9 ms·
The headline and most of this article seem to avoid the real point of the FAA complaint. The problem wasn't flying the drone. The problem wasn't posting the d
by slg 12y ago
The headline and most of this article seem to avoid the real point of the FAA complaint. The problem wasn't flying the drone. The problem wasn't posting the drone video to YouTube. The problem was turning on monetization for the drone videos. If you try to make money a drone flight, you are using the drone commercially. The fact that the money actually made is less than a dollar doesn't really matter as the intention is there to make money. Not saying I agree with the rule, but it seems to be pretty straightforward with relatively little room for interpretation.
EDIT: Even the updated HN headline still doesn't have it right. Neither the video nor the drone flight are illegal. The video just bumps the flight up to a higher tier of regulation from a hobby flight to a commercial flight. A better headline might be "FAA says monetized videos retroactively qualify drone flights as commercial flights."
- Dylan16807 12y agoSure is fun how actions after the fact can change the legality of something like this. I seriously doubt there was any intent at the time of filming to generate income.
- chisleu 12y agoThat is interesting. What if the person shooting the video and operating the drone isn't the one monetizing it? What if he uploads the video to a site that won't pay him and the video is stolen and put on a site that pays the person who stole it? Is the flight of the drone illegal then? Ridiculous logic. We can use them to kill innocent children who happen to be at a party where some scumbag is hanging out, but don't film your birthday party and upload it to youtube! Don't try to sell your house with a video featuring using a drone to show the roof is in good condition! Oh no! This is the end!
- icebraining 12y agoIt's not interesting. If the person flying the thing makes money - or intends to -, it's commercial, if not, it isn't. Profit by unrelated third-parties is, unsurprisingly, unrelated.
- bmelton 12y agoDon't judge me, but during a coding session, I got caught up watching "Gold Rush" on whatever channel it comes on. After sort of passively watching it while doing other things, one of the episodes in the marathon was a "behind the scenes" sort of thing, where they showed that drone cinematography is used, basically, in like 80% of the filming done for that show. They send the cameramen out in two-person teams, one to fly the drone, and the other to operate the camera, with an Oculus-looking visor on so that they can simply see the camera as through a viewfinder. The "intent to generate income" is not only there, it's at some point in the past.
- Dylan16807 12y agoWhen someone is paying you to fly that drone, definitely. Not the guy in the article, though. And thanks for noting an interesting episode to watch.
- FireBeyond 12y agoAnd I guarantee that a) the drone operator doesn't have a CPL, and b) that the FAA hasn't said a word to the show producers.
- awor 12y agoMost of Gold Rush is filmed in Canada, specifically anything involving "The Klondike", which is in the Yukon, Canada. They would need to abide by Transport Canada's UAV regulations, and would most likely require a SFOC, which is possible to get if you're operating <400ft commercially. The FAA does not yet have a similar permitting process for commercial drone use. EDIT: SFOC/Transport Canada regulations: http://www.tc.gc.ca/eng/civilaviation/standards/general-recavi-uav-2265.htm?WT.mc_id=1zfhj#safety http://www.tc.gc.ca/eng/civilaviation/standards/general-reca...
- jsnk 12y ago> Not saying I agree with the rule, [...] I think people understand the rule just fine, and they are angry because they don't agree with the rule at all.
- knorby 12y agoI think the greater point is that the FAA is meant to regulate aircraft, not the monetization button on youtube. The rule is senseless, and I think the FAA knows that; they are too inflexible to adapt to reality, and they should be practicing non-enforcement as a means of coping. Swarms of drone pilots could be flying and recording without the intent to monetize, and the FAA would have the same and only problem they are attempting to thwart.
- jessaustin 12y agoIt's as if FAA are jealous of the smackdown that FEC got in Citizens United, and would like some judicial abuse for themselves. It would be so much easier for the bureaucrats if there were a Department of Speech Regulation to which they could refer all these cases.
- WildUtah 12y agoNot just Citizens United but 44 Liquormart is on point as well. There are five Supremes that don't hold much with commercial and political intentions as a backdoor to the First Amendment. What the other four are thinking is beyond my ken.
- wongarsu 12y agoI think the real point is that in the times of the internet the line between private and commercial use of anything becomes fuzzier and fuzzier. This is now a problem for the FAA because they rely on a clear distinction between the two, and they won't be the only ones who will stumble.
- larrys 12y ago"Swarms of drone pilots could be flying and recording without the intent to monetize" I'm not sure I agree with that. As someone who has flown RC Helicopters for a long long time, one of the reasons I haven't gotten more into drones is a) they are "to easy" to fly and get boring [1] (if you don't believe me try flying a 60 size Gas RC Chopper with no gyros) and b) I can't make any money right now because of the "no commercial" rule. While I don't think people are flying drones to make practically nothing on youtube.com (I think they want to make cool videos obviously) the fact is if you are going to have a rule that says "no commercial" and it hasn't been further defined then you have to stick to that. Separately, there is a similar quasi rule with regards to using a domain name for commercial purposes (re: Trademark and UDRP filings) and often a domain name owner will lose a case if they don't have a good attorney and if the opposing party is able to take the ads and say "they are making money from my trademark". The amount of the money they are making doesn't really enter that much into the picture. [1] I bought an AR Drone which I "flew" exactly one time. It's similar to the difference, if you are a skier, between the bunny slope and a black diamond (and I don't mean an East Coast USA black diamond..)
- Crito 12y agoWhat if the footage was shot of the drone, not by it? Suppose I go to a local RC meetup with a camcorder, film some people flying around, then upload it to youtube and monetize it? What if the RC plane I am filming is owned by me, and flown by one of my friends? What if the RC plane is a drone owned by me, and is flying itself while I film it? What if the RC plane is owned and flown by me, while I film it? What if all of these tapes are 20 years old, and I am only now digging them out of my attic to digitize and monetize them? It seems to me there may be a decent amount of gray-areas around this whole concept.
- apendleton 12y agoAgreed... what if the person flying the drone has no knowledge of the intent by a third party to eventually monetize the video? Can their flying be retroactively and involuntarily criminalized by a third party who is given and then monetizes the footage?
- matthewmcg 12y agoThe legal question is whether "the aircraft is flown strictly for hobby or recreational use." To me, this suggests: (1) the statute looks to the purpose of the flight when the flight occurred--later developments don't matter (2) actions of third-parties not involved in the operation of the drone also don't matter Remember, the FAA has the authority to regulate drone flight for commercial purposes. They don't have the authority to regulate Youtube, other people's filming, etc.
- kenrikm 12y agoWhat if I fly and record footage and then sell the SD card for $500.. I was selling the SS card not the footage. What an interesting court case this is going to turn into, I'm not sure how many hairs need to be split before someone reasonable will come along and call BS on the FAAs position.
- tracker1 12y agoYou still own copyright on the footage, and it can't be used without your permission.
- trose 12y agoWell the FAA wants the drone pilot to have a commercial pilot license in order to shoot commercial video with it. Seems entirely silly to me. In my opinion there should be an altitude requirement involved here. Like, okay if you own a drone that is capable of going over 2000 ft you need a license to fly it regardless of whether you'll be filming. I have no idea if that is a reasonable threshold or not.
- dmitrygr 12y ago0 is a good one As a pilot who wants top live, i'd prefer people without training to stay out of the sky. Flying an extension of you (your drone) is even worse because you have even less interest in the safety since in a mid-air collision between planes, you die too. If your drone hits my plane - you do not die. Want to fly? Get a license. Want to fly a drone? Still get a license! What you ask (FAA to leave the issue alone) is akin to letting 2 year olds drive 18-wheelers on the roads you drive your kids to school on? Feeling comfy with that? To people who claim drones aren’t dangerous: YOU might have almost been killed by one last time you flew commercial: http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/near-collisions-between-drones-airliners-surge-new-faa-reports-show/2014/11/26/9a8c1716-758c-11e4-bd1b-03009bd3e984_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/national-security/near-c...
- CamperBob2 12y ago0 is a good one As a pilot who wants top live, i'd prefer people without training to stay out of the sky. Then I suggest you stay out of the sky, because we're not going to make it 100.000000% safe for you, ever. You don't own the universe above 0 AGL. Other people need to use it, too. Nobody flying a drone below several hundred feet is, or should be, a hazard to you, as long as they're not doing so near an airport. Existing regulations are just fine in that regard without making up a bunch of horseshit about "monetization." What you ask (FAA to leave the issue alone) is akin to letting 2 year olds drive 18-wheelers on the roads you drive your kids to school on? Feeling comfy with that? The arrogance it must take to post something like that is simply breathtaking. You probably throw beer cans at bicyclists when you pass them on the road, too.
- 12y ago
- 6stringmerc 12y agoInteresting point - I think I agree with your logic, re: "retroactive" concept of a commercial use case. What I'm curious about, though, is if the video is considered an artwork, can the FAA reasonably use their authority to classify the flight as commercial in nature? As in, if the purpose of the recording was not simply for profit, but profit comes by way of the artistic contribution (e.g. editing, adding a soundtrack, creating a montage for entertainment) then it's not really a "commercial flight" but simply a personal use resulting in a commerically viable product. There are some hairs to be split in this distinction I think. I mean, taking a video out the window of a personal / private aircraft is suddenly under the FAA's purvue by implication? I don't think they would be wise to go that route, but if they are, that'd be good to know in a hurry. There are a LOT of YouTube videos that suddenly run afoul of an overly broad interpretation, I'd wager. I'm not claiming to have the last word on this, but rather using my inherent stubbornness, creative background, and understanding of intellectual property / fair use / artistic case law as factors in the discussion. Hmm. Seems like a fun debate, and one that could be productive!
- m3rc 12y agoIf you're monetizing it at all it seems pretty straightforward. A video you don't consider art could be monetized, a video you do consider art could be monetized, it doesn't really matter. It's kind of a silly distinction to say that the person's intent means the FAA couldn't make any case to categorize it as commercial, because they laid out a very clear cut definition. I mean if someone does consider their video a purely artistic endeavor, then they just shouldn't monetize it. If it's a case like here where the money would have been nominal, then it shouldn't matter. And if they have an issue with not monetizing it then they're looking to make money off of it, and so it would certainly be commercial use.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 6stringmerc 12y agoWhat I'm saying though is that it's the artistic effort being monetized. It's kind of like saying a person can go buy a lump of clay, but if they turn it into a vase, then they can't sell it. Thus, the flight itself isn't being monetized. My point is that the FAA thinks it has authority to regulate artistic endeavors in this case, because they choose to define the flight's nature retroactively, when in essence, the flight itself is not the commodity, nor is the product of the flight the actual commercial product...I mean, tying a camera to a balloon and then making a video of that runs afoul of the FAA with this/your logic?
- jjcm 12y agoThe problem is that the FAA doesn't issue licenses for private use of commercial drones right now, effectively making monetized videos against the law. Quote from another article: "Chris Servicky, a licensed helicopter pilot who helps run the company, says they never got the FAA’s letter and says that he talked to the FAA about trying to get certified and they said no. 'They don’t want you to make money off of it, so we sell the editing of the video,' he said."[1] Saying monetized drone videos are legal is akin to saying meth is legal. Technically it is if you have a prescription, but it's near impossible to get a prescription, rendering that point moot when it comes to legality. [1] http://motherboard.vice.com/blog/these-are-the-companies-the-faa-has-harassed-for-using-drones http://motherboard.vice.com/blog/these-are-the-companies-the...
- matthewmcg 12y agoThey are hard to get, but they have issued some permits: http://www.faa.gov/news/press_releases/news_story.cfm?newsId=17194 http://www.faa.gov/news/press_releases/news_story.cfm?newsId...
- hkmurakami 12y agoI wonder how large the fines are. I've seen plenty of SV real estate guys using drones for aerial shots for their listings, and since the revenue per deal is large in a residential real estate sale, unless the fine is substantial it'll just get rolled up into "cost of doing business".
- blottsie 12y agoThere aren't many instances of actual fines, but this is the most prominent one: The FAA tried to fine drone pilot Raphael Pirker $10,000 [1] for being paid by the University of Virginia Medical Center to film a promo video with a drone. Pirker challenged the fine and won. The FAA changed its rules after that decision and Pirker eventually settled for $1,100. [1] http://kernelmag.dailydot.com/issue-sections/features-issue-sections/11559/me-irl-raphael-pirker-interview/ http://kernelmag.dailydot.com/issue-sections/features-issue-...
- hatipsa 12y ago
- jsmthrowaway 12y agoIf you use a third-party song in your video, monetization is turned on automatically but not for you. Your logic falls down when you understand YouTube's ad system. An ad can run on your video in any number of circumstances, monetized or not. I am directly impacted by this due to my work to educate folks about proper, safe drone usage given media mischaracterization and fearmongering (like that recent Audi ad) about drones. All of my videos are artistic in nature and work to educate the public on the positive, market-generating usages of drones, such as aerial filmmaking, land survey, search and rescue, and other uses. Your comment smacks of lacking all of the context around FAA enforcement against drone fliers in recent years, and rushing to defend an agency that has burned all positive relationships it ever had with the hobbyist industry, both drones and otherwise. The FAA has repeatedly missed deadlines to get its shit together, and is on track to miss another that was set by Congress for the end of this year. In the meantime, they've devoted their resources to pursuing drone fliers in court (and losing, quite dramatically, on taxpayer dollars) and sending toothless cease and desist notices like this. Nobody with an ounce of common sense can possibly conclude what you have, that a YouTube ad suddenly makes the flight commercial. If a private pilot records the view out of his cockpit window and then puts ads on the video on YouTube, he's not suddenly a (potentially unlicensed) commercial operator. It follows that this action is just another excuse for the FAA to harass drone pilots and people attempting to build a multi-million dollar industry in the United States. Nothing about this is sane, and the FAA is repeatedly demonstrating that it's happy to service those with money and who can make noise in government -- the sudden (and rapid) creation of the certification exemption program for law enforcement after DHS started flying Predators over the border, for example -- while pinching the rest of us in court. You shouldn't make any attempt to defend the FAA; most people (me included) who really want to make something of UAS are already looking to other nations and have begun operating under more progressive regulatory schemes.
- icebraining 12y agoIf you use a third-party song in your video, monetization is turned on automatically but not for you. Your logic falls down when you understand YouTube's ad system. An ad can run on your video in any number of circumstances, monetized or not. Irrelevant; what matters is if the person flying the plane makes money, not if unrelated third-parties do.
- 001sky 12y agoso you can (1) posses flight footage; but (2) you can't sell it. That put these FAA rules into the regulation of media. That sounds like something that will be litigated, IMHO. I doubt a court will let that stand without some threshold of materiality. A flight that costs $5 or whater and makes $0.05 is not implicitly a commercial enterprise. Using basic IRS rules, that is a "hobby" activity not a business activity, by definition. That's at least one objective standard that could be brought to bear. But who knows, maybe I'm missing something.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The fact that the money actually made is less than a dollar doesn't really matter as the intention is there to make money. Not saying I agree with the rule, but it seems to be pretty straightforward with relatively little room for interpretation. Monetizing the video later may be evidence of intent to use the drone commercially at the time the drone was flown, but its fairly weak evidence, since its quite possible for the intent to be formed after the drone was flown. The purpose of an act can't change retroactively, but the proceeds of an act carried out with one purpose may well have a different purpose than that of the act when it was carried out. Now, obviously, in the case where the party flying the drone has an ongoing operation of monetizing videos that exists prior to the time the drone is flown, flies the drone, and quickly turns around and monetizes the video from the drone, the combination of factors is pretty strong evidence that the drone was used commercially rather than the video being commercialized after the drone was flown.