11 ms·
Video games beat interviews to recruit the very best
- Everhusk 12y agoHere is an example of one of their games: https://microcorruption.com/login https://microcorruption.com/login Love the Cy Yombinator part haha
- bentcorner 12y agoI've played a few rounds of this and love it. As far as I've gotten, it's been refreshing to work on a machine where everything is "all there". Too often there are black boxes that contain too much magic, or just too many layers of abstraction to efficiently reason about something.
- VikingCoder 12y agoReminds me of the "Hopeful Parents" Far Side comic. http://farside.wikia.com/wiki/File:Hopeful_parents.jpg http://farside.wikia.com/wiki/File:Hopeful_parents.jpg
- soylentcola 12y agoMy first thought when I saw this posted was "huh...kinda like The Last Starfighter". And sure enough, they named their company Starfighter. Xur and the Ko-dan armada don't stand a chance.
- tptacek 12y agoPatrick gave an interview to The New Scientist when we announced last week. We're a little worried about Starfighter Fatigue and are definitely trying not to get too much onto the front page (Erin's diligently writing the game details post, which we want to be the next thing people see from us). In the meantime though, if any of you have questions, we're watching and will answer.
- patio11 12y agoWhat Thomas said. In particular, while we're really glad that many HNers like Starfighter, we were members of this community far before we were co-founders. We're keenly aware that a) HN is a community, not a marketing channel and b) the community frowns on saying the same thing over and over. I'm CEO of a company and am pot committed to spending the next several years of my life repeating close variations of the same three things to anyone who will listen. ("How is that different from the last eight years, Patrick?" Answer: Previously I only had two things!) We would prefer people exercise their discretion in posting them to HN, to avoid boring anyone here.
- Ao7bei3s 12y ago> HN is a community, not a marketing channel I wish the YC people saw it like that.
- dang 12y agoOh, we do; that's what I spend all my time on. But there must be some reason behind your comment, and I'd be happy to discuss it with you at hn@ycombinator.com if you'd like. (Just not here, though, as the topic at hand is game-driven recruiting.)
- simonebrunozzi 12y agodang, "reply" is not available for your reply to A07bei3s - I suggest it should, and not to start that conversation (agree it should be done separately), but in case someone would like to reply to you.
- nitrogen 12y agoHN pro tip: try clicking the post's timestamp (not sure if this still works).
- pjungwir 12y agoPatrick, best of luck to you. With the success of Appointment Reminder (and consulting, and BCC . . .) I was very surprised to see you launching into something new. But your most recent "annual report" (which felt much more personal and vulnerable than usual) makes me glad you're trying to find something that makes you happy and motivated. I'm skeptical about Starfighter, with so many others trying to gamify and "reinvent" hiring, but you folks have the talent and audience to succeed, like Joel Spolsky with Stack Overflow. Thank you for all you've contributed to us programmers (which I still call myself :-)---it has made a tremendous difference in my life and in many others. I hope Starfighter achieves everything you are dreaming for it.
- pqomdv 12y agoThis only works assuming you can't hack the game itself, publicize the solution, or pay someone to do it for you.
- patio11 12y agoWe're probably one of the few games where exploiting a security vulnerability in the game gets you Achievement Unlocked.
- fsk 12y agoIt also only works if you can get a lot of employers to go along with it. There isn't much point spending a lot of time on something if it's only going to get you an interview or two (if even that). And if I'm looking for a game I still have a lot of stuff in my Steam account from bundles that I haven't had time to play.
- bcg1 12y agoI like the idea, although personally I wouldn't be excited about being "interviewed" like this. I am supportive of its existence however because it has definite upsides (i'm sure there are more, just enumerating a few): 1) eliminates some cultural/gender/language/fashion/appearance/disability biases 2) its not subjective 3) no difference between local and out-of-town candidates I'm glad that the toolbox for candidate search is expanding. I hope one day employers might be able to ask candidates which form of "interview" they prefer to have so that candidates can best demonstrate what they excel at in a way that is most suitable to them.
- tptacek 12y agoThe biggest misconception we've managed to foster about what we're doing is that Starfighter is a form of interview. It isn't. At all. A better way to think about it is that it's a sort of Venn intersection between "Github resume", "Coursera course", "Dwarf Fortress", and "recruiting firm". Our crusade against the tech job interview is roughly analogous to Google's "organizing all of the world's information". It's a mission statement, but it isn't a description of our first offering. That said: the technology we're working on ports beautifully to actual interview processes (it came from a successful process I built at Matasano). We're also very happy to talk to companies building hiring processes and evangelize and help. Companies with smart, modern hiring processes are especially fertile ground for what we're doing, so we'd like to help more of them come into being!
- ZebraCakes 12y agoWill Starfighter be focusing mostly on security? That seems to be most of the examples that I find, and it's not a field I'm terribly interested in. I love the idea though, and would like to see it applied to other areas.
- tptacek 12y agoSecurity is the through-line of the game; it gives us structure, incentives, little dopamine hits, and makes it so that the systems we're building reward exploration. But the game is not about security; it's about programming and interacting with complex systems. If you're a software developer with no security domain expertise, one benefit of goofing around with Starfighter is that you'll come out knowing a lot more about software security. But it's not a tool for getting people security jobs. It'll make a little more sense when Erin posts the game details.
- waspleg 12y agoBecause IT worker shortage, right? (Now with more flaming hoops!!)
- tptacek 12y agohttp://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/2yhcqn/were_not_here_to_fix_the_technical_interview_were/cpafpkb?context=3 http://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/2yhcqn/were_not...
- patio11 12y agoCompanies which are satisfied with their ability to hire and employees who are satisfied with their ability to find jobs don't have to even care we exist, though they're certainly welcome to play our games. Sadly, many companies are dissatisfied with their ability to hire and many qualified engineers are dissatisfied with their ability to secure desirable jobs. In economics, they call this a market failure. In CS, a search problem. In business, "a shedload of money available for the taking." In Starfighter, I guess we categorize that as "the mid-boss."
- Dewie 12y agoMore like a unicorn 10X Developer shortage. Companies will be pleased to find candidates who are eager and willing to jump through yet another proving ground, after having had so much fun with commit histories and stars on GitHub, SO points, and what have you[1]. They'll find smart candidates who are willing to work for them in exchange for being able to work on Interesting Problems and the occasional you-are-so-smart implicit approval. [1] Meet the new standard; same as the old standard, and in addition to it.
- ConfuciusSay 12y agoThis is awesome. I'll definitely become an avid player, right after I contribute meaningfully to several open source projects, have an active GitHub profile, while keeping my Stack Overflow reputation high, and having a fleshed out CodeCombat profile, and of course making sure my LinkedIn page is up to snuff. I hope when I get this awesome job my employer doesn't mind me keeping all my profiles updated on company hours!
- tptacek 12y agohttp://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/2yhcqn/were_not_here_to_fix_the_technical_interview_were/cpafpkb?context=3 http://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/2yhcqn/were_not...
- pjungwir 12y agoI especially like your point there that this will highlight people who don't have a spectacular Github profile. Lots of people complain that they have a great track record writing proprietary code and the recent focus on Github profiles is unhelpful to them. Hopefully a Starfighter score, compared to a Github profile, is more fun to develop, less intimidating to share, more meaningful when still "unfinished", more digestible by hiring staff, less entangled with employer IP, and perhaps most importantly requires less "vision" to get started.
- tptacek 12y agoWe're also not an information source for employers; they can't "query" us for all their candidates to get scores. Anything we ever share is opt-in. We expect most of our participants not to opt-in.
- bitwize 12y agoDon't forget to have had a >3.5 GPA from a top university!
- mahmud 12y ago
- sputknick 12y agoWould this be a good way to teach my son technical skills? He's 6 years old, homeschooled and is interested in technology. He's already figured out how to bipass the parental controls on his Kindle. We're trying to figure out how to stimulate that desire when you can't read well yet.
- patio11 12y agoGeek to geek and parent to parent: honestly, no. Can I recommend Besiege? It doesn't require literacy. It has the same sort of freeform expressiveness you're allowed to do in Minecraft. "Syntax" errors are inherently fun rather than demotivating. There's fun, rewarding visual feedback for success. It doesn't teach programming qua programming, but it is almost perfect for a gateway drug into engineering. (You get to build catapults! And airplanes! And catapults which fire airplanes!)
- pjungwir 12y agoRocky's Boots and Robot Odyssey might be great things to try. You can run both on an emulator. I'm pretty sure you can play Rocky's Boots pre-reading. In fact I would not be sad if v1 of Starfighter was playing Robot Odyssey on a web page. :-)
- krstck 12y agoSuch a cool idea, and I enjoyed Microcorruption, but ended up getting stuck in the second or third level and couldn't even figure out the right questions to ask to get help. (I stepped into the irc channel at some point and asked some simple question, but got an answer that I couldn't even parse. So I realized I was out of my league and needed to learn more basics first.) My one concern is about something that was mentioned during the announcement a little while back. The post mentioned something like "employers will be able to see exactly what you did when you had to create a REST service" (or something like that). Maybe I'm just learning this concept, maybe I'm only playing around! Will I have to have one "play" account, and one "real" account? If I knew that I'd be judged by not only whether I complete a level, but every single thing I tried.... Yeah, no thanks.
- autoreleasepool 12y agoI'm with you. There's no way I'd play a game where my every move was fair game for employers to scrutinize. That's too much stress and it would suck the fun out of everything. The thought of a game like that irritates me to no end. This is one reason I pay for a private github. I hate that if I'm learning a new technology, have "too many" commits on something simple, or am generally messing around it looks "bad" to employers.
- yareally 12y agoI'd argue that if an employer cares about public repo commits to personal repositories, one is probably better off not working for them (at least from my perspective of an ideal employer). If an employer thinks all their developers are infallible and instantly experts in everything they're learning, that sounds like a pretty awful culture. I know I've made silly/trivial commits to my github and it has yet to hurt my employability. I'd much rather work for a company that knows its employees aren't perfect and development can be a trial/error process at times (these kind of places do exist and I live and work in the Mid Western US). I do agree somewhat about game scrutinization, since it's active process by an employer verses employers passively looking at your github profile.
- 12y ago
- westoncb 12y agoMy sci-fi scale projection/evolution of this concept: because the things we do at work aren't intrinsically unenjoyable to begin with, but the way we think about them has the potential to make them feel that way—slow fusion of games that resemble work and work itself produces games that do work, and the distinction between the two is forgotten, a relic from a cruder era. Seems possible since the activity in games (for all the examples I can think of) has a pretty strong relation to 'work' activities to begin with: puzzle solving, mastering agility-dependent procedures, military stuff, social finesse, exploring etc. —though typically it's more 'primordial work' (exploring, hunting/gathering), which makes sense since atm we'd be putt off by something that resembled contemporary jobs too much. Dislike of one's work is not pervasive in human cultures/history.
- pmiller2 12y ago>My sci-fi scale projection/evolution of this concept: because the things we do at work aren't intrinsically unenjoyable to begin with, but the way we think about them has the potential to make them feel that way—slow fusion of games that resemble work and work itself produces games that do work, and the distinction between the two is forgotten, a relic from a cruder era. There was an episode of Black Mirror that hinted at this.
- Leon 12y agoAm I the only one that doesn't entirely enjoy gamification of everything? What's wrong with just writing software?
- 32bitkid 12y agoI know this article is referring to a different kind of gaming, but back in the day, I used to give potential candidates a NES controller and Tetris when they were in the waiting room before the interview... You can tell a lot about how a person deals with time constraints, pressure and approaches problem solving by watching somebody play tetris for 4 minutes. Not that Tetris would be the only input into the decision, but it was a thing.
- pmiller2 12y agoWhat would you do if they didn't play and just waited for the 4 minutes?
- dismal2 12y agoWhat if Tetris is a meaningless "problem" for them
- jameshart 12y agoI've learned to be cautious whenever anybody says "You can tell a lot about a person by..." You probably can't. You can probably justify a lot of preconceptions about a person. But unless you've done statistical studies that demonstrate high correlation between what you're testing, what you think you're observing, and what you're actually looking for, then no - no you can't tell a lot. Young male candidate, lets a big stack build up on one side, then clears the lot down with a couple of well-placed four-long blocks down the edge. Shows an easy confidence, clearly worth considering for the role. Female candidate, lets a big stack build up on one side, what is she doing? Does she even know how this game works? Then she drops a four-long down the side and clears some rows. Huh - lucky break. "Not that Tetris would be the only input into the decision, but it was a thing." Hmm.
- matt_s 12y agoHaving worked on an applicant testing and tracking system in the past, it was a decent business case to operate because a single company has a job type with 100's of openings and high attrition so it helped screen people. In that case it is self-serving and you know if someone is applying twice (SS Number or other identifier) to try and ace the test. If Starfighter is open, there are people out there that will try to game the system ("game the game" doesn't sound right.) If someone wants to be a level 50 app_coder, they could have a pre-made sequence to follow to do that. Much like in a MMORPG where you have helpers level up a character or a "mule" for hand-me-downs. Interviewing candidates last year showed no hesitation on their part to share info with each other or their recruiters. How will Starfighter prevent player "cheating" or knowing the route to leveling? How will content be updated or dynamic? This is a promising thing for software geeks in general, can't wait to try it out. I started playing Microcorruption and if this is similar to that, it will be fun.
- MichaelGG 12y agoThis is my major concern, but they've said that it's easier to learn the skills than cheat. I'm don't know how, but it's something they're obviously concerned about.
- patmcguire 12y agoI am lulzing a bit that the top Google result for Starfighter starts "Official website for Starfighter, an erotic sci-fi m/m webcomic" Kind of like when Django Unchained came out and it got a lot harder to debug one of my projects...
- ezdiy 12y agoWhile the efforts of Matasano to make wargaming cool and hip again certainly is commendable, I think HR drones of the world also appreciate a game of "pretend to be sociable teamplayer/brogrammer". Too often hackers don't get the job because of being overqualified and prima-donna, rather than lack of technical skill - a game teaching/testing the art of office politics could be applicable to wider market [outside of infosec]. tl;dr: Perhaps less of http://alexnisnevich.github.io/untrusted/ http://alexnisnevich.github.io/untrusted/ and more of EVE online.
- tptacek 12y agoThose employers aren't going to be our clients.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- edem 12y agoI wonder whether the name has something to do with the movie "The last Starfighter": http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0087597/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0087597/
- swatow 12y agoI'm not very familiar with this style of programming puzzle, but I wonder how this is less arbitrary than whiteboard coding topcoder or kaggle. I know people who were hired based on all of these, but the latter two are different from Starfighter in that they exist for their own reasons (competition for its own sake, and getting answers to data science questions) with providing a signal to employers being a side effect. I wonder if the selection bias in a system set up for the purpose of employment will be better or worse.
- vskarine 12y agoGreat idea. I loved Microcorruption. But please please don't call it video game! Average person reading this would think this is some sort of World Of Warcraft type game and stuff like that but this is more of a programming competition.
- strags 12y ago> Of 12224 players, just 182 passed the hardest level. The firm will get in touch with these elite players and help place them with one of their clients, who pay Starfighter a fee. As player #181 out of those #182, I'm excited :)