2 ms·
I can't believe HN is reacting to this as if checking location is a bad idea. It does have an emergency override. On the underground, particularly during rush
by TazeTSchnitzel 12y ago
I can't believe HN is reacting to this as if checking location is a bad idea. It does have an emergency override.
On the underground, particularly during rush hour, doors opening on the wrong side, or in the wrong place, could cause people to fall out of the train onto the tracks, in the dark, and risk serious injury or even death (especially with electrified rails).
And using GPS and repeaters in the few spots where the signal's poor sounds like a practical and cost-effective approach. Given the issues, perhaps they should've implemented it some other way, but it's hardly the ridiculous solution you're all making it out to be.
As superuser2 mentions below, there's even a non-safety reason for this feature: long trains in short stations. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9203351 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9203351
- fche 12y agoUse of broadcast signals like GPS for safety-critical purposes makes them a target for adverse interference - like a jammer hoping to mess with / trap people on the train.
- gkoz 12y agoAdding a complex and unreliable dependency that has to be reimplemented underground and isn't really needed (because you don't need the GPS coordinates, just a little bit of local metadata)? Not ridiculous at all.
- sitkack 12y agoUsing an unauthenticated, jammable signal for a safety critical function is wrong, not something dictated by the practicality or expediency of the solution. It is absolutely wrong and stupid. Like Therac stupid. And as someone mentioned below, there is already a solution for this exact problem; https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balise https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balise
- icebraining 12y agoCouldn't one "jam" the balise by throwing a large rock at it?
- maxerickson 12y agoIt's kind of hilarious that you kicked your post off with a glib denouncement of "HN" and then edited it to refer to information someone had posted prior to you making the comment. It's also the case that most of the raspberries are aimed at the idea that it doesn't work very well, which is a failure regardless of the apparent reasonableness of the implementation.