3 ms·
Very good post. Thank you for sharing it. I've been interviewing applicants quite a bit lately, so have been thinking about these issues. Two questions for you
by rdtsc 12y ago
Very good post. Thank you for sharing it. I've been interviewing applicants quite a bit lately, so have been thinking about these issues.
Two questions for you.
What is your experience hiring fresh college grads? Is the process different? Since one of goals of the process seems to not arbitrarily adjust it for every candidate, but rather stay consistent, do you think it makes sense to adjust it for someone who just graduated. They might have been learning computer science type stuff, data structures, did a few group projects and have certainly been practicing the typical interview puzzles, fizbuzz and O(n) times of the all data structures.
How do you account (or do you account at all) for culture fit. That is a fuzzy and slightly dangerous area. Is there a score in that regard? There are some people who are brilliant but they do not work well in a team, or rather would not well in one particular team. This is course full of danger as "culture" fit often becomes an opaque discriminator for racial, sexual and other stereotypes. "He's just not a good culture fit" is such an overload euphemisms that I feel kind of sleazy just saying.
- tptacek 12y agoEveryone has exactly the same process, with the exception of interns. Interns have an abbreviated interview (shorthand: we switch from assessing aptitude to assessing enthusiasm), and any time one came back looking for a full time job, they got fast-tracked. I'm not saying that was the best policy (it did keep us from collecting some extra data), but by the end of an internship you had a really good idea that you wanted to work with someone. The lede I buried in this post is that we hired more-or-less resume-blind. I had final call on every hire and went through some effort not to look at resumes. On our first-calls, I'd ask some questions that would give me background hints about candidates, but that was primarily to tune my spiel (I didn't want to explain blind SQL injection to someone who'd spent 3 years as a pentester already, for instance). If I had it to do over again at Matasano, I'd have done it formally resume-blind. Only Dina would have had access to resumes, and interviewers would be forbidden to ask resume questions. The process would have worked better if resumes were firewalled out completely. There was no culture fit score; in fact, if you gave subjective feedback ("passion", "confidence", "work ethic") your feedback was likely to be discounted. We were proud of the culture diversity we managed to scrounge out of our candidate pool; to have team members with kids who needed to keep strict hours, and team members who'd roll in at 11 and still be there at 8 working on a pet problem. We had drinkers and non drinkers, college students and people with 15+ years of dev experience. You could get booted from the process for being overtly an asshole (I, for instance, might not get hired), but that happened very rarely and with crystalline clarity.
- rdtsc 12y agoThank you for taking the time to answer my questions.
- enraged_camel 12y agoIt's interesting that you make an effort to not read resumes. Do you explain that to people you interview during the first call? The reason I ask is that, if a hiring manager asked me things that are already written on my resume (e.g. what did you study in college?), I would definitely be annoyed, as my default expectation is that they should read the resume before the interview. Don't get me wrong, I understand and agree with your reasoning. I'm just curious how transparent it is to the other side.
- tptacek 12y agoWe weren't super transparent about it, but we tried really hard in a lot of other ways to take hiring seriously as a customer service problem, so maybe we came out ahead anyways.
- enraged_camel 12y agoThank you for the response Thomas. That makes a lot of sense.
- kasey_junk 12y agoI've been arguing for a resume blind hiring practice for years and one of the kickers is that you also need a resume question blind approach. So really "what did you study in college?" needs to come off the list of things you ask (at least as part of the filter).