3 ms·
In my opinion there shouldn't be anything 'wrong' with a BATS front-run; but if you don't want to play in that pond, then you should get out. Thus the volume o
by dnautics 12y ago
In my opinion there shouldn't be anything 'wrong' with a BATS front-run; but if you don't want to play in that pond, then you should get out. Thus the volume of trades for something like IEX would go up.... Let the market decide if people don't like how BATS operates.
If I were to set up an exchange, to discourage HFT-type shenanigans, I would set up "clearance windows". You put in your bid/asks and they are held for one second while the previous bid/asks clear, and if your quote is still available in the next second, then the trade is executed.
- kasey_junk 12y agoYour "clearance windows" are known as a batch auction and are frequently mentioned as a way to prevent speed shenanigans but they don't actually address the problem for a few reasons: - If there are more orders on one side of a price than on the other, how do you handle tie breakers? FIFO leaves the need for speed, Pro rata is already being gamed in other ways, random has transparency issues. - Speed is just as important (if not more sore) for canceling existing orders. Does your batch allow you to cancel orders before the auction takes place? If so you still have a speed game. If not, it is very risky for market makers to participate and they will either leave your exchange or price the spread more conservatively. Both of those put you at a price disadvantage compared to other exchanges. - Your exchange doesn't exist in a vacuum. There are other exchanges. You cannot prevent with your batch auction people using that speed advantage to arbitrage differences between your exchange price and other exchanges.