10 ms·
Apple gold
- acqq 12y agoReading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metal_matrix_composite http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metal_matrix_composite "MMCs are nearly always more expensive than the more conventional materials they are replacing. As a result, they are found where improved properties and performance can justify the added cost. Today these applications are found most often in aircraft components, space systems and high-end or "boutique" sports equipment." So it seems the goal was really first to have the more durable material.
- bpicolo 12y agoNot necessarily. "Nearly" is a key word. They're saving gold, which is a pretty expensive metal...
- achamayou 12y agoThey're saving on the rest of the yellow gold alloy also, which is usually silver and copper, and not that cheap either.
- acqq 12y ago...while paying more to produce the composite vs. what they'd pay to make an alloy. Still, I wanted to see what numbers are: http://www.ebay.com/gds/How-Much-Gold-Is-Really-In-A-Rolex-Watch-/10000000001632748/g.html http://www.ebay.com/gds/How-Much-Gold-Is-Really-In-A-Rolex-W... We see that the golden Rolex has most of the weight in the bracelet and I haven't seen the "full gold" bracelet on the Apple site. The body of the golden Rolex apparently has cca 2 thirds of the golden ounce of pure gold, which is at the moment not more than 700 USD. If Apple can save a half of it, it's around 350 USD saved, not counting the higher expense to make a composite which would reduce the saving. Now if we accept Gruber's guess that the most expensive watch will be priced in the order of 10 K USD, compared to all the profits per unit, it doesn't seem to be a big percent. But if we factor the expected number of the items sold it's not something that should be ignored. Still I can imagine that they could have simply made a body with the steel "reinforcement" inside and nobody would blink. I sure expect somebody will properly tear down the Apple Watch Edition to measure the exact amount of gold. If Archimedes managed to do this 2 millenniums ago, why wouldn't we?
- kudu 12y agoGruber's guess is still just a guess. I'm inclined to side with Marco Arment, who thinks Apple is going for more of a $5k-ish price.
- kenrikm 12y agoI have the feeling that the gold watch portion will actually be significantly smaller portion of the 5K price (if it is 5k) Something like $999 - $1999. The rest of the price will come in the bands at 2 - 4K each.
- delsalk 12y agoThey still have to sell the watch itself with their margins however. There's nothing stopping you from buying an aftermarket strap, and if they require you to purchase a strap with the watch -- well then it doesn't matter how they split the price up.
- shalmanese 12y agoIf the bands are forward compatible with future generations, then it becomes more attractive to spend more on the band vs the face.
- sp332 12y agoArchimedes' trick only works if you know the ratio of materials inside ahead of time. Otherwise it could be e.g. some gold + some copper and have the same density as silver.
- Dylan16807 12y agoIf you know it's 18k then all you have to do is weigh it to know how much gold there is. Then measuring volume can tell you the density of the rest of the alloy.
- 12y ago
- samuelarchibald 12y agoYeah it would be very bad for apple if their top-tier iWatch is easily scratched or damaged.
- alsdifu3 12y ago"Nearly always" adds a lot of ambiguity. Perhaps this is one of the cases in which it is cheaper.
- kudu 12y ago> nearly always Maybe not if you're Apple. It could cost them less to go through a complex yet highly optimized manufacturing process than to buy more gold.
- philwelch 12y agoJust what I was thinking. Apple operates at such a ludicrous scale, they can do things that are unimaginable for other manufacturers.
- lvs 12y agoProbably people should be talking about the reduced density of the material, which is really significant. A men's-size 18k gold watch is heavy... too heavy for many people who don't have enormous meat appendages.
- barrkel 12y agoIn something like a watch, if it looks like gold and has some bulk without corresponding heft, it feels fake. I have a fairly cheap mechanical watch combined with a Milanese mesh strap. I ordered a bunch of different mesh straps, looking for the right material and closeness of weave - it's hard to tell from online photos. The biggest difference between the one I chose and the ones I discarded was weight. The discarded ones felt like they were made of plastic.
- acqq 12y agoConsidering everything that has to be inside, I can't imagine that any Apple Watch of this generation won't feel heavy.
- marincounty 12y agoTry on a 18k Omega Constellation watch. The gold warms up to skin temperature so quick it feels like a lambs skin band. As to weight--it's not heavy. Acually, I need to look down to make sure it's still there. As a Horologist, it's by far my favorite watch. It's a simple watch, but it just feels right. My only concern is thiefs notice it more than high end stainless/alloy watches.
- jdietrich 12y ago>MMCs are nearly always more expensive than the more conventional materials they are replacing. Most MMCs replace base metals that cost a few dollars per kilogram. Gold currently trades at ~$37,000/kg. Even comparing against a relatively costly base metal like tungsten, gold is three orders of magnitude more expensive. Spending $100 or even $1000 per kg to halve the density of a given volume of material vastly increases the cost of aluminium, but greatly reduces the cost of gold. I have absolutely no doubt that Apple could significantly reduce their materials cost by using this process.
- snowwrestler 12y agoOne of the underappreciated competitive advantages of Apple is their ability to scale complex industrial processes for consumer products. Going back to the first iMac, their industrial design work has included developing or scaling new manufacturing techniques. Examples include co-molding white and clear plastic to get the liquid look of the iPod, and of course machining laptop bodies out of aluminum blocks. If there is a company who could make this work at consumer scale, it's Apple.
- comex 12y agoOf course, an 18k gold watch, with the same size as Apple's, that contains more gold is heavier by definition. I wouldn't be surprised if that factored into the decision.
- threeseed 12y agoSurprised people aren't mentioning this more. Weight is critical to the iWatch. Look at the advertising they have done to date. It has all been in women and men's fashion magazines (with a particular focus on Asia) whose readers will generally have slighter frames. The iWatch is quite different from other watch makers in this respect since they are targeting both men/women with the widest age range probably ever seen in the industry. This means the same watch needs to be capable of being worn on a 13 y/o Chinese girl as well as a 35 y/o 6 foot American guy.
- mkr-hn 12y ago> It has all been in women and men's fashion magazines (with a particular focus on Asia) whose readers will generally have slighter frames. This is something I've never heard. What is this based on?
- DiabloD3 12y agoI think you mean Apple black. I'll let myself out.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gfosco 12y agoThis fits right in line with my prediction [1] that we're all overestimating the amount of gold in the enclosure and that it's going to be cheaper than the high estimates. I'm still thinking $2,499 max. Can't wait to see what comes out on Monday. [1]: https://twitter.com/newFosco/status/569407140151959555 https://twitter.com/newFosco/status/569407140151959555
- raldi 12y agoHow many grams of pure gold do you think will go into each watch?
- gfosco 12y agoNot sure... I saw estimates that it would contain ~$1,500 worth of gold, and I'm speculating it's closer to ~$1,000.
- raldi 12y agoYou're not really giving me much reason to put any stock in your prediction. Your complete lack of detail or explanation makes it sound like you're pulling a number out of the air. The people making much higher estimates of the gold watch's price (most notably, John Gruber) are backing their estimates with analysis and citations.
- mrkelley 12y agoIt appears that Apple is making gold better - amazing. What is the desirability of gold? It is the essence of the metal or the appearance? If apple is able to improve the essence of the metal and improve the longevity of the appearance - I say it's a win.
- mod 12y agoI agree. Frankly I don't care if it's gold or not (or, since I don't wear gold jewelry, I don't care if it's silver/titanium/stainless or not). As long as it looks nice and performs well.
- mathgeek 12y agoWhile there are certainly some valuable properties to gold, one has to wonder how much of the value we place on gold is extrinsic.
- jrockway 12y agoGold is important to industry because it's conductive and doesn't oxidize. It's used for plating PCB pads and metal-to-metal contacts. Of course, you only need a tiny, tiny amount relative to a watch to plate a PCB or connector.
- mathgeek 12y agoYep. That's what I meant by the valuable properties.
- jrockway 12y agoTheoretically this is why it has value for hoarders; it's useful. Of course, if suddenly gold was unfashionable and was only needed for plating connectors, I doubt you'd get $1200 an ounce. But it will probably stay fashionable because people like the color. (As someone who regularly uses public transportation, I personally won't be getting a gold watch. But I see the appeal.)
- 12y ago
- higherpurpose 12y agoApple Watch Less-Gold.
- mstolpm 12y agoThe biggest concern for Apple would be the processing part. The new "Apple Gold" could be favorable not only for cost efficiency but especially for machinability. Classic gold watches need a lot of manual work, as far as I know. The new material could help in mass manufacturing the Apple Watch.
- auxym 12y agoI don't know anything about watch-making, but gold is pretty soft and likely easy to machine. Ceramic-based composites, on the other hand... I'd be surprised if this were the case.
- tim333 12y agoYeah I guess you'd get a rough surface and then probably electroplate more gold on top.
- bri3d 12y agoThere's no reason classic gold watches couldn't be machined by CNC - the hand finishing / handmaking process is just part of the cachet of high end watches.
- myth_buster 12y agoFrom an investment POV there is no change but there is tremendous implication to the bling market.
- bch 12y agoI wonder if Specialized lawyers are working overtime... (Specialized introduced a metal matrix bicycle in 1990, and they love to sue [1]). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specialized_Bicycle_Components#Litigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Specialized_Bicycle_Components... EDIT: though, apparently most (all?) of their suits are trademark related, however specious.
- thanatosmin 12y agoThat would have to be an aluminum metal matrix material if related to cycling, which is very different.
- joosters 12y agoOh no! The evil corrupt patent system is stopping me from owning a bicycle made of gold...
- BinaryIdiot 12y ago> Oh no! The evil corrupt patent system is stopping me from owning a bicycle made of gold... Damn. Time to delete the thing from my cart. Sigh, it was prime too.
- matt4077 12y agoA patent from 1990 would have expired by now.
- vbezhenar 12y agoIt's the color and reflections that matters. Not the weight. But competitors will surely make a joke of it.
- alinenache 12y agounnatural desire for luxuries http://waltherpragerandphilosophy1.blogspot.ro/2014/04/to-live-as-sign-for-other-people.html http://waltherpragerandphilosophy1.blogspot.ro/2014/04/to-li...
- Evolved 12y agoFun fact: the fact that boron carbide is used and happens to also increase hardness of the watch band is interesting as boron carbide is the most common type of base ingredient in armor plates for soldiers due to its hardness which results in the ability to fragment rounds before they can achieve any significant penetration. [1] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_Arms_Protective_Insert http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_Arms_Protective_Insert
- BjoernKW 12y agoWhile the process itself seems quite sophisticated the result isn't all that surprising: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archimedes%27_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archimedes%27_principle
- giaour 12y agoDoes this mean that when iWatch 2 comes out I won't even be able to sell my original iWatch for gold scrap? (I.e., can this special Apple Gold(TM) be melted and reused like regular gold, or does it just go in a landfill after two years like every other apple product?)
- snowwrestler 12y agoCeramics typically have a higher melting point than metals. Perhaps you could just heat to gold's melting temp and then separate out the ceramic particles--it should help that they are so much less dense than gold.
- delsalk 12y agoYou would probably get a better deal selling the watch as a watch itself than melting it down for its raw gold. Apple has let you bring you old devices in to be recycled in the past however; Maybe they could extend this to buy back old watches? People have envisioned some upgrade program, though I'm doubtful Apple would be too concerned with melting down old watches for their gold.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- giaour 12y agoIf the tech is outdated enough that the OS no longer receives updates, then it's value will be similar to that of a first generation iPad. I'm sure Apple could buy back, clean, and reuse bands from obsolete watches, but they might be the only buyers if iGold is too difficult for a regular jeweler to work with. It will be interesting to see if one of Apple's first moves on entering the jewelry market is to hamstring the independent secondary market.
- alayne 12y agoDon't send your iDevice to a landfill. Apple stores accept any of their products for recycling at no charge and you can also mail them in.
- gcb0 12y agoit karat is by volume, and it has less gold per volume, isn't advertising as 18 plain false?
- hyperion2010 12y agoKarat is by mass not volume.
- nroose 12y agoNot sure why anyone would think it was a bad thing to make a watch lighter and stronger.
- freegroup 12y agoFor table 1 of the patent, you should just ignore the Δ values in the last column and use values from the previous column instead. All samples are 18k gold, so the reduction in gold mass should be (and actually is) exactly the same as the reduction in total mass. Looking at their data, for some reason there is a reduction factor of 1.25 applied to all values, except for sample F which has no reduction. My suspicion is that someone wanted to correct for the fact that 25% of 18k gold is not gold, but even then they would have needed a factor of 1/0.75 = 1.333...
- ctdonath 12y agoOne meme making the rounds now is that Apple will be consuming a significant fraction of world gold production for making the upper end Watches. Those calculations will now have to be recomputed, considering less will be used per watch as previously anticipated.
- gcr 12y agoHow many people will purchase one? I will be surprised if more than 1,000 are ever sold. I will be shocked if more than 10k are sold. A more delicious question is: how many watches would have to be produced to create a significant impact?
- mark-r 12y agoLower cost, higher hardness. Seems like a win-win. Makes you wonder why nobody ever thought of it before?
- m_mueller 12y agoAs a Swiss it makes me wonder even more. It looks like the Swiss watchmakers are superb when it comes to mechanical engineering, but they're not much into material engineering and electronics. Japanese watchmakers are good with the electronics and materials, not so much with design and marketing. Apple is really in prime position to release a smart watch that people actually want.
- culturestate 12y agoPeople have thought of it before. Notably, Hublot[1] has a material that they call "Magic Gold" which is just this sort of gold/ceramic composite. 1. http://www.watchtime.com/wristwatch-industry-news/technology/hard-timers-hublot-conjured-magic-gold/ http://www.watchtime.com/wristwatch-industry-news/technology...
- besserwisser 12y agoThis should be higher! The patent, filed in 2014, claims exactly what's described in this article written in 2012. That's incredibly blatant.
- aflam 12y agoHublot worked on special flavors of 18k gold with EPFL University and had some press a couple years ago : http://news.discovery.com/tech/unscratchable-gold-111227.htm http://news.discovery.com/tech/unscratchable-gold-111227.htm In French : http://www.lacotedesmontres.com/actu/Hublot-presente-Magic-Gold-un-nouvel-alliage-pour-l-horlogerie-la-bijouterie-et-la-joaillerie-developpe-en-collaboration-avec-l-EPFL-No_8870.htm http://www.lacotedesmontres.com/actu/Hublot-presente-Magic-G...
- Kiro 12y agoWhy would he get blowback for that tweet? How is it inartfully put?
- cowsandmilk 12y agobecause the majority of the internet apparently does not actually understand the relationship between density, mass, and volume. Seriously, just click on the tweet and look at the ignorant responses.
- MRSallee 12y agoWho buys gold by volume? This seems like a complete non-issue. "18 karat" isn't a measure of gold by volume, nobody buys gold by volume, and this "Apple gold" has the same amount of gold by weight as any other 18k gold.
- eli 12y agoArguably the person looking for a "solid gold watch" is buying by volume.
- abbot2 12y agoEveryone. You are not buying "5 grams of golden earrings", you are buying earrings which fit you, hence the volume.
- gutnor 12y agoNot really - unless you are wealthy enough to ignore the price when buying jewellery, you are buying by weight. Except for the high end jewellery, the price has a direct relationship with weight in gold, not the volume of the piece.
- mdbook 12y agoI heard that 18k gold must be 75% solid gold by weight. Anyway I'm not a metallurgist, but it seems to me that if Apple watch is successful the gold watch will sell in large numbers. If that happens it seems to me it might spawn a cottage industry of gold refining to float off the ceramic and such and reclaim the gold. They aren't the first to make a hybrid like this, but they'll be the first to do it in large quantities. Also, as others have pointed out the idea that you have to upgrade Apple products when new models come out is bunk. I use my iphones for at least 4 years. My current iphone is 4 years old and I will probably keep it for 5 years. I don't see why (if successful) the Apple watch after getting past the teething phase by the 2nd or 3rd revision you won't be able to keep it as long as an iphone. People don't need to upgrade their iphones every year. Those that do are doing it purely out of their own desire. Apple devices last in a useful fashion quite a long time. The fact that they design them to do that inspires confidence in their institutional integrity. The fact that people who must have the latest thing don't acknowledge that they're usually upgrading purely for their own felt reasons–not that I'm opposed to it in any way–and not because anyone is forcing them to is just a way to hide the true reasons they upgrade from themselves. They made me do it!
- mdbook 12y agoI heard that 18k gold must be 75% solid gold by weight. Anyway I'm not a metallurgist, but it seems to me that if Apple watch is successful the gold watch will sell in large numbers. If that happens it seems to me it might spawn a cottage industry of gold refining to float off the ceramic and such and reclaim the gold. They aren't the first to make a hybrid like this, but they'll be the first to do it in large quantities. Also, as others have pointed out the idea that you have to upgrade Apple products when new models come out is bunk. I use my iphones for at least 4 years. My current iphone is 4 years old and I will probably keep it for 5 years. I don't see why (if successful) the Apple watch after getting past the teething phase by the 2nd or 3rd revision you won't be able to keep it as long as an iphone. People don't need to upgrade their iphones every year. Those that do are doing it purely out of their own desire. Apple devices last in a useful fashion quite a long time. The fact that they design them to do that inspires confidence in their institutional integrity. The fact that people who must have the latest thing don't acknowledge that they're usually upgrading purely for their own felt reasons–not that I'm opposed to it in any way–and not because anyone is forcing them to is just a way to hide the true reasons they upgrade from themselves. They made me do it!