4 ms·
The thought of being able to abolish death as soon as you have a working BCI by running one's mind on silicon hardware is, if not ludicrous, at least really rea
by vinceguidry 12y ago
The thought of being able to abolish death as soon as you have a working BCI by running one's mind on silicon hardware is, if not ludicrous, at least really really far out. So, you hook your brain up to a computer, and get basic input and output. Great, you now have an upgraded keyboard / mouse. It doesn't get any better no matter how many capabilities you add. Direct memory access, changing the contents of programs on the fly, none of it will abolish death any more than being able to do by 'hand' does. The best you can do is create a really sophisticated program that will continue acting deterministically after the programmer goes away. You will live on in the same way Tolkien lived on after he died in his books.
You're not going to be able to abolish death until you can get neural networks to run at the speed of your current brain hardware and at similar capacity. In other words, you still have to be able to simulate a brain. To take the functions of the brain currently has, and get enough of them working electronically until you can start to build an identity on top of it.
Even once you do that, it won't feel like your brain without a lot of training, both on your artificial hardware and on your biological hardware. I envision an era where early adopters have hybrid consciousness, where we slowly incorporate an electronic identity with our biological one. Going from "This is my brain extension" to "this is another part of me, some of my thoughts are here, some of them are in this piece of hardware."
I suspect this will be a highly individual process that we will slowly gain mass competence with in a similar way we're doing with software now. We'll have to grow our ability to simulate neuronal processes and replicate our psychologies computationally. Even then, it will feel like an artificial prosthetic until you have enough capabilities to where if you suddenly lost the other side, you wouldn't feel trapped in the most hellish solitary-confinement prison ever devised.
Then after they're fully integrated, start prioritizing experiencing through the mind prosthetic. I suspect one would need many many years before cutting off the biological part wouldn't cause grievous trauma to one's sense of identity. Especially since our legal system will need a long time to figure out how to fit non-biological beings into society.
- kanzure 12y ago> You're not going to be able to abolish death until you can get neural networks to run at the speed of your current brain hardware and at similar capacity. That can't possibly be true. You're dead if you are slower than you once were?
- vinceguidry 12y agoIf you can't merge your consciousness with the prosthesis then you'll never actually be able to consider it 'you'. And you won't be able to merge if there's a serious impedance mismatch. Unless you're talking about taking not just a human brain and simulating it, but rather programming a brand new electronic brain to run your own consciousness. Which is even farther out than merging. You'd have to understand neurons to a much-greater depth. This is assuming that neuronal processes aren't relying on quantum dynamics, which I suspect would make true simulation impossible. Just because you can do simulated annealing on silicon doesn't mean you can predict the unfolding of arbitrary quantum states. Merging would be the only viable strategy, and there, your new brain would only have a fraction of its former speed until we're so far along with quantum computers that they're as ubiquitous as silicon processors are today.
- mattbettinson 12y agoBuddhists say a loss of identity can lead to the greatest bliss one can experience. I think the future is going to get really weird.
- hammerandtongs 12y agoI actually agree with your view of the BCI being a long process. I think you are too flippant and dismissive of what he was saying about this in the context of the many different things he was talking about. You are essentially quibbling over his simple presentation of what most people know will be a very complex process.