exist in many contexts. We buy expensive wines over better cheaper ones for the sake of feeling better. It's a life of interpreted experience not cold logic. Life would be too complicated to think of the actuality of everything. It's got commonality with say a concept like pervasive direct democracy. Imagine having to make a decision a d vote on every single government act., even if only local. Most people would become exhausted of the process of this indefinite mobilization mindset. So feeling more secure is easier than actually being statistically more secure. Peace of mind is important. Look at insurance. You could probably run numbers and find other ways to minimize loss in the event of something catastrophic, but most of us just buy into external public insurance policies.
- jmccree 12y agoFor an example of this, in GA last year a bill was passed that allowed people with weapons carry licenses (who have to be fingerprinted, background checked, etc.) to carry weapons into unsecured government buildings. Immediately local governments began complaining about now having to install metal detectors and have police officers to screen people for weapons before entering their buildings. Local government officials said they didn't "feel safe" with the new law, even though by virtue of being an unsecured building, nothing prevented a person with illegal intentions from entering with a weapon before or after the law. The law just exposed the faulty thinking that a "no guns" sticker on the front door would keep bad guys out.
- twoodfin 12y agoNearly every family member or friend with whom I discuss Edward Snowden's revelations and the vast injustice of what the NSA is doing couldn't care less. It's possible they don't believe the Snowden revelations represent a loss of civil liberties. I actually find this to be a pretty rational belief: There's much talk about NSA data harvesting efforts as a "machinery of totalitarianism", but precious little (any?) evidence it's actually been employed that way. Real harm, not just the potential for harm, is what will motivate American citizens and their political leaders. After all, we have an election every four years giving one of us the potential power to kill millions and end civilization as we know it; that he or she also has the power to authorize computer systems that trawl through domestic phone records looking for connections to foreign bad guys doesn't seem that alarming in comparison.
- jgroszko 12y agoIt's weird public discourse has gone from "Na, the NSA couldn't possibly be that widespread and invasive" to "Na, they're not doing anything bad with it..." It's like some collective denial of what the next step could be, apparently we have a lot more faith in government than a lot of people let on...
- twoodfin 12y agoI don't remember that Pollyanna public discourse. What would you consider the most shocking Snowden disclosure? None that I'm aware of were that surprising. It was an open secret at the phone companies that TLA folk of one sort or another have been (only sometimes with direct cooperation) plugging mysterious gear into the network for decades. Really astounding that their methods are now targeted at Gmail and Facebook?
- jgroszko 12y agoThe firmware exploits that were being talked about a few weeks ago are probably the most surprising to me. But IIRC a lot of the stuff that Snowden revealed was previously considered the realm of tin foil hat conspiracy theory.
- 12y ago
- jdp23 12y ago> I really don't have much hope for this bill. It's hard to know. Of course the cards are stacked against any chance to the surveillance state, especially in the Senate, but then again this is happening within the context of several clauses of the Patriot Act (including section 215) sunsetting unless Congress extends it by June. And this bill has been crafted with an eye to getting transpartisan support; it's huge that there's a Republican co-sponsor, and how many other things do Freedom Works and Demand Progress work together on? Also, portions of this bill were actually passed as an amendment to the Defense Authorization last June, with a surprisingly large majority. So, we shall see.
- timepiece 12y agoI hear someone in the security line (which to me resembles a cattle chute) remarking that they're in fact glad for the inconvenience They could be govt stooges (field agents) implanted to distort public opinion and create a false narrative that the general public is happy with these draconian procedures and that they're very popular (peer pressure) to advance their agenda and support the status-quo.
- bhayden 12y agoThis would have to be pretty massive in scale, and the people standing around doing this all day are probably not well qualified or paid. If this was happening there would be people talking about it.
- timepiece 12y agoIt doesn't need to be on a massive scale or not pro-bono. It's enough to some people in the govt to volunteer and go on a disinformation field trip.
- mfringel 12y agoFull text of bill: https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/house-bill/1466/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/house-bill/1466...
- nfoz 12y agoThank you. It is short and fascinating.
- jdp23 12y agoAnd here's a couple of other articles with additional context and quotes - http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/civil-rights/236641-legislate-against-big-brother http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/civil-rights/236641-l... - http://thinkprogress.org/election/2015/03/24/3638234/house-members-move-repeal-patriot-act-strongest-anti-surveillance-bill-date/ http://thinkprogress.org/election/2015/03/24/3638234/house-m...
- kmeves 12y agoCan someone who is informed on this shed some light on its shortcomings? I know this is new, but the article on the bill is a bit too supportive that it feels highly biased. I can't help but feel that the line about collection on foreign enemies for WMD's is some sort of loophole. I agree with bkurtz--its surprising how few people care about Snowden's revelations.
- happyscrappy 12y ago>the line about collection on foreign enemies for WMD's is some sort of loophole The view that the NSA should do no spying at all is a minority absurdist viewpoint that is easily discarded.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoNo it isn't. The NSA doesn't have to exist at all. It didn't used to. Its questionable that they do anything positive. The discussion is very much worthwhile.
- refurb 12y agoThe US has been spying on communications since it's inception. It may not have been called the "NSA", but the activities have always happened.
- tomjen3 12y agoIf you are just going to disregard minority opinions, why should the minority not just disregard you?
- mkempe 12y ago"A Republic, if you can keep it." [1] This is a positive step. It will be interesting to watch who opposes it, and how, in the various branches of government. [1] http://constitutioncenter.org/learn/educational-resources/historical-documents/perspectives-on-the-constitution-a-republic-if-you-can-keep-it http://constitutioncenter.org/learn/educational-resources/hi...
- astrodust 12y agoHow ironic that FreedomWorks (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FreedomWorks http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FreedomWorks) is the source for this reporting.
- adventured 12y agoWhat's the irony? Here's their motto from the Wiki link of yours: "Lower Taxes. Less Government. More Freedom." Ending the Patriot Act would accomplish two of those. They're apparently in part a libertarian leaning group; libertarians are usually against the Patriot Act.
- astrodust 12y agoThe same money that brought about the Bush government, which instituted most of this junk in the first place, is behind FreedomWorks. "Freedom" for billionaires means something different than for you and me.
- briandh 12y agoNot really. Its president and CEO is a self-described libertarian [1] and FreedomWorks is co-plaintiff in Rand Paul's NSA lawsuit [2]. [1] http://reason.com/archives/2014/08/10/being-a-libertarian-in-dc http://reason.com/archives/2014/08/10/being-a-libertarian-in... [2] https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/1017524-rand-paul-complaint.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/1017524-rand-paul-co...
- ck2 12y agoCareful what you wish for. Instead of one big target bill with a set of laws allowing unconstitutional activity by the government, they will replace it with a ton of tiny laws buried in other bills that are impossible to target as a group. Actually now that I think about it, Congress barely passes any bills anyway anymore so that would be tricky for them, but since many of them are there for decades, they have plenty of time. Term limits really would make sense.
- patrickmay 12y ago> Term limits really would make sense. Three terms in the House, two in the Senate. Eighteen years is more than enough time for anyone to hold that much power. A nice side effect would be more people working hard at the state level rather than seeing the state legislature as just a stepping stone to national office.
- worklogin 12y agoTwo terms in the Senate is 12 years, two in the house is 4. So I don't know where you got 18 from!
- chrisparsons 12y agoAssuming one person would hit both term limits: 2 6-year terms in the Senate plus 3 2-year terms in the house would be 18.
- worklogin 12y agoI saw two and two. My mistake.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Term limits really would make sense. Term limits empower the influential actors that aren't directly accountable (lobbyists, professional staff, etc.) because the people that are directly accountable don't have the experience (unless gained through those other avenues) to be effective, and don't have a future in the institution (except as influencers in those other avenues). They don't actually address the problems you point too. Lots of state governments have legislative term limits, and many times have much more of the same kind of problem you seem concerned about.
- glasz 12y agoyeah. nice try. won't happen. the entirety of domestic and foreign politics of the national security state, that is the United States today, is based on the policies introduced or made possible by this very act. you, the people, and your electorate won't just undo 15 years of tyranny without spilling blood. hard words, i know. but that's how i, as a foreigner, see it, see your country. you won't take anything back by making a check on a piece of paper or signing online petitions. that's gone, now.
- unics 12y agoThe disconnect between the legislature and the population is too wide now to expect this to come to fruition. But one can hope.
- tempodox 12y agoPassing this bill would be the first step in restoring the rule of law and hope for the survival of democracy in the U.S. Too good to be true.
- Balgair 12y agohttp://whoismyrepresentative.com/ http://whoismyrepresentative.com/ Go ahead and give them a call to voice you opinion on how you want them to vote. Democracy only works if you participate in it. Remember that phone calls and actual letters are worth a lot to a Rep. Go ahead and give your senators a call too. Make sure to save all 3 numbers in your phone for easy access, that way anytime you want to participate in democracy, it is easier to do so.
- clarkm 12y agoSince it's HN, I'll note that one of the cosponsors, Thomas Massie, is both a Mechanical Engineer and an entrepreneur. In the mid-90s, he and his wife (also an MIT engineer) started SensAble Technologies, a company which develops haptic feedback hardware and software. He has also built his own off the grid house, and even appeared on Junkyard Wars.