8 ms·
Fund Manager Ab Nicholas Has Been Beating S&P 500 for 40 Years
- DontGiveTwoFlux 12y agoBut what are the fees he charges? I bet that 2 million figure doesn't incorporate fees.
- jjoonathan 12y agoAlso, how are they accounting for survivor bias in the "best of" lists? I often hear the outliers make claims like "the models predict that we shouldn't exist -- if the analysts are right, there shouldn't be any outliers as good as we are." The implicit argument is that the people claiming "on average, stock pickers don't beat the index" don't know what tehy're talking about. But it's widely acknowledged that the tails are exactly where modeling of this kind tend to fail, so I'm not convinced. A model that gets the tails wrong might still be much better at figuring out expected value, which is what investors should actually care about. How do I make sure that they're not just trying to sell a product with sub-par expected return by chopping off yesterday's heavy tail and waving it around?
- fsk 12y agoSurvivor bias doesn't really matter here, because we're looking at only the best. In order to properly correct for survivor bias, you'd have to count the # of funds that were created in the past 40 years, and then figure out (assuming a normal distribution of performance), what you expect the best fund performance to be. He has to beat that number to be considered genuinely better (rather than being the luckiest). For example suppose that the volatility of the S&P 500 is 10% per year. In a 40 year period, the volatility is thus 0.10 times sqrt(40), the central limit theorem, or 63%. So, a 1 standard deviation move in the S&P 500 over 40 years is 63%. To outperform by 2% per year, is 1.02^40 = 2.28 = 128% gain. 63% * 2 = 126% So, this guy performed two standard deviations above the mean over 40 years. That certainly is within the realm of random chance, considering he was the best/luckiest. Therefore, I conclude he did not outperform the market by a statistically significant margin. Actually, I'd expect the best fund to be 3 or 4 standard deviations above the mean (given the # of funds), so this result is an argument AGAINST active managers. Actually, the volatility of the S&P 500 is more than 10%, so I overestimated his performance. It's closer to 15% long-term, but it's varied a lot over 40 years.
- jjoonathan 12y ago> assuming a normal distribution of performance If someone assumes that performance is normally distributed (e.g. by dividing by standard deviation and using the gaussian CDF to reject null hypotheses), couldn't you arbitrage against them by creating a bunch of "heavy tail" funds, waiting for a few of them to beat the market in a more extreme fashion than the normal distribution would predict is possible, and then using the normal distribution to "prove" that it couldn't have happened by chance?
- fsk 12y agoNo, because 1. You can't normally short sell mutual funds. As a retail investor, short selling is hard. Plus, short selling has fees, even for institutional investors. 2. Even if a fund gets lucky (or unlucky), its future returns are also normally distributed. I.e, if a fund beats the market 20% one year, its next year is just as likely to be lucky again as unlucky. Funds that underperform the market severely are closed or merged into other funds. Funds that get lucky and trounce the market tend to stay open. If your 5 year track record is +20%/year, and you have a "bad" year, your 6 year track record is still +15%/year.
- pwg 12y agoBased upon the Prospectus Summary (http://www.nicholasfunds.com/NF/Summary.html http://www.nicholasfunds.com/NF/Summary.html) the total annual fund operating expenses are 0.73%. Contrast that with Vanguards S&P 500 fund (http://www.vanguard.com/pub/Pdf/p040.pdf http://www.vanguard.com/pub/Pdf/p040.pdf) at 0.17% for Investor Shares and 0.05% for Admiral Shares
- NhanH 12y agoThat's some bad reporting by Bloomberg. The advice against active manage fund isn't that they can't beat the market. It's that they can't beat the market better than random chance. In other words, the argument was that performance of stock picker is a completely random process that follow the standard normal distribution. Some one will beat the market, you can't tell who it is though
- Mikeb85 12y agoYou most definitely can beat the market, and beat it by a lot. However, the bigger your holdings, the less likely it is to beat the market, since your trade execution suffers the more you're trying to trade at a time (try selling off 100K shares in something when the daily volume is less than a million, for instance). Anyhow, half the point of a hedge fund isn't even to beat the market, but to hedge against market downturns. The ones beating the market are prop traders and the like...
- cowsandmilk 12y agofunds 4, 5, and 6 on the bloomberg list (the primecap funds) are all closed to new investors. That is one way to try to avoid the problem.
- vasilipupkin 12y agoyes, if you have a million money managers, 50K of them will beat the market, at a 5% confidence interval another problem is, what is the proper benchmark? say he beat S&P 500. Ok, but we know that small stocks or value stocks outperform S&P 500. Did he beat a small stocks index? My guess is once you construct a proper benchmark, it becomes even less likely that he really did beat it.
- mizzao 12y agoAnother way to look at what you're saying is to ask whether a small cap index beat the S&P 500 over the last 40 years. Of course it did (see the following link for the last 10 years, as Google doesn't have earlier data; https://www.google.com/finance?chdnp=1&chdd=1&chds=1&chdv=1&chvs=maximized&chdeh=0&chfdeh=0&chdet=1427071690248&chddm=1064088&chls=IntervalBasedLine&cmpto=INDEXSP:SP600&cmptdms=0&q=INDEXSP:.INX&ntsp=0&ei=IGIPVYHoB4O38QafpIDABA https://www.google.com/finance?chdnp=1&chdd=1&chds=1&chdv=1&... ); as higher (diversified) risk begets higher return, but the returns were also far more volatile. So if he still achieved the return of a small cap index without as much volatility, that would have accomplished something.
- zdw 12y ago> Nicholas’s focus on avoiding losses helped him in 2008, when he beat 93 percent of peers, and in 2011, when he beat 96 percent as the S&P 500 gained 2.1 percent. So, survivor bias - this guy happens to be the current unicorn. To give a tech comparison, imagine it's 1980 and you're trying to pick who would be on top of the heap of the tech industry in 2015. There's not much more than a dartboard chance. I wonder what the real ROI is compared to a simple S&P 500 tracking index fund with all additional fees taken into account for both cases.
- splike 12y agoI don't know whether you're right or not (that this particular fund is just a lucky survivor), but I don't like this argument. The classification of anyone that beats the market as a lucky unicorn is logically impermeable. If you accept the argument, then no matter who says they're beating the market, you'll be able to dismiss them without further thought. There needs to be a better argument, one that allows for the hypothetical fund that does manage to do something intelligent and beat the market. I find that this style of logically impermeable arguments crop up quite often when dealing with peoples belief structures. Here yours is that the stock market cannot be beaten, which may or may not be true. A useful question to ask in these situations is; Suppose that your belief is wrong, what evidence do you imagine might prove that it is in fact wrong? When you can answer that question, you'll have a more concrete argument for why this fund is indeed just a lucky survivor.
- richardwhiuk 12y agoThe obvious rebuttal is to argue that there is a pattern to picking unicorns, and then argue that a current investor will beat the market this year, and then use the same argument next year. Note, being a unicorn isn't necessarily a sinker for an argument, it just can't be your only defence (i.e. gravity is the unicorn of theories about why things fall :) )
- UnGravitas 12y agoThe argument isn't that anyone who beats the market is a lucky unicorn, it's that you can't tell if they're a lucky unicorn or not. Beliefs about beating the market aren't really relevant, the argument would be the same if we were evaluating a cancer treatment which only one person had taken.
- encoderer 12y agoMillions of people make money trading. Yes, it's hard for hedge funds to generate returns on billions of dollars. Luckily (?) for me, I don't have the problem of investing billions. Instead, I can seek-out high probability trades (pairs trades, spreads, futures and other derivatives, anything really, i'm agnostic to specific product). I'm not saying everybody should do what I do, just offering my own experience.
- jeffreyrogers 12y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted. HN seems to have an aversion to the idea that some people can beat the market. Yes, it's hard, but there are certainly strategies that have performed well historically (value, momentum, selling volatility, as well as the more specialized ones you mentioned), and look like they'll do so going forward. It's odd how very few on HN doubt the ability of HFTs to make money, but when it comes to active management the assumption is that no one can really add value.
- btian 12y agoBecause his comment has zero value.
- encoderer 12y agoI'm being downvoted because people on HN are smart but have been sold a bill of goods that people don't make money trading, and that creates an emotional reaction. As if wall street firms can all make billions but literally nobody else can make a dollar trading. Maybe they lost money and convinced themselves that the game is rigged. Who knows. People like btian below feel they have a moral obligation to protect the innocent from the charlatans, and hey at least that's noble, even if it is misplaced. I don't think the way I trade is right for most people. Primarily because it takes time and many people don't care to invest time in managing their money. Also because it takes a lump sum of capital that many people do not have. But the idea of making very high probability trades using leverage is not even provocative, it's boring and the antithesis of "get rich quick". It's about grinding it out, carefully balancing your delta risk to guard against "black swan" events, managing trade timeline to reduce gamma risk. Anybody can get an education in this stuff, it's not black magic. I avoid talking about this stuff on HN because the downvotes come in swarms, which is something i SMH at -- ideas getting censored here of all places -- but I don't like the "nobody can make any money trading" folks to have the airwaves solely to themselves.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Luc 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Superinvestors_of_Graham-and-Doddsville http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Superinvestors_of_Graham-an...
- cs702 12y agoThe report I'd love to see is one that determines whether there are any unusual characteristics among outperforming fund managers that cannot be explained by chance. For example, I'd love to see: the percent of fund managers who quote Warren Buffett that outperform over five- and 10-year periods; the percent of fund managers who are significant investors in their own funds that outperform the indices over five- and 10-year periods; and so on.
- kriro 12y agoFrom a quick look it seems like he is more of a value investor than a rapid trader. Just to make sure for the people who are claiming he's a unicorn/the top end outlier of a normal distribution...do you claim the same about Buffett? Or is it different because Nicholas basically charges for the stock picking and with Buffett you invest in "his" company?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- natch 12y agoHindsight is 20/20. An index fund is still better than choosing whatever fund someone tells you to. If you can travel in time 40 years ahead and know that your non-index fund is going to be THE one that outperforms, then sure, go for it. But if you don't have that time machine, index fund is the wiser bet.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- eximius 12y agoIf you had the same number of monkeys as you had fund managers, I'm sure at least one would also do well for 40 years. Statistically, one of them is bound to be lucky. (Nothing against this guy - probably a combination of skill and luck, which I doubt he'd deny.)
- firethief 12y ago> This Fund Manager Has Consistently Beaten the S&P 500 for 40 Years ... > The Nicholas Fund, which he has run since 1969, has topped the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index by an average of 2 percentage points a year for the past 40 years and has beaten it every year since 2008. Was 2008 already 40 years ago, or is the title using "consistently" in a figurative sense?
- DavidSJ 12y agoThe title appears to be inaccurate. The fund has, on average, outperformed the market by 2%/year over 40 years, which works out to 120% outperformance with compounding. That is far less impressive than beating the market consistently (i.e. every year) for 40 years. He's only done that for the last 7.
- powera 12y agoFrom the (terrible) article: "The Nicholas Fund, which he has run since 1969, has topped the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index by an average of 2 percentage points a year for the past 40 years and has beaten it every year since 2008. If you think that doesn’t make a big difference, consider this: A $10,000 investment in the Nicholas Fund in September 1974 was worth about $2 million in September 2014, roughly twice the value of the same investment in the index." Sounds impressive, but from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkshire_Hathaway http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkshire_Hathaway : "Berkshire Hathaway averaged an annual growth in book value of 19.7% to its shareholders for the last 49 years (compared to 9.8% from the S&P 500 with dividends included for the same period)"
- ArkyBeagle 12y agoWeird, because y_to_the(1/41) of 200* is about 1.1379 for an annual gain rate of 13.79 - which does not match 9.8 plus 2. *the 41st root of 200... n such than exp(n,41) == 200...
- lewisl9029 12y agoCorrect me if I'm reading this incorrectly, but this is what the article says: "The Nicholas Fund, which he has run since 1969, has topped the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index by an average of 2 percentage points a year for the past 40 years and has beaten it every year since 2008." Does this not mean that it has not, in fact, "been beating S&P 500 for 40 years"? Very misleading title if this is the case. And a lot of the comments I'm reading here seem to have indeed been mislead into thinking that it has beaten S&P consecutively for 40 years. That said, index funds' popularity is part performance, part cost. Were costs factored into these performance metric? If not, I wonder how much of the 2% gains would have been passed on to the individual investor, if any at all.