7 ms·
Network theory suggests consciousness is global in the brain
- doctorstupid 12y agoIt seems rather tenuous to suggest that because all the parts of a conscious brain are active, all of the brain must then be conscious.
- Luc 12y agoAfter reading it, I don't think anything like that is suggested by the article.
- anigbrowl 12y agoI think they're arguing that consciousness is an emergent property of a sufficiently large network, rather than being located in a particular cerebral structure.
- mewwts 12y agoThat's a great explanation.
- klank 12y agoI'm in agreement. Think of large social sites like reddit or 4chan. I think it would be fair to consider them as conscious entities for the same reason. They can have conversations with themselves about themselves and can even have conversations/interactions with outside entities all driven "by their own volition".
- anigbrowl 12y agoAh, so I'm not hte only person that thinks that way. I've found it helpful to imagine the same mechanism at work in any large system like market, a nation and so on. Even things like ant colonies have a sort of slow primitive consciousness. It's particularly interesting that you mention 4chan, since the the fact that it is anonymous by default actually fosters this behavior.
- charlieflowers 12y agoAlso, does awareness of the presence of a disc equate to consciousness? That seems rather tenuous.
- smtucker 12y agoI'm not sure "consciousness" really exists. A computer surely isn't aware of what it is computing and you don't need a global state of consciousness to describe its functionality. Why point to things like "consciousness" when our brains being biological automatons is a perfect explanation already? It gets even sillier when you consider that the criteria for what things are considered conscious seems to be quite arbitrary. They say a human is conscious. Is a dog? I think most people would agree if a human is conscious a dog is. Is a squirrel? I think most people would agree. Is a lizard? Maybe. Is a spider? eh... Is a worm? well some might only have ~300 neurons... Is a plant? Well, no neurons, but they technically do react to stimuli... How about a rock? Well it certainly doesn't have any neurons and doesn't react to stimuli but what is so special about neurons and reacting to stimuli anyway? The concept of a threshold for consciousness doesn't seem to hold any weight to it. It has nothing backing it up. When two particles interact with each other is a barrier of consciousness formed? Are all systems conscious? Is the universe conscious? Are all possible systems made up of all the connections of all the constituent parts of the universe conscious?
- bencollier49 12y agoThat depends what you mean by "consciousness". If you mean the "experience of awareness", then we can't even properly define it, let alone begin to explain it. This whole question is so hard because we find it impossible to define the terms. It could be that by default, we cannot define consciousness. Perhaps that implies that the universe is made of consciousness, rather than the other way around.
- smtucker 12y agoYou are right we should properly define our terms. And of course as you pointed out it is very hard. Maybe if we defined them in a sort of reverse order it would be easier. Consider humans as biological automatons. Our brains are some sort of neural networked computer and the architecture of the neurons makes for, from a programmers point of view, some very advanced sort of "artificial" intelligence. From here there seems to be two possibilities: 1) That is it. Nothing else and their is no "being" experiencing what the brain processes or 2) something else, I think this idea is what we call... Consciousness would be the idea that their is some sort of unifying sort of connectedness that allows the soul, ghost, being, etc to experience what is happening and in some people's viewpoints have an affect on what is happening (freewill in other words). To me this definition seems terribly biased towards my point of view but I don't really know of any other way to define this.
- divan 12y agoJeff Hawkins wrote absolutely the same thing in his "On Intelligence" book (2004), and came to that conclusion from his brain model.
- sebastianconcpt 12y agoSomething that you might find interesting: There are two basic lines of thought here, the hard-electron AI school of thought that pushes the emergent hypothesis and the "Consciousness is not Computation" school of thought that accepts that Mind is Computation but states that Consciousness is something else. Tip: the AI hypothesis does NOT explain nor predicts the thing that a Paramesium can do. https://www.singularityweblog.com/stuart-hameroff-quantum-consciousness/ https://www.singularityweblog.com/stuart-hameroff-quantum-co...
- danielbarla 12y ago> the AI hypothesis does NOT explain nor predicts the thing that a Paramesium can do. Can you elaborate? Off the top of my head, I believe Paramecia display slightly above amoeba-like intelligence; what I'm missing is the leap to how a theory of emergent consciousness would not be able to explain this.
- albertzeyer 12y agoYes, exactly. That's the Hierarchical Temporal Memory (HTM) theory about the Neocortex. According to him, "consciousness is simply what it feels like to have a neocortex". I.e. it's a global property. Some more here: http://vinodwadhawan.blogspot.de/2014/03/122-hawkins-model-for-intelligence-and.html http://vinodwadhawan.blogspot.de/2014/03/122-hawkins-model-f...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dmichulke 12y agoSo analyzing the process of detecting a disk on a screen is somehow supposed to permit conclusions on consciousness? Well, my cat meows when I switch on the light so I suppose I should write about how "Electricity suggests language development is intrinsic in mammals"
- sp332 12y agoYes. When a person is conscious of a disk on the screen, their brain scans look very different from when they do not detect the disk. And there isn't just one part of the brain that changes. I'm not saying fMRI is a great tool for this, but it seems like a pretty clear conclusion.
- dmichulke 12y agoWell I think that 'consciousness' is a pretty strong term for something described in the article. Just to clarify: Are cats or toddlers conscious? Are the people that do not see the disk conscious?
- sp332 12y agoThe fact that it's such a small thing that they're testing is what makes the large reaction so interesting. They were trying to determine what part of the brain is involved in detecting an object, but just that tiny bit of awareness seems to be widely spread out.
- snowwrestler 12y agoThe analogy I fall back on is the concept of a wave in a body of water. Where, in the body of water, is the structure that defines the wave? How does a wave arise from a bunch of water molecules? What we call a "wave" is actually a broadly distributed energy pattern in the water. We just have created a single word for it to help us recognize and talk about that pattern. Consciousness might be like that--a (very complex) pattern of energy in the matter of the brain. "Consciousness" would refer to a pattern of behaviors, rather than a physical "thing" like a rock or a hand.
- lerno 12y agoConsciousness is typically understood as "the one that experiences". The failure of reductionism to explain it can be demonstrated by an example: You accidentally burn your finger on the stove, this is detected by the nerves that send nerve signals to the brain that signifify pain. In the brain those signals create an incredibly complex reaction in the brain that cause you to withdraw your hand. For a "philosofical zombie" - an awareless automaton - that is all that happens. For an aware being, this is followed by an "experience" of pain. How does this experience of pain arise? There is an action and reaction in both the aware and the unaware, an automaton does not EXPERIENCE pain, even though reaction and consequent actions are identical. Let us focus on the experience of the aware observer - where does it start? If it is in the brain, we can reduce it to physical effects, in which case our automaton could replicate it. Plus, at what point does the feeling arise? It's clearly not in the hand itself, nor in the nerves. But nerves are an extension of the brain. We have a part of the brain that handles pain, but why should those particular brain cells cause a painful feeling to arise? These are just like all the other cells in the brain, just differing in connections. Why would the activation of some cells cause pain to arise? If it is due to the connection that cause our brain to decide that this was a negative experience, then this would imply that the feeling arises when the pain center sends signals that it is stimulated to other parts of the brain. Then does the feeling of pain arise in the cells connecting to the part of the brain dealing with pain? If so, by what mechanism do those parts of the brain cause the feelings to arise? There is no way to nail down a mechanism that isn't physical and anonymous (i.e. doe not know the context of what it is connected to), and trying to claim that inanimate objects are self-aware is a bit of a stretch. We reach the conclusion that there is no good way to describe aware experience arising from the physical. Nor do any simple metaphysical notions of "soul" work, as any metaphysical system run into similar issues (if there is a soul, then by what process does it give rise to awareness)