8 ms·
Where's the Generic Insulin?
- xkcd-sucks 12y agoregulatory compliance for biologics (stuff made by living things) is a bitch compared to normal chemicals... maybe the generics companies don't find it worthwhile. on the other hand, making insulin with transgenic bacteria is practically kitchen chemistry, if you're not scared of injecting yourself with your own product.
- dnautics 12y agoYou can't make insulin from bacteria that easily. It's a two chain protein, and stitching together the two chains kinetically competes with precipitation of one of the chains. One chain insulins are typically ineffective (well someone did once engineer a working single chain insulin - Michael Weiss at Cass Western) because signalling requires insulin to unfold, which down not happen when the chains are attached to each other. If you try to design an insulin analog yourself be careful. Insulin cross reacts with the igf-i pathway; igf, like most growth factors, is oncogenic, so you'll have to be vigilant about getting cancer down the line.
- dnautics 12y agoI'd like to add that it might not be impossible to spin up production of a generic low cost insulin... Or to develop direct to generic IP free insulins, but the newer insulins are preferred because of very nice pharmacodynamic properties. That said, the bestiary of insulins we have now is quite comprehensive and as they fall off the patent cliff I think the future looks nice for generics
- xkcd-sucks 12y agooops, thought it was a simple short peptide... refolding from inclusion bodies is still kitchen chemistry, although it probably wants some expensive chromatographic cleanup regardless of how it's made. since pancreas is essentially a waste product, maybe it's easier to do that and the switch to recombinant insulin was for consistency/better analogs.
- refurb 12y agoI would guess it has more to do with demand. Once recombinant insulin came out, most folks switched, a few didn't. Unfortunately, "a few patients" aren't enough to support an entire product line.
- westoncb 12y agoHeh, was just wondering this at the pharmacy a couple of days ago... For one type of insulin I use (Lantus), it costs $400 for ~2.5 months worth, without insurance—which I happen to be without atm. Frustrating. What's worse are the prices for 'test strips' for blood sugar monitors, though: about $120/mo for the cheapest kind, and insurance doesn't help much. And what you really want is a continuous monitor, but they're over twice that last I checked. And what you REALLY want is a glucose monitor/insulin dispenser feedback loop—or a new pancreas (speaking for Type 1's) :D —but those solutions obviously have their problems as well. [/rant]
- wishinghand 12y agoIf you're in need of cheap test strips- get the Wal-Mart brand meter and strips. The strips are something like $9 for 50, instead of the $1 per strip I'm used to paying even when I was on insurance. I'm a type 1 and I use them, and they read pretty accurately with the CGM that I do shell out for.
- bpowell 12y agoI'm also a type 1 and highly recommend the Walmart Reli-On test strips. Cost savings on those is amazing. I do have the Reli-On meter and they work great together.
- westoncb 12y agoWow, that sounds like a great deal. I'd been using True Test and True Track, from Kroger dealers and Walgreens. There isn't a Walmart anywhere near me (downtown Boston), but I'll see if I can get 'em online.
- neckro23 12y agoThe store-brand meters and strips are usually a great deal if you don't have insurance, but the catch-22 is that most Rx insurance won't pay for the generic strips, just the name-brand ones.
- vojant 12y agoHow much Lantus do you use? In Poland I was paying around $100 for 5 pens, in UK not much more (without insurance). Test strips (Accu-Chek) arround $15 for 50.
- gwern 12y agoFulltext: http://sci-hub.org/downloads/a18a/10.1056@NEJMms1411398.pdf http://sci-hub.org/downloads/a18a/10.1056@NEJMms1411398.pdf / https://www.dropbox.com/s/wzdt3ioryz4n7rb/2015-greene.pdf https://www.dropbox.com/s/wzdt3ioryz4n7rb/2015-greene.pdf
- chockablock 12y agoThank you. All the other links mentioned (including the OP) are news pieces about this NEJM article, which is itself a cracking good read, very accessible. For completeness of links: here's the NEJM article page: http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMms1411398 http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMms1411398
- dnautics 12y agoThe prices quoted here seem rather low for a biologic drug. The way insulin is made is somewhat complicated, the best standard is typically production in yeast, followed by reverse proteolysis, then purification and formulation. The chem. Eng. Flowchart is ten 'steps', most requiring lots of chillers; insulin is not at all a thermostable drug (patients know this, over time insulin will flocculate and become useless)
- dekhn 12y agoSure, but as has been pointed out, pricing doesn't just include the cost of manufacture- drug pricing includes the ability of the country to pay for the drug. Pharma amortizes costs globally. Also, many companies have compassionate care programs to get access to people who simply can't pay for expensive biologics.
- dnautics 12y agoCost is however a lower bound. Insulin at $200/month pales in comparison to generic herceptin at $20k for a six month? course. Of course herceptin is made in mammalian cells; going to a microbial platform might result in a 10x decreasr but that's still about 300 a month on razor thin margin.
- xbryanx 12y agoThere was a good summary story on this on NPR this morning as well: http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2015/03/19/393856788/why-is-u-s-insulin-so-expensive http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2015/03/19/393856788/why-is-...
- tzs 12y agoPerhaps we need a regulatory change to allow import of a drug when it would be legal to make a generic in the US but no manufacturer is willing to do so. Even better, perhaps this could be combined with aid to the country the drug is imported from. I was just reading an article on insulin outside the US that talked about an 8 year old girl that died because her family could not afford the cost of insulin (about $1.50 for 40 units). We could allow Americans to import insulin from India if the American buys twice as much as they need, with 1/2 of their purchase being given to a poor Indian who needs but cannot afford it.
- sjg007 12y agohealth kit linked glucose monitor seems like a win win.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cperciva 12y agoTime for a history lesson. From 1922 until 1981, the only insulins available commercially were extracted from bovine and porcine pancreases -- a process which was both expensive and dangerous, since if the product was insufficiently purified it could cause life-threatening immune reactions or carry diseases from the animals used. (This is why insulin-using diabetics are to this day not allowed to donate blood in most of the world.) It took sixty years between discovering insulin and figuring out how to produce it biosynthetically (all modern insulin is now produced by genetically engineered yeast or E. coli). This yielded so-called "regular" insulin, which -- at the concentrations necessary to make it feasible for injection -- has the unfortunate property of hexamerizing. As a result, it has is peak activity about 3 hours after injection, and ends its activity around 6 hours after injection -- compared with endogenous insulin, which acts within 5-10 minutes, but is excreted 24 hours/day. In 1996, we finally had "rapid" insulin -- Insulin Lispro, which adjusts a couple amino acids in order to prevent hexamerization. This makes it act roughly twice as fast as regular insulin, roughly matching the time taken for a meal to be digested and to enter the bloodstream -- thus reducing the postprandial "peak" and cutting down on the chronic hyperglycaemia related complications of diabetes. Remember how I said that regular insulin stops working after around 6 hours? If you want to get 8 hours of sleep, that's not so good. In the 1940s and 50s some modified insulins were released which "slow down" the insulin so that it lasts for longer; but it wasn't until 2003 that the first "24 hour" insulin was released. So why is insulin still so expensive, 90 years after it was first introduced? Because the insulin we're using now is a heck of a lot better than the insulin 90 years ago. You might as well ask why a Tesla is so expensive when the Model T was launched over a century ago.
- dekhn 12y agoThat's not the only reason it's that expensive. Pharma costs are artificially created and amortized globally.
- cperciva 12y agoThe costs of bringing new drugs to market are not simply artificial. Quite aside from the costs of developing the drugs in the first place (tweaking a couple amino acids is cheap; knowing which amino acids to tweak is a bit harder) and the costs of production (significant in the case of insulin, considering the lengthy process for biosynthesis and then purification), demonstrating that a new drug is both effective and safe costs billions of dollars. Novel insulins are harder than most drugs too, since insulin is very closely related to some oncogenic hormones. A lot of novel insulins have died in trials when animals were found to have increased rates of cancer.
- rsheridan6 12y agoThe article fails to mention that you can get a vial of insulin (regular or NPH) without a prescription at Walmart for $25. Not generic, but inexpensive. The rapid acting and the once daily insulins are indeed very expensive, but $25 will get you the very best the early nineties had to offer, just like most drugs that were expensive name-brand drugs back then.
- bbcbasic 12y agohow many days worth can you get from a Walmart vial, out of interest?
- spinchange 12y ago28 days after it's opened according to the literature. I think the actual quantity in the vial would last longer, depending on dosage. (On the first vial of $25 Walmart Novolin N for a diabetic pet)
- bayesianhorse 12y agoJust for clarification: Does Walmart sell an Insulin approved for human use? Animal insulin has been used for human use, and human insulin for use in pets... Insulin's amino acid sequence varies a little by species, but as far as I recall most mammal's insulins are interchangeable.
- kgwgk 12y agoWalmart's store-brand insulin is Lilly's Humulin. It was NovoNordisk's Novolin until 2010.
- spinchange 12y agoNovolin N is human insulin. Walmart pharmacies likely sell more than one brand/type, this was just the one my vet prescribed (although a formal prescription isn't necessary, you just have to ask the pharmacist for it). It was about $25, so I assumed it was the same stuff the parent comment was talking about.
- randcraw 12y agoPerhaps the right policy to serve the public interest is for Uncle Sam to pay the patent owner $1B for each of the remaining years on its insulin patent and then 'genericize' today's insulins. The shareholders would earn their profits while the public would be served by gaining immediate access to superior diabetes treatment for a trivial cost of perhaps $20B -- a pittance when compared to the current scenario where millions of diabetics worldwide continue to suffer because unthinking pols continue to publicly kowtow shamelessly before the altar of Capitalism.
- dogma1138 12y agoHow about getting universal healthcare with a single payer system (at least state wise) so instead of having a billion smaller organizations with a more limited buying power that can't get you the best prices? You know why in the UK drugs cost 20-25% on average of the US price, not because of subsidies but because the NHS provides healthcare for 60M people and they say we are paying X for the drug now bid. Your local HMO not to mention an IPA simply can't do that. But anyhow as people have stated Insulin even the "older" versions is insanely expensive to fabricate and purify, it's simply not something that a generic company will go after. Most generic companies go for medicine which is easy to produce and is compatible with their existing fabrication capabilities.
- refurb 12y agoYou know why in the UK drugs cost 20-25% on average of the US price, not because of subsidies but because the NHS provides healthcare for 60M people and they say we are paying X for the drug now bid. That's not why drugs are cheaper in the UK. The largest US health insurance company is United and it covers almost 40M people. More than in all of Canada. Yet United pays more for drugs than Canada. Also, drugs in the UK don't cost 20-25% of the US price. Maybe you meant 75-80%?
- seesomesense 12y agoWosulin and Zinulin are just two of the generic insulins that are available. They are "regular" zinc protophane insulins.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoHere's a thought: Just make society pay for the better, more expensive insulin for everyonen. Oh wait, that would be the European / communist solution. Can't have that.
- venomsnake 12y agoHow does evergreening works? After all the patent for the original molecule has expired ... so it is free to be copied.
- jedi_master 12y agoFirst off, insulin is HARD TO MAKE. Its synthesized rDNA, this isn't the same as making pills out of powder from china and selling it at a 40% discount with plenty of margin still. This has to be grown and made in a lab with a very high precision. Second off a bottle of insulin is like 25 bucks..... Boo freaking hoo. Most people cant wrap their head around how insane that is. You are buying f*ing DNA.. that someone made.. that's saving your life.. for 25 bucks.