3 ms·
Kudos to this article for pointing out the problem: absentee foreign investors, often laundering dirty money. Real estate in the most desirable cities is becomi
by michaelochurch 12y ago
Kudos to this article for pointing out the problem: absentee foreign investors, often laundering dirty money. Real estate in the most desirable cities is becoming the 21st century's Nazi Gold: stolen wealth that is parked in another country, and with too many third-party beneficiaries who refuse to do the right thing.
Here's another factor that doesn't get much play: price inelasticity. Consider the 1970s oil crises. A 5% drop in supply availability would cause prices to go up 4-5 times. People can look at the statistics and say, "This only effects 10% of property, so it's not a big deal." Wrong. A small amount of supply destruction or removal can have a huge effect on the price. Why do you think De Beers sits on vaults of unused diamonds?
Inelasticity has an interesting effect of creating a lot of fake wealth, which is why so many people are complicit in the crime: Baby Boomer NIMBYs in California who don't give a damn either way about Chinese corruption or money laundering, but who become financially vested in blocking any positive change that might threaten property values by increasing supply (i.e. letting the market do what it's fucking supposed to do).
Too many people are afraid to appear politically incorrect by blaming overseas malefactors. First, it's not just "the Chinese". It's corrupt officials and criminals from all over the world: including some from rich European countries like Italy and France. You don't see them in the SF or Vancouver market, but you have a lot of European drug kingpins buying in Manhattan. Second: these people are the exact opposite of the traditional immigrants that made (and are continuing to make) the U.S. and Canada great. The traditional immigrants were and are trying to get away from poverty, oppression, and a lack of opportunity. They were trying to escape the flaws of other (often corrupt and failing) societies. We welcomed them with open arms, as we should, even though many of them had nothing in terms of economic wealth. These new buyers are the opposite, because they often don't live here (and won't, unless they get caught stealing from their home countries and have to escape) and because they are just trying to park their ill-gotten assets somewhere. Instead of trying to escape from corrupt societies, they're people who actively profit from overseas corruption and our using our real estate to launder their loot.
- api 12y agoReal estate hyperinflation is a scourge of the modern world. It is time for cities and even countries to act to curtail absentee landlords playing Ponzi games with real estate to the extreme detriment of cities, culture, and the real economy. This is the worst kind of non productive market pathology... Worse in many ways than stock market bubbles and non-physical financial Ponzi schemes. Kudos for pointing out the complicity of baby boomer land owners in this. It's another way for them to screw their children, something they've been systemically good at.
- LiweiZ 12y agoVery well said. Political incorrectness is more like a protocol to tolerate differences to some extent for a diversified society. It's an essential element. However, on the other hand, it compromises the ability for most of us to have a more open debate. But perhaps it's the best we can have for now. edit: typo
- IndianAstronaut 12y agoNow is a golden opportunity for Canada to take action on the laundered money in Vancouver. Xi Jinping is taking major steps to stomp out corruption in China and would likely be a partner. The problem is that there is likely some corruption and bribing going on in Canada as well, thus nothing is being done about this issue.
- api 12y agoIn virtually all societies, land owners tend to hold more power than younger people and renters. So far the land owners are doing well from this.
- kyllo 12y agoXi Jinping is taking major steps to stomp out corruption No, he's just doing the same thing every Chinese leader since Mao has done, using anti-corruption measures as a weapon to smite his own political enemies. Xi and his own family are as corrupt as anyone. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-06-29/xi-jinping-millionaire-relations-reveal-fortunes-of-elite http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-06-29/xi-jinping...