14 ms·
Clever hack, but if you're coming up with ways to circumvent your religion's practices, are you really still practicing your religion?
by freehunter 12y ago
Clever hack, but if you're coming up with ways to circumvent your religion's practices, are you really still practicing your religion?
- judah 12y agoDisclaimer: I'm Jewish and religious, but not Orthodox; I don't worry about sabbath mode as I have no problem turning on an oven during shabbat; it's not work. That said, if you ask Orthodox Jews, they will say it's not circumventing the laws about shabbat. Rather, it's keeping the laws of shabbat -- avoiding all forms of work -- while still living in the modern world. To circumvent the law would be to find a way that allows us to work on shabbat. Shabbat mode doesn't do that.
- Shalomm 12y agoTo extend on parent comment: What you call "circumvent your religion's practices", ie building complicated logical arguments or creating new categories and distinctions to re-interpret existing law is considered as a significant part of Jewish religion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talmud#Pilpul https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talmud#Pilpul In that aspect, Judaism is very different from, say, Christianity.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoExcept for Karaites who don't believe in the Talmud or Oral Torah.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoOr quite a few Jews who lived prior to the invention of Rabbinic Judaism.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoWell (and I hate reply spamming here but I keep thinking of new things) The Talmud and Mishnah were written hundreds of years after the birth of Jesus. And in the first century, the Pharisees (or proto-Rabbinics, or whatever) were only one sect amongst many. So yes, Christianity followed on a different path than Judaism.
- _pius 12y agoI hate reply spamming here but I keep thinking of new things Just as a heads up, you can edit your comments within a certain window of time.
- maaku 12y agoThe Jerusalem church, maybe, which didn't survive 70 CE. Modern Christianity descends from Paul and was pretty much made up in a very significant break from Jewish tradition.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoTrue, that makes (most forms) of Christianity today cousins to Rabbinic Judaism, as opposed to siblings (like early Judeo-Christianity and its extinct descendants-Ebionites, Nazarenes, etc).
- gweinberg 12y agoWell, maybe. I don't understand the argument that you are "doing work" when a light automatically comes on for you in the first place. I can see arguing that opening a refrigerator is work, or that it isn't, but I can't see coming to a different conclusion if a light comes on when you open it. I would have made a crappy rabbi.
- krebby 12y agoThe act of turning on an oven or opening a refrigerator isn't "doing work", but igniting a fire (and by extension completing a circuit) is.
- ScottBurson 12y ago> I would have made a crappy rabbi. Me too. When someone asked me whether such-and-so was work, I would have just said, "Use your judgment. If it feels like work, it's work."
- ars 12y agoWork is not a correct translation though. You can carry heavy furniture in your house, but not a feather on the street. And the reason for that is that it's not about work, but about creative action.
- reuven 12y agoThe term "work" is a very inaccurate (but popular) translation of the Jewish legal term, "melacha." There are certain categories of said "work," and rabbis throughout the ages have tried to figure out how to apply those terms to new situations and inventions. Whether operating electric lights is work is a new problem, but boiling water and cooking have been forbidden by Jewish law for at least 2,000 years.
- ars 12y ago> that you are "doing work" That's because work is not the correct translation. A better translation is "creative activity", i.e. creating things, like light. God stopped creating the world on the Sabbath, so Jews also stop creating things (and there is a specific list of what is included).
- icebraining 12y agoI'm not religious, much less Jewish, but I'd say it depends on the intention behind the practice. If it was intended to encourage the abnegation of luxuries, I think the hacks would miss the point, but since the intention seems to be, as I understand it, to remember and celebrate the Biblical creation, I think it could be argued that the hacks actually help to reinforce that. (Like I said, this is my interpretation and opinion as someone from outside. I make no claim to know or understand Jewish law and traditions.)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- reuven 12y agoWelcome to the world of Jewish law, in which it's considered acceptable to find ways around rules. For example: Jews aren't allowed to eat leavened food, known as "chamets," (e.g., bread) on Passover. We're also not allowed to own leavened products. What do you do with all of the food that you bought before Passover? In theory, you have to throw it out, which would be a huge waste of money. The solution is to sell this food to a non-Jew for the duration of the holiday. The contract says that the non-Jew owns these products for seven days (or eight, if you're outside of Israel). At the conclusion of the holiday, the non-Jew sells it back to the Jew, or fails to finalize the sale, or fails to exercise his/her option, etc. Problem solved: Jews don't own chametz. We don't have to throw it out. Is this using a legal loophole? Oh, yes. Is it universally accepted? No, but pretty close to 100% of the religious Jews I know do it. Have there been big arguments over this subject over the years? Of course! It's Jewish religious law, in which arguments are a part of the culture...
- darklajid 12y agoThis, by the way, is a huge problem for a German expat in IL (back in DE now) during Passover. Not only do they hide bread, there's a certain golden drink that is just as off limits in all the 'following' supermarkets and that's quite interesting. (I kid. Yes, you don't get bread and beer, in theory. Tel Aviv has lots of shops that aren't Jewish or don't care or .. so it's mostly a sight to be seen and a way to explore the city, looking for more accommodating places..)
- ninguem2 12y agoI was lost here for a minute until I finally realized that IL was Israel not Illinois.
- theandrewbailey 12y agoAnd likewise, DE != Delaware.
- X-Istence 12y ago
- MichaelAza 12y agoI'm a non-observant Jew and have several observant friends. I always joke with them that Jews are the first hackers, finding ways to circumvent their own religious laws. Some other clever hacks "exploited" by Jews over the years: * Say a door needs to be opened by a button. For some reason which I can't quite remember right now, you can't just press the button to open the door, but say that after you press the button there is a random wait befroe the door is opened, then it's OK. * You can't light fire on shabbat and, by some logic, that also means you can't close an electrical circuit. But say you have a door that requires a keycard to open. You can't put the keycard next to the reader because that will cause a circuit to close but if you were to press a button that turns off the card reader for some random amount of time (which is OK) and then just happen to put your card in range, when the reader turns itself back on it will recognize your card and open the door. * You can't create permanent things on shabbat and that includes writing. But, say you have to write for some reason - you use a shbbat pan with ink that evaporates after several days (hence, is non-permanent). There are lots of theese hacks, and even a whole R&D center dedicated to them[1] in Israel. Funny stuff. [1] http://www.zomet.org.il/ http://www.zomet.org.il/ (Hebrew)
- matt_morgan 12y agoMy favorite is Eruv[1], which in my neighborhood and others in NYC is tiny thin wires strung between streetlights to "enclose" a neighborhood. In some of our big storms recently many of the wires have come down, limiting people's mobility. To call all this hackery "circumvention" is not accurate ... one way or another, in building & using tricks to live with them, you are being "observant," by remembering and practicing the rules. Remembrance being a key part of faith. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eruv https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eruv
- reuven 12y agoMy take on eruv is that it's one of several elements in Jewish law designed to create and foster communities. Community is crucial to Jewish survival. So among other things: - You need 10 adults to have many important prayer services - You need to eat kosher food -- which is only feasible when there's a critical mass of other Jews around - Women need to go to a ritual bath once a month; it's only feasible to have such a ritual bath if you live near other Jews who help to fund it - You can't carry on the Sabbath unless you have an eruv around your community, in which case you can carry within the community. These, together with other rules, have the effect of encouraging Jews to live near other Jews, which helps to strengthen the community more and perpetuate the tradition. I think that much of Jewish law is aimed at this underlying goal. When a rule conflicts with this goal, it's considered desirable to find a way around the rule, such that the community's centrality and strength win out.
- mikeash 12y agoThe Jewish response to this that I've seen is pretty sensible: if God didn't want there to be loopholes then there wouldn't be any.
- cssmoo 12y agoIf there was a god he'd probably be facepalming.
- reuven 12y agoActually, there's a famous story in the Talmud of a rabbinical debate in which the rabbis argue about whether a certain oven is kosher or not. At the end of the story, one of the rabbis is told that God's reaction to this debate is, "My children have defeated me." The Jewish attitude is that God wants us to debate these laws, and that if we come up with interpretations that seem counter to the literal verses in the Bible, then that's totally OK. The rules were given to people to interpret, and now it's up to us to do that as accurately as possible.
- cssmoo 12y agoActually that's really interesting. Thanks for the detailed reply.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoExcept for Karaites...
- reuven 12y agoYa know, we were always taught about Karaites in school, but I didn't realize that they still existed until about 20 years ago, when a friend mentioned that he knew one. There is a Karaite community in Israel, and I've read some fascinating newspaper articles about them. Claiming that they only accept the literal word of the Bible, without any interpretation, is a bit far-fetched, given that the Bible is so ambiguous and self-contradictory. But some of their interpretations, such as the date of the Shavuot holiday, are pretty reasonable -- except that Jews have basically voted with their feet to reject those interpretations. I think that Karaites are pretty cool, even if (or perhaps because) they're not mainstream. And they demonstrate, I think, Judaism's penchant for pluralism.
- rhizome 12y agoSometimes the hack is even built-in to the religion: http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=334624 http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=334624
- darklajid 12y agoMy entirely useless and anecdotal meeting with Jewish people lead me to believe that this is really mostly a 'pick your parts'.. :) Like, 'Seafood is really okay, I eat that. Pork? No way'. Or 'I don't care about Shabbat all that much, but try to avoid grain based stuff during Passover' etc. etc. The situation is more complicated off course, because I still haven't figured out if I read 'Jewish' as a nation, religion, culture, mixture of two or three? Being raised in a somewhat Christian (sort of - my parents don't care about religion) environment I never felt confused about that one ("Religion", in my book) and I tend to lump everyone Muslim into that same category. Different religion, but .. religion. Jews? No Jew was able to explain to me how it all fits together. So .. I'd bet that there are quite a number of people following (a hand-picked number of) Jewish traditions who wouldn't count as religious if you talk to them about God (or if one exists) and attending services or somesuch things.
- reuven 12y agoJudaism is a throwback to ancient times, in which there was no distinction between your nation and your religion. Joining a nation meant joining the religion; moving elsewhere meant (often) adopting another religion. Jews, after the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem, found ways to keep the religion going even in the absence of national sovereignty or a centralized religious authority. But the notion of a "people of Israel" kept going, such that anyone who converts to Judaism is considered a 100 percent member of the people, not just a convert. Jews who meet up with other Jews around the world have long seen one another as long-lost members of a large family, with a common language (Hebrew), history, and tradition. Even when you meet up with Jews whose practices are different from yours, the feeling is one of mutual respect and excitement at meeting another member of the tribe, so to speak.
- darklajid 12y agoSpent a year living and working in TLV [1], my employer has its corporate headquarter in that area (excuse me trying to avoid naming something specific in public). While I often heard variations of your explanation that still doesn't help me, to be honest. I have trouble understanding the mixture of 'tribal' traditions (and the notion of tribes, as far as I understand the matter of 'how to be Jewish') and believing in God with a rather strict list of rules. > Even when you meet up with Jews whose practices are different from yours, the feeling is one of mutual respect That .. is a bit over the top, no? I mean, no group works like that and my experience of the people in Israel is no difference. This breaks down rather quickly, if I think of coworkers and friends telling me that they don't "get" orthodox Jews and even - that was a big one - often ask airlines to make sure not to sit next to one during a flight. That's Jew vs Jew in the same country here. I mean.. I guess I just want to express my doubts at your happy "one family" explanation here, without bashing anyone. The anecdotes above just cement my point: Is it a religion? Doesn't seem that way, but most rules and traditions are based on what I'd consider a religious base. A nation? Hard, because there wasn't a united nation for quite a long time. Tribe? Well, ignoring the problem w/ believing that the tribes described in some book are real and somehow continue to exist until today, how do you cope with people that convert to Judaism? People abandoning the faith and becoming - for example - Christians? How do you rationalize the matriarchal way of automatically 'being' part of the team? And if you look into the biggest country of Jews today, could you stuff a young gay boy from Tel Aviv in a room with a representative of Bnei Brak's population and get a consensus on what it means to be Jewish? No bashing intended. Seriously. I'd love to move back or return for lots and lots of trips. The language is awesome, I fell in love with the country. But .. the identity is a mystery to me and sometimes it seems that the internal view isn't thaaat much clearer (as above: Just pick a number of people from the quite diverse pool of people). 1: And I miss it. Last trip to TLV was a couple month ago, hope to be there soon again.
- DanBC 12y agoI've found the people on http://judaism.stackexchange.com/questions http://judaism.stackexchange.com/questions respond well to polite questions. I've learnt a lot - mostly when I'm planning something to not worry about the rules and to just ask the person involved.
- shmerl 12y agoIt's not a circumvention. It's exactly practicing it.
- arikrak 12y agoWhat laws are being circumvented? Observant Jews could always re-heat food on the Sabbath, this just lets them do it with modern ovens. The Sabbath mode lets them set how long the oven stays on over Sabbath.
- Dylan16807 12y agoThe opposite happens too. Look at where the rule against mixing milk and meat comes from. Such an enormous extrapolation from an ultra-specific line.
- maratd 12y ago> Such an enormous extrapolation from an ultra-specific line. To be fair, cooking a calf in its mother's milk is pretty messed up, so going a bit overboard on that one isn't going to keep me up at night.
- david-given 12y agoWell, not very. The usual agricultural practice for dairy cows is to take the calves away so that they're not consuming the mother's milk (because you want the milk; that's why you're keeping them in the first place). Female calves become more dairy cows, but male calves are pretty much useless, so you eat them. So chances are you'll have prepared veal from the male calf at the same time as its mother is producing milk. I've never been certain what this law was for. Most religious food practices stem from food hygiene laws; unclean animals are usually riddled with parasites, kosher and halal killing practices codify particular (safe) ways of slaughtering animals because otherwise people wouldn't do it properly --- but this one? Dunno.
- shliachtx 12y agoThe laws of kosher are actually used as an example of a law that we don't know the reason. It is kept only because G-d commanded.
- ars 12y ago> I've never been certain what this law was for. Most religious food practices stem from food hygiene laws; This is a made up explanation by people trying to fit religion into their worldview. But actually the kosher laws have no reason, God simply said to do them, and that's it. We keep them because God asked up to. There are some laws God gave reasons for, but Kosher is not one of them.
- alnafie 12y agoThe Quran actually contains a story about a Jewish coastal town that would put their nets out to catch fish before the Sabbath and collect them after the Sabbath. The story is meant to be a warning against going by the letter of the law and ignoring the spirit of it. See [7:163 to 7:170].
- _halgari 12y agoThis (among a few other reasons) is why Jesus went on a rant against the religious leaders of the day in Matthew chapter 23. One of the practices at the time was for Pharisees to give all their possessions to the temple (of which they were members), therefore effectively being so poor that they could tell their elderly parents: "I have nothing to give you", this practice was known as Corban. Jesus condemned the people of the day for that in Mark 7. In short, as Jesus said: "Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! For you travel land and sea to win one proselyte, and when he is won, you make him twice as much a son of hell as yourselves"
- ars 12y ago"Corban"? No, that's not what Corban is. A Corban is an animal sacrifice. Is your error or an error in your source text?