2 ms·
The thing about "genocidal aliens" is... one has to assume such aliens have technology "beyond human knowledge" - since we know of no way to travel between star
by joe_the_user 12y ago
The thing about "genocidal aliens" is... one has to assume such aliens have technology "beyond human knowledge" - since we know of no way to travel between stars. Yet the supposed methods that they used against the supposed Martian civilization seem crude and simplistic, something human beings could now if we put resources into the project.
Once one begins hypothesizing "things that can do anything in ways we don't understand for reasons we don't understand but occasionally do some things we do understand but again for no clear or unambiguous reason" then one's ability to use Occam's razor is gone.
Maybe a spaceship go marooned on Mars and exploded in the process of trying to fix it's warp drive. What are the odds? Clearly we don't know what the odds for any of this.
A simpler hypothesis is a supposed Martian civilization wiped out itself. No necessarily true or supported by much evidence but it seems at least sort-of testable since it doesn't assume variables beyond our conception of what's possible. Human civilization has been poised on the brink of large-scale nuclear in the not-too-distant past so intelligence creating world-destroying-nukes hardly seems like that big a stretch.
- blincoln 12y ago"since we know of no way to travel between stars." We don't know of a way to travel between them _quickly enough to be practical for humans_. That's not a problem for machines. They can be patient and take thousands of years.