4 ms·
McDonald's did get better, and did get menu focus. The problem is that all those franchises aren't part of the McDonald's franchise system and are called In-n-O
by bane 12y ago
McDonald's did get better, and did get menu focus. The problem is that all those franchises aren't part of the McDonald's franchise system and are called In-n-Out Burger.
Except for the prices, the menu at an In-n-out [1] looks alarming like the original McDonald's menu [2]
1 - https://farm6.staticflickr.com/5349/7048945907_6890107167_o.jpg https://farm6.staticflickr.com/5349/7048945907_6890107167_o....
2 - http://s.hswstatic.com/gif/5-failed-mcdonalds-menu-items-6.jpg http://s.hswstatic.com/gif/5-failed-mcdonalds-menu-items-6.j...
when McD's kept their focus, they grew. Here's their menu from 1972, some 30+ years after they started http://cdn.iwastesomuchtime.com/5112014023433.jpg http://cdn.iwastesomuchtime.com/5112014023433.jpg
I can't even find where the beverages are on a modern McD's menu these days.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/dougalug2005/3176399858/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/dougalug2005/3176399858/
In-N-Out's branding [3] even looks like McDonald's 1960s logo [4]
3 - http://typophile.com/files/In-N-Out_Burger_6481.png http://typophile.com/files/In-N-Out_Burger_6481.png
4 - http://goodlogo.com/images/logos/mcdonalds_logo_2465.gif http://goodlogo.com/images/logos/mcdonalds_logo_2465.gif
Importantly, the food, when served [5], carries branding and colors through to the product, which looks pretty much like what the marketing pictures of the food looks like [6]
5 - http://soupbelly.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/DSC_0324_thumb.jpg http://soupbelly.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/DSC_0324_thu...
6 - http://www.wpromote.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/10/in-n-out-burger-fries-shake.png http://www.wpromote.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/10/in-n...
Adding in a relentless focus on quality and most of the In-N-Out burgers I've been to have been packed with customers.
McDonald's is trapped in serving a market that grew up with their product. Their burgers are more or less the same as the ones I remember when I grew up. They keep adding halo items to the menu, but the burgers haven't kept up with the times and growing competitive market. They're also trying to keep prices artificially low, you can still walk in and get a burger for around $1.
Mcdonald's needs to figure out how to adopt and mimic the In-N-Out model as much as In-N-Out was inspired by the McDonald's model.
- joezydeco 12y agoI can't even find where the beverages are on a modern McD's menu these days. You could argue that this is a "dark pattern", by hiding the other beverage choices in the corners of the menu along with other things like the dollar menu (note in image 2C that there isn't even a "$1.00" next to the Dollar Menu items to let you see that as a pricing choice). The larger value menu items are where they want your eye to focus, although I suspect that's also for ordering speed as much as product flow.
- jessaustin 12y agoI can't even find where the beverages are on a modern McD's menu these days. I find most fast-food menus terrible, often for this reason. Mostly I just keep in mind what I've ordered in the past, plus whatever I might have heard or seen advertised in the last two days, and choose one or two items from that set. I think the reason is that most fast food menus have little integrity. They try to be all things. In-n-Out is an exception to this, as is Chipotle. If I'm here, it must be because I want one of these honking giant burritos. I don't need to look at a menu to decide between chicken and carnitas in that burrito. If I wanted a coffee with lots of sugar and dairy added, I would go to a place that specialized in such concoctions, thanks! A fast food restaurant with integrity is legible to the diner; there won't be any surprises after one has eaten there a couple of times. The API is simple. McDonald's OTOH has a complicated API.
- burgreblast 12y ago> If I wanted a coffee with lots of sugar and dairy added, > I would go to a place that specialized in such > concoctions, thanks! I don't necessarily disagree, but would you kill a $2B/yr product? In 2010, McDonald’s CEO Don Thompson said coffee accounted for more than 6% of its U.S. sales. That share may since have increased, but even 6% of the chain’s 2013 domestic sales would be $2.15 billion.
- jessaustin 12y agoHaha you're right of course. I'm not saying the illegible garish mess that McD's has for a menu is the wrong thing for them, but I do see why more footprint-growth-focused chains don't have that.
- err4nt 12y agoYou mean you dont like reading menu screens that abruptly replace the items on the screen with a video promotional half-way through deciding what to order?
- lucaspiller 12y agoWhere do you find a menu? Most stores I've been too (mainly Europe) just have screens above the cashiers with a few key meals and that's it. Some have a menu of all items stuck to the wall, about the size of an A4 sheet on one side of the cashiers.
- maxerickson 12y agoIs there any reason to believe that any of this matters to McDonald's? Like, how do their head to head locations compare on revenue and profitability? If In and Out isn't consistently beating McDonald's on measures like that, all you've done is explain that you find In and Out more appealing.
- bane 12y agoNo idea. In-n-Out is a private company and don't report official figures.
- maxerickson 12y agoThat doesn't jibe very well with Mcdonald's needs to figure out how to adopt and mimic the In-N-Out model as much as In-N-Out was inspired by the McDonald's model.