12 ms·
All Major Browsers Fall at Pwn2Own Day Two
- lost_name 12y agoDo people go into Pwn2Own knowing the exploits they will use in advance? I'm not sure I understand the format of such a contest.
- olliej 12y agoYes, weeks or months of work goes into finding the bugs, and then working out how to exploit them. The continued "hacked in x minutes" crap is nonsense.
- sp332 12y agoYes. It's basically a bug-bounty system, but the bounty includes more prestige :)
- mccr8 12y agoAnd more money.
- Touche 12y agoAnd leaving the exploits in the wild for weeks/months beforehand.
- tptacek 12y agoThis is a valid criticism.
- cssmoo 12y agoPerhaps more worrying, they may have sold them elsewhere first and informed the purchaser that they have until the competition date to use it. Better business if you have to come back after the disclosure date for more holes... Nohig ethical at all going on here.
- rudolf0 12y agoMy understanding is that would violate the rules of the competition. Though of course if a competitor were to do that, odds are no one would find out.
- djrogers 12y agoWould someone willing to sell exploits on the black market really be concerned with "violating the rules of the competition"?
- rudolf0 12y agoWell, presumably they'd want to keep the money from the competition. That's definitely an incentive.
- MichaelGG 12y agoI would imagine it'd be fairly hard to the competition to know and revoke the money. Bad guys are almost certainly exploiting various undisclosed vulnerabilities. The bigger issue, I'd assume, is that by doing this competition, you've now killed that bug you previously sold. So long that was disclosed to the buyer though, I imagine you're all set.
- im2w1l 12y agoOdds are the black market guys find out. I don't know how the market works, but I'd be pretty pissed if I had bought a hole just for it to be patched soon after.
- mccr8 12y agoTo mitigate this problem, Google has recently announced that they are running a similar program year-round: http://blog.chromium.org/2015/02/pwnium-v-never-ending-pwnium.html http://blog.chromium.org/2015/02/pwnium-v-never-ending-pwniu...
- eugeneionesco 12y agoWith very lower rewards, the exploit that nettet $110k would probably be getting less than $50k
- erichurkman 12y agoBut you also minimize the risk that someone else will find and report the vulnerability before you do, negating any & all chance of earning a bounty yourself.
- coderzach 12y agoI was wondering the same thing. It seems like there would be no way to stop someone from having exploits beforehand. And a single person finding exploits in every major browser in one day seems unlikely.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- NathanKP 12y agoIt's basically demo day for browser (and other software) vulnerabilities. Hackers show off their exploits and vendors pay them cash for disclosing them at Pwn2Own instead of selling them on the blackmarket.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 12y agoThey used to sell the hacker, but since they've stopped Pwn2Own is much more popular.
- Crito 12y agoSurely there are 13th amendment concerns with selling the hacker. Do you mean that they used to sell the exploits to other hackers at Pwn2Own?
- liyanchang 12y agoWas similarly curious. Reading the rules here: http://zerodayinitiative.com/Pwn2Own2015Rules.html http://zerodayinitiative.com/Pwn2Own2015Rules.html Major points: - You register for which browser + os combination[0]. Then they randomly order the contestants. - When you are called, you have 30 minutes. - The user browses to a particular piece of content that you specify. Then no further user interaction is allowed (like clicking a dialog, downloading a file). [1][2] - The prize money goes to the first successful exploit. Money differs by browser. [0] Chrome, Firefox, IE, Adobe Reader in IE, Adobe Flash in IE. Safari on OSX. Fully patched OS. [1] How does one get to specify the content? What if I have a http header that downloads a file? [2] I remember back in the day, they used to have a fully no interactive version? Like the user was just on the same wireless network?
- tptacek 12y agoThe exploits that take down hardened browsers take months to develop. The time limits and race dynamics are theater.
- hnnewguy 12y ago>"The time limits and race dynamics are theater." That makes more sense. Otherwise, this is movie-script-like hacking ability.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 12y ago"I just need to break the encryption......ok...it's done."
- smackfu 12y agoIt makes a bit more sense in the original context of the contest, where you were doing the attack on the actual hardware you would win. So time limits were so that everyone got a shot, and a race since there was no prize after someone won it.
- 3pt14159 12y agoI was curious, so here are the rewards: Windows-based targets: 1. Google Chrome (64-bit): $75,000 (USD) 2. Microsoft Internet Explorer 11 (64-bit with EPM-enabled): $65,000 (USD) 3. Mozilla Firefox: $30,000 (USD) 4. Adobe Reader running in Internet Explorer 11 (64-bit with EPM-enabled): $60,000 (USD) 5. Adobe Flash (64-bit) running in Internet Explorer 11 (64-bit with EPM-enabled): $60,000 (USD) Mac OS X-based targets: 1. Apple Safari (64-bit): $50,000 (USD)
- ksk 12y agoThey have to exploit the fully patched versions (on the day). Prior to the contest, vendors are free to patch the exploits, if found.
- serve_yay 12y agoIs this the correct headline? I would expect something more like "Apple Safari falls at Pwn2Own Day Two (Other Browsers Too)"
- stouset 12y agoThe real title hear is ""teams coordinate simultaneous disclosure of vulns targeting all major browsers".
- bmm6o 12y agoNot sure what you're implying. Is ThreatPost supposed to be anti-Apple?
- billyhoffman 12y agoIts a common trend in tech report to mention/place stories in the context of Apple, because they are the largest company in the world (by revenues), and so it drives page views. Even when Apple are only tangentially related to the story. Perfect example of this right now are all the "Is Apple Pay causing fraud?" news stories. The fraud has nothing to do with Apple Pay. The fraud is happening because banks are doing a poor job verifying who someone is when they are trying to register/activate a credit card. But they all focus on Apple, despite being a minor aspect of the story, because it drives page views.
- parasubvert 12y agoFWIW Apple aren't even in the top 10 for revenues. Most are oil or car companies. Apple is #14. http://www.statista.com/statistics/263265/top-companies-in-the-world-by-revenue/ http://www.statista.com/statistics/263265/top-companies-in-t... Top market cap, yes.
- ejstronge 12y agoAny insights into how researchers find these bugs? I'm particularly interested in the kernel timing bug - how did the researcher know that he would find the kind of exploit he needed? It seems like he's a fast learner, going from no native client code to a big exploit...
- diminoten 12y ago> Using an out-of-bounds read/write vulnerability he claims he found through static analysis, ilxu1a’s attack led to medium-integrity code execution in what ZDI called “sub-seconds,” earning $15,000. Looks like some code analysis tools helped for one researcher.
- drinchev 12y agoI've seen a couple of hackers back in the old days. Of course they've probably moved to some more sophisticated techniques, but I doubt they are wearing suits and doing this as a professionals. More concrete answers of your questions guessing : 1. By brute forcing with popular techniques for buffers overflows ; 2. By tracking what the browser is doing via debuggers and trying to match a kernel bug with it ; 3. By reading a lot about latest exploits on the internet and connecting the dots. What I think nobody from them is doing : 1. Analysing open-source code ( basically try to find the exploit by reading the code ) ; 2. Studying 5 years CS before doing this
- mccr8 12y agoPeople certainly do find security vulnerabilities by reading source code.
- trequartista 12y agoIIRC the Google researcher discovered the Heartbleed bug when he was auditing the OpenSSL code
- ScottBurson 12y ago
- diminoten 12y ago> Lee wasn’t done and went on to bolster his daily total to $225,000 later in the day Hooooly shit. That's insane, and if that's what you get from the company, I can't even imagine the price of those exploits on the black market...
- davmre 12y agoIt's large when you present it as a single-day payout. If you imagine it might have taken a year of work to discover and exploit these vulnerabilities, with no guarantee of success, then the money is actually relatively low compared to standard tech benefit packages. Tons of respect for anyone who does this and avoids the urge to go to the black market (or NSA, etc).
- hueving 12y ago>the money is actually relatively low compared to standard tech benefit packages 225K is low compared to the standard? What standard are you talking about?
- perdunov 12y agoI think he is talking about the expected value vs a lucky chance. It's like the stock market. In the long run there are no miracles.
- rudolf0 12y agoSkill definitely plays a role too. If you are smart and experienced enough, you can theoretically churn out a valuable exploit once every 1-2 months on average. At a company, you're generally going to get a flat salary. Many vuln research/development companies do offer bonuses for every effective exploit you write though, in which case it probably is better to work for such a company than to rely solely on bug bounties and competitions for income. Unfortunately, those same companies usually sell the exploits to the NSA and the intelligence agencies of other governments.
- 12y ago
- nightcracker 12y agoSaying that all browsers fall in less than 2 days at Pwn2Own is like saying a mathematician proves a long standing theorem in 2 days of a conference.
- perdunov 12y agoYeah, like at today's provathon Grigori Perelman proved Poincaré conjecture in under 30 minutes.
- deweller 12y ago> Lee was able to take down both stable and beta versions of Chrome by exploiting a buffer overflow race condition in the browser. He then used an info leak and race condition in two Windows kernel drivers to secure SYSTEM access. I'm trying to fully understand. Does this mean that by maliciously crafting a website, someone can get SYSTEM access on a windows machine just by getting someone to visit that site in Chrome? And what does SYSTEM access mean? Is that user-level privileges or admin privileges?
- NathanKP 12y agoThat's correct. The best paying exploits at Pwn2Own are exploits where just browsing to a website gives an attacker root code execution on the machine. These types of exploits pay well because they are extremely difficult to pull off, as they require multiple exploits to break through the browser security, out of the sandbox, and through the OS protections.
- ianlevesque 12y agoAnd yet every year they have been found. It's safe to assume browsing to a site can take over your entire machine at any time. Enjoy the web guys!
- javajosh 12y agoThe regrettable truth is that this pushes us all toward a more centralized web, as it's much less likely that google.com or facebook.com is going to pwn your browser. The real nightmare scenario is when developer machines get hacked and attackers get access to source, but also to build servers where they can inject binaries into the web deployment stream, which themselves exploit end-user browsers. This is, I think, a very good reason to not give devs any access to build/CI servers. (Ironically, actual endpoint servers are slightly less critical to secure from devs.)
- branchless 12y agoThe lovely choice: 1. facebook where the NSA are checking on you 2. faceskibook where a Russian hacker is going to own your pc
- coob 12y agoI can't seem to find any info on versions - Safari 8.0.4 was released a couple of days ago, does the exploit affect this security release?
- notatoad 12y agoIt's my understanding that any vulnerability that has been disclosed is ineligible. If 8.0.4 patched the exploit that won here, it would have been merely by coincidence.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nfoz 12y agoI think it's reasonable to consider that we should stop adding new features to the web until it's at a point where we could have at least one www that doesn't leave users vulnerable. Literally every browser is unsafe, and has always been unsafe. There's zero reason this should be the case. Transferring documents online is not that hard a problem. Perhaps blinging out all the latest features for all the latest ad companies is not worth the cost to users' system security.
- samspot 12y agoAdd operating systems, servers, and languages to your list for completeness. The reason they are unsafe is because they are created by humans, who make mistakes. You are basically proposing that all technology innovation should cease until these things are 100% secure.
- whichfawkes 12y agoWe just have to accept the trade-offs of functionality. Things like airplane autopilot systems and medical equipment are probably pretty close to perfect, but that level of correctness in your browser, much less your operating system, much less your hardware - would be very costly. Even if every computer was running an operating system that was developed as carefully as equipment in charge of people's lives, I'm sure there'd still be vulnerabilities. The low hanging fruit is relative, and there'll always be people cracking computers.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mike_hearn 12y agoI think it's more like saying maybe before massively increasing the browser attack surface we should consider if it's really the right thing to do. A lot of sandbox escapes in recent years have been in very rarely used features like WebGL and Native Client. Cool tech for sure, but also big new exploit zones. The main problem is that what used to be called "mobile code" before smartphones were a thing is really convenient. That's why Java tried it too. Sandboxed code helps a lot, so there's this constant tension between trying to make the sandbox less restrictive and keeping it secure. Sometimes I think that despite poor execution the JVM guys had the right idea. Sandbox code from the net, but also have code signing to fall back on.
- r1ch 12y agoAre regular bug bounty programs simply not paying enough whereby researchers decide to hold onto exploits for high paying events like Pwn2Own? How much would these kind of exploits go for on the black market?
- tptacek 12y agoPwn2Own has a lottery dynamic that the bug bounty programs don't. As for the sub rosa pricing for these exploits, it gets complicated. Among other important details: to maximize your returns you need to be a competent salesperson (you need to have the contacts to sell them to), and the best returns make you at least morally and in some cases even legally culpable for what's done with them. There's probably some headroom left for escalating valuations for browser RCEs, but they're not like an order of magnitude mispriced. Also remember you're looking at the subset of bugs with the absolute peak valuation. (I'm both ideologically opposed to bug sales and not smart enough to get RCE on Chrome, so: take this with a grain of salt).
- perdunov 12y agoIf one read all those headlines and news without proper critique, they would eventually start believing in all kinds of magic, like that one dude can discover race condition exploits in the browser and the drivers in under 30 minutes.
- fierycatnet 12y agoHere's the first lecture among many from FSU on Offensive Security, it looks like they are going pretty indepth, I started watching first few recently. Very relevant for those who want to explore how exploitation is done. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lk3rp53b2NA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lk3rp53b2NA
- bradleysmith 12y agothis was a very good overview, I appreciate the link. May be watching through much more of this class.
- josteink 12y ago> He told Childs via translator that not only was it was his first time writing Native Client code but it was his first time dealing with a kernel exploit. To me this just confirms that no matter what the proponents say, Google native client is just another form of active x, just with a Google badge this time. Letting a website run native code on your machine is a terrible decision, and completely disrespectful to your users. Needles to say, I'm not going to switch to chrome anytime soon.
- mike_hearn 12y agoWell, it means you have to break out of the nacl sandbox instead of the V8 sandbox. Neither allow you to run arbitrary code and I'm not sure if there's any particular difference in hardness between them. That said - Native Client doesn't seem to be used for anything on the web. It might have been useful if other browsers had adopted it, but with Mozilla pushing asm.js I wonder at what point they decide to pull the plug on this ...
- mrottenkolber 12y agoIs nobody paying for Linux bugs or weren't any found?
- eugeneionesco 12y agoVery very few people run Linux a desktop(unfortunately). The Chrome and Firefox bugs are probably exploitable on Linux too.
- kasabali 12y agoMicrosoft Windows: 5 bugs Microsoft IE 11: 4 bugs Mozilla Firefox: 3 bugs Adobe Reader: 3 bugs Adobe Flash: 3 bugs Apple Safari: 2 bugs Google Chrome: 1 bug $442,500 paid out to researchers Looking at these figures, am I the only one who think competitions are not the most effective method for finding bugs? Of course, 21 bugs is not small and $442,500 is not much, but when you think those researches spend months of their time for finding those bugs, wouldn't it be more appropriate to use that money on proper security audits? (I know it will cost more but would be more effective overall?)
- LLWM 12y agoProper audits don't get much publicity.
- genericuser 12y agoI consider the purpose of competitions like this to be as much about finding bugs as the purpose of running a marathon is to get people from point A to point B. That is competitions like this are mainly about public relations in the form of what is intended to be enjoyable community involvement, finding bugs is a pleasant side effect, like the transportation aspect of a marathon.
- billyhoffman 12y agoIt's not 21 bugs. Anyone can find 21 bugs. It's 21 bugs that enable/facilitate Remote Code Execution. These are some of the worse of the worse. $442,000 is a steal to get these identified and fixed.
- soapdog 12y agoWe get that all browsers were pwned, but what OS where they running? For example, we can see on that post that there were three bugs in Firefox but we don`t know in what system those bugs would allow escalation of privileges and arbitrary code execution. Or is there a bug allowing arbitrary code execution in Windows, Linux, *BSD, Macs at the same time?!
- mccr8 12y agoAll were running on Windows, except Safari which was running on OSX. You can see the details at this overly long URL from the contest organizers: http://h30499.www3.hp.com/t5/HP-Security-Research-Blog/Pwn2Own-2015-Exploitation-at-its-Finest/ba-p/6708265#.VQyBsbfYDOQ http://h30499.www3.hp.com/t5/HP-Security-Research-Blog/Pwn2O...
- nodata 12y agoHere is my chance! Anyone know why hp.com urls are still, in 2015, so full of subdomains?
- warkdarrior 12y agoBecause their web admins have not figured out how to do transparent load balancing.
- euyyn 12y agoWhy?
- soapdog 12y agoThanks a lot for the link. I wonder how the score would go if linux and bsd targets were present and if they allowed chrome and firefox on mac os x as well...
- tonyhb 12y agoIf you're interested in doing some research, just google "use after free". Google has a message for you.
- ccvannorman 12y agoThis is one of the core reasons computers need to be reinvented.
- tormeh 12y agoIt's simple. Just stop using memory-unsafe languages. Just say no.
- 0xFFC 12y agoThis is off the topic , but my problem with chrome is it become a OS itself , I don't need another OS on top of my OS.I just need a browser, Chrome was excellent one before they start pushing it to OS/framework level software.
- josephagoss 12y agoI'm on the fence with this one. It does make for a massive attack surface with the massive amount of complexity a modern browser brings to the table, however it's also giving us a truly Operating System agnostic world. (I think? Javascript based applications are OS agnostic right?) The browser may become a universal operating system, where web applications become the norm and it brings an end to the Linux vs Windows vs Mac wars. Who knows?
- vskarine 12y agoCurious to know how WhiteHat Aviator(https://www.whitehatsec.com/aviator/ https://www.whitehatsec.com/aviator/) would perform there, any ideas?
- ossreality 12y agoYeah, I'm going to assume this was a joke.
- eugeneionesco 12y agoVulnerable to the same bugs as Chrome.
- tux 12y agoPwn2Own 2015 Is On! -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IKeUHpUR7g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IKeUHpUR7g Pwn2Own 2015: Day 1 Highlights -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X2Ssw2sLUHI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X2Ssw2sLUHI Pwn2Own 2015: Day 2 Highlights -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V99skqmTyiY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V99skqmTyiY
- maninalift 12y agodumb question: "more ht2000 lines of code" - is that a typo of "more than...", is "ht2000" something I don't know and can't google, or are are these hacks in some way related to an antique motherboard?
- weaksauce 12y agoI'd say it's a safe bet they meant "more than 2000 lines of code"
- kwentine 12y ago> He told Childs via translator that not only was it was his first time writing Native Client code but it was his first time dealing with a kernel exploit. Well, I guess Lee has found a new lucrative hobby for rainy weekends. More seriously, how can someone possibly own three major browser in two days and on a first try at this kind of sport ? A pretty loud way to shout "Hello World"...
- addandsubtract 12y agoI don't think it's supposed to be read as being hacked in two days. I'm sure he's worked on them before attending the conference, but only presented them on the second day due to the format of the conference.
- lawnchair_larry 12y agoThese exploits are all created well in advance. People hold them for the whole year just to use them here. They're usually made by teams, with one person chosen to run it at the event. At the event, each person brings their exploit and the browser is run against it. Somehow this gets changed to "browser hacked in seconds!" because the media is great like that. That said, it is quite impressive for a newcomer to clean house like this, even if he did have a year to prepare, assuming he wasn't working with a team.
- sanxiyn 12y agoI am a friend of a friend of lokihardt, and yes it was a solo effort. Very impressive.
- spyder 12y ago"People hold them for the whole year just to use them here" But does this mean that they will leave the vulnerability alive for a year, half-year (or whenever before the conference they found it) by not reporting it to the vendors till the conference? Because from the description it looks like it has to work on the latest versions of the browser (for example Chrome 42).
- 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- frenchTouch206 12y agoDeleted
- chockablock 12y agoAnyone else find that this comments page crashes their tab in Chrome for Mac? Could be the strange string submitted by frenchtouch206? Yup: it's a known crashing string: http://venturebeat.com/2015/03/20/these-13-characters-will-crash-your-chrome-tab-on-a-mac/ http://venturebeat.com/2015/03/20/these-13-characters-will-c...
- makomk 12y agoBug report closed as a duplicate of a non-public (i.e. security) bug. That's not a great sign.
- greggman 12y agoWhy is that not a great sign. All security bugs are non-public, even on Firefox, until they are fixed. The fact that they are non-public is arguably a sign someone looked at the bug and marked it a security issue which also means it's likely being actively worked on. Keeping the public just means if you want own people's machines you could scan the bug database for bugs marked as "security" and exploit to your heart's content until they were fixed.
- wtbob 12y agoSo, I wonder how lynx, links, elinks, w3m and emacs-w3m fare at this sort of thing…
- largote 12y agoWhat about Opera?
- eugeneionesco 12y agoNobody uses Opera, why add it to this competition? But since you asked, I would be a lot of money Opera is vulnerable to the same bugs as Chrome since it's using the same rendering engine.
- Tloewald 12y agoMy takeaway is that flash, by itself, doubles your vulnerability and acrobat triples it. Obviously these results alone aren't statistically significant but flash and acrobat have been dire sources of vulnerabilities for over a decade (and bear in mind that safari renders pdf natively).
- jeromegv 12y agoSafari uses its own PDF renderer, wondering if the Acrobat bugs really apply for that?
- bsaul 12y agoAnyone knows if mobile OSes are Part of the competition ? I've always thought surfing on safari mobile was the most secure way of surfing (because of the sandbox, but also partly because of app store pre-release evaluation policy that limit the risks of installing a malware ).
- throwaway41597 12y agoThere was a method to jailbreak the iPhone by exploiting some vulnerabilities some years ago, all you had to do was go to a website from safari if I recall correctly. iOS is mainly OS X without unsandboxed apps, no silver bullet.
- thejosh 12y agoAnd the jailbreak fixed it for users as well, which was cool :).
- paulftw 12y agoGood to see microsoft products on top of at least one comparison against opensource alternatives.
- cLeEOGPw 12y ago> Hacked Chrome browser in 2 minutes Does that mean it took 2 minutes for script to finish it's job?