4 ms·
I really enjoy these posts, and would be a happy Backblaze customer if they didn't have this (unpublicized) policy of deleting external hard-drive backups after
by ricardobeat 12y ago
I really enjoy these posts, and would be a happy Backblaze customer if they didn't have this (unpublicized) policy of deleting external hard-drive backups after 30 days:
Backblaze works best if you leave the external hard drive attached to
your computer all the time. [...] If the drive is detached for more
than 30 days, Backblaze interprets this as data that has been
permanently deleted and securely deletes the copy from the
Backblaze datacenter.
This probably reduces the total amount of storage used, making the $5/month economically viable. I'd happily pay more if it weren't for this though, currently paying ~$12/month for Bitcasa.
- atYevP 12y agoYev from Backblaze here -> we do have that on our website (https://www.backblaze.com/cloud-backup.html https://www.backblaze.com/cloud-backup.html and https://www.backblaze.com/remote-backup-everything.html https://www.backblaze.com/remote-backup-everything.html) and in some help articles but I hear you. It's a topic that comes up, but when we've done the calculations in the past, keeping a copy forever as an archive raises our costs to the point where we'd have to raise our prices and we're not too keen on that! We have notification emails so that we let you know ahead of time before data is removed though, so it's rarely become an issue in terms of "accidental deletions".
- carterf 12y agoDamn, I didn't know that either. Been a customer for years and wish I had seen that earlier. I've also had many lapses in time. As long as I'm paying why would you ever delete my data?
- atYevP 12y agoYou should be getting alerts whenever you're nearing a time lapse (up to two weeks ahead of one) so we do try to warn you when your nearing the 30 day timer (if not please contact support - seriously). The reason we have a 30 day timer is that we use the reclaimed space, if we were to infinitely house a copy of every file that was uploaded to us, it would dramatically raise our costs, and at $5/month for an unlimited product our margins are very thin as it is. Most companies that do keep data "forever" augment that cost by having either tiered pricing, or "per GB" pricing so that they can continue covering the cost of the space for as long as that file exists. Since we're unlimited and inexpensive for the service, we don't have that elasticity. That's not to say we haven't thought about enacting an additional fee for that type of service, but we haven't quite figured out a good way of doing it. But we're constantly thinking of ways to better the product, and know this is one that people do feel strongly about!
- free652 12y agoYou don't have it here -> https://www.backblaze.com/cloud-backup.html https://www.backblaze.com/cloud-backup.html. There is no mention of 30 days. I am so what pissed about since I bought the service just to backup my external drive.
- DenisM 12y agoSo if I go on a 4-week vacation, I will return to an empty account? Uh oh. That should be printed in bold red letters everywhere. It's the opposite to peace of mind.
- atYevP 12y agoNo, if your computer is offline, we keep data for 6 months, this is primarily for externals that are plugged in and out.
- ricardobeat 12y agoHi Yev. It is indeed on the website, but only in the second link you mentioned. I only found out after signing up for the service last year, and then decided to cancel. I wanted to backup photo collections that I might only access once a year - not very keen on having to do a maintenance scanning session once a month. Maybe you could come up with a separate plan, with limited storage, that solves this use? In any case, thanks for taking the time to reply.
- atYevP 12y agoYea, there are lots of ways to address it, and we talk about it every now and again though haven't come up with an elegant solution yet! One the first link it states that deleted files will be removed after 30 days. A removed hard drive acts the same as a deleted file, since it's no longer on your computer. I'll chat with our team and see if we can make it clearer.
- ejdyksen 12y ago+1 This is a deal-breaker for me. I have limited SSD space on my MBP, so my Lightroom catalog is on an external hard drive. I can easily go 30 days between plugging it in. That drive contains, by a very wide margin, my most important and least replaceable files.
- gry 12y agoWhat is your backup solution?
- ripdog 12y agoI'm not the person you replied to, but I use crashplan specifically because they offer utterly unlimited backup for the same price. Deleted files and unlimited file revisions are kept forever. I have no idea how they do it, but they've been around for a fair while.
- ejdyksen 12y agoI've been a CrashPlan customer for about 7 years.
- nonissue 12y agoIt actually makes sense. If you think about it, if every external that anyone ever plugged in was backed up and then never seen again, that could be sooo much data. What if that drive was used, wiped, renamed and then used again? You potentially have the same drive on BB twice. A way to alleviate the issue would be to charge a small fee per drive or per account for persistent external back ups. If it was 1-2$ a month extra for the peace of mind that a drive would always be backed up, I'd gladly pay it. At the end of the day, you have a choice as a consumer and you went with bitcasa. I'm happy paying $5/m for unlimited backup for my main computer. All said and done it's an amazing deal, even when you consider the external drive issue.
- matthewmacleod 12y agoI'm a Backblaze user, and think this is a pretty reasonable policy — Backblaze is a backup system with a 30-day history, and not an archival or "unlimited online storage" system. In addition, that policy seems to be pretty obvious. I definitely knew about it before I signed up, I'm sure it's signposted in the app itself, and I receive email notifications about a drive that's not plugged in. All-in-all, seems pretty reasonable.
- Veratyr 12y agoI know you might not care about the security and you're only using them for the cheap storage but just keep in mind that Bitcasa aren't as secure as they claim they are as they're able to provide your data to third parties via both their web interface and their API, which means that they possess all decryption keys. i.e. the second section of the following quote from their 'Personal' page is false: "Bitcasa keeps all of your files secure by applying client-side, AES-256 block-level encryption before they are even uploaded to your Personal Drive. Only you have access to your content. Not even Bitcasa employees can access or determine what files are in any given user’s account." I was a customer of theirs when they first launched beta but ever since they've been screwing with their consumer customers with seemingly little thought to the consequences and their marketing copy is dangerously deceptive. I've since moved to SpiderOak, who are quite transparent about their security and have updated their pricing to be more competitive.