3 ms·
There are few original thoughts ever. Plagiarism and the ownership of thoughts are so misplaced, particularly in modern society. Think of your writings as your
by donatj 12y ago
There are few original thoughts ever. Plagiarism and the ownership of thoughts are so misplaced, particularly in modern society. Think of your writings as your gift to society for its betterment and not something you've done for the advancement of your personal brand and the idea of owning a thought seems silly.
Having to rephrase something because someone already said it that way is an insane waste of time from a bygone era. Open source thought already.
- amelius 12y agoAlso, after having taught this class to 20 students for 5 years, I guess every possible angle of the subject has been studied, so the next one to write an essay on the subject is sure to be committing plagiarism :)
- dagw 12y agoPlagiarism is not copying what someone else said, it's copying what someone else said without attribution. As long as you attribute correctly there is no need to rephrase anything. To use your Open Source analogy, plagiarism is taking some GPL'd software, renaming it and selling it as software you claimed you wrote entirely yourself.
- weland 12y ago> Having to rephrase something because someone already said it that way is an insane waste of time from a bygone era. Which is precisely why you are not required to do it (and never were), as long as you properly quote and attribute it :).
- fnordfnordfnord 12y ago>Which is precisely why you are not required to do it Right or wrong (I know, it's wrong), this silly 'phrase it in your own words' idea is taught to many students as the way to avoid plagiarizing others' works.
- weland 12y agoIt's taught as the way to avoid plagiarism because, for students, the rate of "accidental" plagiarism is extremely high: they tend to unintentionally repeat an author's affirmation simply because it is so well formulated that it "sticks" to their mind. It also helps them avoid "newspaper clipping" articles, where they write a ten-page paper full of "X's view on the matter is that... whereas Y disagrees because...", which is considered a form of plagiarism.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y ago>It's taught as the way to avoid plagiarism because, for students, the rate of "accidental" plagiarism is extremely high Well it's wrong because it is teaching students to avoid detection, not to avoid plagiarizing. Which is it? Can you "properly quote and attribute" or not? Your post seems to be in conflict with what you said two posts ago.
- nraynaud 12y agoYeah, I agree, I read so much stuff, that sometimes I "have" ideas that are not mine (or sometimes, I remember an idea I read, but I can't find the source on google). Sometimes it's just that we have integrated some stuff in our brain, which would be a compliment to the author of the original text, but is actually a minefield. I don't really care because I'm in real life, but in an academic environment I would be trashed. I'm so glad that I'm not a student or academic in the US right now.
- jccalhoun 12y agoWriting is already open source. You just have to give attribution. You don't have to rephrase something. That's what quotes are for. The problem with plagiarism isn't really students not citing where a statistic comes from (which is a problem. I always tell students that no one ever got in trouble for citing too much...) but is when they take whole papers or paragraphs from someone else and present it as their own.
- chasing 12y agoStudents aren't necessarily supposed to have original thoughts -- but they're supposed to have their own thoughts. It's part of engaging with the material and learning.
- stdbrouw 12y ago> Having to rephrase something because someone already said it that way is an insane waste of time from a bygone era. Or, a great way to learn and internalize a concept rather than just regurgitating it.
- Millennium 12y agoIt is true that few students have thoughts that have not already occurred to others. This is not the important part of honest research. The important part is that the student actually HAVE these thoughts, and actually EXPRESS them, rather than just copy/pasting someone else's expression of the idea without ever thinking about it themselves. It is the process that matters, not the outcome. In other words, buckle down and do the damn work. Laziness is not a virtue when it comes to thinking.