8 ms·
Travel is the driver of all human progress and development. What, you think the amount of roads we have now is a lot? We've always had roads, they were for car
by ars 12y ago
Travel is the driver of all human progress and development.
What, you think the amount of roads we have now is a lot? We've always had roads, they were for carts, or horses, or anything else. There is nothing special about cars here.
> Gosh I hope we can figure this out in my lifetime.
We did. We made travel cheap and easy and it has benefited us massively.
- swayvil 12y ago> Travel is the driver of all human progress and development. Actually, people with lots of free time and access to drugs is the driver of all human progress and development.
- s73v3r 12y agoReally? What drugs did Sir Tim Berners-Lee do when he created the World Wide Web?
- breischl 12y agoI think it was that radioactive spider venom stuff. I hear Peter Parker was on it, too.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoSir Tim, as a UK citizen in the late 20thC would have used many drugs in his lifetime, paracetamol, aspirin, penicillin, vaccines... I think you may have leapt to a conclusion about the drugs the parent post meant. Are you thinking about those recreational drugs a bit too much ... :-)
- Dylan16807 12y agoPlease do not insult the reader. Honestly, your comment offends me. I know you're making a joke but it's so condescending I can't stand it.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoYes the last sentence was meant as a joke and is admittedly rather condescending. However the first half of my comment is I think valid - access to medicinal as opposed to recreational drugs is part of the virtuous circle that has driven human development - better agriculture, better sanitation and better medication have all had outsize impacts. To deliberately - or perhaps honestly - miss that point and suggest access to recreational drugs (the only kind we use the term "doing drugs") is necessary to point out.
- Dylan16807 12y ago"free time and access to drugs" is clearly talking about drugs that alter mental state. s73v3r was not the one missing the point.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoI disagree, in the context of the post (human society and development over thousands of years), then I read that as "free time - better agriculture" and "access to drugs - medication to improve quality of life" I can see it as being taken either way though
- swayvil 12y agoI meant psychoactive drugs.
- Dylan16807 12y agoIncreased productivity over time hasn't correlated very well with the amount of free time people have, and there's always been room for tinkering. There were especially large amounts of free time pre-agriculture. And I wouldn't put advances in medical drugs particularly high on the list of advances either. It's not even the top of the list of medical advances. Though I don't classify vaccines as drugs.
- r00fus 12y ago> We did. We made travel cheap and easy and it has benefited us massively. If you're referring to ICE and automobiles, that "cheap" cost is bought by uncountable externalities that aren't on the balance sheet: many lives and wars to secure this cheap fuel, not to mention climate change.
- yellowapple 12y agoThat's being fixed already with new propulsion methods - namely, electric power, which could potentially be provided via cleaner energy sources (wind, solar, fission, geothermal, fusion (someday), etc.). This will soon make automobiles even cheaper on all fronts - even those that - as you say - "aren't on the balance sheet". Arguments to ban cars outright because of climate change and oil might've been relevant in the 20th century, but now they're pretty much moot, so long as electric vehicles continue to grow in popularity.
- guelo 12y agoMost electricity is generated from coal and other fossil fuels.
- yellowapple 12y agoFor now. That, too, will eventually no longer be an issue.
- CalRobert 12y agoElectric vehicles can still kill your family, friends, and self.
- yellowapple 12y agoNo disagreement there. I was merely pointing out that objecting to cars because of their pollution is silly when more and more of us are driving around in electric vehicles.
- makeitsuckless 12y agoWe didn't have roads 4 lanes wide (which is a huge amount of additional land lost), and we didn't have the insane amount of parking space. Even a not particularly car friendly city like Amsterdam would look dramatically different if you removed the parking space, because it would free up such an insane amount of space. Cars have multiplied the amount of space dedicated to transport, without actually adding much to human progress and development, what with most of it being used to carry individuals short distances from A to B and back again. I don't see the massive benefit here. It's a pointless habit we shaped a life/work culture around with a mostly negative impact on the quality of life.
- limeyx 12y agoExactly. The Romans just parked their horses in a nearby field and got them fed at the same time! Renewable fuel and the perfect "green space" parking lot / local park
- ars 12y agoNo, they did not. Those nearby fields only existed in transit (between cities). By cities those areas were simply seas of mud that people avoided. Cities did not value green spaces at all. I understand the desire for the "good old days", but those days never actually existed.
- walshemj 12y agoMud and horse poop - before the car London as the biggest city had serious problems just getting rid of all the waste from the horses used on its streets.
- classicsnoot 12y ago>without adding much to human progress and development I am opposed to vehicles being the priority, but their prevalence is directly related to their usefulness within the economic regions they occur in. If you ever go to the developing world, you will see vehicles used to grow and maintain society. It is easy to forget, living in the suburbs as i do, that most of the world does not joy ride over-produced SUVs. The ability to move freely is a magical thing. Living in a place with bad roads is a reality to itself that i think every westerner should experience. The problem is what we use to take advantage of the roads. Roads are society's rivers.
- breischl 12y agoYes, but carts and horses don't habitually move at 25 MPH or more. It was possible to get run over and killed by a cart, but walking into a busy city street full of cars (without following the signals) is almost certain to get you killed. That's a pretty big difference in how the space can actually be used. The first section of this article is interesting in this context: http://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history http://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history
- mc32 12y agoTo be fair, millions of horses in the streets would cause a lot of pollution in the form of horse dung. Streets would be mired in horse crap... And what would you do with it, if you removed it? Some could be used as fertilizer, but not all. Woe are us after the rains...
- thaumasiotes 12y ago> walking into a busy city street full of cars (without following the signals) is almost certain to get you killed This is total nonsense, easily falsified by just looking at daily urban life in the modern world. The behavior you describe is completely routine in Shanghai; deaths are rare.
- nl 12y agoThis is total nonsense, easily falsified by just looking at daily urban life in the modern world. The behavior you describe is completely routine in Shanghai; deaths are rare. The Chinese appear to disagree: Shanghai traffic police have punished 350,000 cases of pedestrian jaywalking this year.... There have been more than 200 crashes involving pedestrians that have killed 56 people as a result of ignoring traffic signals in Shanghai this year, traffic police said. (2012)[1] and According to Shanghai traffic police, 48 people have been killed and 206 injured in more than 200 accidents in the first 5 months of 2013, involving either jaywalking or scooters and mopeds running red lights[2] [1] http://en.people.cn/90882/8059898.html http://en.people.cn/90882/8059898.html [2] http://www.healthandsafetyinshanghai.com/shanghai-traffic.html http://www.healthandsafetyinshanghai.com/shanghai-traffic.ht...
- wutbrodo 12y agoThis is a hell of a strawman. The proposition isn't to remove the ability to travel, which (as you said) is effectively the removal of geographic barriers to interaction. It's to replace car travel with something that has lower costs in terms of efficiency, health, economics, city planning, fatalities, the environment, etc etc etc etc. > What, you think the amount of roads we have now is a lot? We've always had roads, they were for carts, or horses, or anything else. There is nothing special about cars here. Not all roads are made equal. There's a huge difference between "space reserved for a mode of travel" and the public spaces that roads[1] (in cities) were before cars became ubiquitous.[2] A good analogue is imagining a path in a park: it's generally used for transit (people walking and occasionally biking), but it's also fully open as a public space for the citizenry to use as they please. [1] This whole conversation is about roads in cities, so that's what I'm referring to: roads across sparsely populated countryside don't have nearly as high a cost, nor do they have as many viable alternatives. [2] http://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history http://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history
- ars 12y agoYou have a VERY rosy eyed view of what cities were like before the car. What they were actually like is rivers of mud mixed with horse manure. There were just as many roads before as now, except they were very dirty. > and the public spaces that roads (in cities) were before cars became ubiquitous Absolute nonsense. Go read some history, or even fictionalized accounts. Roads were never public spaces like you imagine. They were roads, and carts and horses routinely road right over people who didn't get out of the way. They were crowded and dirty, and those open spaces you imagine did not exist inside cities. (There plenty of open spaces outside cities, of course.) Your dream world existed to some degree inside farm villages, but never in cities.
- classicsnoot 12y ago>fictionalized accounts The amount of plays, novels, stories, poems, and songs that take place in and on and nearby, as well as revolving around and referencing to, ares of transit is pretty large. When looked at in the context of human existence on the planet, roads are the pathways human cells use to move and multiply and spread and settle. So much culture and development occurs on the paths of humanity. This is not limited to any single road concept; bridges, train tracks, shipping lanes, and airports all spawn society blocks around them. The Pathways have always been public spaces. Are you opposed to those public spaces being safer and more productive? If so, would you say it is because vehicles [methods of human conveyance] have a priority over people [humans living] in the Public Square? The point of travel is the people that can do it, not the profits to be gained or the methods to be employed IMO.
- jdietrich 12y agoWith the automobile came the invention of 'jaywalking', and the idea that the street belongs primarily to cars rather than people. The nature of public space changed fundamentally. Many European cities are heavily pedestrianised, with large areas of the centre accessible only for deliveries. There are big public health impacts - walking and cycling becomes more popular, children have safe spaces to play, accident rates fall and the air quality is drastically improved.
- wlesieutre 12y agoAnd not just an invention after the fact! "Jaywalking" was a word made up by the auto companies to sway public opinion in their direction (and paint pedestrians who use the street as stupid). 99% Invisible did a nice episode on it a while back: http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/episode-76-the-modern-moloch/ http://99percentinvisible.org/episode/episode-76-the-modern-...
- samatman 12y agoThere weren't many powerful automobile companies in 1891. https://books.google.com/books?id=Noo4AQAAMAAJ&q=%22jaywalking%22&dq=%22jaywalking%22&hl=en&sa=X&ei=CHYHVbPCEpO2ogSMi4HwCA&ved=0CC0Q6AEwAw https://books.google.com/books?id=Noo4AQAAMAAJ&q=%22jaywalki...
- wutbrodo 12y agoHm,that's interesting. I wonder why the OED doesn't mention this source in its earliest usage: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaywalking#Origin_of_the_term http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaywalking#Origin_of_the_term EDIT: In case that sounded sarcastic or like I didn't believe you, I'm actually curious about how they're so far off in their "first usage".
- cowsandmilk 12y agoBecause this is Volume 39, which was actually published in 1954, not 1891.[1] Search the book for 1954, or any year before then, you will get results. Search for 1955 and you get nothing. [1] http://onlinebooks.library.upenn.edu/webbin/serial?id=ncycusbio http://onlinebooks.library.upenn.edu/webbin/serial?id=ncycus...
- megablast 12y ago> There is nothing special about cars here. Cars kill 1.2 million people a year. I think that is special, and not something that happened before.