8 ms·
The TSA's FAST Personality Screening Program Violates the Fourth Amendment [pdf]
- hijiri 12y agoWe are living in the cyberpunk future
- dang 12y agoUrl changed from https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2015/03/the_tsas_fast_p.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2015/03/the_tsas_fast..., which points to this.
- Crito 12y agoHave you considered making this (providing the original link after changing it) a feature of HN itself? I like the transparency, but doing it manually every time seems like it could become a bit of a hassle for you.
- robotkilla 12y agodoing it automatically wouldn't prohibit transparency.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jimktrains2 12y agoHe meant he likes the mod posting it because it's transparent, but knows that it's a pain for the mod and feels that having this automatically happen would aid in being transparent because then the mods don't have to do special things.
- dang 12y agoYes, but we would prefer to implement a way to group all related URLs together. That would better solve the underlying problem.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 12y agoThis is a note, written by a law student. Not a reason to discount the analysis, per se, but worth keeping in mind if you were thinking of skipping the article and taking the conclusion at face value. The actual analysis starts at 367. The gist of the argument, from a quick read, is that Kyllo (the case that held that the government could not use infrared cameras to look into peoples' homes) established that the government could not use extrasensory searches to get information about what's inside areas protected by the 4th amendment. To the extent that biological vitals and medical information are protected (an uncontroversial point), it follows that using extrasensory technology to obtain that information violates Kyllo.
- logn 12y agoTo expand on your summary, first the author provides one on the last 2 pages. Also a significant part of this is that these administrative searches (at airports) must be to prevent terrorism not for "ordinary" crime. FAST would make no distinction (and it's hard for it to make a distinction between any crime and mal-intentions). Further, searches of medical data must meet a higher standard and warrants are required (at least in the case of DUI blood draws, with a few exceptions).
- rtpg 12y agoHaven't read the post, but a precision on Kyllo: extrasensory searches are fine if we're talking about doing it with commonly available tools. Binoculars are fine, helicopter-mounted infrared cameras aren't. The idea being that people _expect_ the public to have certain things but not others. Now I imagine that most ways to get vitals would be pretty intrusive and require non-common (as in, not in use by everyday people) hardware, but generally speaking Kyllo only invalidates a certain class of instrument
- panarky 12y agoThe system has an eighty-one percent classification accuracy in a laboratory test setting That sounds pretty good -- "It catches 81% of the bad guys". It sounds good until you realize that bad guys are an infinitesimal portion of the population. If bad guys are 1 in 1,000 or 1 in 100,000, virtually all of the people implicated by the system will be innocent.
- skrowl 12y agoThat's cute. You think the US government is still bound by the Bill of Rights.
- thirsteh 12y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E9ff9EVNHJU&t=61 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E9ff9EVNHJU&t=61
- rbcgerard 12y agoor ever was
- wahsd 12y agoOnly when convenient. Which is why I find myself reluctantly siding with the vehement nature of gun rights advocates in spite of really desiring a world where guns would not be necessary to possibly keep the "government" (which is increasingly fewer and fewer people with more and more oppressive laws) at bay. On a side note, I find it ironic that those who would most need guns to both protect themselves from the kind of government that "gun nuts" fear and under possible circumstances of social collapse to protect themselves from "gun nuts", are also the least likely to know how to properly operate with them or want to keep guns for self protection. There is really very little that would allow me to believe our society is even remotely civilized or responsible enough to not necessitate an armed population. Just take this story for example. Is anyone in the government saying no, you know what, the precursors of mind-reading are too far and not in line with the spirit of the very first and most basic principle of this country. No, you don't and wont hear that, just like you haven't heard that about all the other abuses and violations that have preceded this. Hell, we have the very thing that the "crazies" used to warn about, just even better, self-maintained dossiers on every single person in the country in the form of aggregated social profiles and internet tracking and monitoring.
- mikeash 12y agoI don't understand the idea that gun rights are important because it helps to check oppressive government. Aren't oppressive gun regulations the sort of thing that guns would let you fight against? It's always presented as, "this must be legal, or else we will lose our ability to fight for freedom." If guns don't let you preserve gun rights, how will they let you preserve any other rights?
- guelo 12y agoFAST seems to be some kind of polygraph-type scanner using cameras. It's very likely that it doesn't work but some military contractor will make millions off of it anyway. Any efficacy data will probably be unavailable or classified. Efficacy doesn't matter to the authorities anyway because having people believe that their minds are being read is almost as good as actually reading their minds.
- EazyC 12y agoAre you sure things like this can't work? I work in a computational neuroscience lab and we do a lot of modelling and also machine learning. Things like Eulerian Video magnification (EVM) already prove you can do the rudimentary proof of concepts of such "FAST scans" like being able to extract heart rate and blood flow from a simple video. Techniques like EVM can even be used to detect sound from video files simply based off vibration of the objects captured in video. It seems it wouldn't be too outlandish to assume that EVM techniques + some other more classified technologies + unlimited funding of the NSA/Homeland Security/CIA/TSA could be combined to create something like the tech purported in the link. For the record, I don't work in the actual lab that developed EVM, just in a similar field. EVM info: http://people.csail.mit.edu/mrub/vidmag/ http://people.csail.mit.edu/mrub/vidmag/ http://people.csail.mit.edu/mrub/VisualMic/ http://people.csail.mit.edu/mrub/VisualMic/
- jimktrains2 12y agoOK, so lets assume the cameras work. For the same reasons polygraphs have no basis in science, nor would these. I fucking hate the TSA and am fucking furious every time I have to wait to be sexually molested. I'm also worried that they'll fuck up and I'll miss my flight. I'm nervous because I'm worried. I'm constantly looking around to find out how many TSA agents are just fucking around doing nothing. Yet, I'm not a terrorist. And you know what? most people aren't terrorists. The false positive rate so high it essentially makes the test meaningless and unable to discern an actual threat.
- hurin 12y agoThe rather strong verbal comments aside - I think this is almost certainly correct. Polygraph tests are notoriously inaccurate - where as for something like terrorist threats the number of real positives you are interested is probably in the x > 1/10^6. That's totally fantastic - consider that pregnancy tests have a false positive rate in the single digits.
- logn 12y agoIt seems to me that the law and precedent are used by courts much like the Bible is by preachers. You can justify almost anything you want. I read the whole paper (sans footnotes) and it makes a lot of sense. Had I not also read the legal memo on extra-judicial assassinations, I'd be a lot more confident that an average person could predict court decisions based on the current body of law and precedent. But I think any decision can be reached, at least in practical effect, considering the power to dismiss cases and exclude evidence.
- mdholloway 12y agoThis is true, but only to a point. In principle, if the reasoning is flawed in some obvious way (say, writing a memo on executive power during wartime without citing Youngstown Steel, the leading case on the subject), other people with requisite training will sooner or later recognize that, and the error will be corrected. Of course, this requires public scrutiny to work. Hence the problems with secret legal memos and secret court opinions.
- jostmey 12y agoEerily similar to the concept in "psycho pass".
- jwcacces 12y agoThose footnotes are more like legnotes!
- skj 12y agoLet me begin by stating that I think the TSA, as implemented, is a huge waste of money and time. That said, I am not sure any searching done by the TSA can violate the 4th amendment - you can always refuse a search if you're ok with being ejected from the airport.