3 ms·
Couple of things stood out: The DNA has been sequenced but the article reports that "The bacterial cells have densely packed spirals that are probably DNA". To
by pbhjpbhj 12y ago
Couple of things stood out:
The DNA has been sequenced but the article reports that "The bacterial cells have densely packed spirals that are probably DNA". To me it seems strange not to know the gross anatomy but to be able to sequence the DNA; I can see how it could happen.
Also "The images revealed dividing cells, indicating the bacteria were healthy and not starved to an abnormally small size." but the write up says they appear to need other bacteria to function properly - and suggests the pili are involved in that. If they can stay healthy and divide in an environment without other bacteria then what do they need the other bacteria for, entertainment??
These parts appear to be based on the asbtract viz. "Ultrastructural features potentially related to cell and genome size minimization include tightly packed spirals inferred to be DNA, few densely packed ribosomes and a variety of pili-like structures that might enable inter-organism interactions that compensate for biosynthetic capacities inferred to be missing from genomic data."
- bayesianhorse 12y agoMaybe they wanted to sound careful. I guess that densely packed spirals which take up a significant part of the miniscule volume would almost have to be the DNA, after all 1 Mbp need to have a certain volume, but I don't know the specifics and how bacteria tend to pack their DNA.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> To me it seems strange not to know the gross anatomy but to be able to sequence the DNA; I can see how it could happen. As far as I understand, DNA sequencing is about breaking target into pieces and using clever tricks to fish out nucleotydes and determine their order. It seems to me that you don't need to know where and how DNA is exactly located to be able to brute-force its sequence.
- pbhjpbhj 12y agoThat's what I meant by "I can see how it could happen". I guess I imagined that they would have confirmed the major features with further microscopy prior to publication; perhaps that's harder than I imagined but once you've seen STM images of atoms it seems like recognising DNA in a sample should be easy.
- kyberias 12y ago> To me it seems strange not to know the gross anatomy but to be able to sequence the DNA; I can see how it could happen. They're just looking at an image of the cell and seeing these unknown structures. They cannot be sure what it is. It is impossible to determine whether its DNA or not from the image. Quite independent of this, we can take a sample containing the organism and sequence its DNA without knowing where it originated from in the source cell. DNA is purified for sequencing from other cell structures by chemical and mechanical methods.
- chriswarbo 12y ago> "The images revealed dividing cells, indicating the bacteria were healthy and not starved to an abnormally small size." but the write up says they appear to need other bacteria to function properly - and suggests the pili are involved in that. If they can stay healthy and divide in an environment without other bacteria then what do they need the other bacteria for, entertainment?? I require food and water to function properly, but I'm not currently eating or drinking. These microbes were isolated using filteration, so presumably they were surrounded by other bacteria to leech from, right up to the point they were isolated.
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago"the images revealed dividing cells" - with the present participle "dividing" - to me suggested isolation prior to division; hence the question. The solution you proffer is the expected situation but then the images would be prior to isolation or they'd show _divided_ cells (which is entirely uninteresting and tautological I think).