4 ms·
It's hard to justify the right for people to break copyright law. At the same time, I can see how startups that are depending on the safe harbor clause to host
by amichail 17y ago
It's hard to justify the right for people to break copyright law.
At the same time, I can see how startups that are depending on the safe harbor clause to host copyrighted material to attract users would be upset with the rules of the game changing.
- CamperBob 17y agoIt's hard to justify the right for people to break copyright law. Considering that copyright isn't a natural right in the first place, I don't see the problem.
- amichail 17y agoObviously getting rid of copyright would have a devastating effect on innovation and creativity.
- fizx 17y agoObviously?
- amichail 17y agoActually no... sorry. I forgot my own blog post on this topic. In particular, not much may change on the web if we get rid of patents and copyright: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=920911 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=920911
- Retric 17y agoReally? I have read many great books that where never in any way protected by copyright. Honestly, writers are compensated for around 30-40% of the content I read and the only advantage I see is a slightly higher quality of copy editing. On a more serious note, for profit content is less innovative because it's targeting the widest audience possible. Walking around a book store you can find a lot of bland tasteless garbage to fit even the most snobbish pallet. But, there are other approaches. Wikipedia is a perfect example of what happens when you separate the content creation process from direct monetary gain as is Hacker News and a thousand other places that you never really think about. PS: I don't care one way or the other, but suggesting that copyright is vital for innovation and creativity is just silly. Edit: NM, I missed the sarcasm on that one.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agosuggesting that copyright is vital for innovation and creativity is just silly You realise there are no CC licenses without copyright. That anyone can take my published work and reprint it as their own without any attribution. Copyright has been much abused by big business, but that's capitalism at work, we shouldn't disavow people of the rights to an interest in the results of their labour. Copyright only works as a contract between creators and the public. We're doing our part by protecting rights of content creators via the treaties and laws but we are being denied our part of the contract - having works enter the public domain in a timely fashion. Copyright IMO needs fixing not removing.
- uriel 17y ago> Copyright has been much abused by big business, but that's capitalism at work Rubish, copyright is completely incompatible with capitalism: copyright consists of government granted monopolies.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoThe "capitalism at work" part is the manipulation of copyright to prevent works from entering the public domain. The motive is corporate profit: ensuring those with property retain it and any worth it can generate despite a socialist contract agreeing to give up that property after a certain period.
- uriel 17y agoThat is not "capitalism at work", that is rent seeking and one of the many very common forms of government failure. Just because the motive of something is profit, it doesn't mean it is capitalism, the motive of taxes is also profit (for special interests), but that doesn't mean they are capitalism at work.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoThe stated motive of taxes is usually the public good; if it's profit for special interests then you're probably talking of fraud. I still contend that the pressure by corporations to increase copyright terms in order to maximise the profitability of held IP assets is "capitalism at work". It is sustained holding of IP away from the public domain preventing others from using that IP [for profitable production]. Smells like capitalism to me.
- bonaldi 17y agoJust as a data point -- it is an inalienable human right, at least as defined by the UN. Article 27 of the UN Declaration of Human Rights: (2) Everyone has the right to the protection of the moral and material interests resulting from any scientific, literary or artistic production of which he is the author. (Not that this by any means justifies or demands anything like the copyright regime we have now, let alone this ridiculous power-grab extension of it. And people are of course free to waive their rights at any time.)
- tjogin 17y agoBut enforcing that law means breaking an other inalienable human right; that of privacy. And I'd say that law is more important.
- rjurney 17y agoCan't believe you had 0 on this. Great comment.
- tezza 17y agoIt's for the courts to decide that balance, our opinions on the merits are irrelevant
- kls 17y agoThe second amendment falsifies this statement. The only reason our opinions are irrelevant, is because of complacency and the inevitable slide towards tyranny that every world power faces as it ages. The government feels no threat from the people and therefore feels comfortable in selling our freedoms to the highest bidder. If the populous where not so complacent or indoctrinated then our leaders would think twice before leveraging our rights against us. This is a simple concept that the founding fathers understood all to well. They knew the constitution was a piece of paper and that individuals in the government would always look at it as such.
- tezza 17y ago
- blhack 17y agoI think it is more along the lines of people being afraid that their users might break copyright law. For instance: my website allows users to upload profile pictures. From the sound of this, if one of them were to upload a copyrighted picture, _I_ am liable. My website is small right now, so monitoring this is feasible...if it gets much larger, I would need to hire a team of people just to police it. Obviously, if somebody says "Hey, Ryan, user $foo has uloaded picture $bar, would you mind taking it down?" I will, but if this is the way boingboing is making it sound...it won't be that easy.
- westbywest 17y agoThe concern I see being voiced is less about protecting copyright, for which many protections already exist, and more about implementing a level of regulation/protectionism that is out of step with what is usually just a civil complaint. True, criminal penalties do exist in US for certain instances of willful copyright infringement, but it is still overwhelmingly an area where there must be a plaintiff for any litigation to occur. It is appropriate to treat copyright infringement in the same way one treats the international opium trade?
- danek 17y agoIt is appropriate to treat copyright infringement in the same way one treats the international opium trade? yeah, if you are: the RIAA or MPAA a news organization that doesn't want anyone blogging about the truthiness of your reporting a politician receiving money from these groups a politician wanting to censor certain information i don't like that you merely have to be accused of infringement for bad things to happen. it'd be like getting accused of being a communist in the '50s. this feels like a big step towards global authoritarianism.
- Vivtek 17y agoThat's because it is a big step towards global authoritarianism. My wife is Hungarian, born in 1966 like myself, and she's deathly afraid of expressing political dissent in public venues like the Internet. That's what we're proposing to make the law now - that fear. Makes it ever so much easier to keep control, you see.
- kls 17y agoIt is very hard for Americans to comprehend the idea of blatant oppression by the government as Americas always had a gentler approach to oppressing it's citizenry. I have quite a few friends from eastern European origin and it is always peculiar when you get into a discussion about the government with them and their voice immediately drops into whisper. After all of these years thy still have it in the back of their mind that someone from the party could be listening. Pretty creepy stuff if you stop to think about it.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoThe threat is not that startups wouldn't be able to infringe copyright law. The threat is that startups would have to carry the burden of policing copyright law. The cost of doing that may be prohibitive, and the vulnerability to frivolous claims by bigger competitors would mean that any startup dealing with user generated content would have to employ lawyers at all times. If phone companies were liable for crimes coordinated over their networks, telephony would not exist.
- eru 17y agoImagine the postal system being held responsible for mail bombs.