4 ms·
"Academia" is not shorthand for "Humanities Academia." Maybe this author's argument is true for the humanities, but I know some academic researchers in science
by scott_s 17y ago
"Academia" is not shorthand for "Humanities Academia." Maybe this author's argument is true for the humanities, but I know some academic researchers in science and engineering can move into industry. That is, their skills are valued by people outside of their academic circle.
- amichail 17y agoBut maybe humanities academia has the benefit of giving you more freedom as your research is not evaluated as objectively as in science and engineering?
- scott_s 17y agoMaybe. That makes it less interesting to me, but I wasn't trying to make a value judgment. Although the rest of the article is worth reading. I don't think the author confuses humanities academia with science or engineering academia - I think the submitter did. I think the assumption with his essay is that what he says applies to the humanities, unless explicitly stated otherwise.
- msluyter 17y agoWell, the author's credentials and the preface do suggest a focus on the humanities.
- scott_s 17y agoI agree, the confusion is with the submitted title.
- RyanMcGreal 17y ago> "Academia" is not shorthand for "Humanities Academia." Good point. Unfortunately, I was squeezed by the 80 character title constraint. :)
- bbgm 17y agoIn fact, in the life sciences, the back and forth is getting more common, and will increasingly get so as the models for research, esp in large scale biology change. On the CS side there are any number of examples as well.
- davi 17y agoAs a grad student in neuroscience I think there's some validity to the argument, though. Academic research in my field can be tightly circumscribed by 5 year grant cycles, competition for tenure track positions, etc. I wrote about numerology of this here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=470181 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=470181 I believe this numerology may be a source of generalized conservatism and incrementalism in academic science. And academic science has a different set of objectives than industry, and perhaps also a larger long-term payoff, when done well.
- caffeine 17y ago1/73 of the newly minted Ph.D.s should reasonably go on to start a lab of their own (from your linked comment) Playing devil's advocate: Isn't this winnowing process necessary to identify those capable of starting a successful lab? Research worth doing is, after all, extremely difficult - perhaps the only way to identify such individuals is to train them up to the cutting edge, then let them attempt to do independent research (get a PhD) and see who fails (does a useless PhD). (My own view is somewhere in the middle, but I'm interested in your opinion on this).
- davi 17y agoIsn't this winnowing process necessary to identify those capable of starting a successful lab? Sure, some winnowing is necessary -- but do you (or the devil you're advocating for) think only one out of every 73 newly minted Ph.D.s is capable of starting a successful lab? On the other side, who is the 1 out of 73 who gets the tenure-track job in research? It seems quite often departments make decisions based on number of papers the candidate has, and the brand of journals those papers appear in. Optimizing for these parameters can, I think, be very different from optimizing for deep and/or transformative science. The best postdocs can optimize for all parameters at once, but this is a very difficult row to hoe, and usually requires a bunch of luck to succeed. I'm not saying that the system is broken. Good science is getting done, by good people. I'm saying that from my (admittedly limited) vantage point, the system is unnecessarily adverse to certain kinds of science, to the possible detriment of human knowledge and the public good. (Whew! That was a fun soapbox to get on, thanks for the invitation...)
- buugs 17y agoIt also works in the reverse order as my professors who fill in for those who take sabbaticals are those that work at the national labs near here as well as the engineering companies. Though these professors are a bit harder to reach than full-time professors.
- joe_the_user 17y agoI don't see how the article applies only to the humanities. It seems to be about supply-and-demand and self-regulating professional bodies. I think a lot of the considerations of the article apply to, for example, mathematics. Science and Engineering is the area with the most immediate application but even here, there's quite divide between theoretical CS and what's practiced in the field.
- timwiseman 17y agoCould you elaborate? You bring up an interesting possibility, but it is not intuitively obvious. In mathematics it is relatively easy to break into the field with the backing of an institution (I mean easy relative to doing the same thing in say English or History, not in an absolute sense). In fact, there is a long tradition of amateurs making some significant contributions, with Fermat being the crown (if now somewhat dated example.) Also, one of his major complaints is how long it takes to get the PHD. At least at UNLV (where I am currently seeking a master's in Math) most of my peers that are seeking their PHD expect to get it within 6 years after starting their graduate studies. While this is still longer than a usual JD or MD program, it is at the very low end of the 6-9 year spectrum that was discussed in the article. And while there is certainly a divide between theoretical mathematicians and their applied counterparts (or scientists who us mathematics) it is almost solely in choice of topic, not about disagreement over real facts, which you can see in some topics in the humanities between the professors and the general public.
- scott_s 17y agoFor researchers who can go into industry, the supply-and-demand dynamics are different.