10 ms·
Endurance experiment kills six consumer SSDs over 18 months
- ChuckMcM 12y agoInteresting report. What I got from this is that in production you should swap out an SSD as soon as it starts reallocating sectors.
- S_A_P 12y agoreally impressive showing from all drives involved. I would have liked to see at least one of the drives fail to read only, but its nice to know that at the rate I use SSD sectors I should be ok for a pretty good while. While there is not great way to test this other than wait and see, I wonder if age AND total writes has an appreciable difference vs. marathon testing like this.
- wmf 12y agoThis headline is misleading. This experiment put something like 18 years worth of wear or more on those SSDs.
- shenanigoat 12y agoHeadline is accurate. A cursory glance at the article gives you a clear picture of what the drives were put through. I'm happy to know that SSDs can handle as much r/w as they can.
- Goronmon 12y agoI would argue while the headline is technically accurate, it's easily misunderstood.
- theandrewbailey 12y agoI agree, if only on the basis of HN's title and the linked page's title do not match.
- geoffgasior 12y agoHeadline should have been 18 months, 2.4 petabytes. Dunno what happened there.
- passive 12y agoAt 30 GB/day (still quite high for a consumer SSD), it's 70-200 years, depending on the drive.
- higherpurpose 12y agoDisappointing he didn't test the new Samsung 850 SSD. The old 840 is known to not have such a high endurance so I'm automatically excluding it from my list of choices.
- ris 12y agoIt would be a bit hard to have tested an 850 for 18 months, you know, what with time travel being what it is.
- chisleu 12y agoI don't think it tested 18 months of writing, it tested 18 months worth of writing.
- Goronmon 12y agoThe SSD Endurance Experiment represents the longest test TR has ever conducted. It's been a lot of work, but the results have also been gratifying. Over the past 18 months, we've watched modern SSDs easily write far more data than most consumers will ever need. It looks like they ran the test for 18 months.
- seanp2k2 12y agoThey read and wrote data almost constantly at full speed for 18 months, which is very likely not what normal people using these drives would do with them. Please read the article.
- EC1 12y agoYou're not wired in 24 hours a day all day? Pfft, casual.
- AceJohnny2 12y agoDid you even read the article? The 840 Pro was the top performer, reliability-wise.
- PaulHoule 12y ago840 pro rocks!
- chisleu 12y agoI would love to see how this stacks up to enterprise SSDs. It is my understanding that they will last years under constant full-bus-speed rewriting.
- mrmondo 12y agoCheck out the Intel DC p3600 / p3700 - very nice NVMe SSDs
- chisleu 12y agoAbsolutely correct. Those are some fantastic units. However I'm generally limited to 2.5" SAS/SATA interfaces. I hope to find some benchmarks like this on enterprise level stuff to fight the bullshit around SSDs not being capable of write intensive operations.
- mrmondo 12y agoI'll have you some benchmarks next week / the week after or so. I'm building custom storage servers and will be writing it up as I go: http://smcleod.net/building-a-high-performance-ssd-san/ http://smcleod.net/building-a-high-performance-ssd-san/
- trhway 12y ago>I would love to see how this stacks up to enterprise SSDs. the difference is number of writes an individual flash cell can take. Consumer - multi-level cell (MLC) - 1000-3000 writes (thus 240GB disks start to fail around 600-700TB written) where is enterprise SSD flash - single-level cell (SLC) - up to 100000 writes.
- chisleu 12y agoI'm talking eMLC. I don't see many SLCs on the market anymore.
- ars 12y agoI'm impressed with how long they lasted. I am NOT impressed with the behavior at end of life. In fact it makes it wary of using any SSD. A bad SSD should go read only, and stay that way. Not self-brick, and make the data unrecoverable.
- wnissen 12y agoIs there any explanation for the bricking on power cycle? The reads should be fine forever.
- raverbashing 12y agoNot sure, but I'm imagining it's to avoid someone throwing out a read-only drive filled with sensitive data (and unable to erase it through conventional means - that is, writing to the drive) Of course, there are other solutions to this problem: sledgehammer, etc
- ars 12y agoA bricked device still has the data on it. It's fake security. And you could allow secure erase while still prohibiting normal writes. The cells aren't actually gone or unusable after all, just unreliable. A secure erase would work fine on them.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoAnd, it would be extremely easy to implement, because you only have to assert erase on every page in the device, which can be done in parallel.
- raverbashing 12y ago"A bricked device still has the data on it. It's fake security" No, because they do this http://vxlabs.com/2012/12/22/ssds-with-usable-built-in-hardware-based-full-disk-encryption/ http://vxlabs.com/2012/12/22/ssds-with-usable-built-in-hardw... Erase the AES key -> data is gone
- twotwotwo 12y ago2.4 PB of writes to the 840 Pro is pretty nice.
- rjbwork 12y agoI bought a 1TB Samsung 840 Pro for my new rig in December. Glad to see my research paid off in making the best choice!
- acqq 12y agoApparently that 840 Pro from the article endured more than 2PB. However the new 1TB 850 Pro is declared to endure just 300 TB written: http://www.samsung.com/global/business/semiconductor/minisite/SSD/downloads/document/Samsung_SSD_850_PRO_Data_Sheet_rev_2_0.pdf http://www.samsung.com/global/business/semiconductor/minisit...
- notsony 12y agoThe 840 Pro came with a 5 year warranty, while the 850 Pro has a 10 year warranty. I wonder if the warranty still applies if you exceed the limit.
- acqq 12y agoNo, the warranty for 850 Pro is "10 years or the maximum TB written reached" (at least in EU).
- MertsA 12y agoThe 840 Pro that lasted more than 2 PBW was rated for 73TBW. >With twice the endurance of the previous model, the 850 PRO will keep working as long as you do. Samsung's V-NAND technology is built to handle 300 Terabytes Written (TBW)* which equates to a 40 GB daily read/write workload over a 10-year period. Plus, it comes with the industry's top-level ten-year limited warranty. * 840 PRO: 73 TBW < 850 PRO: 150 TBW 850 PRO 120/250 GB : 150 TBW, 500/1TB(1,024 GB) : 300 TBW
- acqq 12y agoThe drive has 400 MB/s on the interface. That means that it's possible to deliver 34 TB per day to the disk and the rated 300 TB are achieved in less than 9 days. But the scariest effect is the "write multiplication:" the possibility to deliver the small chunks of the data through the 400 MB/s interface which can result in much more data actually overwritten on the flash (as the atomic size of the writes on the flash is quite big). Of course an average consumer can't produce that. A lot of the data I write to any medium at home is never overwritten. But not every use is the use of an average consumer, knowing the actual limits is important.
- mrmondo 12y agoVery impressive - I've been following the story since the start with quite a vested interest - I'm currently building mixed tier SSD only SANs, one tier consisting of high end PCIe NVMe SSDs, the other consisting of Sandisk Extreme Pro III 'consumer - available' drives.
- ocdtrekkie 12y agoThe great experiment is finally over. Very proud to exclusively use 840 Pro SSDs in my towers.
- digi_owl 12y agoNot sure if this would be a problem, if one could easily check the status of a drive without having to grab specialized tools.
- helper 12y agoInspired by some of their earlier articles, we did a similar test in-house on an ssd model we were planning on deploying into production. The goal was to make sure we knew exactly what to look for when our ssds were on their last legs. We actually bought a smaller capacity version of the same model so the test wouldn't take as long. I feel a lot better about that production hardware now that I have seen first hand what SMART reports as the drive is running out of reallocation sectors.
- passive 12y agoThat title seriously misrepresents the findings. These drives lasted orders of magnitude longer than they were rated for. For 99% of people on the internet, you could write all your daily traffic to any one of these drives for the rest of your life (assuming it stayed constant).
- gtwy 12y agoDisappointed that the Crucial MX100 / MX200 wasn't included on this. We've been using Crucial exclusively for just over 5 years with customer laptops. We swap the hard drives out for Crucial SSDs when setting them up for the first time. In 5 years, with average use, we've only ever had a single failure... out of literally hundreds of laptops we setup per year.
- CaseFlatline 12y agoI vote for wierd al to sing the song at the end http://techreport.com/review/27909/the-ssd-endurance-experiment-theyre-all-dead/4 http://techreport.com/review/27909/the-ssd-endurance-experim...