15 ms·
Sabbath mode
- brianwawok 12y agoIt is interesting. I think elevators in some building will run, but with the buttons disabled. So its like Go to floor 1 Open doors Wait 30 seconds Close doors Go to floor 2 <Repeat in a loop>
- judah 12y agoYeah, there are some elevators in Israel that do this on shabbat.
- liveoneggs 12y agoalso in new york city
- kazinator 12y agoWhat if you push the button really slowly, so that it's a thermodynamically an adiabatic process? As you release the button equally slowly, it does an equal amount of work on you. The process has been thermodynamically reversed, so all is cool! (The irreversible state change in the button-driven machine, arguably, increased entropy, though, ouch. Maybe not!)
- k__ 12y agoYou have to slip and fall on the button.
- cssmoo 12y agoCan you ask someone to press it for you?
- krebby 12y agoIt depends on your interpretation of rabbinic law. In most cases the answer would be no (since you're still causing the effect by your actions), but some frum families used to employ a shabbos goy [0] to light candles, do shopping, cook, etc. Any action is permissible if it was going to happen anyway, but you get into degrees of technicality of the definition of "what was going to happen anyway". [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shabbos_goy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shabbos_goy
- ars 12y agoIn general no. Non-Jews are not required to keep the Shabbat, but Jews can not ask them to do things for them. There are two exceptions, one is in the case of urgency that is not life threatening (for example a cold baby in a house with the heat off). (If it was life threatening than you just do it yourself.) The second is you can hint to the non-Jews. For example say: It's so dark in here. Then the non-Jew is doing it for himself and not for you, and it's permitted. However doing this is discouraged except when it's important.
- ars 12y agoThere is a leniency for indirectly causing things to happen. The details of when the leniency is permitted to be used are pretty complicated.
- cssmoo 12y agoI have never observed correlation between the intended floor and the actual lift travel and floor you end up on so I'd suggest that all lifts probably operate in a similar manor. Either that or its just malicious embedded systems engineers :)
- freehunter 12y agoClever hack, but if you're coming up with ways to circumvent your religion's practices, are you really still practicing your religion?
- judah 12y agoDisclaimer: I'm Jewish and religious, but not Orthodox; I don't worry about sabbath mode as I have no problem turning on an oven during shabbat; it's not work. That said, if you ask Orthodox Jews, they will say it's not circumventing the laws about shabbat. Rather, it's keeping the laws of shabbat -- avoiding all forms of work -- while still living in the modern world. To circumvent the law would be to find a way that allows us to work on shabbat. Shabbat mode doesn't do that.
- Shalomm 12y agoTo extend on parent comment: What you call "circumvent your religion's practices", ie building complicated logical arguments or creating new categories and distinctions to re-interpret existing law is considered as a significant part of Jewish religion: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talmud#Pilpul https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talmud#Pilpul In that aspect, Judaism is very different from, say, Christianity.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoExcept for Karaites who don't believe in the Talmud or Oral Torah.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoOr quite a few Jews who lived prior to the invention of Rabbinic Judaism.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoWell (and I hate reply spamming here but I keep thinking of new things) The Talmud and Mishnah were written hundreds of years after the birth of Jesus. And in the first century, the Pharisees (or proto-Rabbinics, or whatever) were only one sect amongst many. So yes, Christianity followed on a different path than Judaism.
- gvb 12y agoFunny true story: My friend bought a fancy new stove. After owning it a couple of weeks his wife commented that the oven didn't work on Thursdays. Odd. So he investigated... and he found that indeed on Thursdays, if he tried to turn the oven on, it reported an error code 5A66. After a bit of searching in the user's manual, he discovered (a) that the stove had a Sabboth mode (b) the "error code" was actually SAbb rendered on the 7 segment display, and (c) he had not set the day of the week on the stove so it thought Thursday was the Sabboth. He turned off Sabboth mode and was happy. His wife less so because she no longer had a reason to go out for supper every Thursday.
- dfan 12y agoOur oven has a Sabbath mode. We looked it up online and half the hits were forum threads with people asking "I accidentally turned on Sabbath mode, how do I turn it off?"
- coolguy43 12y agoNice. I study practice german by skype at http://preply.com/en/german-by-skype http://preply.com/en/german-by-skype
- chimeracoder 12y agoSomewhat related: B&H, an electronics store in New York owned by Hasidic Jews not only closes its brick & mortar store on Saturdays, but its website as well: http://www.bhphotovideo.com/ http://www.bhphotovideo.com/ Screenshot for anyone looking at this after 8:30 EDT today: https://i.imgur.com/XvZHDXA.png https://i.imgur.com/XvZHDXA.png
- mjs 12y agoDo they actually explain on their website why they do this? I've spent some time in the past looking without success.
- bryondowd 12y agoHere's a theory. If the site had an issue, they would be unable to do anything about it that day. Could be too much of a liability, so they shut it down. Or maybe I'm applying too much thought to it.
- ars 12y agoIf that was all it was they could easily hire a non-Jew to monitor it.
- morgante 12y agoYou can't hire a non-Jew to specifically monitor it on the Sabbath.
- ars 12y agoThat's true. But you can hire him full time.
- kelnos 12y agoI wonder how that would work, though. In general the accepted work week is Monday through Friday, so even if you did hire/pay the person on a weekly/yearly basis, you'd still have to specifically say to them that they're required to work on the weekend, and thus the Sabbath. I wonder if that's ok or not...
- IvyMike 12y agoPossibly related: http://www.cnn.com/2015/03/21/us/brooklyn-fire-children-killed/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2015/03/21/us/brooklyn-fire-children-kill... TL;DR: Tragic fire caused by a hot plate left on overnight so that it could be used to warm food on the Sabbath.
- jonathanjaeger 12y agoMy mom just told me about that story, and when I came to HN I thought it had to be related that this made front page on HN exactly when this tragedy happened.
- golergka 12y agoIn Israel they are advertised specifically for that purpose. I'm not religious, but I suspect that this is exactly the case. However, since this user case is non-orthodox for heating surfaces, I think that they need special testing and quality control for hot plates sold for this.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ars 12y agoOh my God, that's horrible! That looks like it was caused by not having any smoke detectors :(
- evincarofautumn 12y agoHalf of these seem quite reasonable—prepare things ahead of time so you don’t need to work on the Sabbath. The other half seem like an affront to God by interpreting his rules literally and then trying to skirt them on technicalities.
- croddin 12y agoThe problem with posting this on a Saturday is that any readers of hacker news that use these devices will be unable to comment.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 12y agoYour body regenerates new cells all the time; that is creative work (certainly, if closing a switch counts as such). I think what you need is a Sabbath cryogenic chamber, so that you don't commit such transgressions as growing stubble.
- ars 12y agoThere is a specific list of what counts as creative. You can't just randomly add others because it seems similar to you.
- krebby 12y agoThis app[0] made the rounds last year and caused a bit of a stir: it keeps your android phone's battery at a constant state, prevents the screen from turning off, and flips the screen orientation, all of which from a disconnected interpretation of halacha should be permissible. Problem is, any touch to the screen completes a circuit (one of the prohibited categories of work) so the whole thing is a bit ridiculous anyway. [0] http://shabbosapp.com/how-it-works/ http://shabbosapp.com/how-it-works/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aEDHi09oyXY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aEDHi09oyXY http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shabbos_App http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shabbos_App
- MichaelAza 12y agoAFAIK, capactive touch screens are permisable from a Jewish law standpoint. For example [1] which is a phone for use on shabbat and uses capactive buttons to avoid closing a circuit. [1] http://www.zomet.org.il/eng/?CategoryID=249&ArticleID=99 http://www.zomet.org.il/eng/?CategoryID=249&ArticleID=99
- krebby 12y agoIt really depends on your definition of the 39 melakhot. Even the idea of "closing a circuit" being the same thing as "starting or tending a fire" is a modern invention, so some people abide and others don't. In my opinion if you're closing a circuit you're closing a circuit, and capitative screens count. Others go so far as to disable thermostats since a person's very presence in a room affects the temperature by a few degrees and could trip the circuit. Depends how deep down the rabbit hole you want to go I guess.
- driverdan 12y agoAll of this stuff is ridiculous.
- ars 12y agoThat site/app likes like satire to me, not a real app.
- VeryVito 12y agoThere are examples of such "loopholes" in any modern religion's rules, but it all makes sense once you realize that, as Eugene Mirman suggests, God is a 12-year-old boy with Asperger's. http://www.cc.com/video-clips/jed186/john-oliver-s-new-york-stand-up-show-accept-me-as-your-god http://www.cc.com/video-clips/jed186/john-oliver-s-new-york-...
- oh_sigh 12y agoThis is what killed the 7 children in Brooklyn yesterday
- trauring 12y agoNo, that was a hot plate that was left on. If they had used a Sabbath Mode oven, there would not have been a fire.
- spacehome 12y agoThat's great; they beat God on a technicality.
- shliachtx 12y agoJewish law states that "six days you shall work, on on the seventh day you shall rest". The Talmud explains that this "rest" (while including) does not specifically refer to manual labor, rather the act of creation, embodied in the 39 "categories" of work which were performed in, and when building, the Tabernacle (the predecessor to the Temple, originally built after Sinai, which accompanied the Jews throughout their travels in the desert). The Talmud discusses at length what is included in these categories, what is considered similar enough to be forbidden as well, etc. Essentially, these aren't loopholes, but ways of getting the same results without performing any forbidden acts. Of course, there are things which are frowned upon as not within the "spirit" of the Sabbath, e.g. leaving a television on. In addition, I noticed some people mentioned the "eruv", a string around a neighborhood which allows the residents to carry within it on the Sabbath. This too is not really a loophole, as the biblical prohibition of carrying on the Sabbath was only to and from or inside a public thoroughfare (at least 24-36 feet wide, with at least 600,000 people passing through each day), which is relatively uncommon. The Rabbis of the Talmud (in accordance with the teaching "make boundaries around the Torah"in order to prevent people from accidentally transgressing the Torah) further added the prohibition to carry to and from or inside "semi-public" areas or, to put it another way, non-private areas, or from one area (private or otherwise) to another. With this added prohibition, however, they included an exception. That is, if one puts a fence or string around the entire area (again, this excludes "true" public thoroughfares), thereby symbolically making it one area, one is permitted to carry within it. This is not technically a "loophole", but a solution that ensures that one remembers not to carry in a public area on the Sabbath. Jewish law is much more complex, logically built, and developed than one might think, and I encourage you not to dismiss most observant Jews' practice of it as "cheating", or "hypocritical". This is of course a very limited discussion of the topics involved, as most observant Jews spend years (!) studying the laws and their implications. For further reference I would recommend you visit http://www.chabad.org/search/keyword_cdo/kid/6967/ http://www.chabad.org/search/keyword_cdo/kid/6967/.
- edward 12y agoI found a photo for Sabbath mode on Flickr and convinced the photographer to make it Creative Commons. The article is now illustrated.
- woofyman 12y agoThe sabbath mode on my oven: 1) oven light is disabled when you open the door 2) when you press the start button, the oven starts after a random period of time