3 ms·
"speculation that anomalous levels of radiation in parts of Mars is due to "big nasty genocidal intelligences," that sounds Dianetics-level bonkers to me." Lik
by jerf 12y ago
"speculation that anomalous levels of radiation in parts of Mars is due to "big nasty genocidal intelligences," that sounds Dianetics-level bonkers to me."
Like so much else, "it depends". If you're sure that's the explanation and no other makes sense, you're bonkers... our knowledge isn't strong enough to make that claim exclusively.
However, as answers to the Fermi Paradox go, "Something out there stomps flat anything that looks like a developing civilization", as unpleasant as it may be to contemplate, is definitely in the running. Along with a difficult-to-bound number of other candidate answers, but it's not a crazy one based on the meager evidence we've collected to date on the topic.
- maxerickson 12y agoHow close are you here to arguing that the probability of a great destroyer is somewhere between 0 and 1?
- colechristensen 12y agoThings that are _unreasonable_ to believe: * That life in our galaxy is unique to our planet given our now solid knowledge that similar planet systems and planets of the correct size in habitable zones are beyond abundant * That intelligent life, given the above, is also not unique to our planet * That some intelligent life is not millions of years more advanced * That there is nothing capable or motivated to wipe out entire planets for reasons to us which seem irrational and murderous --- Lots of folks get confused between the increasing rationality of assuming life exists somewhere besides Earth and conspiracy nuts who think every unusual weather phenomenon and experimental aircraft is an alien. --- The disconnect and irrationality comes from attributing non-Human sentience to unexplained phenomena. If your foot hurts, it's pretty easy to go on WebMD and convince yourself that you have bone cancer. It's not irrational because it's impossible, but because your overactive imagination has chosen the most interesting solution over the most reasonable one. --- Likewise your mind shouldn't be closed to the idea of something we observe in the next century being definitely attributable to extraterrestrial intelligence; but it will take some extraordinary exclusion of natural happenings to make it conclusive.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoStrongly disagree that the specific kind of intelligence that builds spacecraft is not unique to our planet in any way follows from the quite reasonable belief that life is probably not unique to our planet. The latter belief is supported by a lot of evidence: the molecular machinery of our kind of life is pretty common, and the chemistry that drives it appears to be robust and nothing special. To get a sense of how special the kind of intelligence that builds spaceships is, however, consider that every complex feature of organisms, from insect societies to wings to eyes, has evolved many, many times, all independently of one another. Intelligence of the kind that builds spaceships, on the other hand, has evolved exactly once in the history of our planet, and appears to have been the result of a runaway mate competition and mate selection process in our social primate ancestors. There was certainly no material advantage to having a brain big enough and well enough designed to build spaceships when you were busy scrabbling for food (a feat that a huge range of unintelligent organisms, including unintelligent social organisms, manage reasonably well.) So it is quite plausible that there is life all over the place in the universe, and intelligence almost nowhere. Just because we can see the advantages of intelligence doesn't mean there is a clear evolutionary path toward it, and the history of life on Earth suggests in fact that the path to the kind of intelligence that builds spaceships is extremely narrow and twisty.
- afarrell 12y agoI'd argue you have to invoke the way that mate competition involved both tool use and social jockeying.
- joe_the_user 12y agoSo far, all our evidence and understanding says that an intelligence that builds practical spaceships capable of going to and influencing other star system existences nowhere, that humans will likely never build such things and plausibly no other entity can either. Life as such might be common as mold in cosmos but utterly unable to move from star to star or even broadly choose it's "destiny". - And simplest hypothesis is that if these Martians existed, they wiped themselves out, as it human beings seem on the way to doing. What are the odds?
- chiph 12y agoThis has been explored in sci-fi by Jack McDevitt in his Priscilla Hutchins series. He had large Omega Clouds of alien devices attacking anything with straight lines and right-angles, as those were indicative of intelligence.
- talmand 12y agoThere was a similar notion in a sci-fi show, I believe it was Babylon 5, of a alien probe that would promise superior technology if you could prove your species' intelligence; only to destroy you instead if you passed the test.
- blincoln 12y agoFred Saberhagen got there decades earlier with his _Berserker_ novels. AFAIK every "alien machines that wipe out intelligent life" story is descended from them. Greg Bear's _The Forge of God_ / _Anvil of Stars_ (which are both excellent, IMO) followed similar lines in the late 80s.
- acheron 12y agoYeah. The Babylon 5 episode that talmand was referring to was an explicit reference to the Berserker stories.